-Find top-rated Service Providers
Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Reynoldsburg Real Estate Agents

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Real Estate Agents to Avoid

204

Top Rated Real Estate Agents

9

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews
See Verified Local Reviews

Over 285 reviews for
Reynoldsburg Real Estate Agents from people just like you.

A
" and team are consummate professionals, very knowledgable and friendly, flexible, and were willing to go the extra mile for us. That aspect" is what makes all the difference. Many people do their job, only few go above and beyond. does. From the beginning of the process- viewing homes, responsiveness, making superb referrals of attorney and lender, and communication throughout was perfect. Her assistant is also great. has excellent organizational skills, that really help considering all the details and paperwork involved. I recommend without reservation

-SHELLEY B.

A
"Dawn and are the best out there. They helped me find my boutique in Fishers. With the real estate so popular in the area, they were able" to get us right in to see the space and even neg. the deal for us. Talk about prompt service and women who really care about their clients. I highly recommend their service if you are looking for a new place!

-Tonya S.

+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 3 Million People on Angie's List
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Over 3 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 3 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Reynoldsburg

Top 3 Tips to Sell a House

Curious how to sell your house as quickly as possible?

house exterior

Real Estate Agents

A Realtor or real estate agent offers home buyers and sellers his or her expertise and knowledge of the local market while guiding any real estate transactions in order to help both buyers and sellers reach their personal goals.

If your home's masonry is showing signs of age, it may be time to call out an expert. (Photo courtesy of Deborah Schoenholz)

Home improvements can add value to your property.

short sale home
Real Estate Agents, Mortgage Companies

Buying a home on a short sale can save you money, but there are some factors to consider.

Craftsman Bungalow

Want to pay less for real estate services?

If you’re unhappy with your Realtor, consider asking to be released from your contract. (Photo by Katelin Kinney)

What can you do if your Realtor isn't doing a good job?

Angie's Answers

?

I bought my last house and also sold it FSBO.  For me, both ends of the process were simple and relatively hassle free. 

I advertised in the paper once a week and had an open house every Sunday for about three weeks.  I also had an FSBO sign in the front yard that I would put balloons on (for attention) when I had the open house.  It sold quickly. 

The cost of an attorney to go over the paperwork was MUCH less than the price of a relator.  I bought one of those ready-made packages from the nearest office store, read it over and made a few changes to it.  Then I had the attorney look it over.  I think it saved some money having the attorney just look over the document and make changes rather than having him create the entire thing. 

 When I decide to move out of my current house, I will definitely go FSBO again.

?
Yes! Movie tickets, 2 hours at the spa, 10 rides at your local "iFly", etc. Bottom line: You know your clients. Find out what they do to reward/pamper themselves and give them that!

Hope this helps!

David Gowans

?
?
?
?

Real Estate Agent reviews in Reynoldsburg

A

Rating
My experience with 's real estate service always go very well for me. I have contacted her multiple times to support my real estate needs.
- CHRISTI P.
F

Rating
HORRIBLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
They are by far the WORST management co ~ esp !!! Getting anything fixed was almost impossible! I contacted them EVERY week for 4 weeks regarding ALL of the outside lights burned out! I fell and broke my foot the evening after my last email to !!!!!! the following day ...More they were FINALLY out!!! come to find out TWO OTHER tenants had fallen & one is STILL walking with a cane ~ a YEAR LATER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
sent in an email that i could file another frivilous lawsuit ~ since I am them for my foot ~ since I don't know how to accept responsibility ~ my responsbility was to contact them ONCE on the lights ~ it was THEIR RESPONSIBILITY TO FIX THEM IMMEDIATELY!!!!!!!!!!! Excuse me ~ IT IS A SAFETY HAZARD!!!!
MAN THEY SUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- lynette W.
N

Rating

The team is the most professional, well-run, client invested real-estate team we have ever dealt with. We can truly attest to this having moved and bought/sold multiple homes for many years. Both and take time to listen to your needs and concerns before they start searching ...More for your perfect home. and are totally focused on the needs of their clients and not increasing their revenue at the clients’ expense. is extremely knowledgeable of the place and is very pragmatic about the true value of the property. brings his technology savviness to the team and is very easy to work with. He works very well with making sure appointments are on time, needs are being addressed and assessing potential value. Both and have very well trained eyes for catching potential problems, envisioning remodels or knowing how to appeal to buyers or sellers. They have the type of white-glove concierge service today’s busy families are looking for in real-estate. Moving to New from a different state with 4 young children in tow provided enough challenges. and were able to smoothly guide us through offers, inspections, purchase and even contractor recommendations. This is a team that goes above and beyond the typical real-estate contract and makes sure your needs, questions, or concerns are addressed.


We are very thankful that we found the team to help us find our home. We would never think of using any another broker for our real-estate needs in Ridgewood; We found the best in the Team.
- J R.
F

Rating
This is a nightmare! It's not over as of this posting, I've had to hire legal counsel to protect myself. I don't know where to begin other than to say I have fired her twice. Crossroads doesn't seem to care and has not offered to provide another agent. My working septic system failed inspection due to new ...More EPA rules. Ms. Highly failed to inform us of new EPA water rules which would have changed our pricing and negotiations. I questioned her extensively about point of sale inspections regarding septic systems before signing. She told us in her almost 40 years in the business no one has ever had to replace a system! I called the Crossroads office and spoke with manager, representing myself as someone who was interested in selling my home with a septic system but was concerned with the new EPA regulations. I asked him if his agents were aware of the new guidelines? He assured me all the agents have taken courses/seminars and are well educated about new EPA rules. Someone is lying. 2nd issue. Ms. Highly is acting as dual agent, she is representing all parties. Therefore she is only suppose to present offers, she cannot negotiate on behalf of anyone. Well, she tried very hard to renegotiate a signed contract we had with our buyer for less money! This is not in our best interest, she represents us. My husband got so mad he stormed out of her office. 3rd issue. Home I purchased had a light tan roof. Contingent offer the roof will be replaced. I had 3 way call with owner & ms Highly where I was told the exact roof was being put on, same color and grade. Well, they decided to put a red and black roof on the dark brown stained cedar house without ever consulting us, the buyers who will have to live there. This is not the house I signed papers on! The roof issue has been a nightmare. Since September this roof could have been installed! They kept playing around till November when it was cold. We finally said it was too cold for proper roof installation and we requested the money be put in escrow till the spring and weather is warm. The push back we received from Ms was unbelievable! She became rude and verbally abusive! The financial lender even got involved. First the lender said no problem with an escrow account, then story changed to escrow account was only good for 3 months, "so you might as well put the roof on". When she said that, I said good bye, we will find other financing. Then the story changed again, to escrow account is open as long as you need it. Ms. Highly was in my home last Weds. with my buyer. The buyer left. She statred screaming at me, calling me names, calling me ungrateful! I was nervous and frightened in my own home! I moved quickly towards the front door, one of us was getting out of there. There are things I can't post here as now attorneys are involved. But this I can tell you, do yourself a favor, there a thousands of agents out there who will not frighten or intimidate their clients. Find them.
- Kathleen J.
A

Rating
It went GREAT. When says that he will handle everything, he means it. This is a family-run company which values customer service and satisfaction. listens to what your goals are and helps you achieve them. His company does all the grunt work so that you don't have to worry about anything. He will ...More outline all the necessary work that needs to be done before listing, and then present a time line for achieving this. There are no surprises. He updates you on any work that is done. When our property hit the MLS, juggled all the inquiries about our building and then provided us with a summary of the prospective buyers, listing the pros and cons of their offers. He was very accessible by cell phone to answer any of our questions or concerns. Lear is a great guy and is a great company to turn to from beginning to end for your real estate needs.
- Jane C.
A

Rating
Our home sold in just six days which we attribute to the outstanding job that and his company did in conducting the survey, helping us to set a fair selling price, advertising in all the right places, and doing just the right staging to make our house more inviting. coordinated ...More getting minor repairs and cleaning taken care of and the photos he had taken were professionally done. We live in New and the home we were selling was in Miami and made sure we were informed of all the things we needed to know. He sent texts, emails, and called to ensure we never missed information. was a true professional and we would recommend him highly for selling your home.
- Toni W.
A

Rating
was extremely knowledgeable, professional, and attentive throughout the process of selling our home. I really appreciated that went well beyond just listing it. He was extremely knowledgeable of the , and made sure all of our questions were answered in choosing a listing price for ...More our home. also went above and beyond by assisting us with evaluating and staging it. While it took a little elbow grease on our part, the result was well worth it. I also appreciated that scheduled a realtor tour the first weekend on the to make sure that we were quickly aware of any potential buyer concerns. All of this to us selling our home after only 6 days on the !
We LOVE YOU Angie’s list, thank you for helping us find .Every time we had a hiccup in the process, it felt like was right there to ensure things got back to smooth as quickly as possible. One example is that the house we purchased had a leaky tub that was missed during inspection.
I would not hesitate to recommend to anyone! He really made what can be a very difficult process as stress-free as possible!
- Enos M.
N

Rating
This is the third time we have
worked with , and just like the others we were not disappointed. He put in
a lot of work to help us short sale our condo. There were quite a few mishaps
that were out of all of our control, but he never let that affect his work
ethic or effort he put into helping us. He stuck ...More with it for over 7 months
trying to sale this property and always kept us in the loop and a positive
attitude the whole time. In the end, he was able to sell the condo for the best
deal possible, and made the process as for us as he could. Whenever we
have a real estate need we always turn to because we know we are getting a
knowledgeable, professional, and dedicated person.


- Natalie V.

Real Estate Agents in Reynoldsburg, OH

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

Adria Thompson, Key Realty

5537 Congresssional
Hilliard

Al Waddell, Realtor

108 N. 20th St
Columbus

Alterra Real Estate Advisors

540 Officenter Pl
Columbus

Altimate Home Inspections

684 Colton Road
Columbus

amanda biggins

9139 unit b us highway 62

AMERICAN HOMES

PO Box 632
Reynoldsburg

AMY WEINSZ

100 E Wilson Bridge Rd
Columbus

ASSET INVESTMENTS LLC

1145 BRIARCLIFF RD
Reynoldsburg

Auctions By Maggie Inc

3350 Harrison Ave
Cincinnati

Auto Transporters Online

25108 Marguerite PKWY, Ste A-353

BATES & SON REALTOR

7888 PALMER RD SW
Reynoldsburg

Best Corporate Real Estate

2121 Riverside Dr
Upper Arlington

BeSure Home Inspection Service

2151 West Fair Ave
Lancaster

Beth Dittmar- RE/MAX Affiliates

570 N. State Street, Suite 110
Westerville

BICKIS INC REALTORS

PO Box 92
Reynoldsburg

Bill & Susan Clifford-Keller Williams Capitol Part

100 E. Wilson Bridge Rd.
Worthington

Bill Wernet Realty

935 River Rd
Granville

Bob & Lorene Hetherington

5400 Frantz Road
Dublin

BuySelf Realty Flat Fee MLS Listing

1690 Woodlands Dr
Maumee

C.G. Boyce Real Estate Co.

425 South Sandusky Street
Delaware

C.R. O'Neil & Co.

3151 N High St
Columbus

CAMILLUS ENTERPRISES LTD

6281 RIPPEY CIR
Reynoldsburg

CAP-CITY PROPERTIES

6880 TUSSING RD
Reynoldsburg

Carla Peters

10400 Blacklick Eastern Rd
Pickerington

Carla Peters

8233 Howe Industrial Pkwy
Canal Winchester

Casto Info

250 Civic Center Dr 500
Columbus

CENTRAL MANAGEMENT CO

1405 HAFT DR
Reynoldsburg

CENTURY 21

1952 State Route 256
Reynoldsburg

COLDWELL BANKER

405 Coleman's Crossing Blvd
Marysville

Coldwell Banker King Thompson

960 North Hamilton Rd
Gahanna

Connie Watson-Realtor

16 S. Main Street, Suite 101
Mt. Gilead

COOK REALTORS

7673 Godfrey Cir
Reynoldsburg

CORBAN CO

7596 SLATE RIDGE BLVD
Reynoldsburg

Core Ohio Realty Advisors

100 E Campus View Blvd
Columbus

Craig and Judy Mosier

3499 Main St.
Hilliard

Crosscountry Mortgage

5625 N High St
Worthington

CTM MANAGEMENT

6432 E Main St Ste 201
Reynoldsburg

Cutler Real Estate

11 W. Bridge St.
Dublin

Darrin Grieves

155 Green Meadows Dr. S.
Lewis Center

Dave Flora

8740 Carroll Northern
Pickerington

David Scurria DDS

6780 Perimeter Dr
Dublin

DENNIS SWARTZ

7640 SLATE RIDGE BLVD
Reynoldsburg

Dickens Team Keller Williams Consultants

5400 Frantz Rd Suite 100
Dublin

DONNA M. TRAVIS TWIN TEAM PLUS

3354 US HIGHWAY 23 N
Delaware

Epic Group Ohio

180 S Riverview Street
Dublin

ERA

3050 DELTA MARINE DR
Reynoldsburg

ERA Real Solutions

168 South State Street
Westerville

ERA Real Solutions Realty

3656 Broadway
Grove City

Exit Trinity Realty

146 Granville St
Gahanna

GENE P JOHNSON REALTY INC

6899 E MAIN ST
Reynoldsburg

GENE SHIVENER & CO

150 BRICE RD
Reynoldsburg

GERMANY REALTY CO

2070 Lublin Dr Apt B
Reynoldsburg

Gorsuch Realty

603 W Wheeling St
Lancaster

GREENTREE GROUP UNLIMITED LLC

6515 E LIVINGSTON AVE
Reynoldsburg

Gregory A Gleaves, MBA - Coldwell Banker

3160 Kingsdale Center
Columbus

Griffith RE/MAX Stars

15 W Main St
Centerburg

Hawks Nest Ohio

5590 Waterloo RD NW
Canal Winchester

Her Real Living

4041 N. High St.
Columbus

HER REAL LIVING

3714 FISHINGER BLVD
Hilliard

HER Realtors - Mary Brown

4455 Columbia Rd SW
Pataskala

HER Realtors Michelle Morris Group

3311 Tremont Rd
Columbus

HER REALTORS- Char Evans King

116 Granville St.
Columbus

HER Realtors-Lori Hicks

4261 Morse Road
Columbus

Hilligas Surveying, L.L.C.

46007 Foxes Bottom Road
Cadiz

HOME BUYERS REALTY

7732 PALMER RD SW
Reynoldsburg

Home Central Realty

74 Mill St
Gahanna

Home Scan

1170 Old Henderson Rd
Columbus

HOME SOLUTION RESOURCE

185 BROOKHILL DR
Columbus

HOME SOLUTIONS NETWORK

2097 S HAMILTON RD
Reynoldsburg

Home Team Builders & Remodelers

22 Westerville Sq
Westerville

Homes That Click Realtors

200 E Campus View Blvd Suite 200
Columbus

Hot-Rod Realty & Investments LLC

1200 North Federal Highway,

J E GIBSON REALTY

1000 ROSEHILL RD
Reynoldsburg

Jack Gabalski, REALTOR

Solutions for Real Estate
Columbus

Jaysen Barlow: iHome Realtors

1565 Bethel Rd. Suite 201
Columbus

Jeffery Buren

2404 E Main St
Columbus

Jerry Xiong, Realtor

3805 N High St #100
Columbus

Jesse Snodgrass

7240 Muirfield Dr
Dublin

Jill Rudler & The Rudler Team

550 Polaris Parkway
Westerville

Jim Van Paepeghem, Remax Consulting Group

6065 Walnut Street
New Albany

Jim West Team

1042 Columbus Avenue
Marysville

Jimmy Johnson, Realtor

960 N. Hamilton Rd.
Columbus

JOE WALKER & ASSOC

409 W MAIN ST
Westerville

JP Faulkner, Faulkner Realty Group

3003 N HIGH ST
Columbus

K KARR LLC

7620 FARMSBURY DR
Reynoldsburg

Karen Disbrow - HER Realtors

5655 Wexler Rd.
Dublin

KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY

5400 Frantz Rd Ste 100
Dublin

Kelly Cantwell, Street Sotheby's Realty

2126 Tremont Center
Columbus

Kevin Sadeski Realtor

6500 East Main St
Reynoldsburg

KING THOMPSON

175 S 3rd St Ste 100
Columbus

LEE GOODMAN TRANSACTION REALTY

100 EAST CAMPUS VIEW BLVD
Columbus

Leslie Cady McFadden HER Realtors

681 High St
Worthington

LESLIE PEARSON

6329 PERIMETER LP DR
Dublin

Linda & Marty Soller-Coldwell Banker King Thompson

4535 W. Dublin Granville Rd.
Dublin

LINDA KNIGHT

2815 E MAIN ST
Columbus

Lotus Real Estate Advisors

79 S. State Street Ste #D5

LYNNE WHITTMAN

7315 E MAIN ST
Reynoldsburg

M L SLANE REALTY

1500 BRICE RD
Reynoldsburg

M&Q Realty, LLC

PO Box 307231
Columbus

Machoman moving and delivery

3 high street
Columbus

Marsh Realty Group, LLC

100 E Wilson Bridge Rd
Columbus

Matt Roehrenbeck / The Roehrenbeck Group

4100 Regent Street, Suite B
Columbus

Michael Smith, Obvious Choice Realty

6320 E Main St
Reynoldsburg

MID OHIO FIELD SVC

6434 E Main St
Reynoldsburg

Mimi Hamer - Realtor

5400 Frantz Rd, #100
Dublin

MoveDowntownColumbus.com

1020 Dennison Avenue
Columbus

MYERS REAL ESTATE

1221 GRANDVIEW AVE
Columbus

MyPlatinumServiceGroup.com

735 Lyons Brook Ct
Columbus

New Albany Realty

220 Market St
New Albany

New Millennium Realty

7640 Slate Ridge Blvd
Reynoldsburg

NEWBURY BUILDERS

169 S LIBERTY ST
Powell

noAppdeals

PO Box 2415
Newark

OAKWOOD MANAGEMENT CO

6950 AMERICANA PKWY
Reynoldsburg

OneLove Lawn

Independence st
Grove City

Onyx Realty

3465 Henderson Road
Columbus

Onyx Realty

1500 Brice Rd Ste 103
Reynoldsburg

PCS Construction

1641 Windsor Ave

PEARL ENERPRISES OF CENTRAL

3085 BREED DR
Reynoldsburg

PRICED RIGHT REALTY

7374 E MAIN ST
Reynoldsburg

Property Keepers, Inc

15000 S Cicero Ave

PRUDENTIAL PLATINUM REALTY

121 COMMERCE PARK DR
Westerville

Ravemor Property Services

5316 Franklin St
Hilliard

RE/MAX

870 HIGH ST
Columbus

RE/MAX 24/7

106 S High St., Dublin, OH 43017
Dublin

Re/Max Affiliates - Emma Yanok

570 North State Street
Westerville

Re/Max Capital Centre Inc

3805 N High St
Columbus

RE/MAX ONE

8233 Howe Industrial Pkwy
Canal Winchester

RE/MAX Resource

2109 West Fifth Ave.
Columbus

Real Estate Opportunity

2246 S Hamilton Rd
Columbus

REAL LIVING

8500 TAYLOR CHASE DR
Reynoldsburg

Real Living

190 E Broad St
Pataskala

REAL LIVING DARBY CREEK REAL ESTATE

32 S MAIN ST
Mechanicsburg

Real Living Her

413 N State St
Westerville

REALLIVING HER

4183 PARKWAY CENTRE
Grove City

REALNET SWO

6810 E MAIN ST
Reynoldsburg

REALTY OHIO REAL ESTATE

1281 Worthington Woods Blvd
Columbus

RELOCATION SERVICES

2866 LIBERTY BELL LN
Reynoldsburg

RICHARD SANFORD- RE/MAX Achievers

7124 Muirfield Dr.
Dublin

RJ Wise - Century 21 Bob McElroy

1245 County RD 218
Marengo

RL Partners

PO Box 3
Columbus

RLS Investment Group LLC

8142 Bellow Pk Dr
Reynoldsburg

Ron Guzzo ReMax Premier Choice

450 W Wilson Bridge Rd
Worthington

Scott Marvin Remax One

1131 Hill Rd N
Pickerington

Select Sales By Michael

9696 Grandview Ave
Pickerington

SHARP KEATON & CO REALTORS

7333 E LIVINGSTON AVE
Reynoldsburg

SHE Realtors-Wendy Hansel

3276 N HIGH ST
Columbus

Sheila Straub

2288 E Main St
Columbus

Signature Real Estate

1385 Dublin Road
Columbus

SILVESTRI INTERIORS LTD

5603 LOCH MORE CRT W
Dublin

SOSKIM REALTY

7411 DAUGHERTY DR
Reynoldsburg

Standard Realtors: Jim Wootton

8405 Pulsar Pl
Columbus

Sterling Place

5399 Coachman Road
Columbus

Steven Jon Baldwin Realtor@

5495 New Albany Road West

Sue Berg

7240 Muirfield Dr.
Dublin

SUNBELT RENTALS

275 S REYNOLDSBURG NEW ALBANY
Reynoldsburg

SUPERIOR HOMES REALTY

1601 SCHROCK RD
Columbus

Tailored Tasks

P.O Box 362
Columbus

Tax Xpress & Financial Services

1753 E. Livingston Ave
Columbus

The Alt Company, Realtors

3637 N. High St.
Columbus

The Barcus Company, Inc.

1601 Bethel Rd
Columbus

The Barker Team Realtors

4183 Parkway Centre Dr
Grove City

The Carsey Pros

5495 New Albany Road West

The Fenters Realty Group

4475 Hickory Rock Dr.

The Founding Partners at The Realty Firm

7801 Olentangy River Road
Columbus

The HomeBuyer's Advocate

77 E Wilson Bridge Rd
Columbus

THE INSPECTION GROUP

12551 LESLEY RD
Heath

The McCurdy Team

42 N State St
Westerville

The Ohio Real Estate Company

71 E Schrock Rd
Westerville

The Real Estate Exchange, LLC

3800 Broadway
Grove City

The Ringer Group

5400 Frantz Rd. Suite 100
Dublin

TINKER REALTY

811 CUMMINGTON RD
Columbus

TNT Home Renovations

1889 Victory Dr
Columbus

Tony and Krystin Macaluso

3160 Kingdale Center
Upper Arlington

Upward Home Solutions

40 Grace Dr. Box 183
Powell

USA-1 REAL ESTATE

1676 BRICE RD
Reynoldsburg

Vision Realty

4608 N High St
Columbus

WALLICK CONSTRUCTION CO

6880 TUSSING RD
Reynoldsburg

Weaver Property Services

5820 Sullivant Ave #224
Galloway

WILLIAM FANNIN REALTY INC

424 BEECHER RD
Columbus

World Realty PRA

4663 Executive Dr
Columbus

Zach Bish | HER Realtors

116 Granville Street Ste 104
Columbus

Shop Local Real Estate Agent Services in Reynoldsburg, OH

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Reynoldsburg.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Real Estate Agent
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money