Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Indianapolis Insurance Companies

There are 37 top-rated insurance companies in your area and 1K to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

Over 4 million people rely on ...

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Select filters
  • Become a member to sort service providers.
  • Rating (hi-lo)
  • Rating (lo-hi)
  • # of reviews (hi-lo)
  • # of reviews (lo-hi)
  • Time on Angie's List (most-least)
  • Time on Angie's List (least-most)

Shop Offers from Local Insurance Companies

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Insurance Agent Articles

Go to the article: 

Do I Need Special Insurance When Remodeling?

remodeling contractor holds hammer on roof
Go to the article: 

Getting Insurance Quotes? Ask These Questions

white car
Go to the article: 

7 New Year’s Resolutions from Your Home

gingerbread house in Savannah
Join Angie's List Now To see all 37 highly rated companies in Indianapolis

Insurance Agent reviews in Indianapolis

Real People ~ Real Reviews ~ Real Results

  • My Dad was in the military and I was covered by Provider name locked. throughout my childhood. Once I became an adult, I shopped around for other insurance companies. I already knew no one could beat the customer service of Provider name locked. ...I was in 5 car wrecks through my teens and early 20s, and every single time I called Provider name locked. crying, they were so empathetic and helpful. They pay out claims immediately and reimbursed me for many extras, like towing between 3 facilities after a car wreck. The automobile insurance through Provider name locked. is actually cheaper than all competitors except Safe Auto and State Farm--both of those companies are known for poor customer service and fighting to pay out claims to their clients.
    I rented throughout my adulthood until last year--their prices for rental coverage were always cheaper than competitors.  When I purchased a home last year, of course I wanted to use Provider name locked. --but I still shopped around.  Unfortunately, Provider name locked. is one of the most expensive homeowner's insurance coverage from my research.  State Farm was $600, American Family was $800, and Provider name locked. is $1000.  I researched further, into how quickly all home insurance companies paid out claims, how they treat clients in need, and how often they go above and beyond the insurance agreement.  Provider name locked. is bar none the top in customer service, which is no surpriseto me.  During environmental disasters, like Provider name locked. or Hurricane Sandy, the people affected were treated terribly by all other insurance companies. State Farm still refuses to pay out claims to most of their clients from Hurricane Sandy.  The only insurance provider that immediately put families into hotels, paid out claims, and worked with their clients was Provider name locked. . I will never use another insurance company, Provider name locked. has proved time and again to me how valuable of a company they are.
    You do have to be tied to the military, at least within 3 generations of a military member by direct descendance, that is the only problem.
    - Audrey B.
  • He is amazing and helps with all my needs. He has helped with so many issues even outside of insurance needs. He is very kind and I really appreciate the way I am treated. He is a great resource and knowledgable. Easy to communicate with.
    - Stephen L.
  • I have been with them for many years. I have never had any issues with filing a claim or getting answers to questions about how we should handle certain situations. Either Provider name locked. or one of his associates always follows up with inquires in a timely manner. Usually the same day that I email or call I will receive a call back or a response to my email. I would highly recommend this group is you need insurance.
    - Christopher J.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Insurance Companies in Indianapolis

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.
To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!