Pickerington Insurance Companies

in Pickerington, OH

156
Insurance Agents are
in Pickerington

21
Insurance Agents in Pickerington
are top rated

A
Rated by
Erika F.
"We found
on Angie's List, and he was at our house within an hour of our initial call. We had a water leak under our wood floors.
" worked up the valuation, our claim was submitted to the insurance company and
negotiated with the insurance company's adjuster to reach an agreed amount. We received our claim payment within a couple weeks of discovering the leak.
was invaluable in the process. We would use
again in the future and recommend him highly.
F
Rated by
Amy B.
"We have been clients of Rich
for 20 years and given them over $80,000. We thought we had a good agent, this is what we have learned: This agent is simply a" salesman. They do not handle claims, they do not have any control over your actual insurance policy. They simply collect your money to maintain an office and make a profit, and exist to sell you more insurance. We were fraudulently denied a claim from
. The "professional” they sent out to inspect the damage was ill-qualified and couldn't distinguish a hardwood floor from laminate. He also stated that flooding couldn't warp wood flooring. On the basis of this inspection
denied an obviously covered damage. We have had two independent contractors out to inspect the damage and both came away with the exact opposite assessment of the damage. We called Rich
's office and were told they could do nothing; they did not talk about claims to the insurance they sell. We were blown off by the office manager
(i??), we were told the owner Rich does not talk to clients, only his office staff does. Look up State farms records; they are in several class action and personal lawsuits. Spend your money wisely. Spend it elsewhere.
F
Rated by
Carla O.
"My fire insurance was cancelled after 19 years of premiums paid on time. I was told because I owned an American Staffordshire Terrier. He was very well behaved with compliments about" him from the Auburn University Small Animal Hospital. Besides the fact that he didn't play with matches

Pickerington Insurance Agents

Pickerington, OH

156
Insurance Agentsare in Pickerington

21
Pickerington Insurance Agents are TOP RATED

Pickerington Insurance Agent Articles

Insurance Agent reviews in Pickerington

A

Rating
When I lived in California, my insurance agent was a person with whom I had been close friends for around 25 years. We had become friends long before he started his career in the insurance industry. When I needed insurance, I turned to him and he serviced me with all the care that you'd expect from an old friend.
Moving to Tampa I had to secure new policies. I went through several agents, receiving service that was mediocre at best. Even the most conscientious often took several days to return my calls, and then take a couple more days to get back to me with answers to my questions.
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
was referred to me by my attorney who had referred me to a couple other helpful professionals. From our initial conversation he was interested in my needs, really understood what I told him and worked hard to get me the most suitable coverage.
When I have had questions on claims, he has contacted the carrier himself, and gotten all the answers which he has explained clearly & patiently. He always answers my calls and emails immediately. I do not believe that there is a time that he has not returned a call or message the same day.
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
is every bit as interested in my well-being as my friend/agent in California. In fact, I would have to say that he is one of the most caring people I have ever met. He is also very knowledgeable and competent giving me full peace of mind with regard to my insurance needs.

- SUZANNE P.
A

Rating
Mr
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
dealt with absolutely everything. I did not have to speak to my insurance company at all and he got me a new roof and money for the interior repairs. He was always very punctual, kept me up to date on proceedings and explained I would not get the full amount until after the roof had been fixed because the insurance company would hold onto the depreciation until then. Once the roof had been replaced my insurance company did send me the full amount.
I would absolutely recommend anyone who has an insurance claim to contact him. He was very professional and reassuring and his fee was extremely reasonable. I would not hesitate to call him again if I have another insurance claim on my house.
- Jacqueline T.
A

Rating
They saved me quite a bit of money on my homeowner's policy, and discovered that my previous agent had done a very poor job of assessing my needed coverage. State Farm made sure that I am now properly covered for the value of my home and my possessions. Their office staff is incredibly friendly and professional, and I am very happy with my experience.
- KARON F.
A

Rating
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
's customer service is the differentiator. I felt comfortable he was giving me reliable information and delivered when he promised or earlier. His prices were competitive with what I expected to pay and he was able to guide me through some of the more confusing aspects of insuring property. I'm going back to
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
to consolidate all my insurance needs.
- Robert T.
A

Rating
He is a true professional. He is truthful, honest, and always available if I ever have any questions on my policies. I would definitely recommend anyone who is looking for an insurance agent to give
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
a call. He is great to work with and will always take care of you.
- Eddie K.
A

Rating
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
provided me with three quotes within 24 hours of my call. When the insurer (Travelers) wanted repairs made to the roof and railings on the back porch,
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
provided me with the name of a roofer, whom I did hire. Excellent work. Once work was completed,
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
came by and took pictures and provided all of the necessary information to Travelers. A great experience!
- Anne S.
A

Rating
Not only is
Pickerington Insurance Agents Provider Name Locked
a great insurance agent, she is reliable, very responsive, and gives better than great personal service. She takes the time each year to review my policy and make sure I have all the coverage I need. In addition, she does everything she can to get me the most coverage for the best price, which I truly appreciate.
- Carole T.
110% Guaranteed Money Back

We think we're the best, and we can prove it.

Try an annual plan and if you want to cancel in your first year, we'll refund you 110%

Annual Plans Only

All Insurance Agents in Pickerington, OH

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

3 Pointe Financial

8001 Irvine Center Dr
Irvine, CA

A Plus Insurance

401 W Vine St
Mount Vernon, OH

ABEL FINANCIAL STRATEGIES

3130 Winding Woods Dr
Powell, OH

AK Utilities

310 Morton St
Richmond, TX

ALFA VISION

210 WESTWOOD PL S
Brentwood, TN

Allegiant Group Inc

189 W Clarkston Rd Ste 1
Lake Orion, MI

Allstate Insurance - Billy Joe Williams

1324 Cooper Foster Park Road
Lorain, OH

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

12920 Stonecreek Dr Ste D
Pickerington, OH

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

8378 Alderpoint Terrace
Pickerington, OH

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

670 HILL RD N
Pickerington, OH

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

12920 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington, OH

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO

11299 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington, OH

Allstate Insurance Company - Phil Dietz

385 County Line Rd W
Westerville, OH

Allstate-Rob Hyburg Agency

1105 Mt Vernon Ave
Marion, OH

Allsup Inc

300 Allsup Pl
Belleville, IL

American Family Insurance

3040 Riverside Dr
Columbus, OH

AMERICAN FAMILY INSURANCE

1180 HILL RD N
Pickerington, OH

AMERICAN FAMILY INSURANCE

10400 BLACKLICK EASTERN RD
Pickerington, OH

AMERICAN FAMILY INSURANCE

1255 HILL RD N
Pickerington, OH

ANTHEM BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD

6740 N High St
Columbus, OH

Asbury Insurance Agency

Westerville, oh

Associated Insurance Agencies Inc

63 Commerce Park Dr
Westerville, OH

Augustine Insurance

3851 N High Street
Columbus, OH

Beltran Constrution LLC

676 Bell Fountain Ave
Marion, OH

Benchmark Insurance

515 Executive Campus Dr Ste 140
Westerville, OH

BENEFIT SOLUTION INC

13570 SUDBURY PL
Pickerington, OH

BILL OLSON INSURANCE

263 W 5TH ST
Marysville, OH

BREWSTER INSURANCE

11299 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington, OH

Browning Reagle Insurance Agency

117 South Main Street
Mount Airy, MD

Bruce Johnson Insurance

5648 TARA HILL DR
Dublin, OH

Capital City Financial Partners LLC

6600 Perimeter Dr.
Dublin, OH

Capital Collision Ctr

3315 Refugee Rd
Columbus, OH

Careington Care 500 Plan

7400 Gaylord Pkwy
Frisco, TX

Central Ohio Insurance

10400 Blacklick Eastern Rd., Suite 120
Pickerington, OH

CHAMPION INSURANCE ASSOCIATES

3938 DAYTON-XENIA RD
Dayton, OH

CIGNA

Columbus, OH

Columbus Insurance Market

4621 Community Way
Hilliard, OH

Columbus Insurance Market - Brianna Baiocco

4719 Reed Rd suite 158
Columbus, OH

Combs Insurance

8500 Cotter St
Lewis Center, OH

Cornerstone Insurance Services

1505 Stonecreek Dr S
Pickerington, OH

County Jail Bail Bonds

PO Box 30
Reynoldsburg, OH

Creative Financial Insurance

7585 BROWN RD
Ostrander, OH

D A WILLIAMS INSURANCE LLC

8686 ASHFORD LN
Pickerington, OH

DALE WHIMS INSURANCE

109 HILL RD N
Pickerington, OH

Dan Coonfare Agency - Nationwide Insurance

1080 Fishinger Rd
Columbus, OH

David Grant State Farm Insurance

4612 N High St
Columbus, OH

DAVIS INSURANCE

1110 BLUE HERON DR
Westerville, OH

Dawson, Disantis & Myers LLC

21 W Central Ave
Delaware, OH

Delaware Insurance Advisors

39 W Winter St
Delaware, OH

DOLBOW INSURANCE

212 S. STATE STREET
Westerville, OH

Duckie Exterior Solutions

2099 Hamilton Eaton Rd
Hamilton, OH

Dumbaugh Insurance

13 E Winter St
Delaware, OH

DUMBAUGH INSURANCE

122 S MAIN ST
Mount Vernon, OH

Dunlap Wealth Management Group

14074 Trade Center Dr
Fishers, IN

Eagle Insurance Agency

206 N Columbus St
Sunbury, OH

Eck Insurance Agency - Farmers Insurance

2500 Farmers Dr
Columbus, OH

Eggleston Agency - Nationwide Insurance

1596 Stringtown Rd
Grove City, OH

EISCHEN FINANCIAL GROUP

245 MT VERNON AVE
Columbus, OH

ENGLAND INSURANCE

47 W Columbus St
Pickerington, OH

Estate Planning Solutions

655 Metro Place South, Suite 600
Dublin, OH

FARMERS INSURANCE GROUP

1251 HILL RD N
Pickerington, OH

FINANCIAL SECURITY SVC

237 LOCKVILLE RD
Pickerington, OH

G W MOHLER & ASSOC

12927 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington, OH

Gardiner Allen DeRoberts Insurance, Inc

777 Goodale Blvd
Columbus, OH

GESWEIN INSURANCE AGENCY

5214 BETHEL CTR MALL
Columbus, OH

Glenn Insurance Group

3 W Main Street
Westerville, OH

Grange Insurance

671 S High St
Columbus, OH

GREENLEE INSURANCE

8525 Refugee Rd
Pickerington, OH

GWYNN VAUGHAN INSURANCE

888 HIGH ST
Columbus, OH

HEALTH BENEFIT CONSULTANTS LLC.

20275 Honeysuckle Dr.
Elkhorn, NE

Health Quote Insider

USA
Orlando, FL

Heischman Financial Services

7676 Slate Ridge Blvd
Reynoldsburg, OH

Henry Insurance Agency LLC

2757 Observatory Ave #22
Cincinnati, OH

HORACE MANN CO

9846 CAMELOT ST
Pickerington, OH

Integrated Small Biz Solutions

5880 Venture Dr
Dublin, OH

Investments For You, Inc.

1040 N Maple St
Marysville, OH

Jami Norman - Allstate Agent

325 S Sandusky St
Delaware, OH

JEFF FINEGAN AGENCY

1180 HILL RD N
Pickerington, OH

JOHN PYSARCHUK INSURANCE

515 HILL RD N
Pickerington, OH

JOHNSON INSURANCE

40 HILL RD S
Pickerington, OH

Jon Pantone Insurance Agency

2500 Farmers Dr
Columbus, OH

JUSTICE INSURANCE

1029 Refugee Rd Ste 200
Pickerington, OH

Kahrl & Company Insurance

11 S Melberry St
Mount Vernon, OH

KYM BUCHANAN AGENCY

444 Sycamore St
Urbana, OH

Legacy Insurance & Financial Group

PO BOX 09600
Columbus, OH

LEONE INSURANCE

PO Box 538
Sunbury, OH

LIBERTY MUTUAL GROUP

1306 HILL ROAD NORTH
Pickerington, OH

LOY INSURANCE INC

6338 HIBISCUS CT
Westerville, OH

LTC Financial Partners

1537 Guilford Rd
Columbus, OH

LUTZ INSURANCE

1180 HILL RD N
Pickerington, OH

Malhotra & Associates - Nationwide Insurance

4372 Glenallen Ct
Hilliard, OH

MARKER INSURANCE SVC

1258 Hill Rd N
Pickerington, OH

Martin J Mitchell - Allstate Agent

3816 Fishinger Blvd
Hilliard, OH

Martin J. Mitchell Insurance

51B N Sandusky St
Delaware, OH

MASTERS INSURANCE GROUP

5525 PARKCENTER CIR
Dublin, OH

Max Moarefdoust Agency-Allstate Insurance

1190 County Line Rd
Westerville, OH

McGlothin Insurance

1090 Georgesville Rd
Columbus, OH

Michael Borne Insurance

80222 Avenida Santa Olivia
Indio, CA

Miller-Lewis Benefit Consultants

121 E 6th Ave
Lancaster, OH

Mitchell Insurance Agency, Inc.

7450 Industrial Pkwy
Plain City, OH

MMA Insurance

107 W COLUMBUS ST
Pickerington, OH

MOCCABEE INSURANCE

341 Norton Rd
Columbus, OH

Montana Insurance and Financial Services

1311 WORTHINGTON WOODS BLVD
Columbus, OH

MULIT FAMILY INS PARTNERS LLC

9274 SOUTHCHESTER DR
Pickerington, OH

MVP Agency

73 S Main St
Johnstown, OH

NATIONWIDE INSURANCE

6834 CAINE RD
Columbus, OH

NBC, Inc.

470 Forest Ave
Plymouth, MI

Newco Insurance

2939 Kenny Rd
Columbus, OH

Nibert Insurance

118 S Main St
Marysville, OH

NORMAN J RISOYA ASSN INC

11299 STONECREEK DR
Pickerington, OH

Outcalt Kerns Insurance

1001 Eastwind Dr Suite 108
Westerville, OH

Patel & Associates LLC.

2530 Berryessa Rd
San Jose, CA

Pathway Insurance Services, Inc

4221 Malsbary Rd
Cincinnati, OH

PECK FAMILY INSURANCE

155 E COLUMBUS ST
Pickerington, OH

PERSONAL LINES ADMINISTRATION

118 WAGNALLS CT
Pickerington, OH

PFEIFER ORNSTEIN INSURANCE

3291 E MAIN ST
Columbus, OH

PHILLIP BREAKEY INSURANCE AGENCY INC/STATE FARM

7620 FARMSBURY DR
Reynoldsburg, OH

Physicians Mutual

925 N State St
Westerville, OH

Polaris Financial Services

7129 Hilmar Dr
Westerville, OH

Premier Insurance Restoration Services LLC

7088 Missy Park Ct
Dublin, OH

RAY INSURANCE AGENCY INC

1580 FISHINGER RD
Columbus, OH

Ryan Rito Agency - Nationwide Insurance

999 County Line Rd W
Westerville, OH

S L PIERCE AGENCY

3976 Clark Shaw Rd
Powell, OH

S P Johnson Group

293 Mulberry St
Buffalo, NY

Safe Harbor Retirement Group

6099 Frantz Rd
Dublin, OH

SafeAuto

4 Easton Oval
Columbus, OH

Scharver Insurance Group

14 2nd St
New Albany, OH

Scott Bricker - Allstate Agent

54 Dillmont Dr
Columbus, OH

Senior Health Direct

719 E. Grand River Ave.
Brighton, MI

Shane N Tressler State Farm Insurance Agency

6075 Chandler Crt
Westerville, OH

SKY INSURANCE

221 S Church St
Bowling Green, OH

SLYMAN INSURANCE

172 Granville St
Columbus, OH

STATE FARM - MARK SCHAEFER

1258 GRANDVIEW AVE
Columbus, OH

State Farm - Matt Simonds Ins Agency Inc

2986 N High St
Columbus, OH

STATE FARM INSURANCE

1670 COLUMBUS RD
Granville, OH

STATE FARM INSURANCE

1239 HILL RD N
Pickerington, OH

STATE FARM INSURANCE

194 W CHURCH ST
Pickerington, OH

STATE FARM – BILL ALSNAUER

2500 W DUBLIN GRANVILLE RD
Columbus, OH

State Farm – Suzanne Rizer

2930 Hayden Run Plz
Columbus, OH

State Farm- Jason Hoy

5806 Zarley St
New Albany, OH

STRUCTURED EMPLOYEE BENEFITS

815 Grandview Ave Ste 200
Columbus, OH

TAXMOM

3079 W Broad St
Columbus, OH

The DeVelvis Group - Nationwide Insurance

488 Polaris Parkway
Westerville, OH

The Main Street Group

4510 Cox Road
Glen Allen, VA

The Weinzierl Agency

1258 Hill Rd N
Pickerington, OH

Thompson Cunningham Insurance

5760 N High St
Columbus, OH

THRIVENT FINANCIAL

250 W Old Wilson Bridge Rd Ste 255
Worthington, OH

United Health Care

PO Box 30555
Salt Lake City, UT

VASBINDER INSURANCE

21735 PLANK RD, Suite E
Howard, OH

WE DAVIS INSURANCE AGENCY

29 FREDERICK ST
Columbus, OH

Wendy R. Sams Insurance Agency, Inc.

9039 Antares Ave Ste D-1a
Columbus, OH

WESTFIELD INSURANCE COMPANY

2000 POLARIS PKWY
Columbus, OH

WHITNEY INSURANCE INC

560 SUNBURY RD
Delaware, OH

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Pickerington.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Insurance Agent
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money