Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Ely Insurance Companies

There are 5 top-rated insurance companies in your area and 35 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 5 highly rated companies in Ely

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Insurance Company Articles

Go to the article: 

Simplify Shopping: Navigate Store Return Policies

Go to the article: 

Do You Need to Update Your Homeowners Insurance?

Go to the article: 

7 Things New Homeowners Don't Know They Need to Do


Recent Insurance Agent Reviews in Ely

  • A
    Heath Kilpatrick Ins Agcy Inc
    I have been with State Farm since 2000. It is part of my house payment. I have had to make claims and they were very prompt, and very professional, and very understanding.
    - Sonya W.
  • A
    Mark McCullough
    When I bought a new (to me) car I decided to look at other insurance companies to see if I could get a better deal somewhere else. I came back to Mark McMullough. They are always polite, professional and helpful. They worked hard with me to get the best rates possible. Mark McCullough also does financial advice.
    - Martha S.
  • A
    Farm Bureau Financial Services - Jason Klein
    Dylan Moore was trying to find an insurance carrier for health as I was about to run out of Cobra coverage. The situation was complicating. He had to do a lot of work on the phone and he kept me well informed. He is a nice and personable. He was very easy to work with.
    - Michelle B.
  • A
    I requested Home Insurance quotes from (which I do not recommend, as I am now getting spammed like crazy, especially by ones requesting I sign in to my various financial accounts!) and instead of getting online quotes, my information was sent out to various agents, most of whom then called me several times a day for a couple of weeks requesting additional information before they could give me a quote, during which time I was working nights and fully did NOT appreciate it. But Allstate emailed me an instant quote and did not bother me with phone calls or requests for more info. The Allstate quote was the lowest of all the quotes we received, with equal or better terms. A week or so after the initial quote, Dan checked in with me via email, and we began a dialogue to get a more exact quote; and I then also requested auto insurance quotes for my fiance and I, individually and together, and combined with the home insurance. Dan was very accomodating, had the best prices, policies and service, and in general gave us the best "vibe" so before we closed on our new home, we met with him (conveniently, he has a local office) and switched our auto policies over and got a new home policy for what what we believe was the best deal for us. We previously had separate auto policies, and by switching companies and combining them, we're saving at least $500 a year.
    - Brenda H.
  • A
    Millhiser-Smith Insurance Agency
    Jeremy has been my agent for at least 5 years. I called him in order to renew my auto insurance which involved having a newly purchased used car and my daughter's insurance added onto the policy. Jeremy researched the market and came up with the best policy for my situation. He arranged that it be renewed along with my homeowner's policy at the discounted price and for payment in full to get even more discount. All of this was conducted efficiently in one phone call and an on-line payment.
    - William M.
  • A
    Mark McCullough
    Mark McCullough is very professional, he likes to do a year review of our various policies with him and he does the initiation of contact with us and lets us know the time for our normal review so if we need to do any adjustments for changes then we could at the time. We had our first experience with them when my husband had an accident in his truck and out truck was towed and no one told us that we had to have the work done here, then we got a call a week later from the tow company saying that if we don't get the car then it would be a problem, so we went to get it and they said that we had to pay for the storage before they released it and we had to get a hold of Mark and it was a big mess.
    - Jillaine W.
  • A
    Klug Insurance had been my automotive and home insurance provider for nearly 5 years now and I am extremely happy and satisfied with their service and product.  When my wife and I got married we seriously discussed who's insurance company to keep and who's to move on from.  I conceded to her and couldn't be happier. I haven't had the need to submit a claim thankfully, but from my other experiences with them I'm sure it would be as smooth as possible should the need arise.   I receive a check with a small rebate each year when we don't have a claim which is nice.  Additionally, this past year, Klug reached out to my wife and I with a few suggestions on how to reduce our premiums due to our specific needs and policies.   They made the effort to bring these idea to our attention without any initiative from my wife or me.  It would have been very easy for them to leave everything as it was and I would have continued to be happy with the service, but they saw that a few small changes to our policy would allow us to have the same level of coverage yet save some money each year.  I can't tell you how that impressed me.  We took their advice and they were completely on the money (no pun intended ;) ).  I will continue to use Klug as my insurance provider and would recommend them to anyone shopping for these services. Anytime I've had questions about a policy or even about different payment options, they have been prompt, courteous and made me feel like I was their only priority the entire time I was talking with them.
    - Jason E.
  • A
    Caldwell Willie Cisco
    He is awesome!  He is prompt with questions and problems.  They are very quick to deal with everything!
    - Becky D.
  • A
    Great! Got one-on-one service. Answered all of my questions. Also provided several different quotes based on different levels of coverage.
    - tara m.
  • A
    Shelter Insurance
    Overall, Don is an excellent agent. I first got my homeowners insurance, and he was able to answer all my questions. I was a first time homeowner, so I had a lot of questions. He helped me create the policy I needed, and the price was comparable or better than other companies. Later I got auto insurance through Don as well.
    - Christopher M.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Insurance Companies in Ely

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!