-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated New Berlin Property Management Companies

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Property Management Companies to Avoid


Top Rated Property Management Companies


Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 1,207 reviews for
New Berlin Property Management Companies from people just like you.

"I hired
to manage my rental condo, and this is the first time I've ever rented out a property. From day one, my experience with them" has been positive: The staff have been very attentive, responsive, and easy to reach. Furthermore, their work has been professionally done, and they appear to be experienced with what they do. My initial in-person meeting with someone at CC (
) went well and he clearly explained all that was involved in renting out my condo, and how his company would help. He was very flexible in meeting immediately and evaluating my condo. Once I decided to sign with CC, they quickly cleaned up and fixed up the condo to be ready for rental. This was conveniently done without me needing to be there. Because they have their own contractors, communication between CC, the contractor, and myself was seamless. They also handled all rental listings (on several major websites), showings, and rental applications, credit/background checks, etc. They kept me apprised with who had submitted rental applications so that I could make an informed decision on who to accept. Signing a tenant was likewise handled without a problem. I'm very happy with the tenant that ultimately rented, and still is renting, my place. Issues with the rental, such as appliances breaking down, have been brought to my attention quickly and resolved accordingly. CC also acts as the primary contact for the rental unit with the
management company which they handle very well. I'm copied on all correspondence from the
manager, but I rarely need to respond to issues. The CC team is always very easily reached and they give me the sense of providing direct attention via individuals' e-mails and phone numbers, i.e. not like having to work through a 1-800 hotline. The staff are friendly, reasonable, and professional. Finally, the cost of their services is very competitive, and I really believe I'm getting the best value out of my money with
when comparing with other rental management companies.

-David C.

"We recently found a home we super loved for rent that this company was showing. They told us it was available and to apply there would be a 50$ per person charge" for application, which would come out for us to be 150$ since we are also taking care of our retired, disabled father. We then found out right before we were going to give them this non-refundable amount that they had done my
and a few friends pretty dirty with this "scam" by taking this money and already having it rented or just picking out another application instead without returning money. So we looked deeper and found that the home was already rented out a week before!!! They actually told us a lie and when we tried to contact them, they deleted our comments on their Facebook. Really shameful way to run a business scamming people out of money, especially a lot of people who are already struggling. I know firsthand, along with other people I know personally who I have urged to write a review to warn others, that this company is running some sort of scam. I will be reporting this to the BBB just as soon as I can get time out of my life raising two daughters, one with a disability and a father who is also disabled. Thanks a lot! So glad we were smart enough to do some research first.

-Marinella C.

+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in New Berlin

How to Find a House to Rent

Finding a rental home doesn't have to be a hassle.

Renting vs. Buying a Home: What’s Best for You?

Is home ownership still the ultimate American dream?

Homeowner mowing yard with shed in background
Property Management

HOA supporters say rules protect home values, but some worry they wield too much power.

Brick condominium
Apartments, Real Estate Agents, Property Management

Living in a condominium has its obvious pros and cons.

Apartment repair
Apartments, Property Management

Why you should never try to fix something in an apartment.

Angie's List
Appraisals - Real Estate, Home Inspection, Home Staging, Mortgage Companies, Property Management, Real Estate Agents

The current housing climate requires today's home buyers to know as much as possible about appraisers, mortgage brokers and real estate agents.

Angie's Answers

Most states require a seller or landlord to disclose a death in the home. Absent of there being an undisclosed death, the tenant doesn't have a leg to stand on. Usually, small claims court will order the tenant to forfeit the deposit and pay for any unrented time in the home. However, if the tenant can prove that there was an undisclosed death in the home prior to their renting it, you may be liable for a full refund of all rents, deposits and moving expenses.
Are the heat pumps commercial or residential units?
Are the heat pumps Package or Split System?
Are there actually 33 PTAC units?
Are you an EPA certified person( refrigerant )?

Here is my suggestion, break it down into manageable portions(ie one heat pump and a few PTAC units every other month) to keep from being overloaded.  
Clean/Replace filters
Check/inspect electrical wiring and connections
Check amperage draw of compressors/motors 
Check capacitance of start and run capacitors
Check contractors/relays for wear/pitting
Check refrigerant levels and record superheated/subcooling
Check external static pressures across air handler(s)
Check deltaT (return and supply air temps) 
Lubricate motors( if applicable)
Inspect Belts/Pulleys( if applicable)
Clean outdoor coils
Clean indoor coils

Start there and HAVE FUN!!! 

Property Management reviews in New Berlin


They are wonderful. The staff are very professional and yet they make you feel like family. They also handle any minor repairs if needed through licensed technicians. They are amazing, a huge blessing to me since I live in PA, but I can always count on them with communication and their help.
- Eric V.

Phenomenal Service by
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
, they did an amazing job of selling my home here in Sequim, even when others couldn't. I was desperate when I met them to sell my home, after several failed attempts by others, I should have come to them first, they are miracle workers and will sell your home for the most money possible and quickly! I highly recommend them to everyone I meet, down to earth professionals, I felt comfortable with them instantly and they are highly knowledgeable too! Best advice I can offer is to work with them first instead of wasting your time and patience!
- Jim J.

Overall the repairs are fantastic!
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
's contractor came out and assist the whole issue and with in 24 hrs i had a bid emailed to be and all work was completed and set by the following Friday! Cost was great as you can see only paid $1000 but most of all the quality of service and professionalism that was provided was pronominal 5 STARTS.
Thank you
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
for all your hard work!
- John E.

I was in the
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
for a property manager to manage one of my apartment
buildings. I contacted
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
during business hours and the
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
to voicemail. I left a detailed message with my contact
information and never received a call back. From the view of an
investment property owner it's already a bad sign when a property
manager doesn't answer the phone during business hours, although I do
understand being on the other line, or driving, or working something
else at the moment the call was received. Not immediately calling back,
however, indicates a lack of concern for your customers and even the
tenants which is simply bad for business. I didn't even need an
interview to know this company wasn't what I was looking for.
- Jeremy F.

Everything was fine until it was time to return our deposit and they took out 300.00 for a broken HDMI cord that we never
used. My husband was there for the final walk-thru and turned our keys in, they never mentioned a damaged cord so anyone
could have damaged the cord. They will not return the deposit and a HDMI cord is about 50.00 they claim drywall work to get
to the HDMI cord, again not our fault nor did we use the item. Park Ave
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
is a rental company to be very cautious
of using.
- theresa R.

New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
is extremely unreliable and unprofessional. They do everything they can to get you to rent, don't live up to their promises, are unreliable in repair orders, and seem to have different employees every week. If you have to do business with them (not recommended), make sure you get EVERYTHING in writing.
- Grace J.

We were looking for our first home and after dealing with a few Realtors we finally met
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
Brown and we are glad we did.
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
's patience with us was wonderful as he knew we wanted the perfect home and were not in a hurry to find exactly what we wanted .
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
was easy to contact and always responded to our calls and emails quickly. He was also willing to setup immediate showings of properties we were interested in. His knowledge on the housing
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
was extremely helpful for us as first time home buyers.
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
's expertise helped guide us through buying a house with ease. I highly recommend
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
as a Realtor.

- Adrian B.

Yes, I will ask for his help on all future work at my home.
New Berlin Property Management Companies Provider Name Locked
is an honest, hard working guy with insight as to what's required to complete the job!


Property Management Companies in New Berlin, WI

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

24 HourGlass Concierge and Events Services

200 S Executive Dr

Aatuzi Contracting

2888 Mayfield Rd

ACME Property Management, LLC

1571 W Lincoln Ave

Al's Lawn Care Plus, LLC

W375S2045 County Road Z

All American Gutters LLC

795 South Main

American Family Insurance - Scott Hood Agency

W168N8932 Appleton Ave
Menomonee Falls

Anderson Commercial Group

8575 W. Forest Home Avenue #40

Atmosphere Construction, LLC

7425 S Chapel Dr.
Oak Creek

Baker Painting Co

819 Surrey Ln

Bark River Tree Service

S21w35990 Parry Rd

Bartsch Management, LLC

PO BOX 26915

Best Choice Landscape Inc

2938 S Waukesha Rd

Camp Industries Inc.

1522 87th Place

Creekstone Custom Carpentry, LLC

N144w6818 Pioneer Rd

Cudahy PC

4846 S Packard Ave

D & D Odor Eliminators

4535 N 161st St

Daniel Labrasca Services

5233 County Rd V



Done Right Builders LLC

1100 s 1st street

Down Under Faux

36 Prince Street

Echelon Realty Group, LLC

409 Prairie View Dr
North Prairie

Elite Improvements LLC

240 Amanda St

Elite Properties, Inc.

3415 N. 127th Street

Floor Concepts

14803 W. Hidden Creek Court
New Berlin

Golden Maid INC

3921 s 50 th st

Handyman Specialties

po box 210222


2124 N 12th Street

Hines & Forbes remodeling LLC

P.O. Box 90705

Home Owner Helpers Painting

2551 S 66th St

horaitis electric

2033 N 57 th st

Impact Land Care

5828-80th Place

Integrity renovations

3414 s 113 th st

Integrity Small Engine Repair

4218 N. 95th St

IQ! Remodeling and Construction

1257 N Breezeland Dr.

J2O Pool and Spa

826 Timber Ridge Dr

JBOS Custom Remodeling LLC

11006 N River Rd

JEK Lawn and Snow Services

N74W36110 Thomas Dr

JH Loggers, LLC

PO Box 532

JW Painting & Decorating Service

957 E. Mackinac Ave.
Oak Creek

Kingdom Realty LLC

6205 N. Teutonia Ave.



KMF Construction LLC

7690 Overlook Dr

Koessler Enterprises

510 N. Lake St., Suite 7



Martin's Property Management LLC

6825 W Brown Deer Rd, #242443

Merry Men Services

S42 W34859 Big Oak Drive


North Prairie



Mount Zion Construction & Senior Services

N 6238 W Lakeshore dr.

My Dwelling, LLC

101 West Pleasant Street


611 W National Ave # 315

Phillips, Cymerman & Stein

161 W Wisconsin Ave

Pinnacle Home Improvements LLC

15320 Mars Ct

Professional Safe & Lock Service, Inc.

5132 West Howard Avenue

Prospect Management Company


Proud Precision Painters

2825 N Mayfair Rd

R&G Maintenance

5572 S Obrien Ave

Real Estate Rita - Realtor

8112 West Bluemound Road

RMH Remodeling and Renovations llc

1911 s. 69th st.

Rooming Inc.

Servicing all 50 states

Scott's Property Management

715 Sumner

Tic Tac Remodeling

1236 N. 10th Ave.
West Bend

TKOR, LLC Owners Representative

W158 N7738 Deer Tr.
Menomonee Falls

TLC Repair Service LLC

W254 N4935 McKerrow Dr

Two Brothers Lawn & Snow LLC

8615 N 52nd

UpKeepers Inc

219 55th St

Wargolet Construction LLC

3823 E Barnard Ave

Wisconsin Tax Appeals

3500 South 92nd Street, Suite 3C

Shop Local Property Management Services in New Berlin, WI

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in New Berlin.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Property Management Company
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money