Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Fairport Auto Repair Shops

There are 80 top-rated Auto Repair Shops in your area and 192 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 80 highly rated companies in Fairport

Auto Repair reviews in Fairport

  • A
    I use North Greece Automotive.  They're fantastic!  He's a young guy and he actually used to work for my uncle, so I know him personally.  He, for years, wanted to open up his own auto shop.  It's in an abandoned firehouse that he converted over to work on cars.  He's just always wanted it and he's very honest.  If something breaks he'll show you what it was.  I still take my wife's car to the dealership and so they'll say oh you need brakes, you need this, you need that.  I'll say well, I'm gonna wait on that and then I'll take it out to him and he'll say well you definitely need them on the front but I don't know why they were telling you on the back. He'll show you, this is gonna get you through till next Fall, and you save money.  He's trying to put food on his family's table, but he wants you to come back.  I will absolutely use him again.
    - Bryan C.
  • A
    Rytek Automotive
    I go to them all of the time for both of my cars. They get an "A" for everything. In fact, I am going to schedule an appointment very soon. They are honest, fair pricing, and good, quality craftsmanship.
    - TOM M.
  • F
    The Muffler Shop II Inc
    My car sat at the muffler shop for over a week.  I called them three times for an estimate on repairs and never got a phone call back with an estimate.  finally I called AAA --since they towed the car there, I had them tow the car to another repair shop.   There are always a lot of cars at this place.  Now I know why.  They just sit there for weeks and they don't  work on them!!!
    - kathy l.
  • A
    In mid July when I took the car back to have the timing belt kit put in Jamie halted work when he discovered some metal rot on the frame that was hidden by the plastic shields under the engine compartment.  He said in good conscience he couldn't do the timing belt job until I found out if the frame problem could be fixed. He recommended a company that specializes in frame work and I took the car there for the frame repair. 
    My good deal on the car has become a medium deal but that's ok it will be a classic in just a couple of years.
    As noted above he's working on the timing belt kit and radiator as I write.  He called me to tell me I could come down to see the engine after he had removed the valve cover and a bunch of other stuff and noted that things are in very good shape.  He spent time explaining various components and reviewing the frame repair.
    This is a high quality mechanic who knows his stuff and is very ethical.  His pricing is standard, he doesn't pad the hour count and as noted above he won't do unnecessary or unwarranted work.  I recommend him highly.  He'll be doing all the maintenance on my other vehicles.
    - David O.
  • A
    I just joined Angie's list so this review is being submitted a month after the work was actually done.
     Excellent work, good pricing.
     He's going to replace the timing belt, water pump, and associated seals on the car tomorrow (its due for these).  He said go ahead and order a kit I found online, after considerable research into the proper mix of OEM & aftermarket parts, and he'd do the installation of all the components. Many mechanics won't do this as they want to make some money by selling parts at marked up prices.
     I'll update this review after that is done.
    - David O.
  • A
    Schoen Auto
    Jerry and his crew do a fabulous job, and the level of customer service is outstanding. I had one complicated problem that took a long time to diagnose and fix -- they didn't charge me anything beyond the first visit, even though I came back several times just to have them check on it. Jerry called me at home to follow up just to make sure it wasn't giving me any more trouble. They always make sure my car is in tip-top condition before a long trip, even if it means squeezing me in at the last minute. I really appreciate that they don't push me towards the most expensive option, instead they tell me what really needs doing and what can wait. I'm delighted to recommend Schoen Place Auto to all my friends, and have done so many times
    - Annie M.
  • F
    Hoselton Toyota
    The parts that they installed in my car were not good, and I had to take it back more than once.  I plan on writing to the owner of the dealership with my complaint, and I will not be going here for service again.
    - Gail R.
  • F
    I can't use it because there are no Shell gas stations in the Rochester area! That was not disclosed to me! I would have to go out of state to use it.
    I looked up where there might be a Shell gas station. Google claims there is one at 871 Fairport Road, East Rochester, NY 14445!
    I went there. I was told they were a Shell station 5 years ago!!! They used to be a Citgo, but are now a Gulf station!!! So, its been that long since The Lobster Trap (who also sells gas) was a Shell gas station!
    So, I can't use it!

    - Kevin B.
  • A


    They were most considerate in squeezing me into their schedule, since my grandson was ill and I was anxious to gave my car back. Everything was clearly explained to me, Staff was courteous and professional at all time I was given an accurate estimate. The wait time was minimal. The car has worked fine since then! No more engine or oil light.

    - Chris S.
  • A
    Rytek Automotive
    Jim and crew at Rytek have been servicing our family cars for at least 20 yrs. They are upfront with repairs needed, help prioritize repairs when we have had a few to make on hand me down cars to our kids, have advised when it may not be value-added to keep repairing a vehicle and recommended retirement of a vehicle, and have assessed vehicles prior to purchasing as used car. They are very good diagnosticians and technicians and we have recommended their shop to several friends. We drive both foreign and domestic vehicles and they take care of just about any need. They are timely, reasonably priced and always very professional. Work is done rIght the first time and they are always responsive when you call to ask a question. I would highly recommend Rytek to others.
    - Terri N.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Auto Repair Shops in Fairport

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!