-Find top-rated Service Providers
Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Reynoldsburg Auto Repair Shops

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Auto Repair Shops to Avoid

105

Top Rated Auto Repair Shops

70

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews
See Verified Local Reviews

Over 3,049 reviews for
Reynoldsburg Auto Repair Shops from people just like you.

A
"I dropped my car off at and he called me about 5 hours later and said he was done. I paid him and left. Great job and reasonably priced!!

-Patrick M.

A
"Outstanding! Like other reviewers, I dropped off the car for one day after 's ordered, prepped, and painted" the needed part. I am a busy parent with young kids on a tight budget, so I looked for an auto repair shop that would minimize my time without my car. 's price was within about $100 of the other estimates I got, but they saved me days of being without a car (negating the need for a car rental). Support staff was friendly and professional, and provided drop off to/from my home while car was being repaired! I will definitely use 's again in the future if I need such repair work done!

-Barrie H.

+Join 3 Million People on Angie's List
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Over 3 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 3 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Reynoldsburg

Auto Repair reviews in Reynoldsburg

A

Rating
Maybe this doesn't seem like much, but this is the second time they have done this for my mom. They have done body work on her car three times. The first time there was more damage than the second and third times. I recommended to her because she didn't know where to go. My dad passed away in May of 2013, and my mom ...More had never done anything like having a car repaired n her own.
When brought her car back to her, they asked her f they had given her a price. She thought, okay, here we go! You're going to charge me more than you said. Well, it was exactly the opposite. They charge her less!
I can't tell you how much it means to me to know there is a place that, not only didn't take advantage of an older recently widowed women, but they also gave her a break.
They are great in doing their jobs, but they are also great people!


- Cyndi G.
A

Rating
The damage to our car came from a parking lot "drive by" from some good citizen who failed to acknowledge his/her poor driving ability. Cy gave us an estimate after seeing a couple of pictures that were emailed to him, and upon arriving at our home and looking at the car first hand, he stayed with the original cost estimation. We had a minor ...More mix-up on the timing for the job, and, thus, the small ding (no pun intended, ha!) in that category. Once we got that straightened out, Cy was here on time and went right to work. He has all the equipment and all the experience to do this type of work in an outstanding manner, and that is what he did for us --- an outstanding job. Believe me, you can not tell that the damage had ever been on the bumper. The color match is right on!! Additionally, Cy is an interesting guy who is fun and enlightening to talk with; so the time taken for the job (about three and a half hours) went quickly. I most strongly recommend Cy for similar work -- he is the best!
- NANCY S.
A

Rating
I got two estimates both from reputable companies. was significantly lower. The repairs were made as promised and the car looks as good as new. The splash guard on the right side of the car needed to be replaced and was not included in the original estimate. I offered to pay for the added cost and ...More declined. I strongly recommend this company.
- JAMES K.
A

Rating
I could not have asked for a better job! I just got a new car and someone decided to open their door on my car causing a visible in the rear door. You can imagine my despair for having a on the first day of driving. I found on the list and he was able to come out to my home that ...More same day. He explained the process and was able to carefully remove the COMPLETELY! I cannot find the area that was dented. AMAZING! True artist. Expectations were way exceeded. Thanks !
- David L.
A

Rating
I had to wait a week to bring it in since shop was busy. They did a good job - looks as good as new. Work was finished earlier than expected. Also, it was much less cost than other places quoted me - half price of the most expensive quote.
- Nancy K.
A

Rating
Our Honda CRV received a deep, 2" wide by 6" long scratch on the right rear quarter panel occurring during shipment from the East Coast to Texas. After seeking several estimates, was the most favorable.
For various reasons, we had to reschedule the repair appointment several times. ...More was accommodating without complaint.
On the appointed day, took in the car as promised, completed the repair and had the vehicle ready a day before the estimate promised. The repair completely matches the color of the rest of the car. Several weeks, and several washes, later the repair is still holding up.
- Douglas W.
A

Rating
performed a paintless repair caused by a shopping cart. was responsive, professional, arrived on time and did an excellent job repairing the . definitely left no of the ! I would hire ...More him again to fix any dents on my car and would highly recommend him to my friends!
- Anne B.
N

Rating
Great job on dealing with the insurance company, looking out for their client and not the insurance interest. Great staff and good quality work.
.
- Bob C.

Auto Repair Shops in Reynoldsburg, OH

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

4 Low Towing

1822 E Cherry St
Columbus

A & A TOWING

2527 Agler Rd
Columbus

A and E Towing

1366 Duxberry Ave.
Columbus

A C AUTOMOTIVE & TRUCK SVC

7791 TAYLOR RD SW
Reynoldsburg

A Plus Complete Car Care

506 W High St
Mount Vernon

A Team Transmissions

6200 Huntley Rd
Columbus

A Z TRANSMISSION REBUILDERS LLC

1371 Frank Rd
Columbus

A+ Autobrokers, Inc.

504 West High Street
Mount Vernon

A-1 ECONOMY TRANSMISSIONS

854 E HUDSON ST
Columbus

A-1 TOWING

600 HUDSON RD
Delaware

A/T Towing & Recovery

488 Wingate Pl
Mount Sterling

AAMCO Transmissions

US Rt 33 N & Ety Rd
Lancaster

AAMCO Transmissions

12981 National Rd SW
Pataskala

AAMCO Transmissions

1770 Harding Hwy E
Marion

AAMCO Transmissions

320 LONDON RD
Delaware

AAMCO Transmissions & Total Car Care

3580 Cleveland Ave
Columbus

Accident Care Solutions

62 E. Barthman Ave
Columbus

ACCURATE AUTO CENTER

1726 E MAIN ST
Columbus

Accurate Mobile Diagnostics LLC

3921 Aries Brook Drive
Columbus

Action Auto & Recovery

432 E 18th Ave
Columbus

ACURA COLUMBUS

4340 DUBLIN GRANVILLE RD
Dublin

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

6901 E MAIN ST
Reynoldsburg

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

3011 GENDER RD
Reynoldsburg

Affliction Car Audio

3312 Morse Rd.
Columbus

Alternative Auto Care

136 W 5th Ave
Columbus

Auto & Truck MD

212 Franklin St
Canal Winchester

auto add-ons llc

6620 National Rd
Jacksontown

AUTO BODY COLLISION & GLASS

6520 E BROAD ST
Columbus

Auto Tech One

2189 S James Rd
Columbus

AUTO ZONE

2141 W BROAD ST
Columbus

AUTO ZONE

6445 E MAIN ST
Reynoldsburg

AUTOMOTIVE TECHNICIANS

7277 E MAIN ST
Reynoldsburg

Automotive Xperts LLC

4853 Westerville Rd
Columbus

backyard auto repair

283 east main st
Newark

Bexley Car Care

2140 E Livingston Ave
Columbus

Bill's On Broadway

4326 Broadway
Grove City

Boxcar One LLC

1319 Indiana Avenue
Marion

Boyd's Eastpointe Goodyear

55 Reynoldsburg - New Albany Rd
Blacklick

Buckeye Collision & Glass

2555 Brice Rd
Reynoldsburg

Buckeye Collision Service Inc

287 Lincoln Ave
Marion

BUCKEYE COMPLETE AUTO CARE

3701 KARL RD
Columbus

Byers Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram

465 S Hamilton Rd
Columbus

C & M Towing & Auto Repair

432 E 18th Ave
Columbus

CAPITAL CORE INC

3790 E 5TH AVE
Columbus

Capital Towing & Recovery, Inc.

1111 Stimmel Rd
Columbus

CAR CARE OF REYNOLDSBURG

6273 E MAIN ST
Columbus

CENTRAL GARAGE COMPANY INC

13000 NATIONAL RD
Reynoldsburg

Chris Williams

1538 Orson Dr
Columbus

Collision One LLC

5511 Westerville Rd
Westerville

COLLISION SPECIALISTS OF OHIO

10 4TH AVE SW
Pataskala

COLUMBUS CAR AUDIO & ACCESSORIES

2879 Taylor Rd Ext
Reynoldsburg

Columbus Car Audio & Accessories

2975A MORSE RD
Columbus

Columbus Scrap Cars

Front St
Columbus

COLUMBUS TRANSMISSION TECHNICIANS

201 N HAMILTON RD
Columbus

Costco

1500 Gemini Pl
Columbus

Coughlin Automotive Group

9000 E Broad St
Pataskala

Coughlin Ford of Johnstown

670 W Coshocton St
Johnstown

Court House Collision Center

2011 Columbus Ave.
Washington Courthouse

Crown Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram Dublin

6350 Perimeter Loop Rd
Dublin

CUSTOM FLEET & AUTO BODY

3303 E 11th Ave
Columbus

D & L BODY SHOP

10880 BORROR RD
Orient

DANDINI'S

112 E College Ave
Westerville

DAVE GILL CHEVROLET

4700 E BROAD ST
Columbus

DAVIDSON AUTO BODY COLLISION CENTER

2140 INTEGRITY DR S
Columbus

Delaware Automotive Service

201 E. William St.
Delaware

DENT AWAY

14628 E Broad St
Reynoldsburg

DENT MAGIC

6451 Sawmill Rd.
Dublin

Dent Mender

87 Smith Rd
Bellville

Dirty Truck Mobile Detailing

4653 Chatham Court
Dublin

DISCOUNT TIRE

2882 BRICE RD
Columbus

Dodds Bodyworks Inc

6350 E Main St
Reynoldsburg

Don's Body Shop Inc

13169 National Rd SW
Reynoldsburg

DON'S CAR CARE

4915 E MAIN ST
Columbus

Evans Towing

1178 Joyce Ave
Columbus

Faslube

1233 W 5th Ave
Columbus

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

2750 BRICE RD
Reynoldsburg

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

7085 E Main St
Reynoldsburg

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

3349 CLEVELAND AVE
Columbus

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

2847 S Hamilton Rd
Columbus

Fleetmax

2804 Johnstown Rd
Columbus

FRONT ROW BODY SHOP

940 BARNETT RD
Columbus

Geek Squad - Best Buy

1375 Polaris Pkwy
Columbus

Geek Squad - Best Buy

3840 MORSE RD
Columbus

Geek Squad - Best Buy

2782 Taylor Rd Ext
Reynoldsburg

Geek Squad - Best Buy

701 HEBRON RD
Heath

Germain Nissan

4300 Morse Rd
Columbus

Grismer Tire & Auto Service Center

9672 Liberty Crossings Drive
Powell

Harris Automotive

6159 Maxtown Rd
Westerville

Heston's Auto Service & Used Cars

603 Lincoln Ave
Lancaster

Hometown Service Center Inc

130 East College Ave
Westerville

HONDA BUCKEYE

2615 N MEMORIAL DR
Lancaster

HONNAMAN AUTOMOTIVE

5505 Chantry Drive
Columbus

Jack Maxton Lewis Center Used Cars

10200 Columbus Pike
Lewis Center

Jack Maxton Used Cars on Harrisburg Pike

1516 Harrisburg Pike
Columbus

JEG'S HIGH-PERFORMANCE CTR

6597 E MAIN ST
Reynoldsburg

JMM Towing

2553 Sandbury Blvd
Columbus

John's Auto Service Inc

749 E Lincoln Ave
Columbus

Junk Car Columbus - Cash For Cars

5491 San Gabriel Dr. Apt B
Columbus

Kj's towing

2941 Clime Rd
Columbus

Kraft's Body & Fender Co

600 Greenlawn Ave
Columbus

Kraftwerks

4797 Township Rd
Marengo

LIBERTY TOWING

2555 BRICE RD
Reynoldsburg

Local Boys Auto Service & Repair

13934 Broad St SW
Pataskala

LUBE DEPOT

792 Oak Dr
Marion

Lyon's Body Shop

7560 Mitchell-Dewitt Rd.
Plain City

L~N~J towing

1456 east 4 Th Ave
Columbus

MAGIC INDUSTRIES

4629 POTH RD
Reynoldsburg

Mathews Ford Newark

500 Hebron Road
Newark

MD Transmissions Ltd

320 London Rd
Delaware

METRO COLLISION OF COLUMBUS

200 OPM COMPANIES DR
Galloway

MIDAS MUFFLER & BRAKES

5559 N HIGH ST
Columbus

MIKE WARD RACING

67 KLEMA DR N
Reynoldsburg

MOGAVERO BROTHERS TOWING

7874 Slate Ridge Blvd
Reynoldsburg

N A P A AUTO PARTS

6370 E MAIN ST
Reynoldsburg

noAppdeals

PO Box 2415
Newark

NTB

2195 BALTIMORE REYNOLDSBURG RD
Reynoldsburg

OHIO ENGINE & TRANSMISSION EXC

3265 MCKINLEY AVE
Columbus

Optimum Maintenance Services, LLC

27420 Jackson Road, Building C
Circleville

Pagani's Downtown Car Care

175 Everett Ave
Newark

Performance Chrysler Jeep Dodge

1130 Automall Dr
Columbus

polaris automotive

8556 oak village blvd
Lewis Center

Polley Service Center

26525 Claibourne Rd
Richwood

precise automotive

2413 e.main st.
Lancaster

Rader Collision Center

3130 Switzer Ave
Columbus

Rieser’s Autobody East

6751 Taylor Road,
Blacklick

RJ WHEELS INC.

PO Box 340752
Columbus

Ron's Auto Restoration and Service Center

81 C East College Ave
Johnstown

Roush Honda

100 W Schrock Rd
Westerville

Rushman Automotive Transmissions

860 Refugee Rd
Pickerington

Safelite AutoGlass

760 Dearborn Park Ln
Worthington

SALTS TIRE

838 N CASSADY AVE
Columbus

Sears

771 S 30 St
Heath

SMITH'S TOWING

PO BOX 277
West Jefferson

Soda Clean of Ohio

6969 Worthington Galena Rd
Worthington

SOUNDCHAMBER

1101 E HUDSON ST
Columbus

SPOONER MARINE SVC

396 MORRISON RD
Reynoldsburg

Stringer Auto Repair

7 N. Main Street

SUPERIOR TOWING SVC LLC

121 HUMPHRIES DR
Reynoldsburg

Tailored Tasks

P.O Box 362
Columbus

Thompson's Towing

692 Lawrence Street
Lancaster

Tire Discounters

8197 E Broad St
Reynoldsburg

TireDiscounters

1968 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Rd
Reynoldsburg

Tomy Turbos Complete Care & Repair

1169 Chambers Rd
Columbus

Total Auto Repair

30 Lawn Ave
Columbus

Total Auto Repair

1890 S. High St
Columbus

TRAILS WEST AUTO & RV SALES

8600 E MAIN ST
Reynoldsburg

TRUE PERFORMANCE

7854 INDUSTRIAL PKWY
Plain City

Tuffy Tire & Auto Service

7854 Smoky Row Rd
Powell

Wayne's Auto Repair

2375 Schrock Rd.

Westerville Automotive

5591 Westerville Rd
Westerville

Westerville Automotive Uptown

31 E Main St
Westerville

Your Neighborhood Mechanic

13730 Ulery Rd
Sunbury

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Reynoldsburg.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Auto Repair Shop
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money