-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Lancaster Tire Shops

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Tire Shops to Avoid

123

Top Rated Tire Shops

9

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 440 reviews for
Lancaster Tire Shops from people just like you.

A
"They were very professional from beginning to end. The owners
and
Brown always explain what need to be done to complete" the repair correctly and always come in right on the money with their estimate costs. Honesty is hard to find in the auto repair industry and I trust them with all my work. They service my business vehicles and my personal vehicles. In the past year they have completed everything from Oil changes, tune ups, air conditioning, brakes to suspension and tires. No one ever wants to spend money repairing vehicles, but if you have to I would highly recommend
for all your auto repair and tires.

-Robert W.

B
"I called and asked for my options over the phone. They answered my questions, quoted me a fair price and did the work quickly. My only negative is the ridiculously" heavy handed way they sell tire insurance. I had to turn it down three times and then say out loud "Let's move on" to get the guy to accept that I didn't want it. Other than that no complaints,but the hard sell made me like them less.

-Dani R.

+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Lancaster

Tires

Tires not only transfer the engine’s horsepower directly to the road, their grip ensures your car handles, turns and brakes safely. Overlooking tire maintenance can lead to poor fuel economy, poor handling and possibly hazardous driving conditions.

The front of a white classic car
Classic cars, Auto Tires

Inactivity, low tire pressure and excessive heat are the primary culprits that cause automobile tire dry rot.

Auto Tires

Have you ever found yourself on the side of the road with a flat tire? If so, did you know how to change it?

Auto mechanics and tire dealers say many people no longer take the time to learn how to change their own tires.

They, instead, rely on AAA or another roadside assistance services to bail them out, sometimes even if they have a spare tire in the trunk.

snowy house
Garage Doors, Roofing, Holiday Decorating, Gutter Cleaning, Pest Control/Exterminating, Lawn & Yard Work, Carpet Cleaning, Chimney Sweep, Fireplaces, Electrical, Handymen, Housecleaning, Animal & House Sitting, Cabinet Refacing/Restoration, Lighting, Wallpapering, Plumbing, Heating & A/C, Auto Service, Auto Tires, Allergy & Immunology

It's the time of year when the winter weather can take a toll. Follow this winter maintenance checklist to protect your home, your car and your health.

Angie's List
Auto Accessories, Auto Alarms, Auto Body Work, Auto Detailing, Auto Glass, Auto Inspections, Auto Mufflers, Auto Painting, Auto Radiators, Auto Radio Service, Auto Sales, Auto Service, Auto Tires, Auto Towing, Auto Transmission, Auto Transportation

Buying a new car is a big investment. Researching your available options will make you a better consumer.

Tire Buying And Repair reviews in Lancaster

B

Rating
I've been there multiple times. I thought the price was competitive but I didn't do a lot of checking. I've used them for years. They get to you and I think they're honest and tell you the truth about things. When they put the tires on, they put the tires on just fine but they didn't check the air pressure in the remaining tire and it was a little low and so we had to go back to have them redo that.
- Martin J W.
F

Rating
Well he had my car for3 days stating that the parts did not come for over a day even thought the parts warehouse was in maimi. The car a/c worked fine during the runs to the store and onetrip to the beach (less then 10miles). We went home to Georgia and the A/ c Wsnt blowing as cold. Teh next day the A/c wS NOT BLOWING AT ALL. I kept running the A/c it stayed hot . My mom told me to take the car to out local mechanic, not only did he say that the parts werent not verifiable through a manufacturer, But that the A/C compresser blew and putmetaL THROUGHOUT MY WHOLE A/C SYSTEM. And he repaired it for me , it was $900. HE had to flush the system 4 times ,and then he did could not even get the metal out the system that cools the rear cabin of the van .So now my kids have to suffer the heat because the rear system does not work . it actually worked better before we had the service done at
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
. We called them , and all he said was " bring it in mama,i will look at it " knowing very well that we live out of state.
- beverley R.
A

Rating
They were timely and didn't apply a lot of high pressure, and they also handled a conflict they had with another customer really well.
- Karen J.
A

Rating
The guys at
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
are always friendly, quick, and reasonably priced. I've been getting flats fixed there for years and always recommend them to friends and family. They are also the cheapest around and stand behind their work!
- Tyler L.
A

Rating
I've been using them for several years. They do a good job. They're quick and get the job done well. They're knowledgeable and they can always answer my questions and resolve the situation.
- trey M.
B

Rating
I take my car to
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
. I have been using that company for 4 or 5 years. They do good service and have good customer service. I used that company just by
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
. I would recommend them to a friend or neighbor.
- andrew G.
F

Rating
I had been going to
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
(Mr. Tire) in Canandaigua for years to have tires mounted, wheels balanced ,etc., and never had a problem. So I decided to have them change the spark plugs in my Nissan Pathfinder when the engine started feeling sluggish. Big mistake.....immediately after the new plugs were installed the engine started hesitating and missing to the point where the entire vehicle would shake when idling. I was having no problems like that before having the plugs changed , so I knew it had something to do with the plug installation. I brought the vehicle back to
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
and set up an appointment for them to have a look at it the next day. I took it in, they "looked" at it, and gave me some story about a loose hose they found and re-connected. The problem was...it was still idling just as bad as when I brought it in. I popped the hood and even showed the guy who worked on it how rough the idle was. He was short with me, and rude. He became very defensive and asked me if I thought that the
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
technician did something on purpose to cause the problem. I explained that I wasn't accusing anyone of doing anything like that on purpose.....but reiterated that I was sure it had something to do with the plug installation, because the problem wasn't occurring before. He then said he would look at it again, but he would have to charge me for troubleshooting time. I had just paid almost $160 to have 6 spark plugs installed, and I wasn't going to pay them to troubleshoot a problem caused by their own installation work. I suspected that one of the new plugs was bad and asked him if he would just install the old plugs to prove the point. Again, he said he would have to charge me. I was shocked....I couldn't believe he wouldn't even put the old plugs back in without charging me. So he turns away and walks back into the shop, leaving me there with my vehicle shaking at idle. He lost a good customer that day.
A few days later I took the vehicle to another repair shop to have the old plugs put back in, and they pulled the new number 6 plug out and handed it to me. It looked like it had been run over by a semi. The inner metal core of the plug was bent and twisted and the ceramic was in pieces. I was lucky that some of the ceramic pieces didn't fall back into the cylinder head and cause major engine damage when the new plug was put in. It was apparent that the
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
tech had extensively damaged the plug during installation.
Needless to say, I'm very disappointed. It seems they never even looked at the plugs when I brought the vehicle back in.
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
was a complete waste of time and money on this job, and they obviously care a lot more about the almighty dollar than they do about doing a good job for their customers.
- Stephen W.
F

Rating
The Saturday before the work was performed I took my car in because one of my tires had a slow leak. I had to wait over two hours to find out that it was not repairable. They did not have a replacement. They would get a new one by Monday. I specifically asked if I could get an appointment and was told I would not need it. Monday I was ill and couldn't go in. On the 19th a friend took it in for me after I called
Lancaster Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
to make sure they still had it. My friend was so angry when he got back after another two hour wait. The LADY who he dealt with was very rude and was not going to give him the keys because he was not me even though he was the one who brought it in. Tire price was higher than other local tire dealers. I wish I would have done some research before going there.
- Sheila R.

Tire Shops in Lancaster, PA

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

1274 LITITZ PIKE
Lancaster

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

2038 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

1003 E KING ST
Lancaster

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

1282 MILLERSVILLE PIKE
Lancaster

AFG Tire & Auto Service

4685 Carlisle Road
Gardners

Al's Auto Parts & Service

1301 N Sherman St
York

AMERICAN SPEED CTR-LANCASTER

1714 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

Apple Nissan

1510 Whiteford Rd
York

Arnold's Garage

15 South River Street
Maytown

AUTO ZONE

2121 COLUMBIA AVE
Lancaster

Autocamp Tire & Auto Service Ctr

3609 Hartzdale Dr
Camp Hill

AUTOMOTIVE MASTERS LLC

2090 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

AUTORAGEOUS AUTO CUSTOMIZING

309 HARRISBURG AVE
Lancaster

B & J AUTOMOTIVE

3634 COLUMBIA AVE
Lancaster

Beasley Ford Lincoln

1801 WHITEFORD RD
York

BEAST Automotive

106 North High Street
Duncannon

Blatt & Tillett Truck and Trailer Repair, LLC

10630 Allentown Blvd
Jonestown

BLAZER'S BODY SHOP

13 S YORK RD
Dillsburg

Brookside Collision

33 Industrial Rd
Ephrata

BYERS TIRE SALE

6470 CARLISLE RD
Dover

CAR-MIC ENTERPRISES INC

789 FLORY MILL RD
Lancaster

CarMart Automotive

147 Hamilton Ave
York

CARQUEST AUTO PARTS

1285 MANHEIM PIKE
Lancaster

CARSON'S SOUTHSIDE AUTO & TIRE

820 HERSHEY AVE
Lancaster

Carson's Southside Tire and Auto

820 Hershey Ave.
Lancaster

Chapman Ford Lancaster

5201 Main St
East Petersburg

Chris' Automotive Repair Shop

243 S REAMSTOWN RD
Ephrata

Ciocca Honda

8001 Allentown Blvd
Harrisburg

CNM Auto Repair

202 Seymour st
Lancaster

Coke's Auto Repair

3535 N 6th St
Harrisburg

COOL-TECH

1034 N LIME ST
Lancaster

CUSTOM HOT WHIPS LLC

470 N Franklin St
Lancaster

D & D Auto Service

808 W Trindle Rd
Mechanicsburg

D & L AUTO ACCESSORIES

606 Rohrerstown Rd
Lancaster

D-M TIRE SUPPLY INC

501 SERVICE RD
Lancaster

Daddario Tire & Auto

1464 Manheim Pike
Lancaster

dayne's automotive

328 e main st
Palmyra

Done Right Autoworks

975 Cartref Rd
Etters

E-TOWN AUTO PARTS

220 W HIGH ST
Lancaster

EDEN TIRE & AUTOMOTIVE INC

1713 NEW HOLLAND PIKE
Lancaster

EMORY TRANSMISSION

1599 Hummel Ave
Camp Hill

Evans Auto Repair

2350 Grandview Dr
Etters

Faulkner Hyundai

2060 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

4719 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

180 N NORTHERN WAY
York

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

1530 OREGON PIKE
Lancaster

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

395 Eisenhower Dr
Hanover

FIRESTONE STORES

700 N 2ND ST
Harrisburg

FIRESTONE STORES

2201 PAXTON ST
Harrisburg

FIRESTONE STORES

208 W ORANGE ST
Lancaster

GARDNER MOTORS

218 Hershey Road
Elizabethtown

GILBERT'S AUTOMOTIVE

32 PITNEY RD
Lancaster

Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co

1151 Mae St
Hummelstown

Graham Motor Company

1402 Holly Pike
Carlisle

H & F TIRE SVC

1834 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

Hanover Honda

1226 Carlisle St
Hanover

Hanover Hyundai

720 Carlisle St
Hanover

Harry Cramer Inc

1998 W Harrisburg Pike
Middletown

Hess Garage Inc

145 Gettysburg Pike
Mechanicsburg

Hirt Motorsports LLC

11 Kamp street
Duncannon

Hoffman Ford

5200 Jonestown Rd
Harrisburg

Hondru Chevrolet of Elizabethtown

2005 S Market St
Elizabethtown

HORACE KRUGER

1675 COLUMBIA AVE
Lancaster

Jack's Auto & Aero

231 Race St
Bainbridge

Jacks Auto Sales and Service

2189 W Harrisburg Pike
Middletown

JONES GM PARTS

1335 MANHEIM PIKE
Lancaster

K & J AUTOMOTIVE REPAIR LLC

239 RIDGE AVE
Hanover

keisers Service Center Inc

2401 Gettysburg Rd
Camp Hill

Keystone Trailer Services

100 W Crone Rd
York

Lawrence Chevrolet

6445 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

LEBZELTERS TOTAL CAR CARE

237 MANOR AVE
Millersville

LINCOLNWAY SALES & SVC INC

586 W KING ST
Abbottstown

Maguire's Ford Lincoln Mercury

100 N Thistledown Dr
Palmyra

Main Car Care LLC

57 Loccust Grove RD
York

MANOR AUTO

850 MANOR ST
Lancaster

MARTIN'S TIRE SVC

102 W BURKHOLDER DR
Lititz

Matthews Garage Inc

17525 Gerry Ln
New Freedom

McCafferty Ford of Mechanicsburg

6320 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

MEALS ON WHEELS HEMPFIELD

1520 HARRISBURG PIKE
Lancaster

MIDAS AUTO SVC EXPERTS

2070 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

Midas Harrisburg

2471 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Mose's Gulf Service

1885 W Market St
York

Mr Tire Auto Service Ctr

884 E Main St
Ephrata

Mugsy's Repair

570 Lancaster Ave
York

National Tire & Battery

1431 Manheim Pike
Lancaster

New Holland Ford Isuzu

508 W Main St
New Holland

New Holland Scion

524 W Main St
New Holland

Penn Tire Exchange, LLC

3062 S Queen St
Dallastown

PEP BOYS MANNY MOE & JACK

1700 FRUITVILLE PIKE
Lancaster

PEP BOYS MANNY MOE & JACK

2080 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

Precision Tune Auto Care

55 Eisenhower Dr
Hanover

Pros Now

45 S 8th street
Lemoyne

R.A.W Automotive

8 West Allen Street
Mechanicsburg

Racekrafters Machine Shop

1140 Dillerville Rd
Lancaster

REBMAN RACING

1011 Stonemanor Dr
Lancaster

Roberto's Towing and Service Center

401 East Cumberland Street
Lebanon

ROBERTS AUTOMOTIVE INC

3846 COLUMBIA AVE
Mountville

ROD'S AUTO BODY

885 IVY DR.
Lancaster

Route 94 Motors, LLC

1155 700 RD
New Oxford

SCHMITT MARINE STEERING WHEELS

1001 RANCK MILL RD
Lancaster

Semper Fi Truck & Auto LLC

PO Box 131
Holtwood

SERVICE TIRE TRUCK CTR

1770 ROHRERSTOWN RD
Lancaster

Sidler's Garage

227 Park Ave

SNAVELY & DOSCH INC

426 N PRINCE ST
Lancaster

STEFFY'S GARAGE INC

235 W MAIN ST
Leola

SUNOCO AUTO DOCTOR

4101 N FRONT ST
Harrisburg

Sutliff Chevrolet Co

1251 Paxton St
Harrisburg

Sutliff Volkswagen

1301 Paxton St
Harrisburg

SWEDISH MOTORS

7 N DECATUR ST
Marietta

TAW Service Center Inc

180 S Main St
Berrysburg

Templeton Performance

297 Main St
Felton

TIRE SERVICE CO OF LANCASTER

875 PLAZA BLVD
Lancaster

Tom Keefer Auto & Truck Repair

2540 Baltimore Pike
Gettysburg

TOMMY'S AUTO REPAIR

899 NEW HOLLAND AVE
Lancaster

Toyota of York

1885 Whiteford Rd
York

Trailer Superstore!

6799 Carlisle Pike
Mechanicsburg

Ultimate RV

10070 Allentown Blvd
Grantville

UNITED TIRE & AUTO REPAIR

620 E BROADWAY
Red Lion

WALMART SUPERSTORE

2034 LINCOLN HWY E
Lancaster

WARWICK AUTOPARK

700 FURNACE HILLS PIKE
Lititz

West Main Auto

14 W Main St
Mount Joy

West Shore Auto Care

736 State St
Lemoyne

Wheatfield Auto

1526 Newport Rd
Duncannon

Whites Automotive Services

951 W Collage Ave.
York

Willow Street Tire & Auto

326 Beaver Valley Pike
Willow Street

Winters Automotive LLC

PO Box 301
East Prospect

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Lancaster.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Tire Shop
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money