Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Allegany Insurance Companies

There are 6 top-rated insurance companies in your area and 43 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 6 highly rated companies in Allegany

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Insurance Company Articles

Go to the article: 

Simplify Shopping: Navigate Store Return Policies

.
Go to the article: 

Do You Need to Update Your Homeowners Insurance?

.
Go to the article: 

7 Things New Homeowners Don't Know They Need to Do

.

Recent Insurance Agent Reviews in Allegany

  • A
    Pauldine Insurance Brokerage
    Went to his office and all the employees were very happy and made you feel welcomed in his office. We have told other friends and family about the experenice that we had with the broker.
    - Danielle V.
  • A
    Geico
    GEICO is one of the best large companies I have ever dealt with. Not only do they have the best prices but their customer service agents are the nicest people to deal with. I have had two instances where I required roadside assistance and the customer service people I dealt with were quite helpful and had someone out in a timely fashion. Their web site is well designed so it is easy to manage your policy.
    - John S.
  • A
    EXCELLUS BLUECROSS BLUESHIELD
    The company is easy to get in touch with, representatives are knowledgeable and helpful, and all claims have been handled properly.
    - Richard M.
  • A
    HART'S INSURANCE
    They are very good. They are responsive. I've had to file a claim and it went very well. I've been using them for 15 years. They are an independent agent so they can find me another company if I am not happy with the company I'm with. They had a better price.
    - Ian M.
  • A
    Highland Insurance & Financial Services
    Agent was great. Professional, explained everything to us. Came to our house. Was able to find us life insurance for us when other agents werent able to.
    - Bill S.
  • A
    John Patrick Stone Agency - Nationwide Insurance
    John provided us with competitive auto life and homeowners insurance. He is great to work with and knows is product offerings very well. I would highly recommend his agency.
    - joe f.
  • A
    AAA WESTERN & CENTRAL NY
    Bad luck day around 2pm. driving home from a road trip with kids car decided to stop running called triple A for assistance, they are always very helpful, car decided to start back up, called them back to cancel tow truck made it home.  Went out later in the day about 5:00 pm with my husbands truck broke  linkage for gear shifting  in McDonalds drive through (LOL) Called triple A again they sent a tow truck driver out quickly , he manually put the gear into drive so I could get the vehicle home.  Just to let you know I have been a customer of AAA here in NY of almost 10 years I was a customer in NJ for 7 and in GA for 5. I would say for most of my driving years. I also use them for the discounts they provide at hotels, museums etc. They are a Great service to have, when you drive. Make sure as your children begin to drive get them a membership. It will give you a nice state of mind knowing if anything happens when they are away from home, they can call AAA.
    - Kathleen K.
  • A
    CARDINAL AGENCY INC
    Somehow, I had misunderstood a mailing from my insurance provider. I thought all was well with my coverage, but the folks at Cardinal notice the problem and worked quickly to help me rectify the situation and even contacted the company on my behalf to have a penalty removed.
    - Danielle L.
  • A
    Geico
    I chose them because their rates are better than anybody else as far as I know. I pay $300 for half-a-year. So, I pay $600 a year. I do not do it through a facility. I do it online.
    - Nancy F.
  • A
    CDPHP
    I purchased health insurance for myself through the New York Health Exchange. I decided to go with CDPHP as I am a healthcare provider and find they are one of the better insurance companies to deal with. I met all of the deadlines but there were still problems -- information on the exchange was wrong (e.g. it said there were no high deductible HMOs eligible for HSAs when in fact there were several), I received bills for two other people, access to the CDPHP web site was unavailable for about two months, automatic payments were not available. I took it in stride as the Healthcare Exchange was new and buggy. Plus CDPHP was very open about the problems whenever I contacted them. In terms of price you will pay more for CDPHP -- both Empire Blue Cross and MVP had less expensive plans for my area. I probably could have saved a few hundred dollars per year with comparable plans from either Empire or MVP but due to my professional experience with CDPHP I decided to stick with them. Plus I knew just about every provider in the Capital Region accepts CDPHP. A few months after getting coverage I developed a rather serious medical problem that required diagnostic work-up and surgery. I knew when I chose my coverage I would have some costs I would have to pay since I had a high deductible HMO. I have found CDPHP great to work with. I stayed within their preferred network for my radiology studies (and you do have a lot of choices) and a PET scan was paid in full (except the radiologist charge, which is normal). My bills have been easy to understand and paid in a timely fashion without any problems. When I have called CDPHP to ask questions they have answered my questions in a timely fashion. What you learn with insurance is it is the service and coverage that you get when it is needed that counts. CDPHP is a bit more expensive but when you need it they deliver.
    - John S.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Insurance Companies in Allegany

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!