-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Middleton Auto Repair Shops

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Auto Repair Shops to Avoid

35

Top Rated Auto Repair Shops

124

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 1,298 reviews for
Middleton Auto Repair Shops from people just like you.

A
"Everything went smoothly and timely. They even touched up some major scratches on the car exterior. paint matched well and you could see the retouching but it was" an improvement with out additional costs.

-Janet & David B.

A
"Hands down BEST Body Shop I have ever dealt with. Unfortunately this is the third body shop I have had to use in the last 18 months. This is the first one who" took the time to explain the risks in his estimate, kept me informed along the way and actually came in UNDER his estimate!! The work was very high quality - impossible to see that any damage had been done and even addressed a couple of small dings that was not part of the scope of work. Definitely will be the body shop that I will use from now on!!

-Nancy T.

+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Middleton

Auto Repair reviews in Middleton

N

Rating
They give you a tour of the shop, or tell you to look around at all the cool projects. The shop manager is a good guy. The problem is the
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
artist shop owner “
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
” who has no problem ripping off his customers. Personally I can tell you that from my experience, I dropped off my car and I was told I would be contacted with an estimate. It was very
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
things like an oil change, change a hose, and tightening up a few bolts. I asked for an estimate and I was told it would take a day or two. Then I get an email saying the work is all done already and attaches an $750 bill! I question it naturally, and the owner's response was that he practically was doing me a favor by charging me so little. How is this guy in business?? I can confidently say based on my personal experience that
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
FROM
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
CORVETTES & CUSTOMS RIPS OFF HIS CUSTOMERS!!! Not only did he stick me with a huge bill, the work wasn’t even done!!! I asked for 1 hose to be changed - and it didn't even get done. The same leaky hose is still on car, almost $800 later. The garage does have some decent people working there (who should leave and move on to better things). But learn from my mistakes,
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
’t be a victim to this CHEAT and take your classic car business elsewhere. The guy says he wants to deal in cash and if you want to pay with a credit card, he tacks on an additional hefty percentage. In Dallas you have lots of options, and I would do everything to avoid dealing with this shady character. NOT RECOMMENDED!!!
- J B.
A

Rating
Super service! Dropped truck off and had it repaired within 2 days - ahead of schedule. A beautiful job at that!
- Bernie S.
A

Rating
Professional, friendly, efficient. Car was ready exactly when
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
said it would be ready. Excellent work.
- Delia M.
A

Rating
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
Body Shop was great. We can't say enough good things about our experience. They did a lot of work direct with the other drivers insurance company so we wouldn't have to. They found some things that were damaged that couldn't be seen until the back bumper was removed. They made sure everything was fixed to our satisfaction. They detailed the car when they were done as well. They updated us on a regular basis as to what was going on and how long the repairs were going to take. I highly recommend
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
's if you have auto body work that needs to be done on your vehicle.
- Joshua H.
A

Rating
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
called to schedule the drop off date and the week before we confirmed drop off day and time. The Monday morning I dropped off my car someone from the rental car place was there to pick me up. On Wednesday,
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
called to let me know how the repairs were going. It was ready for pick up on Friday. I dropped of the rental at
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
, pick up my car keys and drove off in my beautifully fixed car. I was happy with the repairs and how professional
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
was through the process; very little hassle with great results.
- Laura K.
A

Rating
Great family owned business. Fast quote, and scheduled service. Car auto body repairs were done quickly and at an affordable price! Can't even tell that anything was ever wrong! Great service.
- Andrew G.
F

Rating
While the Allstate claim was to replace the door, this body shop kept my car for two weeks and did not call to keep me "in the loop." I always had to call them regarding the progress of the work being done.
On at
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
two occassions, I called to ask them to check under the car, as I had hear a noise like something dragging. Allstate assurred me they would cover the extended cost. When I went to pick up the car, I inquired about the noise under the car. I was told there was a "piece of wood" I must have picked up, and it had been removed. Three minutes on the highway, the noise was back. I returned to the provider and showed them what was happening (yes, it took me THREE minutes to find). The manager involved took off in my car and said he would take care of it. No one could find him for a while; however, when he returned, the problem was still very visible. I was told the insurance had not included it in the original claim.
The day before I had a three-way conversation with Allstate, the provider, and myself. Again I asked about the noise. The Allstate provider any I were treated rudely and I the conversation ended with both of us not knowing what to expect next.
Again, they had my car for two weeks. They never called until the day it was to be picked up. The lied about a fax sent to Allstate. And they did not check on a problem I had inquired about three times.
They were rude, slow, and did not return phone messages.
I encourage anyone who DOES choose to use their service to stay on top of them every day and to make sure your insurance company maintains communication on an ongoing basis. I will never return to them and will spread my experience to others.
Raised voices on their part only added fuel to the fire.

- Patricia C.
A

Rating
Met
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
, discussed damage and price to repair, and date to begin that met my schedule. When I delivered car we reviewed work to be done we found front bumper was also damaged.. Without
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
's trained eye I would missed this problem. Upon agreed pickup the car was beautifully prep'd, like new. The interior was even cleaned. During all face-time
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
was professional yet friendly, easy to deal with. I would recommend
Middleton Auto Repair Shops Provider Name Locked
to anyone not wanting to go to "big shop" body repair experience especially if insurance is not involved i.e.your own "dime."
- david H.

Auto Repair Shops in Middleton, WI

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

A & K's Acoustic Edge

203 Phillips Blvd
Sauk City

AAMCO Transmissions

921 Walsh Rd
Madison

ABRA Auto Body & Glass - East Madison

3602 Cross Hill Dr
Madison

ADVANCE AUTO BODY

2533 ADVANCE RD
Madison

Aeschbach Automotive LLC

7182 US Hwy 14 Suite 102
Middleton

All-Tranzmission Services LLC

931 Stewart St
Madison

ALTERNATIVE AUTOMOBILE LLC

N6404 RIVER RD
Monticello

AMS

5380-C KING JAMES WY
Madison

Apex Auto Sales & Repair

3029 Milwaukee St
Madison

Applegate Auto

1217 Greenway Cross
Madison

ATTENTION TO DETAIL

801 ATLAS AVE
Madison

Auto Color Inc

2610 Parmenter St
Middleton

Auto Transporters Online

25108 Marguerite PKWY, Ste A-353

AUTO WORKS UNLIMITED

7510 CENTURY PL
Middleton

AutoPartsNerd.com

(no pick-up)

Ballweg Chevrolet-Buick Inc

783 Phillips Blvd
Sauk City

BENNETT'S OF MIDDLETON

3415 W. BELTLINE HWY
Middleton

BERGSTROM CADILLAC-HUMMER

1025 JONATHON DR
Madison

Bibliotech

Madison

BLUE CHIP

18 Greystone Cir
Middleton

Broadway Tire and Auto

801 E Broadway
Madison

Budd's Auto Repair

2422 Monroe St
Madison

CAMBRIDGE AUTOMOTIVE REPAIRS

501 VERBURG ST
Cambridge

Capitol Tire And Service

5610 Odana Rd
Madison

Car Care Clinic

2733 University Ave
Madison

Charlies Paintless Dent Repair

2115 Wood View Dr
Stoughton

Chet's Auto Svc & Repair Inc

PO Box 111
Mc Farland

Chet's Car Care Center

2020 Aberg Ave
Madison

Chrysler Dodge Jeep RAM of Madison

3502 Lancaster Dr
Madison

Clanton Muffler Center

4077-A Sullivan St

Conant Automotive Inc

1324 Us Highway 51 And 138
Stoughton

Copus Towing LLC

4775 County Highway B
Oregon

Costco Warehouse

2150 Deming Way
Middleton

CRAWLEY AUTOMOTIVE

6060 Keller Dr
Sun Prairie

Crestwood Auto Clinic

5325 Old Middleton Rd
Madison

D Mobile Media LLC

4510 femrite dr
Madison

DB's Service Center

902 Atlas Ave
Madison

De Forest Collision Repair Inc

416 N Main St
De Forest

Dent Free, Inc.

1536 North Maple Street
Ellsworth

Dimaggios Service Center

901 W Broadway
Madison

DISCOUNT TIRE

611 JUNCTION RD
Madison

Don Larson Chevrolet Cadillac Buick GMC

S3801 County Highway BD
Baraboo

DON MILLER SUBARU

801 E WASHINGTON AVE
Madison

Don Miller Subaru East, LLC

5339 Wayne Terrace
Madison

DuBois Auto Clinic

801 Atlas Ave
Madison

Dunn's Import Car Service Inc.

6516 University Ave
Middleton

Dutch's Auto Service Inc.

202 Regas Rd
Madison

East Madison Toyota

3501 Lancaster Dr
Madison

Eastside Transmission Service Inc

99 S Stoughton Rd
Madison

ECONOMY TRANSMISSION

7912 FORSYTHIA CT
Middleton

European Autowerks LLC

223 Jefferson St.
Cambridge

Exhaust Pros

3900 Monona Dr
Madison

Farm & Fleet of Madison Inc

2202 S Stoughton Rd
Madison

Firestone Complete Auto Care

7105 Mineral Point Rd
Madison

Flynn Audio LLC

Southwest Side
Madison

Ford’S Mobile Repair

1917 North Western Avenue
Madison

FOREIGN CAR SPECIALISTS

6805 Seybold Rd
Madison

Gary Wille's Auto & Tire Center

870 North Main St
Oregon

GATES AUTO BODY

202 W BELTLINE HWY
Madison

GATES AUTO BODY

7520 CENTURY AVE
Middleton

GATES AUTO BODY INC

5317 WAYNE TER
Madison

Gates Auto Body Inc

339 S Walker Way
Sun Prairie

Geek Squad - Best Buy

2452 E SPRINGS DR
Madison

Geek Squad - Best Buy

7357 W TOWNE WAY
Madison

German Auto House LLC

209 Swanton Rd Apt 5
Madison

Goodyear Auto Service Center

608 E Washington Ave
Madison

Handel Automotive Service

5705 Monona Drrive

Hansen's Auto Service Center

1405 S Park St
Madison

Harlans Hauling LLC

4510 Femrite Dr
Madison

Hill Automotive

3013 City Hwy Cx
Portage

Holiday Automotive Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac

321 N Rolling Meadows Dr
Fond Du Lac

Import Auto Clinic

129 N Franklin Ave
Madison

JENKS SERVICE CENTER

2318 S Stoughton Rd
Madison

Jiffy Lube - Madison

1102 E Washington Ave
Madison

Jiffy Lube - Madison

15 Junction CT
Madison

JIM PARKS AUTOMOTIVE

625 W NORTH ST
De Forest

JIM'S PAINT AND REPAIR

113 N DURKEE ST
De Forest

Kayser Automotive Group Stoughton

1411 Highway 51
Stoughton

KRAEMER AIR FILTER CO

8608 UNIVERSITY GRN
Middleton

LYNCH AUTO BODY INC

2305 ATWOOD AVE
Madison

M & M AUTO BODY

3720 MILWAUKEE ST
Madison

M & M Roadside Service LLC

Madison and Surrounding Area
Madison

MANNERS CO LLC

7182 US HIGHWAY 14
Middleton

Marc's Garage & Rockdale Towing

206 COMMERCE AVE
Cambridge

MAX MUFFLER

7984 COUNTY ROAD PD
Verona

McDermotts Service & Repair Inc

6525 Seybold Rd
Madison

Metro Ford & Kia

5422 Wayne Ter
Madison

Midas Muffler Co

1501 S Park St
Madison

MIDDLETON FORD

7520 CENTURY AVE
Middleton

MIDWEST ENGINE SERVICE, INC.

3712 MILWAUKEE ST
Madison

Montway Auto Transport

4740 N Cumberland Ave

MOORE'S TOWING & SERVICE

3802 MINERAL POINT RD
Madison

Mortensen's Auto Repair

104 S Rutland St
Brooklyn

Move My Automobile

5573 Bryan Drive

NAKOMA PLAZA AUTO, LLC

4514 VERONA RD
Madison

Neal's Towing Service

4212 Dempsey Rd
Madison

PORTAGE MOTORS L.L.C.

515 E WISCONSIN ST
Portage

Reliable Carriers Inc

41555 Koppernick Rd

Rock Auto LLC

6680 Odana Rd
Madison

ROMAN AUTO BODY

2409 DANIELS ST
Madison

Rose Custom & Collision LLC

5003 Femrite Dr
Madison

RPM Motors Inc

98 Hwy 69 N
New Glarus

RUFFIN' IT RESORT

635 STRUCK ST
Madison

Russ Darrow Group

3502 Lancaster Dr
Madison

Ryan's Auto Care Inc

160 Owen St
Lake Mills

SCHMIDT'S AUTO INC

1621 Beld Street
Madison

Schoepp's Motor

2424 S Stoughton Rd
Madison

SCOOTER THERAPY INC

12 N Few St
Madison

SHADEL AUTO & TRUCK CLINIC

107 E DODGE ST
Portage

SHERWOOD AUTOMOTIVE

1137 PARK AVE
Columbus

SID'S TIRE AUTO & MUFFLER

10 Shannon St
Edgerton

Smart Motors Toyota Scion

5901 Odana Rd
Madison

SMITH'S SERVICE CENTER

4313 NAKOOSA TRAIL
Madison

SPARKLE AUTO BODY

1 Sparkle Ct
Madison

SPEEDY MUFFLER

2450 E WASHINGTON AVE
Madison

SPRING HARBOR AUTO CLINIC

5530 UNIVERSITY AVE
Madison

STOUGHTON COLLISION CTR

140 WEST ST
Stoughton

Stoughton Tire & Auto

801 W Main St
Stoughton

Terrys Car Care

332 W Johnson St
Madison

THE RADIO DR

4806 E BROADWAY
Madison

The Tire Shop

114 Dodge St.
Portage

Tom's Auto Center Inc

5402 Paulson Rd
Mc Farland

Tonys Auto Repair & Towing

2792 South Syene Rd
Madison

Turn Two Auto

5400 King James Way
Madison

VERN'S BODY SHOP

7621 TERRACE AVE
Middleton

VERONA SERVICE

225 PAOLI ST
Verona

Walt's Garage

1117 State St
Black Earth

Wayne's Automotive

220 Cottage Grove Rd
Madison

West-Side Radiator Service

6814 Elmwood Ave
Middleton

Westside Service Center

2014 Freeport Rd
Madison

Wilde East Towne Honda

5555 High Crossing Blvd
Madison

WRENCH AUTO SERVICE

3113 Laura Lane
Middleton

Zapata Auto Repair

1014 Stewart St
Madison

Zimbrick Body Shop Fish Hatchery Rd

1601 W Beltline Hwy
Madison

Zimbrick Body Shop Sun Prairie

1877 W Main St
Sun Prairie

Zimbrick Body Shop, Stoughton Rd

1707 N Stoughton Rd
Madison

Zimbrick Buick GMC West

1601 W Beltline Hwy
Madison

Zimbrick Honda

1601 W Beltline Hwy
Madison

Zimbrick Honda Service Center

430 Grand Canyon Drive
Madison

Zimbrick Hyundai West

320 W Beltline Hwy
Madison

Zimbrick Isuzu/Imports Service Center

1601 W Beltline Hwy
Madison

ZIMBRICK NISSAN

5421 WAYNE TER
Madison

Zimbrick Saab & Used Imports Superstore

1809 W Beltline Hwy
Madison

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Middleton.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Auto Repair Shop
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money