Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Brooklyn Insurance Companies

There are 21 top-rated insurance companies in your area and 551 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 21 highly rated companies in Brooklyn

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Insurance Company Articles

Go to the article: 

Do I Need Special Insurance When Remodeling?

.
remodeling contractor holds hammer on roof
Go to the article: 

When to Sign Letter of Intent or Roof Contract

.
A man works on a roof with a hammer
Go to the article: 

Is Moving Insurance Worth the Cost?

.
boxes in moving truck no moving insurance

Insurance Agent reviews in Brooklyn

  • A
    5Boroughs Insurance Agency Inc
    It was a very good experience. Tom was totally responsive both to my original call and to any questions I had as we went along. 5Boroughs doesn't charge us; it charges the insurance companies. He asked questions, looked to find me something equivalent for lower premiums, which he did. I saved about $800 by switching. Also, he told me an inspector would come out and what they look for. I learned my old circuit breakers were no long safe! I changed them.
    - Marcia S.
  • A
    GMG Brokerage Corp.
    Melissa is the health insurance fairy godmother I've been looking for! She took the time to thoughtfully assess my unique situation and provide me with solid recommendations. The health care system is so difficult and stressful to navigate ��� her expertise and resources made me feel confident and calm in choosing a new plan. She's easy to work with over the phone and email and always quick to answer my questions.
    - Rachelle D.
  • A
    5Boroughs Insurance Agency Inc
    It was a pleasure working with the staff at 5Boroughs Insurance. I was able to save money from my previous policy. They were very knowledgable about the product. It was a smooth and pleasant transition.
    - Laura B.
  • A
    5Boroughs Insurance Agency Inc
    My previous insurance company had canceled my policy and while I was out of the country on business. I called 5Boroughs Insurance and they were able to get me a new policy within 30 minutes. Not only were they very helpful, but I found the staff to be very honest and knowledgable. I have now given them all my insurance policies.
    - marcia a.
  • A
    Koba Capital LLC
    It went pretty well, considering it is a difficult business to insure for a fair price. The company representative came by to do an inspection, and coverage was approved with only one small request (to install a piece of safety equipment), which was duly done.
    - George A.
  • A
    Koba Capital LLC
    We recently had an issue with an insurance provider where an audit was conducted but the results were not being submitted, forcing us to pay a significantly higher insurance premium. This has been an ongoing issue for two months, with us being given the run around by the auditor and policy underwriter. I called Mike last week to inform him what was happening, and he was able to chase down the auditor within minutes our conversation and made sure that this issue is rectified. Mike and his staff have been saving our company tens of thousands of dollars by doing this type of work over the past three years
    - Ronen D.
  • A
    Farmers Insurance- Auto & Home NY
    I had been paying a ridiculous premium for my rental building. I had tried to shop around and I guess no one got me a better price or actually understood my risk probably. I sat with the agent and he went through my whole building. They looked it up on Google street view, city records and other places to make sure they insured it properly. Not only did I get a lower rate but also an agent who knew what they were doing.
    - Usman K.
  • A
    GMG Brokerage Corp.
    Melissa jumped right in and gave me all the information I needed to know and took care of everything.  She was a life saver. She was also one of the kindest and most thoughtdful professionals I have ever come across. I have a history of cancer so getting the right health insurance is important to me.    Melissa understood my situation completely and with that knowledge she searched for the right health insurance and drug plan. I cannot speak highly enouugh of GMG.   They are the best!!
    - Mark W.
  • A
    Kurtz & Associates Public Adjusters
    We hired Kelli Kurtz to handle property damage claim related to Superstorm Sandy after our own efforts to deal with the issue have failed. Her vast knowledge and experience helped us to get through the process with minimal stress as she was very attentive and responsive during the process.. She helped us to settle the claim to our satisfaction. I would not hesitate to recommend Kelli Kurtz to prospective clients


    - Alla S.
  • D
    OptumRx Inc
    The phone reps are unfailingly courteous and pleasant, but the back office and computer systems are constantly in confusion. Orders are sometimes very late in arriving, we have had problems with addresses and they don't track orders well, so it is difficult to fix anything which goes wrong. I think the price changes from year to year are too high, but that may partly be due to Medicare policies. I would never recommend them, and each year swear to change providers, but just haven't.
    - Harriett H.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Insurance Companies in Brooklyn

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!