Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Columbia Jewelry Stores

There are 4 top-rated jewelry stores in your area and 98 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 4 highly rated companies in Columbia

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Jewelry Store Articles

Go to the article: 

How to Pick the Perfect Engagement Ring

Go to the article: 

Former Pro Race Car Driver Rings up Success in Concierge Jewelry

Gold ring on shiny pocket watch expensive jewelry
Go to the article: 

Searching for a Unique Gift? Consider Custom Jewelry

Gold ring jewelry in hand over notebook appraisal

Jewelry reviews in Columbia

Real People ~ Real Reviews ~ Real Results

  • These are two excellent and personal jewelers to work with!  Their store features fabulous and different stones in novel settings for rings, earrings, bracelets and necklaces.  If they don't have exactly what you want, they will create it.  Mary and Steve can craft the design of your dreams.  They will procure the stones to choose from, and the setting of your choice.  Do you have a creative setting in mind?  As goldsmiths, Mary and Steve can develop a new design with you, as they did with me when I wanted a new setting for resetting a diamond.  Additionally, any commercially-made setting or product can be obtained through them.  I ordered my husband's wedding band from them after he decided on the style and width he wanted.  Wonderful service and outstanding merchandise await you at this diverse, privately owned store.
    I trust these jewelers implicitly.  Mary and Steve have reassuring, up front integrity.  I have traded with them for at least 20 years and have always been more than satisfied with their work.
    Jarrett and Hart soldered my ($15K) engagement and wedding rings together after the wedding.  I was completely comfortable leaving my bejeweled rings with them, knowing I would get them back in the same condition (only cleaner!); with the same stones I started out with. I've heard horror stories about people leaving their rings for repair at a chain jeweler, only to discover that the stone was 'switched out' when it was picked it up.  This would NEVER happen at Jarrett & Hart.
    - Roger D.
  • We ordered our rings about a month before we finally got them (just in time to leave for our wedding!). The woman who works there (I believe she's one of the owners) suggested a size 10.5 for my fiance, but when the ring arrived, it was impossible for him to get it on his finger. We ended up having to wait a few more weeks for his replacement ring to arrive (which is a little bigger than a size 12).
    The two people who run Unforgettable are very friendly and honest. They didn't charge us extra for the replacement ring, even though the company they ordered the ring from only covers re-sizing if it's a half size or less difference from the original. They were also upfront about the delay, and we appreciated that. However, the two owners are quite young and it doesn't seem as though they had the experience to suggest the correct size in the first place. 
    One additional complaint I have about this place is that they don't have a jeweler on site. I needed to get my engagement ring (which is 100 years old) re-sized, but I wanted to actually speak to the person who would do the re-sizing. So I couldn't get my ring re-sized here, which was sort of annoying. Not employing their own jeweler makes this store more like something you would find in the mall than a reliable, family-run business.  
    Overall, things went okay, but we won't be back.  
    - Elizabeth C.
  • unknown
    - Chip G.
  • unknown
    - Randy M.
  • Fits perfectly & necklace is beautiful. "Home town" affordable prices and excellent work.
    - Carol N.
  • unknown
    - Cheryl H.
  • unknown
    - Pamela K.
  • Excellent work at a fair price. Family-owned business with super customer service. We drove across town because of their reputation and it was worth it!
    - Lis T.
  • We were so impressed with the quality of work that they do. Whether it was a simple repair or a purchase, they delivered! And literally, they delivered!
    - Kathryn C.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Jewelry Stores in Columbia

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!