-Find top-rated Service Providers
Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Columbus Health Insurance Providers

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Health Insurance Providers to Avoid

24

Top Rated Health Insurance Providers

23

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews
See Verified Local Reviews

Over 3,139 reviews for
Columbus Health Insurance Providers from people just like you.

C
"I had problems with them when they were changing over their computer system. If you ask me they have not totally been resolved. Going back to 2013 I corrected some" bills. The problem is you never get the same person when you call there.; you get whoever happens to answer the phone. They put the stuff in the system, which you don't really have any continuity if you are working on resolving an issue. They said it was right and I had some money coming back. Well, here it is, almost 2016 and I am still waiting for the money. I am in County. I just use my card wherever I go. I just go to a hospital or doctor and they bill and they eventually take care of the bill. I would say their price is competitive with other people. Nobody has been communicating with me for quite some time. I did all of the communicating, but it was all on behalf of my wife. The coverage is pretty good.

-Donald N.

F
"After numerous tests, dr visits, even though I had reached my deductible, all the services rendered to me were considered non covered. The EOBs differed from the" actual costs of the service. I ended up paying for the insurance as well as for the procedures and the tests. I did understand the policy and was aware of the lack of coverage, but Uniterd Health did not even authorize the providers to use the repriced charge--nor were they interested in working with me. I would never, ever use this company in any circumstance. I am changing tomorrow, even though I go on Medicare in 2 months. BEWARE!!!!

-Jan H.

+Join 3 Million People on Angie's List
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Over 3 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 3 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Columbus

help emergency guide

Emergencies happen to all of us, in all areas of life. But you can and will make it through, especially if you follow this one simple rule: Don’t panic.

elderly man smiling while talking to a physician

The Consumer Bill of Rights and Responsibilities ensures that patients receive a certain quality of treatment from health care professionals and guarantees that specific patient rights before, during, and after treatment are honored.

doctor takes patient blood pressure

Changes are coming to the 2016 healthcare marketplace, including more plan options and insurance rate increases.

A nurse checks a patient's blood pressure. (Photo by Photo by Brandon Smith)

If the fine print in your benefits plan gives you a headache, here are four simple questions you should ask your insurance company before you visit the doctor.

Angie's Answers

?
?
?
?
?
?

Hi,

 

This is Leah B. in Member Services, happy to help!

 

I may need more clarification in order to accurately answer your question. It sounds like you may be trying to locate or review health insurance brokers or agents. You may also be referring to Navigators hired by state and federal government to help people choose an Affordable Care Act plan prior to the sign-up deadline of March 31. In any case, we do not have a category to rate ACA Navigators at this time. If you want to review or locate an insurance provider, a specialist would be happy to help at 888-944-5478, or memberservices@angieslist.com.

Health Insurance reviews in Columbus

N

Rating
I was so relieved when took all of my information over the phone and completed the application process for me. Within days I received my insurance card and confirmation of coverage. I am very grateful to for making a daunting process virtually effortless. He is the best.
- Eliana D.
B

Rating
Generally find a doctor who accepts this insurance is very easy. We have almost never had any extra charges over and above what this and basic pays.
- Maureen K.
F

Rating
It is awful; it couldn't have been worse. The technology on the site has failed multiple times. Representatives have rarely been well-informed. To this moment, there is still no satisfaction for the issues I have had. I have spent hours on the phone with them. They claim that they will escalate the situation and get a resolution. I still have not ...More had any results. There have been serious problems. When I see commercials about how great and easy it is, I am livid. If I could avoid it, I would not use them again.
- Barb K.
F

Rating
I called on June 25, 2015 to request they send new cards. I explained that the card was missing & that we had found out by accident when we were trying to get my mother's medicince from the pharmacy. explained that it takes 5-10 business days in order for new cards to be sent to me. I then asked ...More for a supervisor & was willing to pay to have them overnight the cards or to send them priority mail. I finally spoke to a supervisor & was told that it would be sent out priority mail. The card actually ended up arriving on 07.08.15 in yesterday's mail via pre-sorted first class mail. I am highly upset that it was not sent priority mail as I was promised. I am disturbed at their misleading me, effectively they lied to me because they didn't do what they said they were going to do. I want someone held accountable for what they did. They didn't say that they couldn't do it or wouldn't do it, they said that they would do it & someone dropped the ball.
- Joyce Theresa P.
D

Rating
This past year has implimennted an new accouting system that can not handle plans with deductables correctly. Once I reached my decutable and they should have started paying for coverage, the mistakes began. They would new bills as coming under the deductable. I would call them up and point out the error ...More and ask them to pay the bill. They would notice that there was an "overage" in the deductable. Then instead of paying the new bill that they should have paid, they would pay a random old bill that I had already paiid and then told me that I was responcible for the new bill as part of the dedutable. They would not tell me which old bill that they paid, nor how to get my money back, nor why they would make such a foolish error. This happened over and over again. I ended up paying much more than my very high deductable and spending hours of time trying to solve their mistakes. They continue to claim that there is no way for them to fix the problem, nor to prevent it from happening again.
- MARGARET W.
F

Rating
I got a call from a sales agent from Blue Shield and sold me this policy and I was to believe that I could use pretty much provider that I wanted and they only had one provider for me to see and that person is about 17 miles away over on Panama City Beach which would have taken me an hour to get to. ...More And I called them and tried to set up an appointment and they wouldn't see me and do the cleaning on the first day. I had to make two trips out there. So I called the insurance company and they weren't gonna cancel my policy because there's no cancellation clause in it so I complained to the district and I got a letter in the mail saying they're canceling my policy. It was horrible. It's a scam basically.
- Edwin T.
A

Rating
Absolutely no problems with this provider. The services were great. Quick and professional. I shopped around for price and their fee is all inclusive so it was nice knowing that I was not going get multiple bills.
- Denise G.
F

Rating
This company has refused to cover my medication which wasn't a problem for 10 years and now some how I have this insurance company not a doctor telling me that my medication isn't required for my condition. I even had my appeal rejected .I was supposed to receive a phone call when they had it all worked out well, the call never came so don't ...More expect any help from calling them. These people are far from professional they could care aless about my health or the fact that I'm disabled. So if your looking for health insurance don't look there
- kevin H.

Health Insurance Providers in Columbus

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

AETNA

7400 W CAMPUS RD
New Albany

AETNA

4004 GREENERY DR
Columbus

AETNA

8101 N HIGH ST
Columbus

Aetna Inc

151 Farmington Ave

ANTHEM BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD

6740 N High St
Columbus

Ardina

1275 Kinnear Rd
Columbus

Argus Tech

23200 Forest North Dr Apt 801

Bruce Johnson Insurance

5648 TARA HILL DR
Dublin

Cheapest Insurance Deals

395 East Broad Street
Columbus

Daniel Gallagher

1798 Bassett Rd
Westlake

Diverse Home Care

1100 Morse Road Suite 102
Columbus

Embrace Pet Insurance

4530 Richmond Rd
Cleveland

Estate Planning Solutions

655 Metro Place South, Suite 600
Dublin

Glenn Insurance Group

3 W Main Street
Westerville

healthmarkets

250 w old wilson bridge suite 270

iHealthBrokers Medicare Advisers

1333 Temple Johnson Rd

InHealth Mutual

501 W Schrock Rd
Westerville

Jobes Insurance Agency, LLC

482 Harcourt Rd
Mount Vernon

KYM BUCHANAN AGENCY

444 Sycamore St
Urbana

Martin J Mitchell - Allstate Agent

3816 Fishinger Blvd
Hilliard

Max Moarefdoust Agency-Allstate Insurance

1190 County Line Rd
Westerville

Medical Mutual

2060 E 9th St
Cleveland

MEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO

9961 BREWSTER LN
Powell

MEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO

2600 CORPORATE EXCHANGE
Columbus

MEDIGOLD

6150 E BROAD ST
Columbus

MEDIGOLD

6150 E BROAD ST
Columbus

MMA Insurance

107 W COLUMBUS ST
Pickerington

NGS American

PO Box 7676

OHIO HEALTH

765 N HAMILTON RD
Columbus

Pathway Insurance Services, Inc

4221 Malsbary Rd
Cincinnati

Samuel Gallo MD

6620 Perimeter Dr
Dublin

Sanford Siegel LMT

20 E High St
Mount Vernon

Thomas Solutions Group, LLC

7779 Cheriton Cir
Reynoldsburg

United Health Care

9200 Worthington Rd
Westerville

United Health Care

PO Box 30555

USAA Bank

PO Box 33490

ValuMed of Columbus

1030 Alum Creek Dr
Columbus

Shop Local Health Insurance Services in Columbus

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Columbus.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Health Insurance Agency
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money