Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated San Antonio Insurance Companies

There are 23 top-rated insurance companies in your area and 1.6K to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

Over 4 million people rely on ...

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Select filters
  • Become a member to sort service providers.
  • Rating (hi-lo)
  • Rating (lo-hi)
  • # of reviews (hi-lo)
  • # of reviews (lo-hi)
  • Time on Angie's List (most-least)
  • Time on Angie's List (least-most)

Shop Offers from Local Insurance Companies

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Insurance Agent Articles

Go to the article: 

Do I Need Special Insurance When Remodeling?

remodeling contractor holds hammer on roof
Go to the article: 

Getting Insurance Quotes? Ask These Questions

white car
Go to the article: 

7 New Year’s Resolutions from Your Home

gingerbread house in Savannah
Join Angie's List Now To see all 23 highly rated companies in San Antonio

Insurance Agent reviews in San Antonio

Real People ~ Real Reviews ~ Real Results

  • I notice that Provider name locked. has tons of 'A' ratings on this site from members who have been with them a long time.  My bet is that these members never had complicated claims with Provider name locked. or never filed claims at all.  I have been with Provider name locked. for 12 years.  I also would have rated them superbly, A++++ ratings down the board before actually dealing with them regarding a claim.  I was naïve - I put them up on a pedestal, believing all the rhetoric they spout in their commercials and advertisements.  They'll protect you.  They'll be there for you and your family.  Their coverage is better.  You're a member of an exclusive, better "club".  We're not "insurance", we're "family".  The reality is, your coverage is only as good as your policy.  Which is the same as it is with any other insurance company.  What I did not realize is that Provider name locked. charges a hefty premium for the privilege of membership.  My sister recently bought a house and she had Provider name locked. homeowners insurance with her old home (like I did), but she was shopping around for insurance on her new home. She told me every other insurance company quoted her $100 LESS PER MONTH or more than what Provider name locked. quoted her for the same coverage.  She ended up switching for the cheaper premium.  I too shopped around and had the other insurance companies give the me EXACT same coverage as I had with Provider name locked. (line for line) - and the premiums were $500+ a year cheaper with other companies.  I have been overpaying for coverage.  I think people are so shocked when Provider name locked. denies a claim because Provider name locked. tries to make you feel special - like you are a member of their exclusive club and they are better than everyone else.  Not so.  Sure, they'll pay your claims for the obvious - car accidents, sudden water loss, home burglaries - and they'll be SUPER nice about it and make you feel REALLY taken care of.  But wait until you have something unexpected and uncommon happen to you - a slow water leak under your home, expensive jewelry stolen that you didn't have extra policy coverage for, neck injuries from a car accident - you'll be shocked to discover that Provider name locked. will say they're "so sorry" but your policy doesn't cover that.  They'll happily leave your family to pay out of pocket and pick up the pieces.  When these VERY expensive, catastrophic things happen to you insurance SHOULD be there for you.  Every member of Provider name locked. should review their policy coverage every 2 years, shop around on price, and know the areas of loss where you are vulnerable if something happens.  Provider name locked. is not "the best" insurance company - they are the best swindlers, touting "legacy" and using their image to con all of us out of our money by convincing us to pay more for the same mediocre, typical coverage as the insurance company next door.  Tricking us into trusting them because our fathers and grandfathers think so highly of them and recommended them to us.  Talk about the fleecing of America!  Provider name locked. wrote the book.

    - Mary W.
  • Safe co was great and did all of the contacting. I did not have to call them for anything. They explained all my plans and options available and acted very promptly. They overall did great and were good to deal with.
    - Frank V.
  • Several years ago I had some claims for hail damage on the roof .  They were very good and understanding.  They told me exactly what I needed to do to be reimbursed.  They reimbursed everything.  The roof was totally covered.  They were very professional and very easy to work with.
    - Ray C.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Insurance Companies in San Antonio

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.
To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!