Pickerington Insurance Agents

in Pickerington, OH

164
Insurance Agents are
in Pickerington

24
Insurance Agents in Pickerington
are top rated

A
Rated by
Olivia B.
"I was looking for a Life Insurance Policy and
was very prompt about getting me some quotes that were within my price range. She was very courteous and professional." She was willing to work within the price range I could afford and not try to talk me into something else. I would highly recommend her to anyone.
A
Rated by
JOSEPH G.
"
submitted the claim and tenaciously followed it through the various stalling tactics of the insurer. Since the roof was not actually leaking, they didn't" seem to have an urgency to resolve the claim. Had I been handling this claim myself I probably would have given up. The result with
was that the insurer settled by paying for an entire new roof more than I ever expected as the roof was 26 years old.
F
Rated by
Manav G.
"Worst State Farm agent ever!!! I have been with State Farm for 16 years and recently moved to the Princeton, NJ area and had to switch from my agent in VA to this new agent in NJ."
is absolutely horrible. After a couple of months after I booked insurance from him my policy was terminated because of an error on their end and they didn't even bother to tell me, they just sent me a letter saying that my coverage has ended and that I was no longer covered. When I called their office
said that they made an error on the current policy and that I need to pay more money for the right coverage. So i decided to forgive them for their error and pay for the new policy. A month goes by and I received a letter in the mail saying again that my coverage was going to be terminated. Then a couple of days after I received this letter I received another letter saying please ignore the letter of termination and that my coverage was still active. Then I received a check from State Farm because my coverage had been terminated. I then received a bill from State Farm asking me for more money. I called my agents office and spoke to the office manager and asked about what is going on and they said that they made another error and that my policy amount has increased by 60%, so basically they want more money. I asked to speak to my actual agent and it has been over 1 week and my agent still has not contacted me back even though i try to call their office everyday. This agent doesn't really care about his clients. I've been requesting for him to contact me and he still hasn't. When a customer has an issue and wants to speak to his agent they should contact me back. This is the worst experience I have ever had with dealing with my car insurance. Stay away from using this agent!!

Pickerington Insurance Agent Articles

Insurance Agent reviews in Pickerington

A

Rating
A+. Highly recommended. Whereas other agents either didn't reply or took many days,
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
replied within 10 minutes of my email and had several options for me within 1 hour. He was courteous, professional, prompt, and precise the entire time. In addition, he communicated several times with my mortgage company so that I didn't have to endure endless wait times on the phone. The real kicker is that agents really don't make much money at all on these types of short-term investment property policies! Yet,
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
still did a great job.
- Phillip S.
A

Rating
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
, rep through
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
Agency, is a great insurance agent to find the right policy for you regardless of what your needs are. He has provided insurance for both of my companies, house, car and motorcycles. He's very diligent and finds just the right deal for any project. Great person to get a quote from!
- KRISTIN S.
F

Rating
Their tactics are very undermining and they try to make it nearly impossible to cancel your contract. You have to make sure you send a certified letter to cancel and pray that it actually gets there. I have canceled via e-mail, fax, phone call and certified letter and they will not send a notice of cancelation to my insurance company until that certified letter gets there and it is taking forever. They seemed like nice people at first, but I am not so sure after how impossible they are making things to cancel. I should have noticed that the only other review on their site is actually from them. Proceed with caution.
- laura S.
A

Rating
Note: the address that Angie's List defaults to for this provider is incorrect or outdated. Their current address is: 3443 1st Ave N St. Petersburg, FL 33713. Now for my review:
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
is my insurance agency for my homeowner's insurance, for the house I just bought at the end of June. I have been very pleased with the service I have received from them. My agent (named
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
) took a lot of time on the phone with me, explaining my options for insurance. I felt it was a very personalized experience. Since then, there has been something that came up which gave me an opportunity to learn how they would be as an agency, above and beyond simply procuring me the insurance in the first place. It turns out that the home inspector, who did my required four-point inspection, did not provide the insurance company with the requisite photos that are supposed to go with the report--he only provided the report itself. I didn't know any of this for a few months, as my loan went through and my insurance was obtained, but apparently the insurance company had told the agency that they would need to get those photos, and my agent was trying to get them from the inspector for quite a while, yet he didn't respond to her requests (review of him will probably be forthcoming at a later date!). Finally, she cc'd me in on her third email attempt to get him to send the pictures, but by then the insurance company had sent out a Notice of Cancellation of my policy, which was going to be cancelled as of tomorrow (October 3), if the photos were not sent! Long story short, my agent advised me on what to do, since the inspector either never took the photos or lost them or SOMETHING, but he never provided them. I got the photos taken for her by my handyman (who happens to have been a home inspector in the past, so he understood exactly what was needed and did a great job accessing my hot water heater, which is covered in a vinyl sided container that would have been hard for me to get into--thank goodness for my wonderful handyman!--and snapping the pics of the plumbing under the sinks in the house), and my agent then got them to the insurance company. I just confirmed with her today that my insurance has been reinstated. All this because a home inspector inexplicably did not do his basic job during the 4-point inspection, but don't get me started on him. The point here is: the
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
insurance agency really came through for me, they did what they were supposed to do by repeatedly contacting the home inspector to ask for the photos, and then ultimately bringing me, the homeowner, into the mix, and advising me what I needed to do to get the insurance reinstated. Thanks to them, there will be no lapse in my insurance, and everything is in order, and my mortgage company won't end up going into my escrow and buying some expensive insurance of their choosing.
It is situations such as this that really give you an opportunity to see how your insurance agency is going to come through for you if something weird and unforeseen comes up. You hope it never does, but if it does, you want an agency like
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
behind you to help you through it!!
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
was great, very reassuring and professional throughout, and very proactive in emailing the home inspector and even calling their office, and then in telling me what I needed to do, since the home inspector was unresponsive. Like I said, thanks to
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
, my insurance is reinstated. Not only that, I felt like I was dealing with a person throughout the entire thing--which I was--instead of an uncaring, big company.
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
is very personalized. I hope to stick with them as my agent/agency the entire time I own my new house, which hopefully will be the rest of my life. Thank you,
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
and
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
!!!
- EDNA W.
A

Rating
My roof was damaged in a storm. Water came through the roof and part of the ceiling fell off. Water ran down to the second floor into all three bedrooms. The kitchen was also damaged from the water. What a mess. I didn't know what to do. I have heard horror stories from other people who didn't hire an adjuster and they got robbed by their insurance companies. So I found
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
on Angie List and loved the reviews he got. I called and left a message. He called me back right away.
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
and I set up an appointment for that week. He came over and looked at everything. I gave him the insurance info and
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
took over. I didn't have to worry about dealing with the insurance company. He kept me up to date with phone calls and then I got the check less depreciation. Even after paying
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
for his services after he gave me the check at the end of
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
he is still helping me to get the depreciation money and
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
said he is pages in full even if after having everything fixed and I go over the check amount.
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
will submit the receipts for me so I can get my money back.
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
is an angel sent down to help those of us in need and worth every penny. Thanks
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
. You Rock!
- Eileen V.
F

Rating
The process of getting the bumper repair was terrible. American Insurance sent my vehicle to
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
Honda Dealership for repairs. According to American Auto Insurance Company they would only allow me to receive a rental car for 3 days because the bumper repair was considered minimal. I returned to drop of the rental car on the date specified. The rental company would not accept the vehicle back because my car was not yet repaired. I waited over 30 mins for them to tell me
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
Auto Insurance Company would not approve or accept the return of the rental car because repairs were not yet completed. The dealer ended up taking almost two weeks on a minor,
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
bumper repair.
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
did not cover or reimburse me the cost of the rental vehicle for the dates the dealership took extra. After, finally receiving my vehicle back the repairs were lousy and of poor quality, not what you would expect from a dealership.
- Roberto V.
A

Rating
We found
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
on Angie's List, and he was at our house within an hour of our initial call. We had a water leak under our wood floors.
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
worked up the valuation, our claim was submitted to the insurance company and
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
negotiated with the insurance company's adjuster to reach an agreed amount. We received our claim payment within a couple weeks of discovering the leak.
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
was invaluable in the process. We would use
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
again in the future and recommend him highly.
- Erika F.

All Insurance Agents in Pickerington, OH

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

3 Pointe Financial

8001 Irvine Center Dr

A Plus Insurance

401 W Vine St
Mount Vernon

AAA Car Center

90 E Wilson Bridge Rd
Worthington

ABEL FINANCIAL STRATEGIES

3130 Winding Woods Dr
Powell

AK Utilities

310 Morton St

ALFA VISION

210 WESTWOOD PL S

Allegiant Group Inc

189 W Clarkston Rd Ste 1

Allstate Insurance - Billy Joe Williams

1324 Cooper Foster Park Road
Lorain

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

12920 Stonecreek Dr Ste D
Pickerington

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

8378 Alderpoint Terrace
Pickerington

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

670 HILL RD N
Pickerington

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

11299 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

12920 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

Allstate Insurance Company - Phil Dietz

385 County Line Rd W
Westerville

Allstate-Rob Hyburg Agency

1105 Mt Vernon Ave
Marion

Allsup Inc

300 Allsup Pl

American Family Insurance

3040 Riverside Dr
Columbus

AMERICAN FAMILY INSURANCE

1180 HILL RD N
Pickerington

AMERICAN FAMILY INSURANCE

10400 BLACKLICK EASTERN RD
Pickerington

AMERICAN FAMILY INSURANCE

1255 HILL RD N
Pickerington

Associated Insurance Agencies Inc

63 Commerce Park Dr
Westerville

Augustine Insurance

3851 N High Street
Columbus

Barton & Associates, Inc.

945 River Road
Granville

Beltran Constrution LLC

676 Bell Fountain Ave
Marion

Benchmark Insurance

515 Executive Campus Dr Ste 140
Westerville

BENEFIT SOLUTION INC

13570 SUDBURY PL
Pickerington

BILL OLSON INSURANCE

263 W 5TH ST
Marysville

BREWSTER INSURANCE

11299 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

Bruce Johnson Insurance

5648 TARA HILL DR
Dublin

Capital City Financial Partners LLC

6600 Perimeter Dr.
Dublin

Capital Collision Ctr

3315 Refugee Rd
Columbus

Careington Care 500 Plan

7400 Gaylord Pkwy

Central Ohio Insurance

10400 Blacklick Eastern Rd., Suite 120
Pickerington

CHAMPION INSURANCE ASSOCIATES

3938 DAYTON-XENIA RD
Dayton

CIGNA

Columbus

Columbus Insurance Market

4621 Community Way
Hilliard

Columbus Insurance Market - Brianna Baiocco

4719 Reed Rd suite 158
Columbus

Combs Insurance

8500 Cotter St
Lewis Center

CompManagement Inc

6377 Emerald Parkway
Dublin

Cornerstone Insurance Services

1505 Stonecreek Dr S
Pickerington

County Jail Bail Bonds

PO Box 30
Reynoldsburg

Creative Financial Insurance

7585 BROWN RD
Ostrander

D A WILLIAMS INSURANCE LLC

8686 ASHFORD LN
Pickerington

DALE WHIMS INSURANCE

109 HILL RD N
Pickerington

David Grant State Farm Insurance

4612 N High St
Columbus

DAVIS INSURANCE

1110 BLUE HERON DR
Westerville

Dawson, Disantis & Myers LLC

21 W Central Ave
Delaware

Delaware Insurance Advisors

39 W Winter St
Delaware

DOLBOW INSURANCE

212 S. STATE STREET
Westerville

Duckie Exterior Solutions

2099 Hamilton Eaton Rd
Hamilton

Dumbaugh Insurance

13 E Winter St
Delaware

DUMBAUGH INSURANCE

122 S MAIN ST
Mount Vernon

Dunlap Wealth Management Group

14074 Trade Center Dr

Eagle Insurance Agency

206 N Columbus St
Sunbury

Eggleston Agency - Nationwide Insurance

1596 Stringtown Rd
Grove City

EISCHEN FINANCIAL GROUP

245 MT VERNON AVE
Columbus

ENGLAND INSURANCE

47 W Columbus St
Pickerington

Estate Planning Solutions

655 Metro Place South, Suite 600
Dublin

FARMERS INSURANCE GROUP

1251 HILL RD N
Pickerington

FINANCIAL SECURITY SVC

237 LOCKVILLE RD
Pickerington

G W MOHLER & ASSOC

12927 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

GESWEIN INSURANCE AGENCY

5214 BETHEL CTR MALL
Columbus

Glenn Insurance Group

3 W Main Street
Westerville

Grange Insurance

671 S High St
Columbus

GREENLEE INSURANCE

8525 Refugee Rd
Pickerington

GWYNN VAUGHAN INSURANCE

888 HIGH ST
Columbus

HEALTH BENEFIT CONSULTANTS LLC.

20275 Honeysuckle Dr.

Heischman Financial Services

7676 Slate Ridge Blvd
Reynoldsburg

Henry Insurance Agency LLC

2757 Observatory Ave #22
Cincinnati

HORACE MANN CO

9846 CAMELOT ST
Pickerington

Integrated Small Biz Solutions

5880 Venture Dr
Dublin

Investments For You, Inc.

1040 N Maple St
Marysville

Jami Norman - Allstate Agent

325 S Sandusky St
Delaware

JEFF FINEGAN AGENCY

1180 HILL RD N
Pickerington

Joe Duke Insurance / IIS Agency Inc.

133 S Main St
Marysville

JOHN PYSARCHUK INSURANCE

515 HILL RD N
Pickerington

JOHNSON INSURANCE

40 HILL RD S
Pickerington

Jon Pantone Insurance Agency

2500 Farmers Dr
Columbus

JUSTICE INSURANCE

1029 Refugee Rd Ste 200
Pickerington

Kahrl & Company Insurance

11 S Melberry St
Mount Vernon

KYM BUCHANAN AGENCY

444 Sycamore St
Urbana

LEONE INSURANCE

PO Box 538
Sunbury

LIBERTY MUTUAL GROUP

1306 HILL ROAD NORTH
Pickerington

LOY INSURANCE INC

6338 HIBISCUS CT
Westerville

LTC Financial Partners

1537 Guilford Rd
Columbus

LUTZ INSURANCE

1180 HILL RD N
Pickerington

MARKER INSURANCE SVC

1258 Hill Rd N
Pickerington

Martin J Mitchell - Allstate Agent

3816 Fishinger Blvd
Hilliard

Martin J. Mitchell Insurance

51B N Sandusky St
Delaware

MASTERS INSURANCE GROUP

5525 PARKCENTER CIR
Dublin

Max Moarefdoust Agency-Allstate Insurance

1190 County Line Rd
Westerville

McGlothin Insurance

6059 Frantz Rd Ste 106
Dublin

Michael Borne Insurance

80222 Avenida Santa Olivia

Miller-Lewis Benefit Consultants

121 E 6th Ave
Lancaster

Mitchell Insurance Agency, Inc.

7450 Industrial Pkwy
Plain City

MMA Insurance

107 W COLUMBUS ST
Pickerington

MOCCABEE INSURANCE

341 Norton Rd
Columbus

Montana Insurance and Financial Services

1311 WORTHINGTON WOODS BLVD
Columbus

MULIT FAMILY INS PARTNERS LLC

9274 SOUTHCHESTER DR
Pickerington

MVP Agency

73 S Main St
Johnstown

NATIONWIDE INSURANCE

6834 CAINE RD
Columbus

NBC, Inc.

470 Forest Ave

Newco Insurance

2939 Kenny Rd
Columbus

Nibert Insurance

118 S Main St
Marysville

NORMAN J RISOYA ASSN INC

11299 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington

Outcalt Kerns Insurance

1001 Eastwind Dr Suite 108
Westerville

Patel & Associates LLC.

2530 Berryessa Rd

Pathway Insurance Services, Inc

4221 Malsbary Rd
Cincinnati

PECK FAMILY INSURANCE

155 E COLUMBUS ST
Pickerington

PERSONAL LINES ADMINISTRATION

118 WAGNALLS CT
Pickerington

PFEIFER ORNSTEIN INSURANCE

3291 E MAIN ST
Columbus

Physicians Mutual

925 N State St
Westerville

Polaris Financial Services

7129 Hilmar Dr
Westerville

Rapp Insurance Service, LLC

20550 State Route 245
Marysville

RAY INSURANCE AGENCY INC

1580 FISHINGER RD
Columbus

Ryan Rito Agency - Nationwide Insurance

999 County Line Rd W
Westerville

S L PIERCE AGENCY

3976 Clark Shaw Rd
Powell

S P Johnson Group

293 Mulberry St

Safe Harbor Retirement Group

6099 Frantz Rd
Dublin

SafeAuto

4 Easton Oval
Columbus

Scharver Insurance Group

14 2nd St
New Albany

Scott Bricker - Allstate Agent

54 Dillmont Dr
Columbus

Senior Health Direct

719 E. Grand River Ave.

SKY INSURANCE

221 S Church St
Bowling Green

SLYMAN INSURANCE

172 Granville St
Columbus

Smith-Brogan Insurance

1471 Granville Rd
Newark

STATE FARM - MARK SCHAEFER

1258 GRANDVIEW AVE
Columbus

STATE FARM BILL ALSNAUER

2500 W DUBLIN GRANVILLE RD
Columbus

STATE FARM INSURANCE

1670 COLUMBUS RD
Granville

STATE FARM INSURANCE

194 W CHURCH ST
Pickerington

STATE FARM INSURANCE

1239 HILL RD N
Pickerington

State Farm – Suzanne Rizer

2930 Hayden Run Plaza
Columbus

State Farm- Jason Hoy

5806 Zarley St
New Albany

STRUCTURED EMPLOYEE BENEFITS

815 Grandview Ave Ste 200
Columbus

TAXMOM

3079 W Broad St
Columbus

The DeVelvis Group - Nationwide Insurance

488 Polaris Parkway
Westerville

The Weinzierl Agency

1258 Hill Rd N
Pickerington

Thompson Cunningham Insurance

5760 N High St
Columbus

THRIVENT FINANCIAL

250 W Old Wilson Bridge Rd Ste 255
Worthington

United Health Care

PO Box 30555

VASBINDER INSURANCE

21735 PLANK RD, Suite E
Howard

WE DAVIS INSURANCE AGENCY

29 FREDERICK ST
Columbus

Wendy R. Sams Insurance Agency, Inc.

9039 Antares Ave Ste D-1a
Columbus

WESTFIELD INSURANCE COMPANY

2000 POLARIS PKWY
Columbus

WHITNEY INSURANCE INC

560 SUNBURY RD
Delaware

Shop Local Insurance Agent Services in Pickerington, OH

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Pickerington.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Insurance Agent
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money