Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Oyster Bay Jewelry Stores

There are 3 top-rated jewelry stores in your area and 398 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 3 highly rated companies in Oyster Bay

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Jewelry Store Articles

Go to the article: 

Former Pro Race Car Driver Rings up Success in Concierge Jewelry

.
Gold ring on shiny pocket watch expensive jewelry
Go to the article: 

Searching for a Unique Gift? Consider Custom Jewelry

.
Gold ring jewelry in hand over notebook appraisal
Go to the article: 

Finding a Worthy Jewelry Appraiser

.
Dirty work fingers thumb appraising ring jewelry with tool black dirt and diamond in gold

Recent Jewelry Reviews in Oyster Bay

  • A
    The Jewelry Appraiser Inc
    Deborah is incredibly knowledgeable, approachable, reasonable, and kind! She made my fiancé’s process of getting the ring appraised seamless and easy. She was responsive and truly guided him throughout every step! Deborah is now assisting me even after the appraisal with all the small things women are concerned about after being proposed to (like keeping our rings sparkling). Thank you again, Deborah! Giuseppe and I look forward to continuing to do business with you.
    - Alessandria A.
  • A
    Junk Removal ~ NJ. Cleanouts Junk Be Gone Bretts
    Called Brett and arranged an appointment the following day. Showed up on time, was very cordial. Did everything we asked efficiently. Would definitely use again.
    - Susan W.
  • A
    ARTHUR GROOM & CO
    It could not have gone better. The store is beautiful and elegant, but the most important part of it was working with their gemologist Ali. She was exceptionally knowledgable and experienced and had a manner that made me feel she had nothing more important thing to do than to take her time examining my jewelry. As she worked at lightening speed (two hours for everything), she chatted with me, explaining how some of the more very old confusing pieces would have been used or worn. I feel she made every effort to see that I received full value from this inheritance. I couldn't imagine a more positive and pleasant and profitable experience.
    - Judith H.
  • A
    G JEZARIAN Purveyor of Fine Jewelry
    It was a professional, personalized, fun experience. Greg collaborated with me, even when my first selection ended up not being the best fit for me. I value his opinion, style & service & would confidently recommend him.
    - colleen m.
  • A
    Brown's Jewelers
    I chose Brown's because of the positive reviews on Angie's list, which included clock repair. I didn't know whether jewelers near me do clock repair. It's not near where I live, but is in an area that I visit. They were as described in the reviews. It took just slightly longer than they estimated because they had to order a part, but they called me when it was ready. I'm very happy with the result.
    - Ann N.
  • A
    Gennaro Jewelers
    “Gennaro Jewelers” is by far the most professional and conscientious jeweler with whom I have ever worked. I was greeted promptly and warmly welcomed upon arrival. My ring was examined and placed where it could be seen on one of the many large flat "tv" screens so that I could precisely see the unique identifying marks on my stone. I was given a reasonable price for repair of broken prongs on the setting. However, In lieu of repair I opted to completely replace the setting. I looked at many settings and Kathryn, the sales manager, could not have been more patient. No sales pressure whatsoever. Once I had made my choice she explained the process to follow. Since my setting had to be ordered and sized I went home with my original ring intact. One week later I was called; the new setting had arrived. The jeweler removed the stone from my original ring and began the process of replacement. I must stress that, at no time was my stone out of my sight. Even when the jeweler had his back to me I could see everything being done one of the large flat screens. Once the initial placement had been made, I was then "walked" through the finishing process. Gennaro's is absolutely insistent that your jewelry is never out of your view. Once the work had been completed, my ring was once again shown on the flat screen. The slight inclusion that I could see on the stone guarantees that I will always know it is mine. I received an education that went far beyond the "4Cs". A rating of “A” just doesn’t seem to be enough. I have found a jeweler for life.
    - Deborah G.
  • A
    ECOLIN CO INC
    They are 100% professional and friendly. They know there jewelry and guide you in the right direction.
    - Joseph F.
  • A
    FLIEGAUF JEWELERS
    It was our first time there, and we were so impressed with Greg Fliegauf, 4the generation family business ower, and his employees. My husband's ring was repaired superbly with a replaced shank for a reasonable price. Additionally we sold them an unwanted 14K pin and left my grandmother's engagement ring for appraisal. Satisfaction with those jobs has led to others, and we now feel like we have found an honest, reliable, professional jeweler. We highly recommend them.
    - Susan W.
  • A
    Global Gold and Silver
    During the holidays I was given antique pieces of fine jewelry that were heirlooms and in my family for several generations.  My husband and I really weren't sure where to start in evaluating what do with them as far as selling them or keeping them and we really didn't even know what the quality was, we just knew they were old.   We found a few other places that told us they were real gold, and we could sell them and have them melted down and be paid based on the total gold amount.  I just didn't feel right about having these items melted, they felt like they were worth more than just gold- 2 gorgeous antique broches and a watch. We found Global Gold and silver online and set up an appointment with Steve.. It felt like he appreciated the items for more than just their value in ct wt of gold and educated us on where they were from. Because of their age, he also told us they may not be melted down and that they may be able to be resold at auction or in the marketplace which made us feel a lot better about moving forward. We sold the items to them at what we feel was a very fair negotiated rate which was above everyone else's price and left feeling comfortable that our family's antiques were left in good hands.  We definitely recommend.
    - Nona u.
  • A
    LORD'S DIAMONDS
    My husband gave me this ring to mark our 45 years of marriage. The graciousness and professionalism of Anu made this experience even more special.
    - Linda F.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Jewelry Stores in Oyster Bay

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!