Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Oyster Bay Pet Insurance Plans

There are 3 top-rated pet insurance plans in your area and 24 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 3 highly rated companies in Oyster Bay

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Pet Insurance Provider Articles

Go to the article: 

Remove These 7 Household Pet Dangers

Go to the article: 

Why Is Advanced Veterinary Care So Expensive?

Veterinarian uses medical equipment on an unconscious dog
Go to the article: 

The Different Types of Veterinary Clinics

A veterinarian examines a long haired dachshund.

Recent Pet Insurance Reviews in Oyster Bay

  • A
    Dr. Manfredi came to the house-was WONDERFUL, calm, caring. This is so hard, to euthanize your pet, that you have had for 16 years...Dr. Manfredi made this hard tough decision, a peaceful and beautiful experience. I will never again have my pet euthanized anywhere but at home. It is so worth the extra money you pay, compared to bringing your dog to the vet. You are at home, no stress for your dog on getting to vet, for my pet, it was just another day at home. So peaceful.
    - JAN H.
  • A
    My experience was excellent. I sent in a claim, which they paid promptly. I received a letter from them saying that if my vet sent in the vet's notes on my pet's treatmenet, they can send me additional money based on the notes. I have never received anything from any insurance company saying we paid your claim, but we may be able to send you more. I sent in my vet's information, and as a result, Nationwide paid me an additional $97 on top of what they already sent me. I was very satisfied.
    - Robert P.
  • A
    Healthy Paws Pet Insurance
    They are excellent. They have an app on my phone. They are a life saver. They really were good. I have an automatic withdrawal from my checking account for like $36 or $37 a month but it is so worth it. I don't have to worry about paying the bill. They paid out a h*** of a lot more. The bill was about $2800. The phone app is excellent to keep track of your claims and keep check of your dogs health records. Not regular records, just for the care that they pay for which is any kind of emergency: any emergencies at all.Their customer service is so helpful to get all the documentation from the hospital. They basically will leave you out of it if they can deal with the hospital. They know what the codes are just like a human being and they were on top of it with that. It is really convenient. You also get notifications from them like if they didn't get something they'll let you know that they are waiting for it. They're not doctors just insurance agents. The customer service, everybody I dealt with was very professional.
    - Laurie A.
  • A
    They have been very good. My cat needed to get some teeth pulled, and they covered most of it. They were really remarkable and fabulous.
    - jane r.
  • A
    Healthy Paws Pet Insurance
    Healthy Paws is simply a wonderful insurance company. Our 3-year-old English Mastiff, Jeff, has had medical problem after medical problem -- skin, ear, and eye infections, tick-borne illness, kennel cough, giardia, you name it, he's had it. In the three years we've had him, there have only been a handful of months that we haven't ended up in the vet's office. The only saving grace through all this has been Healthy Paws. They've been there for us every time. Prompt. Friendly. Caring. Simply lovely. It's like working with a friend instead of a company. At one point, they even asked for a photo of Jeff so they could get to know him better. And, they are so efficient. Last Friday, the day after Thanksgiving, Jeff had to go back to see some specialists. Healthy Paws sent us a notice of reimbursement, which covered virtually everything, that night, hours after his visit. This company is truly amazing. I couldn't imagine going with another insurance company after working with Healthy Paws.
    - Joseph S.
  • A
    They are great. When my dog got sick, they were responsive. There was no argument. Whenever bill came, they paid it. When talking with them, they really care about animals. They really care about their service and there are no hassles. The price seems comparable with everything else.
    - Robert K.
  • A
    Healthy Paws Pet Insurance
    I recently adopted a cat and purchased an insurance plan through Healthy Paws, and was I glad I did!  About six weeks later my cat needed surgery for what turned out to be a blocked bile duct.  The vet bills were staggering (I live in Manhattan, so you can imagine!).  Healthy Paws paid out on my claims in less than a week!  I (and my credit card company) were thrilled!  I was very happy with their service and their follow up emails to check on how my cat was recovering.  I highly recommend Healthy Paws.
    - Linda S.
  • A
    I haven't made a claim yet but I've been paying the premium. I was referred to them by my veterinarian. I haven't made a claim, but they have been very professional. I also feel that the price is fair.
    - Martin G.
  • A
    VPI Pet Insurance
    They are a national company. They cover 80% of vet is charged but no vets take pet insurance. So they give you 80% of what you spend and even in regular well checkup. When I brought my dog for a well checkup it was $600 for everything to be checked and I had a $400 cheque within a week which is phenomenal.
    - Stacey M.
  • A
    It's a good one. I just renewed my insurance. They have different policies. I pay $371a year for the annual insurance policy. Then I get a wellness plan on top of it. A lot of tests were done. Veterinary services in general are very expensive in this area. I had a wellness coverage plan. That was another $144. I paid about $500 in total. They paid me back over $900 with the veterinary expenses. It certainly was worth the while. He is young, so he eats things he shouldn’t. He gets sick because he gets into things. It's been very helpful to have that when I needed to go. They have been good. With regard to price, I researched other places, I think it was the best. I would absolutely use them again; I just signed up again yesterday.
    - susan m p.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Pet Insurance Plans in Oyster Bay

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!

  • Sam's Club

    333 Saw Mill River Rd
    Elmsford, New York
  • Trupanion

    907 NW Ballard Way
    Seattle, Washington