Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Warners Property Management Companies

There are 8 top-rated property management companies in your area and 64 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 8 highly rated companies in Warners

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Property Manager Articles

Go to the article: 

6 Tips for Renting a House

.
pink house, manor, estate
Go to the article: 

Renting vs. Buying a Home: What’s Best for You?

.
couple stares out apartment window at street
Go to the article: 

Should I Invest in Rental Property?

.
house for rent

Property Management reviews in Warners

  • A
    Real Property Management PROS
    Mary found us a good deal with the purchase of a dishwasher from Home Depot. She was very concerned about keeping our costs to a reasonable amount, which turned out to be within our budget. She is very descriptive and detailed in conveying what our tenant issues are and what we need to do to resolve them. Overall good experience!
    - Michael W.
  • A
    Real Property Management PROS
    Very well with no problems. Chuck was professional and easy to work with. Kept us well informed about all aspects of the rental process and expectations. Very good experience.
    - Michael W.
  • A
    CNY Asset Management LLC
    Good service overall  contacts me right away when there's a problem. Replies to email quickly as well.  Sends me a statement every month with details of expenses and income. They found responsible tenants with good backgrounds. Helped me manage a two family house for about 2 years.
    - Helena H.
  • A
    Upstate Leasing
    Great.  John gets me my rent immediately once he gets it.  he communicates well and is flexible to my needs as an owner.  He is friendly with tenants, he gets things done.  I am thrilled he is now in charge of my properties.
    - eric r.
  • D
    Flynn Management Group
    Flynn Management Group was hired to manage one of my rental properties.  I liked the idea of them because they were cheap and did not offer any services I did not need.  After about 2 months I realized that they were cheap for a reason.  They did not respond to any phone calls or emails.  Also, I told them several times that a tenant was not paying their rent and they should be evicted.  After 2 months of no responses to my inquiries into the status of the eviction they said they did not start the eviction because the tenant told them they were going to pay.  They might be good at maintenance (I'm not sure since they did not do anything), but they need a lot of work before they become a reliable property management company.
    - Bradley O.
  • D
    CNY Asset Management LLC
    I hired this company to take care of my property in Syracuse since the last company closed down right after I signed and paid the contract fees. I was hoping that this company wouldn't give me any stress about the property. First off, they haven't been responding to my emails on time especially urgent ones. Also, when there were new tenants whom they signed a lease with and never informed me about until I asked about it.  Recently, the property manager told me about some problems about the property for example, the broken window. Of coarse, I had to pay for the repairs and everything but I requested for pictures or some evidence for the problem so that I can have a peace of mind. However, even after three to four times that I mentioned to him, I never got the evidence or pictures that I wanted. Another problem arose which is even more expensive than the last, not only did he not give me proof of the repairs, I was also losing money that month because of a $1,250 repair that I had to pay for. It just makes me very uncomfortable to be paying that much money for some problem that he could've made up. On top of that, every time I spoke with him over the phone or via email, his attitude was unfriendly and instead of helping me out with the property, I was having more stress.
    - Helena H.
  • F
    Mel & Jay Management, LLC
    Property Management company who said all the right things at first. However as soon as we had signed contract the problems began. My tenants at the time that already lived there for years prior were sent non-payment eviction notices the first month. This was an administrative error they said after the tenants called me in a worry and i called Jay. The next month the same letter went out. When i sounded frustrated with this happening I was told to stop answering calls from my tenants and they were just over reacting. After a few other calls from my tenants; incidents with maintenance issues not being addressed timely,  I cancelled my contract. Mistakes happen, but to have them repeated and no acountability that was not acceptable.  I do believe Jay and his daughter mean well, but that doesn't cut it in property management, no attention to detail.
    - Eamon O.
  • F
    Mel & Jay Management, LLC
    Mel & Jay Management, LLC managed a rental of mine in the Syracuse area. They seem very nice and pleasant BUT beware. They will not get back to you or come to the phone when important matters arise. They hold the rent for long periods of time and you must beg them to release it. They make mistakes, double bill and lie. They do not get repair quotes or tell you if there is a problem with the rent, but then suddenly take it our of their rent transfer that month with no corresponding repair bills or pictures.  They do not pay you and actually will tell you the tenant did not pay when the tenant in fact has paid. They lie about repairs and refuse to ever show any proof in form of bill or photo (their camera is always mysteriously missing and their phones apparently aren't capable of capturing a picture and their scanner is always down. There is ALWAYS an excuse. They let tenants make modifications without telling the home owner. They would not even allow me to get repair men or contractors into the home - into my own home! I fired them and they have refused to provide me with the remaining rent the tenants paid. They acknowledge they collected the money but say they need to use it for other purposes that has absolutely nothing to do with my property - this is criminal. The tenants also confirmed that the work Mel & Jay billed me for never occurred in the home. Do NOT use this company.
    - Debra H.
  • F
    BELLA PROPERTIES LLC
    They rented the apartments to tenants who moved in at least 4 room mates to each unit. In many instances they issued the last set of keys to tenants thereby loosing total key control. Then they charged me hundreds of dollars for non existant paint jobs. Whenever a refridgerator would fail they would do me a favor and replace it with a good used avacado or harvest gold colored refridgerator for only $300. I can get a brand new one at Lowes for $400. For almost two months I did not receive rent rolls, and they didn't answer the phone or respond to Emails. At one point they pocketed a tenants security deposit and even intercepted a tenants rent after they had been fired.
    - MIKE K.
  • F
    Bennett Realty Group LLC
    I called the office number during normal business hours and no one answered. I submitted an e-form on the website asking someone please get back to me. I called the office again the next day and no answer. This time I left a voicemail. I tried emailing Scott Gerni directly asking for a response. No avail, he did not respond.  I have reached out to another agent who was listed on the website but have yet to hear back from her also. Eventually I called the cell phone listed for what seems to be the "main agent of the company" before I got someone on the other line. The entire process have been a week just for someone to answer my question, which was a very simple question! What a pain.   I would not recommend listing your house with them since no one will answer interested buyers. 1 star.
    - Elizabeth M.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Property Management Companies in Warners

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!