-Find top-rated Service Providers
Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Middletown Car Dealerships

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Car Dealerships to Avoid

97

Top Rated Car Dealerships

6

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews
See Verified Local Reviews

Over 294 reviews for
Middletown Car Dealerships from people just like you.

D
""Repeated bad service forces me to write this..I have serviced my MDX a couple of times at . The first time," I spent more than a few thousand dollars and they were regular in updating me. But when I got the car back, I still had some issues. The second time, I had specifically requested a loaner car when I was going to drop by car for service which they had agreed to, but when I went there there was none. I was to go to airport to pick someone up (which I had specifically told them earlier) and I was kept waiting. After a while, I could not wait and I left. I came back to give the car for service the next day and got a loaner (they did give a discount due to inconvenience). May be I should have learnt by then, but I did not! I had scheduled for another service a few weeks ago and was supposed to get a loaner. I went there, waited... and waited... After 20 minutes or so, no service rep, no loaner and I walked out. I normally don't vent for bad service, since I think may be someone is having a bad day and it is an isolated incident, but a premier car dealer having such poor customer service repeatedly deserves to be pointed out. This has been very frustrating and disappointing.

-RAJESH K.

F
"I purchased a car off eBay from this company and had it shipped. It was described as having "flawless paint". When I received it, I noticed paint bubbled-up" on the rear quarter panels. I notified the seller who offered to pay for some of the cost to have the rust repaired. They stopped answering emails and phone calls and never sent the money.

-Harry F.

+Join 3 Million People on Angie's List
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Over 3 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 3 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Middletown

Auto Sales and Financing

You must take certain steps when buying a car to protect yourself. Whether you buy a new or used car, there are common procedures which will help you avoid a lemon and maximize your investment.

new car (Photo by Angie's List)

Compare auto financing options before buying a new car, truck or SUV to get the best loan rate and terms.

Picture of a car hood up
Auto Service, Auto Sales,

An auto warranty is like a safety net for your car. But make sure you know what's covered.

rear view mirror

Many consumers skip the test drive and buy a new car without knowing what they like or dislike about it.

Local Motors uses a 3-D printer to build its new car, the Strati. (Photo courtesy of Local Motors)
Auto Body Work,

National Harbor will be home to a Local Motors facility where customers can 'print out' their new Strati

Angie's Answers

?

Personally, I would never spend the money on a new car, regardless of any incentives offered.  Nor would I ever buy a used car from an individual.  You never know what is under the hood...

I would find a reputable dealership and look for a certified pre-owned vehicle that has a clear carfax report, and a make/model that is highly rated by Consumers Report or another reputable source.  I'm going thru that process right now. I'm taking my time until the right vehicle comes up for sale thru a dealership I trust.   

?

For donation options, here is a link to a prior response -

http://answers.angieslist.com/were-place-donate-car-q27711.aspx

For sale, here is another answer I previously gave to same type question -

http://answers.angieslist.com/how-sell-damaged-auto-q57349.aspx

?
?
?

Sounds like your biggest problem will be narrowing your list to a limited number of models, and deciding what brand names you are willing to consider to narrow the field.

You can search for websites blogging complaints for each model you are considering to see how they rate with users, and you can also go to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration website at     www.nhtsa.gov     to see how many recalls there have been on a specific model and year.

Most dealers these days have websites with their listed prices for new and used cars that you can browse to get an idea of available listed prices.

I would also recommend that you check out the used car values (free) for models you might be interested in on    www.edmunds.com    and on Kelley Blue Book  -  www.kbb.com

Those 2 sources will give you a lot of negotiating power, because they list what the dealer pays the manufacturer on new cars, shows what people have been paying for each vehicle model and model year, and shows used valuations also. There are undoubtedly other such sources also - these are just the ones I have used and seem to be the best known.

?

Car Dealership reviews in Middletown

F

Rating
Right after buying the new car I was driving over railroad tracks and it was very rough. Everyone said it was fine, even the President said it was fine, making me feel crazy. Turns out they didn't deflate some of the air out of the tires. I needed some work done and the two times I took it back I had a horrible service, leaving grease on the seats ...More and the headlights not hooked up. I am very unhappy with their professionalism and service.
- lucia D.
A

Rating
It has gone very well. The customer service is very friendly and they have been very punctual. Also, my actual car buying experience went really well and the salesman worked very hard to get me into the right car.
- Jeffrey D.
N

Rating
DO NOT BUY FROM THIS DEALERSHIP. We assumed that since was owned by the of the city, that they would operate in a manner of integrity. We were wrong. We were in an emergency situation when we went to buy a car, ended up purchasing a vehicle above KKB value with multiple problems. We were told that one ...More of the problems (low tire pressure) would be fixed, but when it turned out to be a nail in a tire (discovered after the sale, despite car going through an inspection before sale), the dealership refused to repair the tire because it wasn't in writing. We inquired about tha battery since it was a hybrid and were assured that it had already been replaced or was in perfect condition. Unfortunately, within days we were seeing issues that turned out to be related to the battery. Now, nine months later, we have to pay around 3k to replace the battery after being discouraged from purchasing an extended warranty and the dealership is absolved of all responsibility despite our certainty that we were knowingly sold a failing car. To make matters worse, we were informed that our battery could have caught fire and endangered ours and our child's lives. After consulting with hybrid experts, we are certain that the dealership knew the battery was failing and chose not to disclose. We will never buy from here again and will discourage all friends and family from ever doing so.
- Brigette Y.
N

Rating
DO NOT BUY FROM THIS DEALERSHIP. We assumed that since was owned by the of the city, that they would operate in a manner of integrity. We were wrong. We were in an emergency situation when we went to buy a car, ended up purchasing a vehicle above KKB value with multiple problems. We were told that one ...More of the problems (low tire pressure) would be fixed, but when it turned out to be a nail in a tire (discovered after the sale, despite car going through an inspection before sale), the dealership refused to repair the tire because it wasn't in writing. We inquired about tha battery since it was a hybrid and were assured that it had already been replaced or was in perfect condition. Unfortunately, within days we were seeing issues that turned out to be related to the battery. Now, nine months later, we have to pay around 3k to replace the battery after being discouraged from purchasing an extended warranty and the dealership is absolved of all responsibility despite our certainty that we were knowingly sold a failing car. To make matters worse, we were informed that our battery could have caught fire and endangered ours and our child's lives. After consulting with hybrid experts, we are certain that the dealership knew the battery was failing and chose not to disclose. We will never buy from here again and will discourage all friends and family from ever doing so.
- Brigette Y.
F

Rating
The dealership changed their name In November 2015. When the car was purchased, it came with a lifetime oil change contract. When they changed their name, the cancelled all lifetime oil changes. This is affecting many customers. They are not calling people to advise them of the change. Just come in next time for your oil change and let them say ...More "SURPRISE". This was a major selling factor for many people. Very dishonest company.
- Sandra P.
N

Rating
They did the inspection on my car and it should've never passed inspection because the brakes and the turn signals do not work. I have print out of who did the inspection and 's employee signed the inspection as a certified inspection expert. I called the number on the internet and it is a fax number. I can't ...More get ahold of them at all.
- Richard E.
A

Rating
I knew what type of car I wanted. They found the car and had it shipped in. Everything was what I wanted. There was not a lot of negotiations. The place was very clean and pleasant. I did ask a lot of questions and the sales person did have to look up the answers for me. I have also been there for the service and it did not take long and it was very good.
- Arlene E.
A

Rating
They are quick, they are efficient, their prices are reasonable. But what I really like is when I asked them to double check some stuff on my car and I have never felt like they are adding or tacking on additional work that needs done. Very honest!
- DAVID & KIMBERLY H.

Car Dealerships in Middletown, PA

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

AFG Tire & Auto Service

4685 Carlisle Road
Gardners

AIC AUTO SALES

BLACK RD
Quarryville

Apple Honda

1212 Loucks Rd
York

Apple Nissan

1510 Whiteford Rd
York

Arnold's Garage

15 South River Street
Maytown

Auto First Sales

6506 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

AUTO FIRST SVC CTR

6506 CARLISLE PIKE
Mechanicsburg

Auto Transporters Online

25108 Marguerite PKWY, Ste A-353

AUTOHAUS LANCASTER INC

1373 MANHEIM PIKE
Lancaster

BIG LOT MOTORS

PO Box 3052
York

BILL BORING'S USED CARS, LLC

2415 W MARKET ST
York

BILL COLLINS COLLECTOR FORDS

1801 OBERLIN RD
Middletown

BLEVINS INC

621 KREIDER DR
Middletown

BOB NISSLEY'S AUTO CTR

405 SPRUCE ST
Middletown

Bob Ruth Ford

700 N. US RT 15
Dillsburg

CarMart Automotive

147 Hamilton Ave
York

Chapman Ford Lancaster

5201 Main St
East Petersburg

Clift Auto Sales

1236 East Main Street
Annville

Coke's Auto Repair

3535 N 6th St
Harrisburg

Conover Racing & Restoration Inc

1016 Old Westminster Rd
Hanover

Countryside Auto Center

3072 N Reading Rd
Adamstown

CRUISE AMERICA MOTORHOME RNTL

1998 W HARRISBURG PIKE
Middletown

DEALS ON WHEELS AUTO SALES

304 E MAIN ST
Middletown

EDEN TIRE & AUTOMOTIVE INC

1713 NEW HOLLAND PIKE
Lancaster

El-Mor Chevrolet

3820 E Main St
Morgantown

Faulkner Buick GMC Harrisburg

2650 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Faulkner Cadillac

6643 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

Faulkner Dodge Ram

6720 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

Faulkner Honda

2020 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Faulkner Hyundai

2060 Paxton St
Harrisburg

FAULKNER NISSAN

3925 PAXTON ST
Harrisburg

Faulkner Subaru

3233 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Freedom Toyota Harrisburg

6060 Allentown Blvd
Harrisburg

Freysinger Hyundai

6115 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

Freysinger Mazda

6155 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

FRONT LINE MOTORS

719 ROTHSVILLE RD
Lititz

GARDNER MOTORS

218 Hershey Road
Elizabethtown

Graham Motor Company

1402 Holly Pike
Carlisle

GREYLAG CORP

2100 W HARRISBURG PIKE
Middletown

Hanover Honda

1226 Carlisle St
Hanover

Harry Cramer Inc

1998 W Harrisburg Pike
Middletown

Hondru Chevrolet of Elizabethtown

2005 S Market St
Elizabethtown

Jack's Auto & Aero

231 Race St
Bainbridge

Jacks Auto Sales and Service

2189 W Harrisburg Pike
Middletown

Jones Honda

1335 Manheim Pike
Lancaster

K & A AUTO SALES

117 Sunrise Dr
Middletown

Keim Chevrolet Inc

3265 Lincoln Hwy E
Paradise

keisers Service Center Inc

2401 Gettysburg Rd
Camp Hill

KELLER BROTHERS FORD

730 S BROAD ST
Lititz

KELLERS AUTO REPAIR

35 BELMONT RD
Gettysburg

KELLY CADILLAC

1986 STATE RD
Lancaster

Lancaster Mitsu

1009 N Prince St
Lancaster

LINCOLNWAY SALES & SVC INC

586 W KING ST
Abbottstown

Lititz Car Company

723 S Broad St
Lititz

M & R Auto Center

535-B E Ross St
Lancaster

M&S Auto Service Inc

2 E 2nd St
Hummelstown

Maguire's Ford Lincoln Mercury

100 N Thistledown Dr
Palmyra

Manheim Car King Inc

3570 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Marysville Motor Cars Inc

700 N State Rd
Marysville

McCafferty Ford of Mechanicsburg

6320 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

McCafferty Kia of Mechanicsburg

6302 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

MIKE JONES AUTO SALES

900 ROOSEVELT AVE.
York

National Tire & Battery

1431 Manheim Pike
Lancaster

Nevin's Automotive Sales Hanover

548 Carlisle St
Hanover

New Holland Ford Isuzu

508 W Main St
New Holland

New Holland Scion

524 W Main St
New Holland

NOAKER'S AUTO BODY & SALES LLC

819 NEW BLOOMFIELD RD
Duncannon

Oasis Auto Group

7 Lismore Pl
Mechanicsburg

Obsidian AUTO GROUP LLC

485 E Main St
Middletown

OLD GOLD AUTO SHOP

969 HORSESHOE PIKE
Lebanon

Performance Diesel Warehouse

8211 Rabbit Lane
Grantville

PINE MANOR HOMES

3857 E HARRISBURG PIKE
Middletown

Red Lion Chevy

3220 Cape Horn Road
Red Lion

Redline Auto LLC

520 N Enola Rd
Enola

RENN KIRBY CHEVROLET

523 N QUEEN ST
Littlestown

Renn Kirby Chevrolet-Buick

55 Expedition Trl
Gettysburg

Roberto's Towing and Service Center

401 East Cumberland Street
Lebanon

Route 94 Motors, LLC

1155 700 RD
New Oxford

Shore Auto Lease Inc

1913 Atlantic Ave

South Hanover Automotive

852 Baltimore St
Hanover

Sterling Motor Car

4352 Oregon Pike
Ephrata

STETLER DODGE

1405 ROOSEVELT AVE
York

Sweet Automotive

1200 E Main St
Palmyra

THORNTON CHEVROLET INC

180 S MAIN ST
Manchester

Trailer Superstore!

6799 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

Turner Kia

4201 Chambers Hill Rd
Harrisburg

Vision Porsche Audi & VW

2746 Bernville Rd
Leesport

VNOSM

617 EMERALD ST HARRISBURG PA
Harrisburg

WARWICK AUTOPARK

700 FURNACE HILLS PIKE
Lititz

Werner Brothers Pre Owned Auto

389 Leaders Heights Rd
York

Whitmoyer Auto Group

1001 E Main St
Mount Joy

WILLIAM H WESSELS USED CARS

811 N US HIGHWAY 15
Dillsburg

Winters Automotive LLC

PO Box 301
East Prospect

Xtremepa

PO Box 154
Hanover

YOUR AUTO SOURCE INC

2249 Bannister Street
York

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Middletown.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Car Dealership
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money