-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Madison Collision Repair

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Collision Repair to Avoid

97

Top Rated Collision Repair

24

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 388 reviews for
Madison Collision Repair from people just like you.

A
"The work was done exaxtely as estimated, in the time that was estimated. The work was of the highest quality. The facilities were clean and inviting. The entire" staff was friendly and efficient. On top of that, I saved hundreds of dollars over what others said it would cost. I highly recommend
on Odana Rd.,
, WI

-Vito M.

A
"Found company on Angie's List Stopped in, receptionest very friendly and helpful Appraiser (Customer Service Representative) looked at car immediately, gave" me estimate I checked with family responsible for damage Called Appraiser (Customer Service Representative) set up date to bring car in for repair Left car on Monday, they gave me a free rental,said car would be ready on Friday They called and said my car was done on the day they promised Very well pleased with service from beginning to end. Staff very friendly, efficient

-Lois S.

+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Madison

How to work with insurance to fix your car after a crash

Been in a car accident? Here's what to do to alert your insurance of the car crash and find a local auto body repair shop to fix your damaged vehicle.

Accidents & Auto Body Repair

A consumer's guide for steps to take when involved in an auto accident, including contacting towing companies and finding an auto body shop to complete repairs.

A chipped or cracked windshield can be a major safety hazard. (Photo by Photo courtesy of Angie's List member Stephen M.)
Auto Glass, Auto Body Work

That cracked car window won't repair itself, but putting off fixing it could cost you more if the windshield crack spreads.

car buffing
Auto Detailing, Auto Body Work

Have scratches on your car? Read on to learn the best ways to remove them.

Make sure your headlights, taillights, turn signals and brake lights are working before your trip. (Photo courtesy of Angie's List member Danielle J. of Columbus, Ohio)
Auto Body Work

Before you hit the highway with your family on a road trip, check this list of must-do tips. From tires and brakes to lights, make your journey safe and fun.

Cabin air filters prevent pollutants from entering your vehicle. (Photo by Eldon Lindsay)
Auto Body Work

The cabin air filter cleans air that flows through cars’ heating and cooling systems, to block dust, pollen, smog, mold spores and other pollutants.

Angie's Answers

?

You could have paid a little more per month and gotten a lower deductible policy. The deductible is the amount you agreed to. To "get out of it" it is breaking the law. You probably thought, like we all do, that nothing will happen to me, so I'll get the cheapest per month. I think that's what most people do, so you're not alone there.  

 

See if you can make  a deal with the repair company; they may let you pay a little per month. The repair shop may be your best best bet in getting some sort of "deal". Nothing illegal, of course.....

 
Next time though, think about paying a little more per month for a little more ins. (One-day less fast food lunch, or movie night, or smart phone, etc) and you can reduce your deductible quite a bit.
 
Hope that last paragraph doesn't sound too judgemental, it's what I'd tell my son or daughter. (Before they bought the crap insurance in the first place, if they'd only ask, right?)  
Too late now though, just live and learn.
 
 
 
?

Hi there! This is Weston from Member Services.

 

It seems you spoke with my colleague yesterday afternoon and she passed along some highly-rated providers to help you out with your auto needs. I hope the information was helpful which she passed along to you!

 

Please let me know if I can provide any additional assistance or information. You can respond by submitting a new answers as a response in this Q&A, email us at memberservices@angieslist.com or toll-free at 1-866-783-2980 to speak with a live representative. Our call center hours are Monday through Friday 8:30 am-8:15 pm Eastern Time or Saturday from 8:30 am-3:00 pm ET.

 

?
?
Hi,

This is Leah B. in Member Care, happy to help!

You can actually submit a review on any provider nationwide. Just sign in at www.angieslist.com and click on the “Write a Review” tab. On the next page, you can adjust the chapter using the drop down menu in the search bar.

You can also provide your feedback via email at memberservices@angieslist.com.
?
Hi,

This is Kyle K from Member Care. I'm happy to help!

I apologize for any confusion, but your membership has been expired since February of 2011. If you would like assistance in finding top rated providers in your area you will need to renew your membership.

You can renew online at any time by signing in to your old account at www.angieslist.com. Once logged in, you'll be asked to rejoin, and you can just follow the prompt.
 
If you’d prefer to speak with someone over the phone, our Member Care Team would be happy to assist you. They can be reached toll-free at 1-888-944-5478. Don’t forget to check-out our money saving multi-year plans, too.
?

Hi,

 

This is Kelly M. in Member Care. I'm happy to help!

 

Currently, you have access to our Traditional membership which only includes information in your local area. However, our Plus and Premium plans feature nationwide access. The difference between these two plans are outlined below:

 

Plus: $29.99 - This includes both our home and health lists, online and call center customer care, print magazines, nationwide access, and a $15 rebate on your first deal purchase.

 

Premium: $59.99 - This includes our home and health lists, online and call center support, print and digital magazines, nationwide access, priority customer care, complaint resolution and a $50 rebate on your first deal purchase.

 

If you prefer, give us a quick call at 1.888.944.5478, and our Member Care team will be happy to help. We're open weekdays from 8:00 am- 9:00 pm ET and Saturdays from 8:00 am- 5:00 pm ET.

 

If you only need to do a quick search, though, we also offer a one-time, complementary cross chapter search. Just let us know the type of service you need and the zip code to look around, and we would be happy to get this done for you.

 

Thanks!

Auto Body Work reviews in Madison

A

Rating
Gard's prices are very reasonable and he is a really nice guy. He does the work timely manner - my vehicle is always ready on time.
- Teresa B.
B

Rating
Staff was polite whether on the phone or in person. The service was done professionally. The only down side from this experience is there seems a lack of communication among staff. First of all, I gave my name to a male staff. Shortly, a female staff assumed that I was another customer who was bringing the car in for estimate. After I explained the purpose of my visit, my name was not on the schedule. I was then told to bring in the car the next day because the mechanic wouldn't be at the shop until the next day for a major
Madison Collision Repair Provider Name Locked
damage case. Fortunately, the female staff who scheduled me showed up and the mechanic was there for fixing my car as well. It was a little bit chaotic, but everything turned out all right. I got my car within an hour since I pulled in. i am a happy person because I didn't need to or expect to leave my car overnight and to get a rental car from Gates for that ding on the door.
- Chaolan K.
A

Rating
I was glad to find M&M Auto Body again after so many years. I think
Madison Collision Repair Provider Name Locked
does a great job and takes his business seriously.
Overall, I was very happy to get good quality service at a reasonable price.
- Barbara W.
A

Rating
We got an estimate from the dealer which was 50% higher -- and included unnecessary work like replacing a headlight that worked just fine. These guys looked carefully at what could be done adequately -- while not trying to return the 6 year old car to "new car" status. I really appreciated their taking the time to listen to what we wanted, get a sense of our values for the job, and execute it consistent with what we wanted. They didn't insist on perfection, which we didn't want to pay for. That said, the work they did was first rate, looks great, they just didn't replace unnecessary parts. Especially as a woman customer in the auto body world, I really appreciated
Madison Collision Repair Provider Name Locked
's respect and straight shooting. He was happy to explain things when necessary.

Madison Collision Repair Provider Name Locked
enjoys talking with clients so, if you're in a hurry, just say so. He's such an honest, reasonable, fair guy -- owns the business his father passed down to him. His son is a mechanic in town as well. Good people. Good, fair minded people. I would go there again in a heartbeat (but hope I don't need to!).
- Martha G.
A

Rating
I took my car into the shop for an estimate after my car was hit in the right front. The right front corner of the car was damaged so that I didn't have any lights or directional/marker lights. The front bumper cover and shock absorber material was severely damaged. The passenger door would not open. My a car is an older car and the complete repair of various aspects of the car to new condition would have been a waste of money. At at the time of the estimate,
Madison Collision Repair Provider Name Locked
gave me an estimate to repair the car to "new condition". (His estimate was lower than other shops.) He also discussed with me various options to save money. He gave me estimates based an various repair scenarios. I chose to have the bumper, lights and fender replaced. I asked that he ignore a minor
Madison Collision Repair Provider Name Locked
in the door and just paint repaint the door. I asked that he only do adequate repairs to the hood. The car went in on Friday afternoon and it was ready on Thursday morning as promised. The replaced parts of the car look really good. The fit of the fender and lights etc. was very good. The paint on the fender and the bumper and the paint on the blended door blends perfectly. The hood was repaired to my specs. He even painted out and unrelated small area of bare metal. The inside of the car was very clean.
Madison Collision Repair Provider Name Locked
had to make several calls to the insurance company and send them various documents. He submitted those documents in a very timely matter. He issued a letter to the insurance company that the car had been restored to a safe and completely functional condition and the repairs restored the value of the vehicle to similar vehicles of like kind and year. I would definitely go to this body shop again.
- Thomas A.
A

Rating
They did a very good job. They referred my insurance people, and they have some shops. They
Madison Collision Repair Provider Name Locked
?t even have to have their person come out willing to take the estimate and willing to approve the work. It is done there. I was very pleased with what they were able to do. They were very professional and very detailed. The work looks very good. I had a couple of friends sent over there.
- Roger B.
A

Rating
It went very well. The first estimate was significantly higher than the estimate I had gotten from another body shop, but Gates was willing to meet the other shop's price, plus supplied a free rental car for the three days my car was in the shop.
- Jackie K.
A

Rating
They are very professional and they do excellent body work. They will clean up your car when they are done and take it through the car wash. They also give a detailed estimate. They are a little pricey but if you want good body work done they are the place to go.
- Jacqueline B.

All Collision Repair in Madison

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

A-ONE AUTOWORKS

4921 MEINDERS RD
Mc Farland

ABRA Auto Body & Glass - East Madison

3602 Cross Hill Dr
Madison

ACCURATE AUTO REFINISHING

4601 FEMRITE DR
Madison

ADVANCE AUTO BODY

2533 ADVANCE RD
Madison

AFFORDABLE AUTOBODY

4375 OLD STONE RD
Oregon

Apex Auto Sales & Repair

3029 Milwaukee St
Madison

ATARK AUTOMOTIVE GROUP

1877 W MAIN ST
Sun Prairie

ATTENTION TO DETAIL

801 ATLAS AVE
Madison

AUTO BODY TLC

825 W PINE ST
Baraboo

Auto Color, Inc.

2610 Parmenter Street
Middleton

AUTO TECH

6417 Westgate Rd
Madison

AUTO WORKS UNLIMITED

7510 CENTURY PL
Middleton

BADGER AUTO BODY

142 JANESVILLE ST
Oregon

BERGSTROM CADILLAC-HUMMER

1025 JONATHON DR
Madison

BEST TOUCH UP

308 W MAIN ST
Brooklyn

Bibliotech

Madison

BILL'S BODY & REPAIR

214 W MAIN ST
Marshall

BLUE CHIP

18 Greystone Cir
Middleton

BRANDT'S AUTO BODY

N4207 TEMKIN RD
Columbus

CAMBRIDGE AUTOMOTIVE REPAIRS

501 VERBURG ST
Cambridge

Charlies Paintless Dent Repair

2115 Wood View Dr
Stoughton

Chet's Auto Svc & Repair Inc

PO Box 111
Mc Farland

COLLISION REPAIR

1702 S PARK ST
Madison

CRUISIN AUTO BODY INC

403 S CP AVE
Lake Mills

De Forest Collision Repair Inc

416 N Main St
De Forest

DELLS BARABOO AUTO BODY

S2479 HWY BD
Baraboo

DENT DOCTOR

1850 S STOUGHTON RD
Madison

Dependable Carstar

221 Paoli St
Verona

DON MILLER SUBARU

801 E WASHINGTON AVE
Madison

ERFURTH'S BODY SHOP INC

880 N Main St
Oregon

EVERETT'S BODY SHOP & TOWING

847 15th St
Prairie Du Sac

Ford’S Mobile Repair

1917 North Western Avenue
Madison

FOXHILL AUTO BODY INC

S4157 FOX HILL RD
Baraboo

GARY C ESSE C ACCESSORIES

2418 VONDRON RD
Madison

GARY SMITH'S AUTO BODY

S2479 US HIGHWAY 12
Baraboo

GATES AUTO BODY

202 W BELTLINE HWY
Madison

GATES AUTO BODY

7520 CENTURY AVE
Middleton

GATES AUTO BODY INC

5317 WAYNE TER
Madison

Gates Auto Body Inc

339 S Walker Way
Sun Prairie

GENIN'S AUTO CARE

3505 UNIVERSITY AVE
Madison

German Auto House LLC

209 Swanton Rd Apt 5
Madison

Goodyear Auto Service Center

608 E Washington Ave
Madison

GRAVES AUTO BODY

7403 US HIGHWAY 14
Arena

GRAY BAHL COLLISION

3321 COMMERCIAL AVE
Madison

GUSTAFSON'S BODY SHOP

212 E MAIN ST
Dane

Hill Automotive

3013 City Hwy Cx
Portage

HOFFMAN'S AUTO BODY

W6253 STATE ROAD
Pardeeville

Holiday Automotive Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac

321 N Rolling Meadows Dr
Fond Du Lac

HOUSE OF HOSE POWER & CUSTOM

2180 PENNSYLVANIA AVE
Madison

HUINKER'S BODY SHOP

636 W MULBERRY ST
Baraboo

IDEAL BODY SHOP

5426 County Road A
Brooklyn

INFINITE AUTO

120 E ALBERT ST
Portage

J & L Repair

212 Columbia Avenue
De Forest

JIM'S PAINT AND REPAIR

113 N DURKEE ST
De Forest

KAHL KUSTOMS

987 MAPLE GROVE RD
Edgerton

KAROW AUTO BODY & REPAIR

W12318 HWY 16-60
Columbus

LARRY & DOUG & SHERM'S AUTO

722 ALBION RD
Edgerton

LYNCH AUTO BODY INC

2305 ATWOOD AVE
Madison

M & M AUTO BODY

3720 MILWAUKEE ST
Madison

MADISON AUTO BODY

5003 FEMRITE DR
Madison

MARK'S AUTO BODY

4260 ACKER RD
Madison

Marshall Auto Body Collision Repair

22300 W Bluemound Road
Waukesha

MAX MUFFLER

7984 COUNTY ROAD PD
Verona

MCR INC

906 WATER ST
Sauk City

Midas of Madison

1501 S. Park Street
Madison

MIKE'S AUTO BODY

300 US HIGHWAY 12 AND
Cambridge

MOBILE DENT REPAIR INC

3066 Shadyside Dr
Stoughton

MORTIMER CLASSICS

W4498 LONG CROSSING RD
Rio

NOSTALGIA AUTO BODY

3419 VILAS RD
Cottage Grove

OREN'S AUTO BODY & CAR WASH

101 SWIFT ST
Edgerton

PAINT DOCTOR

2701 Progress Rd
Madison

PARAGON CUSTOMS LLC

821 INDUSTRY RD
Sauk City

PORTAGE BODY SHOP

120 HURON ST
Portage

POYNETTE AUTO BODY LLC

299 E NORTH ST
Poynette

Quantum Express Network

5540 Gerend Rd.
Waunakee

R & J AUTO BODY

754 15th St
Prairie Du Sac

R & M AUTO BODY

109 WATER ST
Baraboo

RENU AUTO BODY

834 S PARK ST
Madison

RICHARD HAMRE AUTO BODY

909 STEWART ST
Madison

RICK'S AUTO & TRUCK REPAIR

3575 STATE ROAD
Mount Horeb

ROBERT'S RESTORATIONS

4275 ACKER RD
Madison

Rock County Honda

3636 E Milwaukee St
Janesville

ROCK LAKE CUSTOMS

114 ASHLAND AVE
Lake Mills

RODELL AUTO

2123 N STOUGHTON RD
Madison

ROMAN AUTO BODY

2409 DANIELS ST
Madison

RON'S BODY & WELDING

2514 County Rd N
Stoughton

Rose Custom & Collision LLC

5003 Femrite Dr
Madison

Russ Darrow Group

3502 Lancaster Dr
Madison

SACRED BODY

2042 E DAYTON ST
Madison

SHERM'S BODY & PAINT SHOP

722 ALBION RD
Edgerton

SIMMONS AUTO BODY

43 STATE ROAD 51 N
Edgerton

Smart Motors Toyota Scion

5901 Odana Rd
Madison

SMOKEY'S AUTO BODY REPAIR

327 S Division St
Stoughton

SPARKLE AUTO BODY

1 Sparkle Ct
Madison

STARK BUICK-PONTIAC-GMC

1509 US HWY 51/138
Stoughton

STARK COLLISION REPAIR CTR

1477 US HIGHWAY 51
Stoughton

STEVE'S BODY & REPAIR

W7188 PATCHIN RD
Pardeeville

STOUGHTON COLLISION CTR

140 WEST ST
Stoughton

Style One Custom Motoring

2870 Terra Ct
Sun Prairie

TEMPLIN'S OLD TIME AUTO LLC

N3127 Meadow Lark Rd
Poynette

THORSTAD CHEVROLET

PO Box 258038
Madison

TOBY'S AUTO SALES

221 BONNIE RD
Cottage Grove

TOM MEYER

371 CONCORD DR
Oregon

TOM MEYER V8 FORD

1161 US HIGHWAY 14
Oregon

TRUCKSTAR COLLISION CTR INC

38 W NELSON ST
Deerfield

UTZIG CARSTAR

315 WATER
Evansville

V T CUSTOMS

514 S NINE MOUND RD
Verona

VERN'S BODY SHOP

7621 TERRACE AVE
Middleton

WATER DOCTORS OF SOUTHERN WI

700 SCHUYKILL CT
De Forest

WRENCH AUTO SERVICE

3113 Laura Lane
Middleton

Zimbrick Buick GMC West

1601 W Beltline Hwy
Madison

Zimbrick Honda

1601 W Beltline Hwy
Madison

Zimbrick Honda Service Center

430 Grand Canyon Drive
Madison

Zimbrick Hyundai West

320 W Beltline Hwy
Madison

ZIMBRICK NISSAN

5421 WAYNE TER
Madison

Zimbrick Saab & Used Imports Superstore

1809 W Beltline Hwy
Madison

ZIMMERMAN BODY SHOP

582 QUARRY ST
Baraboo

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Madison.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Auto Repair Shops
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money