Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Indianapolis Jewelry Stores

There are 16 top-rated jewelry stores in your area and 93 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 16 highly rated companies in Indianapolis

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Jewelry Store Articles

Go to the article: 

Former Pro Race Car Driver Rings up Success in Concierge Jewelry

.
Gold ring on shiny pocket watch expensive jewelry
Go to the article: 

Searching for a Unique Gift? Consider Custom Jewelry

.
Gold ring jewelry in hand over notebook appraisal
Go to the article: 

Finding a Worthy Jewelry Appraiser

.
Dirty work fingers thumb appraising ring jewelry with tool black dirt and diamond in gold

Jewelry reviews in Indianapolis

  • A
    JC Sipe Jewelers
    Excellent. We have purchased many jewelry items from Sipe Jewelers and my wife has always been very pleased with the service, selection and jewelry. Sipe Jewelers also has repaired and changed several pieces of jewelry and my wife has been very happy with the finished product in all cases. Sipe Jewelers is our go to location for jewelry and we highly recommend them.
    - CHARLES T.
  • A
    Heirloom Classics - Jewelry & Beads
    I had some loose beads that I wanted made into necklaces and bracelets, as well as other beaded jewelry that needed repair. Heirloom Classics did a wonderful job creating the jewelry and fixing the broken pieces I brought in. We discussed findings, to be sure they were what I wanted and it was such a pleasure to pick up finished pieces!
    - ROBYN P.
  • D
    Shane Co
    The only reason I am not giving Shane Co. 1 star is due to our first visit. Our first visit we were primarily going to just look but ended up trying on multiple styles and learning more about the diamonds. The staff was very friendly and patient with my girlfriend. They helped her hone in on the ring that she liked most. At the end of the visit, we had a plan of something we wanted to create (a unique design). A few weeks ago we my girlfriend's mother offered my girlfriend's grandmother's ring and we decided to go that route instead. I had hoped to go back to Shane Co. in order to have them resize, clean and strengthen the prongs holding the center diamond. However, they didn't keep the notes of what size my girlfriend was and then informed me that they would not be able to resize the ring due to the design of the smaller diamonds on the band. I then went into a small family owned jewelry store and they informed me of the exact opposite. The work I would like done is very possible and they will be able to do it in less than a week. In closing, it really depends on what you want from this place. If you want a unique store that is willing to go the extra mile for any customer, don't go here. They only want buyers purchasing rings of $4,000 or for you to go higher so they can finance you. If you are looking for a place that will be patient and help you out any way possible in hopes of you buying that $4,000 plus ring, then this place is for you. For me, we aren't going back here; I can get this type car salesmen service from Helzberg, Kay or Zales. For our engagement ring I'm sticking with Miller's Jewelry for repair and resizing and then going to Jared's to get our wedding bands designed. Lastly, please check out the link below prior to purchasing here. [*** Link removed ***]
    - jared n.
  • A
    Shane Co
    I did a fairly exhaustive search by going to five local jewelers and three internet websites looking for an unset diamond to put in a new mounting. I had taken the GIA diamond course several years ago, so I have a good knowledge of diamond quality factors. I had identified three diamonds at one of the internet sites which included the GIA certification for each stone. I compared the quality (color, cut and clarity) of these diamonds against similar diamonds at the local jewelers. Shane Co was the only local store that was willing to work with me on price (the sales person was Whitney). I ended up buying the diamond and new mounting at Shane Co. because I got an excellent diamond (G color and VS2 clarity) at a price similar to the internet options. I also liked Shane Co's lifetime warranty and free of charge semi-annual inspections and cleanings.
    - EDWIN S.
  • A
    KIRLES JEWELERS
    Great service. Gave a free evaluation of two rings. Very helpful and friendly. Will definitely use them in the future .
    - Thomas I.
  • A
    ARONSTAM FINE JEWELERS
    My husband decided on a Sunday that he wanted to propose to me on a trip we were taking on the following Friday. Everyone there was so helpful and they even promised they would have the ring sized, set and completely ready by Thursday! Four days! They were able to get everything done in four days! Our wedding bands were also custom made to match the pattern on my engagement ring. They told me I could come in any time to get my rings polished at no cost. It was always fun to get my rings back and realize how dirty they really were and have them back to their original sparkle! I went back in there about a month ago to have my 10 year old band fixed and it was done in less than a week without charge. They've also fixed a bracelet of mine that wasn't even purchased there.
    - Amy C.
  • A
    MASTER JEWELERS
    After getting an estimate from a high-end jeweler, I checked with Master Jewelers and was so pleased with their estimate and skilled job with my rings, I will never use anyone else!
    - JUDY L.
  • A
    WINDSOR JEWELERS
    Greg Bires was genius in how he reset all the diamonds in a new mounting. The ring is absolutely beautiful and I feel I have my parents with me every day.
    - Brenda L.
  • A
    Smith's Jewelers
    This well-established business on the town square seems always business, and for good reason. The staff is friendly, professional, and there to serve. Minor work is done while you wait and the prices are very reasonable. Have yet to make a jewelry purchase there but will eventually as they have a fine display of estate jewelry that is always tempting
    - Delbert S.
  • A
    Smith's Jewelers
    Excellent. Work performed immediately and successfully. Very friendly folks in this well-established business on courthouse square in Noblesville.
    - Delbert S.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!