Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Westerville Jewelry Stores

There are 8 top-rated jewelry stores in your area and 90 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 8 highly rated companies in Westerville

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Jewelry Store Articles

Go to the article: 

Former Pro Race Car Driver Rings up Success in Concierge Jewelry

.
Gold ring on shiny pocket watch expensive jewelry
Go to the article: 

Searching for a Unique Gift? Consider Custom Jewelry

.
Gold ring jewelry in hand over notebook appraisal
Go to the article: 

Finding a Worthy Jewelry Appraiser

.
Dirty work fingers thumb appraising ring jewelry with tool black dirt and diamond in gold

Recent Jewelry Reviews in Westerville

  • A
    WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
    My bracelet broke a week before Christmas. They gave me a price and promised a reasonable turnaround time which they beat by a day. Although it was a very busy time of year for them, they respected the importance of a medical alert bracelet and performed the service quickly and very well. I appreciate that they have in-house jewelers to do the work. I'm very satisfied.
    - Amy C.
  • A
    WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
    The jeweler did an assessment on the spot and provided a reasonable quote. The repair was done in less than a week and the ring looks as good as new.
    - Karyn P.
  • A
    WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
    Each time the results were beautiful and the work was done ahead of the expected date. When I had questions I was able to talk to the designer who was doing the work.
    - Cinda W.
  • A
    WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
    My wife's engagement ring Diamond fell out due to all the prongs breaking. They rebuilt the prongs and resized the ring and she was very pleased said it look better the new.
    - Gary S.
  • A
    WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
    I love Worthington Jewelers. I will always have a soft spot in my heart for this team of very high end professionals. My husband created my engagement ring and we bought our wedding bands here over a year ago. I go in every six months to have my rings cleaned and the staff is consistent with their service every single time. I cannot get over how fantastic they are - plus you get to know them - they keep their talented people. You don't have to worry if someone you connected with before is now gone - this isn't a typical jewelry store. Worthington Jewelers is exceptional. Super service super staff and super jewelry. Very satisfied!
    - Laura W.
  • A
    Beechwold Custom Jewelry LLC
    The new ring is gorgeous! The detail on the liquid amber leaves surrounding the diamond is exquisite. This ring us even more beautiful than the one I lost. We are so thankful to have found such a talented, dedicated artist.
    - BEVERLY D.
  • A
    WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
    I bought a broken pearl bracelet in to be fixed (it was purchased elsewhere) and Worthington did a great job. The piece was re-designed into a necklace and bracelet and the bracelet was made stronger to prevent further breakage. I had a tough time, however, getting the clasp to work so I could put the bracelet on. I took it back and the added another jump ring and a new clasp. Problem solved. I love both pieces and wear them often. I would highly recommend Worthington Jewelers for fast, professional service.
    - Nona N.
  • F
    BEYER JEWELERS
    Worst Ever!!! She ruined the history of our 30 years! So Sad! She TOOK OUR GOLD! making the ring weigh less, when it was supposed to weigh more. We paid extra to have gold added and the ring is hammered and stretched very badly, so badly the HALLMARKS AND STAMP on the inside are POUNDED FLAT WITH HAMMER MARKS ON ENTIRE RING!!! No legible hallmarks remain. When we tried to resolve the problem even showing pictures, she screamed at us! She yelled hallmarks don't matter. We Say Google it! Call GIA or any Jeweler... Please do not take your jewelry there for repairs! I have not purchased new from there so I do not know what type of quality you will get but I have had several rings sized there and only one came back perfect. The others were satisfactory until this very special ring, she totally ruined!!! The Lady in the shop Tracy said she was the owner but when we were in there before Stephanie said she was the owner. Tracy changes whether or not she works on sizing, saying (when we took rings in) "its too filthy a job for me" but now says she has so many years experience. Googles says Stephanie Beyer is the owner. Back in March another girl said she was Stephanie, so they maybe hiding something as well. Also she screamed she had GIA but did not say anything they agree with or show proof. I DO NOT want this to happen to anyone! It feels so sad especially when the history of our precious jewels are so sentimental to us. PLEASE DO NOT TRUST THEM WITH YOUR PRECIOUS INVESTMENTS!!!
    - Penny C.
  • A
    WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
    I had my husband’s, who recently passed away, wedding band and a diamond pendant he game me for our anniversary that I wanted made into a necklace. The gentleman who helped me was very kind and offered suggestions as he helped me come up with a design. I had my own gold chain also. The cost was much less than I thought it would be and it was done within a few days even though it was the week before Christmas. They polished everything and it came out beautiful. I’m so thankful for their help in making this cherished keepsake.
    - Tammy J.
  • A
    WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
    Theresa and Bob are unbelievable at what they do and so great to work with. We’ve purchased a number of items from them over the years including a custom designed necklace and pendant for my wife when our daughter was born. They have become my family’s exclusive jeweler and I promise you won’t be disappointed.
    - AUTUMN P.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Jewelry Stores in Westerville

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!