-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Lancaster Tire Shops

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Tire Shops to Avoid

138

Top Rated Tire Shops

29

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Only 17% of Lancaster Tire Shops are reliable
  • Tardiness is the #1 complaint against Lancaster Tire Shops
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 535 reviews for
Lancaster Tire Shops from people just like you.

B
"I have been going to this service center back in the days when it was Tire Center but also managed by
. Service has been great and I stayed" when it became a Firestone store, as
was the manager.

-Joseph S.

A
"He's absolutely someone you can trust. They did a great job. We buy all our tires there. They have the best tires at the best prices. No one's close. I" would absolutely recommend them to others.

-Robert E.

+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Lancaster

Tires

Tires not only transfer the engine’s horsepower directly to the road, their grip ensures your car handles, turns and brakes safely. Overlooking tire maintenance can lead to poor fuel economy, poor handling and possibly hazardous driving conditions.

snowy house
Garage Doors, Roofing, Holiday Decorating, Gutter Cleaning, Pest Control/Exterminating, Lawn & Yard Work, Carpet Cleaning, Chimney Sweep, Fireplaces, Electrical, Handymen, Housecleaning, Animal & House Sitting, Cabinet Refacing/Restoration, Lighting, Wallpapering, Plumbing, Heating & A/C, Auto Service, Auto Tires, Allergy & Immunology

It's the time of year when the winter weather can take a toll. Follow this winter maintenance checklist to protect your home, your car and your health.

If you live in an area with frequent snowfall, it's wise to make sure that your tires have enough traction depth for slippery conditions. (Photo by Fred Patton).
Auto Tires

The special tread design of snow tires, also known as winter tires, allows drivers to move easily through snow and ice, say tire experts on Angie’s List.

Causes of tire dry rot.
Classic cars, Auto Tires

Mechanics say you shouldn't drive with tires that have dry rot. Learn how you can repair tire dry rot and what steps you can take prevent it.

Many new cars are not equipped with spare tires, forcing their owners to find alternatives. (Photo courtesy of Marc Yount's Tire Pros in Evans, Ga.)
Auto Tires

In an effort to increase fuel efficiency, many manufacturers are eliminating the car spare tire from new vehicles. How much does it cost to add a spare tire?

Tire Buying And Repair reviews in Lancaster

A

Rating
I had taken the car just for air (5 service stations had broken pumps) with the intent to set up an appt. Instead they checked all the tires (others were low) discovered the problem. They offered me the choice of attempting to fix then, but a part could break leaving me without a car. They ordered the part ultimately not needed when I returned in 2 days. All is well. I have used them many times and have always been pleased. They don't nickel and dime. They are knowledgable and do good work.
- Barbara H.
A

Rating
I think they are fairly straightforward. They told us about the choices we had and we didn’t feel any high pressure at all from the service people. They seem to be friendly and customer oriented.
- PHILIP C.
A

Rating
We have been using their services for many years. They are usually reasonable in price and I feel that they are fair. If you
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
’t know a lot about cars, you have to trust the person. They are honest and trustworthy. They are really busy and I would suggest planning ahead a bit for scheduling. My car is always ready when he says it will be, unless there was a part needed. We will continue to use their services.
- DAVID P.
F

Rating
Last 11/17/2014, I went to the store, my 2006 Honda element was with some noise in the front, they told left the car we will call you.
2 hrs. later they called me and said; YOUR CAR NEED, FORNT & REAR BRAKE PADS, BRAKE SHOES, BRAKE ROTOR FRONT AND REAR VKAKE ROTOR.
$ 735.60 dlls TOTAL, I asked them with all this part the car will be fixed, THEY SAID YES ABSOLUTELY.
3 hrs, later after I approve the cost they called me "your car is ready" when I arrived "Sorry your car is not ready", ok I went back to
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
house, finally around 7:00 P.M., they called me again, "your car is ready" I went again to the store and yes again ' YOUR CAR IS NOT READY SORRY" THE MANAGER
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
, they delivered my car at 10:30 P.M., yes 10:30 P.M.
Next day 11/18/2014, I drove the car and surprise: THE CAR HAVE THE SAME PROBLEM, YES EXACTLY THE SAME PRBLEM, I called to the store, they told me please come with the car to inspect again, the car are busy every day.
finally I went on 01/17/15, oil change, state inspection, and new windshield blades and obviously fix the noise, they called me 5 hrs. later, your car is ready.
I went to the store they FORGOT CHANGE THE BALDES, and incredible the noise still at the car, after drove with the technician and the manager, they told me come back to inspect the car again.
I went on 2/16/15, after 5 hrs. they called me and said:
SORRY WE CAN'T DO NOTHING, THEY TOLD ME THAT I MUST TO GO TO THE HONDA DEALER, PROBABLY THEY COULD FIX IT, SORRY WE CAN'T DO NOTHING,
AND MY MONEY I ASKED, SORRY WE CAN'T REIMBURSE YOUR MONEY"
Really this is incredible, the "manager"
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
, never spoke with me "he's busy really busy" they told me.
Now I lost $ 735.60 dlls.
and my car have the same problem.
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
de
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
.
- GABRIEL D.
A

Rating
He could have sold me more expensive tires but he found a much better quality for less with a better warranty. I was told by the dealership that I need a front end alignment. I called
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
and he said he doesn't do alignments there and instead of being a middleman, he told me which company he goes to get alignments done. They told me there that I didn't need the alignment after all.
- Susan T.
A

Rating
They do an excellent job. They are very forthright and honest. They referred the electrical work on my 1984 Lincoln to an electrical specialist. They paid the specialist themselves to take care of it. The car starts up all the time.
- David A.
D

Rating
I normally do not like to write bad reviews. However, I had such a negative experience with this company when I needed to get my two front tires replaced. Not only did I have to wait such a long time just to talk to someone, but the gentleman tried to up sell me on more expensive tires stating that they did not carry the same ones that I had. I know that they have been around a long time so maybe I just came at a bad day, but the employee I spoke to just seemed too stressed out to really care.
Needless to say, I ended up saving a bunch of money by ordering online at TireRack.com instead.
- Karen D.
B

Rating
The staff is good. Had issues in the past, but typically professional. I can drop my car off and they will do good work within time. I have never had them try to sell me anything that I did not need. They helped me save money by recommending a different place for certain services.
- Lara N.

All Tire Shops in Lancaster, PA

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

A&B Automotive

415 South Market Street
Mechanicsburg

AAMCO Transmissions & Total Auto Repair

1117 Lancaster Ave
Reading

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

1274 LITITZ PIKE
Lancaster

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

2038 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

1003 E KING ST
Lancaster

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

1282 MILLERSVILLE PIKE
Lancaster

Al's Auto Parts & Service

1301 N Sherman St
York

AMERICAN SPEED CTR-LANCASTER

1714 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

Apple Nissan

1510 Whiteford Rd
York

Arnold's Garage

15 South River Street
Maytown

AUTO TECH AUTOMOTIVE CENTER

9156 ALLENTOWN BLVD
Grantville

AUTO ZONE

2121 COLUMBIA AVE
Lancaster

Autocamp Tire & Auto Service Ctr

3609 Hartzdale Dr
Camp Hill

AUTOMOTIVE MASTERS LLC

2090 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

AUTORAGEOUS AUTO CUSTOMIZING

309 HARRISBURG AVE
Lancaster

B & E Automotive Services Ctr

200 N Walnut St
Mechanicsburg

B & J AUTOMOTIVE

3634 COLUMBIA AVE
Lancaster

Beasley Ford Lincoln

1801 WHITEFORD RD
York

BEAST Automotive

106 North High Street
Duncannon

Beaver Valley Auto Service

2442 Beaver Valley Pike

Blatt & Tillett Truck and Trailer Repair, LLC

10630 Allentown Blvd
Jonestown

BLAZER'S BODY SHOP

13 S YORK RD
Dillsburg

Brookside Collision

33 Industrial Rd
Ephrata

BYERS TIRE SALE

6470 CARLISLE RD
Dover

Callen Kinback Inc

905 Market St
Lemoyne

CAR FIXERS AUTO REPAIR

5170 Lincoln Hwy W
Thomasville

CAR-MIC ENTERPRISES INC

789 FLORY MILL RD
Lancaster

CarMart Automotive

147 Hamilton Ave
York

CARQUEST AUTO PARTS

1285 MANHEIM PIKE
Lancaster

CARSON'S SOUTHSIDE AUTO & TIRE

820 HERSHEY AVE
Lancaster

Carson's Southside Tire and Auto

820 Hershey Ave.
Lancaster

Chapman Ford Lancaster

5201 Main St
East Petersburg

Chris' Automotive Repair Shop

243 S REAMSTOWN RD
Ephrata

Ciocca Honda

8001 Allentown Blvd
Harrisburg

CNM Auto Repair

202 Seymour st
Lancaster

Coke's Auto Repair

3535 N 6th St
Harrisburg

COOL-TECH

1034 N LIME ST
Lancaster

Costco Tires

5125 Jonestown Rd
Harrisburg

CUSTOM HOT WHIPS LLC

470 N Franklin St
Lancaster

D & D Auto Service

808 W Trindle Rd
Mechanicsburg

D & L AUTO ACCESSORIES

606 Rohrerstown Rd
Lancaster

D-M TIRE SUPPLY INC

501 SERVICE RD
Lancaster

Daddario Tire & Auto

1464 Manheim Pike
Lancaster

dayne's automotive

328 e main st
Palmyra

DEARDORFF'S AUTO SVC

108 S MAIN ST
Dover

Done Right Autoworks

480 Hemlock Ln
Etters

E-TOWN AUTO PARTS

220 W HIGH ST
Lancaster

EARLE BLACK'S GARAGE

5490 HANOVER RD
Hanover

EDEN TIRE & AUTOMOTIVE INC

1713 NEW HOLLAND PIKE
Lancaster

ELM CHEVROLET

301 E Church St.

EMORY TRANSMISSION

1599 Hummel Ave
Camp Hill

Evans Auto Repair

2350 Grandview Dr
Etters

Fadely's Auto Masters & Tires

3177 W Market St
York

Faulkner Hyundai

2060 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Faulkner Subaru

3233 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Faulkner Toyota

3400 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

4719 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

1143 Quentin Rd
Lebanon

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

180 N NORTHERN WAY
York

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

1530 OREGON PIKE
Lancaster

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

395 Eisenhower Dr
Hanover

FIRESTONE STORES

700 N 2ND ST
Harrisburg

FIRESTONE STORES

2201 PAXTON ST
Harrisburg

FIRESTONE STORES

208 W ORANGE ST
Lancaster

Freysinger Hyundai

6115 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

G & G AUTOMOTIVE

2511 S GEORGE ST
York

GARDNER MOTORS

218 Hershey Road
Elizabethtown

GILBERT'S AUTOMOTIVE

32 PITNEY RD
Lancaster

Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co

1151 Mae St
Hummelstown

Graham Motor Company

1402 Holly Pike
Carlisle

H & F TIRE SVC

1834 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

Hanover Honda

1226 Carlisle St
Hanover

Harry Cramer Inc

1998 W Harrisburg Pike
Middletown

Hess Garage Inc

145 Gettysburg Pike
Mechanicsburg

Hirt Motorsports LLC

11 Kamp street
Duncannon

Hoffman Ford

5200 Jonestown Rd
Harrisburg

Hondru Chevrolet of Elizabethtown

2005 S Market St
Elizabethtown

Hondru Chevrolet of Manheim

350 South Main St
Manheim

Hondru Ford of Manheim

300 South Main St
Manheim

HORACE KRUGER

1675 COLUMBIA AVE
Lancaster

Jack Giambalvo Motor Co

1390 Eden Rd
York

Jack Williams Tire & Auto Service Centers

4611 Jonestown Rd
Harrisburg

Jack's Auto & Aero

231 Race St
Bainbridge

Jacks Auto Sales and Service

2189 W Harrisburg Pike
Middletown

JONES GM PARTS

1335 MANHEIM PIKE
Lancaster

K & J AUTOMOTIVE REPAIR LLC

239 RIDGE AVE
Hanover

keisers Service Center Inc

2401 Gettysburg Rd
Camp Hill

Keystone Trailer Services

100 W Crone Rd
York

L H ZIMMERMAN GARAGE

730 GLENWOOD DR
Ephrata

Lawrence Chevrolet

6445 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

Leach's Automotive Service

609 Market St
Lemoyne

LINCOLNWAY SALES & SVC INC

586 W KING ST
Abbottstown

Maguire's Ford Lincoln Mercury

100 N Thistledown Dr
Palmyra

Main Car Care LLC

57 Loccust Grove RD
York

MANOR AUTO

850 MANOR ST
Lancaster

MARTIN'S TIRE SVC

102 W BURKHOLDER DR
Lititz

McCafferty Ford of Mechanicsburg

6320 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

MEALS ON WHEELS HEMPFIELD

1520 HARRISBURG PIKE
Lancaster

Meineke Car Care Center

6510 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

MEM Automotive

936 York St
Hanover

MIDAS AUTO SVC EXPERTS

2070 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

Midas Harrisburg

2471 Paxton St
Harrisburg

MONRO MUFFLER BRAKE & SERVICE

10 Anchor Rd
Elizabethtown

Mose's Gulf Service

1885 W Market St
York

Mr Tire Auto Service Ctr

884 E Main St
Ephrata

National Tire & Battery

1431 Manheim Pike
Lancaster

New Holland Ford Isuzu

508 W Main St
New Holland

New Holland Scion

524 W Main St
New Holland

NOAKER'S AUTO BODY & SALES LLC

819 NEW BLOOMFIELD RD
Duncannon

PEIFFER AUTO REPAIR

301 MACLAY ST
Harrisburg

PEP BOYS MANNY MOE & JACK

1700 FRUITVILLE PIKE
Lancaster

PEP BOYS MANNY MOE & JACK

2080 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

PEP BOYS#380

908 W STREET RD
Lancaster

PILGRIM'S CAR CARE CENTER

367 ROSE AVE
York

Precision Tune Auto Care

55 Eisenhower Dr
Hanover

Pros Now

45 S 8th street
Lemoyne

Quality Service Center

28 S Oxford St
York

Racekrafters Machine Shop

1140 Dillerville Rd
Lancaster

REBMAN RACING

1011 Stonemanor Dr
Lancaster

Roberto's Towing and Service Center

401 East Cumberland Street
Lebanon

ROD'S AUTO BODY

885 IVY DR.
Lancaster

Route 94 Motors, LLC

1155 700 RD
New Oxford

Sam's Club

6781 Grayson Rd
Harrisburg

SCHMITT MARINE STEERING WHEELS

1001 RANCK MILL RD
Lancaster

Sears Auto & Tire Ctr Hanover

1155 Carlisle St
Hanover

Semper Fi Truck & Auto LLC

PO Box 131
Holtwood

SERVICE TIRE TRUCK CTR

1770 ROHRERSTOWN RD
Lancaster

Sidler's Garage

227 Park Ave

Smith Bros. Garage Inc

238 N Main St
Shrewsbury

SNAVELY & DOSCH INC

426 N PRINCE ST
Lancaster

STEFFY'S GARAGE INC

235 W MAIN ST
Leola

STRAW'S AUTO CTR INC

635 RANGE END RD
Dillsburg

SUNOCO AUTO DOCTOR

4101 N FRONT ST
Harrisburg

SUTLIFF CHEVROLET CO

1251 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Sutliff Volkswagen

1301 Paxton St
Harrisburg

SWEDISH MOTORS

7 N DECATUR ST
Marietta

TAW Service Center Inc

180 S Main St
Berrysburg

TEAM ONE AUTO GROUP

1401 PAXTON ST
Harrisburg

Templeton Performance

297 Main St
Felton

TIRE CONSULTANTS INC

560 N READING RD
Ephrata

TIRE SERVICE CO OF LANCASTER

875 PLAZA BLVD
Lancaster

Tom Keefer Auto Sales and Service

2540 Baltimore Pike
Gettysburg

TOMMY'S AUTO REPAIR

899 NEW HOLLAND AVE
Lancaster

Toyota of York

1885 Whiteford Rd
York

Trailer Superstore!

6799 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

Tristate Truck & Equipment LLC

1115 W 11TH AVE
Coatesville

Twisted Turn Auto

1673 N. Market St
Elizabethtown

Ultimate RV

10070 Allentown Blvd
Grantville

UNITED TIRE & AUTO REPAIR

620 E BROADWAY
Red Lion

WALMART SUPERSTORE

2034 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

WARWICK AUTOPARK

700 FURNACE HILLS PIKE
Lititz

WEAVER'S BODY SHOP

5670 Hanover Rd.
Hanover

West Main Auto

14 W Main St
Mount Joy

West Shore Auto Care

736 State St
Lemoyne

Wheatfield Auto

1526 Newport Rd
Duncannon

Whites Automotive Services

951 W Collage Ave.
York

Winters Automotive LLC

PO Box 301
East Prospect

Shop Local Tire Buying And Repair Services in Lancaster, PA

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Lancaster.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Discount Tires
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money