-Find top-rated Service Providers
Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Pickerington Insurance Companies

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Insurance Companies to Avoid

176

Top Rated Insurance Companies

10

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews
See Verified Local Reviews

Over 904 reviews for
Pickerington Insurance Companies from people just like you.

A
"We have been using for all of our insurance needs for the past several years. They are efficient, competitive, and locally owned and operated. Great experience!

-Ward S.

A
" is a remarkable insurance agent who goes way above and beyond to make sure that we have the right coverage. He has helped with several claims" and has walked us through the process and watched out for us on many occasions. I give and his agency the highest possible recommendation.

-Teresa P.

+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 3 Million People on Angie's List
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Over 3 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 3 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Pickerington

burned down house

Insurance Agents

Insurance agents represent one or more insurance companies and sell a variety of products including life, homeowners, auto and long-term care insurance.

drywall application

Think you can bypass the permit process when it's time to remodel?

drones used for home inspection
Home Inspection, Insurance Agencies

Drones make checking hard-to-reach places, such as steep roofs, much easier for home inspectors and insurance agents.

asphalt shingle roof and plumbing vent

Follow this advice from the roofing pros to check for and fix damage to your roof after a storm.

A man works on a roof with a hammer

Is a roofing company pressuring you to sign a contract or letter of intent before you’re ready? Don’t do it.

Angie's Answers

?
?
?

First, call your insurance company and tell them you do not want any proceeds paid to the contractor under your policy as you are not going with them.  This way they can not collect money on your behalf.  Insurance will typically have you sign a form for release of funds anyway but this is a good extra step to make sure your signature isn't forged.  Second, call the contractor and tell them you will not be needing their services afterall.  Did your husband pay a deposit?  If so it may be non-refundable.  Then follow up with a certified letter. 

 

An email as well doesn't hurt but some states don't yet recognize email as a form of communication for legally binding documentation.  This may have changed and I'm sure more states do recognize them as I haven't followed that topic elsewhere as much as I used to.  The contractor's office should be local.  A sure fire way to ensure they got the message is to deliver the letter to the office of the contractor and have someone at the office sign a duplicate stating it has been recieved and read.  There's no arguing whether they received it or not by doing that.

 

Hopefully you've learned your lesson about high pressure sales techniques and storm chasers looking for a quick buck.  Some people find out a much harder way.  While these guys may be legitimate you should always do your homework on a contractor before signing the contract.  Unless you have water running out of the house and the work has to be done on the spot it's not so much of an emergency that it can't wait until the next day.

 

Todd Shell

Todd's Home Services

San Antonio, TX

?
?
?
Consider going to library an reading Consumer Reports rating on home insurance companies in your area.  For affordabilty elect the highest deductable you can stomach.  This will lower your premioum, I went thru Costco, they and Sam's Club can be a valuable resource for home and car insurance. Shop on line with your needs to save money.  Unless you have major assets forget large policy. For your gutter and roofing needs see my blog.
Jim Casper 

Insurance Agent reviews in Pickerington

N

Rating
If there was a grade below F for professionalism I would of checked it instead. Very poor customer service, quite disappointed. Do not dare ask to make changes or corrections to an insurance binder as this was a HUGE inconvenience for the insurance agent. She got quite pissy about having to do her job. Wouldn't recommend this company at all!!!
- Diana S.
C

Rating
The lack of organization is unreal. I also blame myself for staying too long with this company. I have to make 2-3 phone calls or 2-3 emails to even get a response from this office. It's frustrating. I plan to spend some time looking for a new agent because my frustration has hit a new high.
- NANCY S K.
A

Rating
Dal was very friendly and knowledgeable and I didn't feel like I was pressured into making any choices. I would recommend going through him for anyone who has questions about life insurance.
- Lucas R.
F

Rating
In 2008, my mother passed away. The car and home insurance had been in her name, as it was less expensive that way. When she died, I informed of that, and that now only one car and the house would be on the insurance, under my name, as my sister had been given our mother's car. Subsequently, I received bills every six months ...More that seemed a bit high, but I had thought they this would be the combined cost of home and car insurance, as my driving record was excellent, and we had made no homeowner claims in quite some time. Also, during that time, I was kept busy not only with the title transfer of the house, but with several health issues that left me permanently disabled.
In April of 2012, I received and paid their bill. In May, I received a letter from them, stating that they could not find my homeowner insurance. The very next day, I received another letter, stating that I did not have a homeowner policy, and that I now owed more on my car insurance. The next two months I spent calling and emailing them, trying to see if I could get or renew the policy, with little or no response. Finally, I reached someone who would speak with me-I was told they did not do homeowner polices, and gave me no suggestions as to what I might do about getting a policy. A week later, I received a letter apologizing for all the difficulties, with the offer of donating $25 to one of their supported charities.
At that time, I looked into getting car insurance with a different company-when I found one I liked, with an office in my town, I got a policy with them, and called to cancel. I received several letters asking me to come back, but with no offers of homeowner insurance. I replied that I would never again go to them for any type of insurance.
With my new insurance company, I looked into getting homeowner insurance with them. Just before they were to come out for an inspection, Sandy hit, taking out most of my roof, and doing damage to the interior. It was livable, but just barely. Obviously, I could not get homeowner insurance at that time. FEMA helped pay for a new roof, and one of the Sandy Aid groups is helping with the interior.
I am permanently disabled, living on a very limited budget; and not having homeowner insurance to help out with the repair work was very distressing. When the new roof was finished, I was able to get homeowner insurance, and the combination of home & car is now less than I was paying for car insurance with .
I will never advise someone to use , and I will ever go to them for insurance again.
- Stephanie D.
N

Rating
We cancelled our insurance after 34 days. The refund proration was calculated at 796 dollars, but they only refunded 453 dollars. I have let them know of the problem and they have not corrected the refund. The refund took over 2 months to receive.

Very poor!

Refunds from Farmers and State Farm occur with days. This company ...More was very slow and communication came to a halt. When they were selling the policy they were very good, but refunds from cancelled policies were ignored or put on a slow track, hoping you would forget. If I had not been on them, we may never have gotten anything.

Bottom line, we were shorted a few hundred dollars and they have not responded to my concerns.
- John M.
F

Rating
Signed up with him based off of our mortgage companies recommendation. Switched our car insurance with them as well. We were insured several times that it was the exact same coverage. Price wasn't a concern for us as we just liked the policy we had and was switching to have all the insurance under one company. We found out that it wasn't the ...More same when we got in a wreck. We called the owner and he "called his guy" to check on if the gap coverage was on the insurance on the form he got from my previous insurance company. He called me back in 5 mins and said sorry it was never on there. I informed him that I was looking at the same form from the insurance company and its there. He said to call the insurance company he signed us up with and try to figure it out. There is no accountability here as they just want your money and unconcerned with the mistakes they cause people.


- Mo C.
A

Rating
It went awesome.
We had been working with another broker, but the policies they quoted us were too hard to decipher, so we reached out to for a second opinion. He was instantly helpful, responsive, provided excellent and thoughtful advice on the level of coverage we needed (and what we could clip). He proactively tailored ...More our policies to our needs, and was a dream to work with. Smart, efficient, and cheap, I will never buy insurance from any one else ever again.
- Daniel G.
A

Rating
Adjusters were amazing after I suffered a home fire. arrived at my home on the agreed upon time. He knew just what to do. He told me that I would get through this and with tears in my eyes I wanted to believe him. Everything he said came true. A rental home near my kids school was found. They helped ...More me every step of the way. I got a excellent settlement from my insurance provider. I would tell anyone to use . I can't thank them enough.
- Patricia T.

Insurance Companies in Pickerington, OH

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

A Plus Insurance

502 W High St
Mount Vernon

AAXIA CHEMICAL INSURANCE SERVICES

3946 NORTHHAMPTON DR
Powell

Accelerated Benefits

5880 Venture Drive
Dublin

ALFA VISION

210 WESTWOOD PL S

Allen Insurance & Financial Services

1505 Bethel Road Suite 202
Columbus

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

8378 Alderpoint Terrace
Pickerington

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

12920 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

670 HILL RD N
Pickerington

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

11299 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

Allstate Insurance Company - Phil Dietz

385 County Line Rd W
Westerville

Allstate-Rob Hyburg Agency

1105 Mt Vernon Ave
Marion

AMERICAN FAMILY INSURANCE

1180 HILL RD N
Pickerington

AMERICAN FAMILY INSURANCE

1255 HILL RD N
Pickerington

American Family Terry Gardner Agency

2686 N Columbus St Ste 100
Lancaster

Andrew Smarra - Allstate Insurance

104 E College Ave
Westerville

ANTHEM BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD

6740 N High St
Columbus

Aspire Benefit Services

6099 Riverside Drive, Suite 104

Associated Insurance Agencies Inc

63 Commerce Park Dr
Westerville

Augustine Insurance

3851 N High Street
Columbus

AUTO-OWNERS INSURANCE

PO Box 569
Worthington

Barton & Associates, Inc.

945 River Road
Granville

Beltran Constrution LLC

317 S Main St
Marion

Benchmark Insurance

515 Executive Campus Dr Ste 140
Westerville

BENEFIT SOLUTION INC

13570 SUDBURY PL
Pickerington

BILL OLSON INSURANCE

263 W 5TH ST
Marysville

Blascak Insurance Services

5000 Arlington Centre Blvd.
Upper Arlington

BREWSTER INSURANCE

11299 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

Bruce Johnson Insurance

5648 TARA HILL DR
Dublin

Business Insurance Solutions

407 Stelzer Road
Columbus

Capital City Financial Partners LLC

6600 Perimeter Dr.
Dublin

Capital Collision Ctr

3315 Refugee Rd
Columbus

Carinsurancezoom.org

21 W. Broad Street
Columbus

Central Ohio Insurance Services

1205 Hill Rd N
Pickerington

CHAMPION INSURANCE ASSOCIATES

3938 DAYTON-XENIA RD
Dayton

Cheapest Insurance Deals

395 East Broad Street
Columbus

Choice Home Warranty

1090 King Georges Post Rd

CIGNA

Columbus

Columbus Bail Bonds

330 S. High St

Columbus Insurance Market

4621 Community Way
Hilliard

Columbus Insurance Market - Brianna Baiocco

4719 Reed Rd suite 158
Columbus

Combs Insurance

8500 Cotter St
Lewis Center

CompManagement

6377 Emerald Pkwy
Dublin

Cornerstone Insurance Services

1505 Stonecreek Dr S
Pickerington

County Jail Bail Bonds

PO Box 30
Reynoldsburg

Creative Financial Insurance

201 Pennsylvania Avenue
Delaware

D A WILLIAMS INSURANCE LLC

8686 ASHFORD LN
Pickerington

DALE WHIMS INSURANCE

109 HILL RD N
Pickerington

David Grant State Farm Insurance

4612 N High St
Columbus

DAVIS INSURANCE

1110 BLUE HERON DR
Westerville

Dawson, Disantis & Myers LLC

21 W Central Ave
Delaware

Delaware Insurance Advisors

39 W Winter St
Delaware

Devin Koser - Americo

372 N 40th St
Newark

Duckie Exterior Solutions

2099 Hamilton Eaton Rd
Hamilton

Dumbaugh Insurance

13 E Winter St
Delaware

DUMBAUGH INSURANCE

122 S MAIN ST
Mount Vernon

Eagle Insurance Agency

206 N Columbus St
Sunbury

Eggleston Agency - Nationwide Insurance

1596 Stringtown Rd
Grove City

EISCHEN FINANCIAL GROUP

245 MT VERNON AVE
Columbus

ENGLAND INSURANCE

47 W Columbus St
Pickerington

ERIE INSURANCE

1335 DUBLIN RD
Columbus

Estate Planning Solutions

655 Metro Place South, Suite 600
Dublin

FARMERS INSURANCE GROUP

1251 HILL RD N
Pickerington

FINANCIAL SECURITY SVC

237 LOCKVILLE RD
Pickerington

G W MOHLER & ASSOC

12927 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

Gellner Insurance Services

103B Commerce Park Drive
Westerville

GESWEIN INSURANCE AGENCY

5214 BETHEL CTR MALL
Columbus

Gilles Insurance Agency

163 N Sandusky St 204
Delaware

Glenn Insurance Group

3 W Main Street
Westerville

GREENLEE INSURANCE

8525 Refugee Rd
Pickerington

Guy P Williams Insurance Agency

1335 Dublin Rd
Columbus

GWYNN VAUGHAN INSURANCE

888 HIGH ST
Columbus

Health Benefit Consultants LLC

20275 Honeysuckle Dr.

healthmarkets

250 w old wilson bridge suite 270

Heischman Financial Services

7676 Slate Ridge Blvd
Reynoldsburg

Heyward Group, LLC

2970 McKinley Ave
Columbus

Hilborn Insurance

42 N Sandusky St
Delaware

HORACE MANN CO

9846 CAMELOT ST
Pickerington

Hyers and Associates, Inc.

240 Collins Avenue
Columbus

Insuractive, Inc.

8420 W. Dodge Rd.

INSURANCE CIRCLE

44 S HIGH ST
Canal Winchester

Insurance-Quotes.net

3291 E Main St
Columbus

Integrated Small Biz Solutions

5880 Venture Dr
Dublin

Investments For You, Inc.

1040 N Maple St
Marysville

Jami Norman - Allstate Agent

325 S Sandusky St
Delaware

JEFF FINEGAN AGENCY

1180 HILL RD N
Pickerington

Jobes Insurance Agency, LLC

482 Harcourt Rd
Mount Vernon

Joe Duke Insurance / IIS Agency Inc.

133 S Main St
Marysville

JOHN PYSARCHUK INSURANCE

515 HILL RD N
Pickerington

JOHNSON INSURANCE

40 HILL RD S
Pickerington

Jon Pantone Insurance Agency

2500 Farmers Dr
Columbus

JUSTICE INSURANCE

1029 Refugee Rd Ste 200
Pickerington

Kahrl & Company Insurance

11 S Melberry St
Mount Vernon

KERNAN INSURANCE AGENCY, INC

9932 Brewster Lane
Powell

KYM BUCHANAN AGENCY

444 Sycamore St
Urbana

Lawrence Insurance Agency

150 S. Greenwood St
Marion

Leist Mercantile Inc.

133 Pinckney Street
Circleville

LEONE INSURANCE

PO Box 538
Sunbury

LIBERTY MUTUAL GROUP

1306 HILL ROAD NORTH
Pickerington

Local Life Agents

1515 Bethel Rd suite 105a
Columbus

LOY INSURANCE INC

6338 HIBISCUS CT
Westerville

LTC Financial Partners

1537 Guilford Rd
Columbus

LUTZ INSURANCE

1180 HILL RD N
Pickerington

MARKER INSURANCE SVC

1258 Hill Rd N
Pickerington

Martin J. Mitchell Insurance

51B N Sandusky St
Delaware

MASTERS INSURANCE GROUP

5525 PARKCENTER CIR
Dublin

Max Moarefdoust Agency-Allstate Insurance

1190 County Line Rd
Westerville

McGlothin Insurance

6059 Frantz Rd Ste 106
Dublin

Miller-Lewis Benefit Consultants

121 E 6th Ave
Lancaster

MMA Insurance

107 W COLUMBUS ST
Pickerington

MOCCABEE INSURANCE

341 Norton Rd
Columbus

Montana Insurance and Financial Services

1311 WORTHINGTON WOODS BLVD
Columbus

MReed Financial

2807 Vista Mariana

MULIT FAMILY INS PARTNERS LLC

9274 SOUTHCHESTER DR
Pickerington

MVP Agency

73 S Main St
Johnstown

NBC, Inc.

470 Forest Ave

New York Life Insurance

485 Metro Place South, STE 350
Dublin

Newco Insurance

2939 Kenny Rd
Columbus

noAppdeals

PO Box 2415
Newark

NORMAN J RISOYA ASSN INC

11299 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

Outcalt Kerns Insurance

1001 Eastwind Dr Suite 108
Westerville

Patel & Associates LLC.

2530 Berryessa Rd

Pathway Insurance Services, Inc

4221 Malsbary Rd
Cincinnati

PECK FAMILY INSURANCE

155 E COLUMBUS ST
Pickerington

PERSONAL LINES ADMINISTRATION

118 WAGNALLS CT
Pickerington

Physicians Mutual

925 N State St
Westerville

Polaris Financial Services

7129 Hilmar Dr
Westerville

Quickinsured

580 N 4th St
Columbus

Rapp Insurance Service, LLC

20550 State Route 245
Marysville

RAY INSURANCE AGENCY INC

1580 FISHINGER RD
Columbus

Rivers Insurance Group

2185 Pace Street G2B
Columbus

Rugloski and Associates

537 E. Gail Lane

Ryan Rito Agency - Nationwide Insurance

999 County Line Rd W
Westerville

S L PIERCE AGENCY

3976 Clark Shaw Rd
Powell

SafeAuto

4 Easton Oval
Columbus

Scharver Insurance Group

14 2nd St
New Albany

SELECTIVE INSURANCE CO

831 LISMORE PL
Pickerington

Senior Health Direct

719 E. Grand River Ave.

SKEEN INSURANCE

12927 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

SKY INSURANCE

221 S Church St
Bowling Green

SLYMAN INSURANCE

172 Granville St
Columbus

Smith-Brogan Insurance

1471 Granville Rd
Newark

SOLLER INSURANCE AGENCY

891 S JAMES RD
Columbus

STATE FARM - MARK SCHAEFER

1258 GRANDVIEW AVE
Columbus

STATE FARM INSURANCE

1670 COLUMBUS RD
Granville

STATE FARM INSURANCE

1239 HILL RD N
Pickerington

STATE FARM INSURANCE

194 W CHURCH ST
Pickerington

State Farm – Suzanne Rizer

2930 Hayden Run Plaza
Columbus

State Farm- Jason Hoy

5806 Zarley St
New Albany

Staten & Associates, LLC

5441 Mirage Drive
Hilliard

STRUCTURED EMPLOYEE BENEFITS

815 Grandview Ave Ste 200
Columbus

TAXMOM

3079 W Broad St
Columbus

The DeVelvis Group - Nationwide Insurance

488 Polaris Parkway
Westerville

The Financial Solutions Network, LLC

6641 North High St
Worthington

The Granville Investment Group, Inc.

1911 Newark Granville Rd
Granville

The Weinzierl Agency

1258 Hill Rd N
Pickerington

Thompson Cunningham Insurance

5760 N High St
Columbus

THRIVENT FINANCIAL

250 W Old Wilson Bridge Rd Ste 255
Worthington

Tom Jones Insurance Inc

12165 Lancaster St
Millersport

United Health Care

PO Box 30555

Vardar Insurance Group, LLC

3322 Kristin Ct.
Columbus

VASBINDER INSURANCE

21735 PLANK RD, Suite E
Howard

WE DAVIS INSURANCE AGENCY

29 FREDERICK ST
Columbus

Wendy R. Sams Insurance Agency, Inc.

9039 Antares Ave Ste D-1a
Columbus

WESTFIELD INSURANCE COMPANY

2000 POLARIS PKWY
Columbus

WHITNEY INSURANCE INC

560 SUNBURY RD
Delaware

Williamson Insurance Service

686 W. Church Street
Newark

Shop Local Insurance Agent Services in Pickerington, OH

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Pickerington.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Insurance Company
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money