Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Indianapolis Jewelry Stores

There are 9 top-rated jewelry stores in your area and 170 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 9 highly rated companies in Indianapolis

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Jewelry Store Articles

Go to the article: 

How to Pick the Perfect Engagement Ring

Go to the article: 

Former Pro Race Car Driver Rings up Success in Concierge Jewelry

Gold ring on shiny pocket watch expensive jewelry
Go to the article: 

Searching for a Unique Gift? Consider Custom Jewelry

Gold ring jewelry in hand over notebook appraisal

Jewelry reviews in Indianapolis

Real People ~ Real Reviews ~ Real Results

  • It went well overall. One of the prongs broke off within the first 48 hours, probably because of all the work they had done to the ring. When I brought the ring in the next day, they quickly agreed to replace the missing diamond and fix the broken prong at no charge. They also offered to clean and examine the ring for free at any time. The only thing I wasn't happy about was the overall cost. I chose to pay it, even though it was higher than another quote I had received, because several people had recommended them so highly - mainly based on their quality and integrity.
    - Lisa P.
  • Rudy’s Watch & Jewelry Repair in Brownsburg is great! I want to put in a good word for this wonderful business that I have gone to over the years. They have a great selection of watches. With the help of Monique, Nicole, Pablo, and Cherie, I found a perfect watch for my brother’s birthday! He wanted a stretch band, and they looked through boxes of watch bands to find the one that would work best with the watch. Nicole found the perfect band! They are so good with customers and really go the extra mile to make your visit the best! They are expert in metal frame repair—Jon did a soft weld on the frame to my brother’s glasses—and Monique is expert in cleaning frames and rings with an ultrasonic method that removes grime and tarnish without chemicals. The glasses looked new! His ring glistened! His smile was priceless! My glasses also looked better than they have in years! Rudy’s truly treats customers like family and made us feel special. I highly recommend this wonderful, honest, compassionate, and caring family business!
  • Great Family Business! Rudy's is across from the KMart and Kroger in Brownsburg at 124 E. Northfield Dr. (Suite G). Their email is, Phone: 317-299-6890. All of the techs--Pablo, Luis, Juan, Don--are wonderful and work together as a team. This is a family business: Owners Monique and her sister Nicole work there as well. Monique does watch repairs and replaced the movement of my watch (under warranty). Nicole and Cherie take care of orders. Monique did a great job! She goes the extra mile! She also cleaned the band of the watch around the inserts and replaced my scratched crystal with a new one. The watch looks brand new! I had some earrings that that were too tight, and Monique loosened the tension so that I can now wear them! I highly recommend Rudy's for watch and jewelry repair--they are family and treat their customers like family, too! I now go there for any watch or jewelry repair.
  • My wife had the stone fall out of her ring which quickly turned into the end of the world despite me telling her I was not mad and that things happen. My wife went into distinctive while I was in the car a crying mess and came out still crying but with tears of joy. They took great care of my wife replacing the stone and polishing it up for her. I now have a happy wife and thus I am happy. I am glad I chose Distinctive. We will continue to do business with them and refer friends and family to them. Great Service!
    - Joseph G.
  • They could not have been nicer about my mom's repairs. One ring wasn't very high quality and the stone was cracked. They pointed it out to me. In doing the repair, they either kept the original setting or made a very good duplicate. The band was fantastic. It was actually what my dad envisioned years ago, but another jeweler did a disappoint job. My mom loved the refurbished ring! They also took her wedding set and made a necklace just like my mom wanted and an infinity band as well. The cost was less than half what we expected. We were kept informed and advised throughout the process. I got screwed on a jewelry repair from the store where we purchased my engagement ring. Essentially, the stone chipped and they replaced it with a "lab enhanced" stone that looked like glass. Reis Nichols brought in a selection of replacement stones so I could chose which one I liked best. The stone wasn't an exact match, but it was a bigger and better stone than the original. They also polished it up for me and the ring looked better than when purchased.
    - Natalie R.
  • CH Jeweler Engraver repaired two silver bracelets.  One was a relatively easy addition of a safety chain.  However, the second bracelet involved adding new links to existing bracelet.  I didn't have extra links available so they made links for the bracelet.  It's beautiful!  I was so happy and excited to receive the bracelet, it looks great!

    - ROBYN P.
  • It went great. I used the $100.00 for $200.00 Aggies List coupon. The store offers snacks to the customers. The had a great valentines promotion at the time of my purchase. Makes you not want go to chain jewelry stores. Plus the chains upcharge the extras.
    - LARRY B.
  • I adore this place. Have been to a few different tattoo and piercing establishments and this one is by far my favorite. The staff and artists have a great expertise, patent, and very informative. Never felt like any question was to dumb. Everything I have had done here looks amazing.
    - Jason F.
  • I took in two rings to be checked out and have one resized. Kirles had made one of them for me about 10 years earlier but it was now too big. They took the one I thought needed the prongs checked and asked me to leave it for the jeweler to check out and put a ring guard on the one which was too big as a temporary fix until we could get a correct size from the one I was concerned about the prongs.Finding the right size was more complicated than normal because my fingers were puffy. I will be taking the one which needs resizing back soon. They cleaned and checked the other at no charge and said it was fine. The prongs were ok, I guess I just couldn't tell because it needed cleaning. They could have charged me for a repair I did not really need but we're completely ethical. Another jewlery store, a much bigger one, had cracked a ruby in that ring when I had taken it to be resized and didn't call and tell me about it until I went in to pick it up a week after they had said it would be done.
    - JOHN B.
  • This experience was so enjoyable. We told Kris that we had gone to another jewelry store and had been 'trapped' there for HOURS! She made sure to tell us everything that we needed to know and didn't bog us down with information that wasn't important to us. She made us feel well informed! 2 months later we are officially engaged and I still couldn't be happier with our ring choice! I would highly recommend Distinctive Diamonds! The staff was friendly and very helpful!
    - Samantha K.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!

  • 2 M CORP

    1321 W 86TH ST
    Indianapolis, IN