Comparing Cincinnati area trophy shops

Comparing Cincinnati area trophy shops

What services do you offer?

Susan Gilson: "We do all sorts of personalizations. We engrave metals, glass, crystal acrylic and specialized custom awards. We think of ourselves as engravers."

Theresa Mertle: "We do trophies, awards, plaques, apparel, silk screening, signs, banners and custom gifts."

Tim Mathis: "We have plaques, trophies and specialty items. We can put your name or logo on anything down on to your underwear."

Why should people choose you over an online company?

Gilson: "We're family owned and we've been in business since 1974. We're active in the community, and we're nice."

Mertle: "Because our prices are very reasonable and we have excellent customer service and quality."

Mathis: "We have a very personal touch. People like that."

What are some of the options for figures on top of trophies?

Gilson: "They can put anything they want on there. We do more customized things so we're a little more unique."

Mertle: "Well, we have a turkey with gym shoes on, goofy golfers and gag gifts. We range from funny all the way up to the very elegant."

Mathis: "Footballs, baseballs, bowling balls, horses' asses, musical notes - there are probably five hundred choices."

How do you charge for trophies?

Gilson: "It depends on if it's machine-engraved or hand-engraved. There's no set price - it depends on volume and the medium."

Mertle: "Our trophies range from more than $4 and go up depending on material and size. It depends on what you want."

Mathis: The basic trophy, a figure on a piece of marble, is $4 to $5. It goes up from there all the way into the hundreds."

How far in advance should people place their order?

Gilson: "Our turnaround is two days. If I need to order something, at least a week."

Mertle: "A week to ten days is a good amount of time."

Mathis: "I tell people I like a week but it can be next-day service if it needs to be."

What's the funniest or most unusual award or trophy request you've received?

Gilson: "We did the award in [the movie] 'The Great Debaters.' It was just fun to talk to people in the movie business."

Mertle: "Nothing really stands out. We try to personalize it for whatever the occasion."

Mathis: "I built a trophy of a shillelagh. It's an Irish walking stick."

Post New Comment


What is Angie's List?

Angie’s List is the trusted site where more than 3 million households go to get ratings and reviews on everything from home repair to health care. Stop guessing when it comes to hiring! Check Angie’s List to find out who does the best work in town.

Local Discounts

Daily deals up to 70% off popular home improvement projects from top-rated contractors on Angie’s List!