Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Cincinnati Tire Shops

There are 64 top-rated tire shops in your area and 257 to avoid.

After 20 years, it's now free to join.

  • More than 10 Million Verified Reviews
  • Nationwide Coverage
  • Trusted Ratings
Join Angie's List Now To see all 64 highly rated companies in Cincinnati

Explore Our Solution Center for Helpful Tire Shop Articles

Go to the article: 

What to Know About Switching to Power Brakes

classic car, drum brakes, power front disc brakes, rear drum assemblies, safety upgrade, safety changes,
Go to the article: 

5 Car Repairs You Shouldn't Skip

Oil change
Go to the article: 

Do Tire Patches Work?


Tire Buying And Repair reviews in Cincinnati

  • F
    Bob Sumerel Tire & Service - Florence
    Don't even think about taking your vehicle to this place! Took our brand new Lincoln Aviator there simply to have a slow leak in our tire checked out. Unbelievably they punctured our oil pan while hoisting it up on their lift! Their employees are clearly not trained appropriately to even use their lift, let alone repair anything correctly I must assume. They turned us over to their insurance company, Travelers, to deal with us. Haven't seen our car in nearly four months and have no idea when we will because there are no spare oil pans made by Ford yet. That isn't something Bob Sumerel can help, but this is 100% their responsibility and all Traveler's has done is to rent us a used vehicle less than a third the value of our vehicle Sumerel rendered completely inoperable. When calling Sumerel for assistance to compensate us fairly, they didn't even return our call, just sent a message directly to Traveler's to deal with us.
    - Barry J.
  • A
    Pretty good pricing compared to city garages. They do great work and have great quality Napa parts. Easier to make an appointment, but they will take walk-ins if not too busy or if it is an emergency. Very laid back and easy to do business with. The young man there is very respectful and kind. I prefer a small family owned garage over a big franchise shop. Genuine, laid back, wants to get you back on the road safely and quickly.
    - Brittany L.
  • A
    (This company is in Liberty Township, OH, however, the zip code causes automated systems to say, "Middletown") Dave is one of the best (if not the best) mechanics I have ever used. I am in my late 60's, so I have used many mechanics, and I know when their diagnostics make sense. I will not go into a lot of detail, but, the problem diagnoses precluded me having several types of catastrophic failures on distant travel. Dave keeps at it until he finds the problem. He is NOT a superficial mechanic. Aside from that, Dave doesn't wait for a question, he takes you step-by-step into the nature of the more complex problems, answers your questions, and always appreciates the need for excellent communications. The courteous nature of Dave, his co-workers, and his wife, Tracy (she's awesome), make the process a pleasant one. I go away wanting his shop to continue succeeding in car and customer care. The same amount of work at other auto-shops will cost you as much or more, and you won't go away with the confidence of knowing... "It doesn't get better than this!"
    - Harris&Fran C.
  • A
    Very well. Michelin tires I was interested in were in stock, reasonably priced, and installed in a timely manner.
    - PETER T.
  • A
    Burton's Collision Auto & Repair
    The quality of their work was excellent. The car was delivered back to me in great shape on the date promised. Price seemed reasonable to boot.
    - MICHAEL F.
  • A
    Burton's Collision Auto & Repair
    I highly recommend Burton's to anyone in need of auto repair. I had a claim with Allstate and was provided a list of associated repair shops. I looked at Angie's list and Burton's had the best reviews, and understandably so. They fit me in immediately and were even flexible when I wanted to come in earlier. They ordered parts and received them right away. Through the entire process, they kept me informed on the status of parts, completion, etc. Also, I had a tire with a nail. They got a great deal on a new tire and replaced that in the process. The entire staff was incredibly friendly, professional, and courteous. I have lived in the Cinci area for a few years, and haven't found an auto shop that I would consider "mine" until now. In addition to the the staff, they did a great job on the vehicle. My car is a white pearl, which can be hard to color match. They did a fantastic job with the match. The best part is upon receiving my car, they had cleaned it inside and out.... they even managed to get rid of the dog hair, kid messes! I just about felt like I got a full detail along with the repair. If you are trying to decide on a repair shop - through and insurance claim or not - go here without a doubt! We have already gone back to them to fix something on my husbands car... they are getting parts and repairing for less than what we would pay for the parts ourselves! You won't regret it. Thanks guys - obviously, I'm a very impressed customer.
    - Anne D.
  • A
    Mr. Godwrench Automotive
    They are very fair on the costs and we know we can trust Tim and his crew to fix what is needed and to do it right. He also is upfront with us in those times it just did not make sense to put more money into older vehicles. They have been quite the blessing to us.
    - Larry I.
  • A
    Stewart Tire & Auto Service Inc
    We used to live down the street from the person who owned it. You always feel like they are honest with what's wrong and only fix what's wrong.
    - Michelle S.
  • A
    Bob Sumerel Tire & Service - Blue Ash
    Because it was a speedometer they have to find out because there are only certain people that can do that. The speedometer was off by 6 MPH. He is my guy. They take everything.
    - Bob F.
  • A
    Kentucky Auto Service
    KY auto service is more than fair with all the work they do. They only did what was necessary and charged me less than anywhere else I had priced out. One thing that impressed me the most was that they diagnosed my vehicle correctly when the Toyota dealership failed to ***** the problem correctly. I have been amazed of how far above and beyond everyone goes to make sure that you are satisfied. I am torn by writing this review because it is a hidden gem and I almost want to keep it that way.
    - Sean C.
Join Angie's List to view provider's name.

Tire Shops in Cincinnati

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, JOIN ANGIE'S LIST NOW!