-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated New Albany Jewelry Stores

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Jewelry Stores to Avoid

41

Top Rated Jewelry Stores

16

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 554 reviews for
New Albany Jewelry Stores from people just like you.

A
"
spent considerable time with me and my husband explaining what the issue was with my diamond and what to expect if I were to pursue trying" to replace the diamond since it is insured. He took his time with us and offered a lot of helpful advise. He was able to confirm as a second opinion that the diamond had a flaw. I had visited a different store and they said the same thing about the condition of the diamond. I would highly recommend
.

-Mark B.

A
"People at the store are very friendly.
was on time for the appointment and spent time with me to explain the process and the appraisals." She seemed very knowledgeable on the pieces. Since I paid for a rush appraisal (additional $20 per item), I was able to get the information quickly so I could pass along to the attorney managing the probate process. They offered me beverages and went out of their way to try to ensure I felt comfortable.

-Mark B.

+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in New Albany

Jewelry

Take time to educate yourself before buying fine jewelry, and consider hiring experienced, high-rated professionals when having items appraised, repaired or cleaned.

The road to finding the perfect engagement ring begins with finding a reputable and knowledgable jeweler. (Photo by ©Bungalow Photography)
Jewelry Sales/Design/Repair

On this episode of Chat with the Experts, we talk with Greg Bires of Windsor Jewelry about picking an engagement ring and how to find a great holiday gift.

gold pocket watch, wedding band, and chain
Jewelry Sales/Design/Repair, Appraisals - Antiques/Jewelry/Items

Want to know where to sell gold jewelry for the best price or what to expect when you sell gold? Learn the basics of karat, weight and gold prices.

A diamond ring
Appraisals - Antiques/Jewelry/Items, Jewelry Sales/Design/Repair

Finding a reputable buyer and diamond grader is critical.

Angie's List
Billiard Table Sales, Chefs, Dance Instruction, Errands, Fitness - Centers, Fitness - Equipment, Fitness - Training, Florists, Gifts, Housecleaning, Interior Design & Decorating, Jewelry Sales/Design/Repair, Ticket Broker Service

The gift of a chef, housecleaner, errand service or interior designers is sure to make a big impression this Valentine's Day.

Angie's Answers

?
Depends on the design and how much it is being resized, and if reducing or increasing. For a simple one-size change larger, with a simple circular ring, can be as cheap as $20-30 to heat and stretch it.
 
 
If needs to be enlarged more or reduced, then it has to be cut and changed to the size wanted, and fused back together, with new gold or silver if enlarging. Obviously, reducing is cheaper than enlarging as no signficant new metal is needed, and silver is cheaper than gold or platinum because of the six-seven fold difference in the cost of the metals.
 
 
Resizing involving cutting probably in the $50-100 range for silver or for reducing a gold ring, enlarging a gold ring with added metal could run $100-250 depending on how large the ring is - a real hefty men's ring will obviously take more metal, so more cost, than a thin wedding band.
 
 
You want to consider the value of the ring - a real valuable or antique ring you want to take to a true artisan jeweler who makes and modifies rings in-house - a simple economy ring or simple band you would get a cheaper price probably at a chain store like Zales.
 
 
When you drop it off be sure to get a written receipt for it while they work on it (usually unless a simple one-size stretch job, cannot do while you wait), and I would also take a picture or two of it on your cell phone, including a zoom shot of any interior engraving, so if there is any question about whether you got back what you dropped off, you have some proof. Of course, the integrity of the shop is critical.
?
Hi,

This is Kyle K from Member Care. Thanks for reaching out!

I apologize for any confusion but I am unsure what you are referencing. If you could please send an email to memberservices@angieslist.com with more information I would be happy to assist!
?
Hello Clark,

This is Sarah B. in Member Care. I'm happy to help!
 
Angie's List helps you find the best home and health care providers to fit your specific needs. The List is organized by project type (home improvement, personal services, health services, etc.) You can check out the full list of services by visiting http://www.angieslist.com/services.htm.
 
We'd love to have you be a part of the Angie's List community! I'm happy to offer a 20% discount on an annual subscription. Just enter the promo code ANSWERS during the sign-up process online. Annual memberships are fully refundable if you're not satisfied, so there is no risk to try it out!
 
Please let me know if you have any other questions and good luck with your project!
?
?
?

Jewelry reviews in New Albany

F

Rating
My husband's grandmother gave me a pair of earrings before she died which I loved. I took them both in because one needed the rod (part that goes through your ear) replaced because it had broken off. THEY LOST MY EARRING!!!! They said they would call when they were finished and never did. I had to go in and ask if the work was done and they said it was. Then they came back to the counter and said they could not find one of the two earrings I brought in. They said they knew they had done the work on it but could not find the one they worked on. They assured me it was there somewhere and that they would call me and to give them time to look for it. I never heard from them again. I had to keep calling and keep dropping by to see if they had located my family heirloom which they still to this day have not. It was so upsetting because neither
New Albany Jewelry Stores Provider Name Locked
nor
New Albany Jewelry Stores Provider Name Locked
seemed to care that they had lost something very valuable to me. DO NOT take anything of value to this man.
- Chris P.
C

Rating
Two, three and four weeks went by and I still had heard nothing. No, "I am behind schedule." No, "I am struggling with your designs." In the meantime, I saw another clever idea and sent it to her and asked what she thought- since she was already 2 weeks behind the initial date with no feedback. Two days later I got a note saying she was removing herself from my case because I didn't like her designs-which I found funny since I never had the
New Albany Jewelry Stores Provider Name Locked
to see any of her drawing. Also, she made sure I knew how long she had been doing this and how much $ she makes an hour. If someone's ego is so big and has the "my way or the highway" attitude, then it is not a place for me. I still need a coverup so I need to continue my
New Albany Jewelry Stores Provider Name Locked
for the right place.
- Adele O.
A

Rating
Absolutely amazing experience!
Everyone in the store was polite, friendly, helpful, professional and knowledgeable.
I don't think I've ever had a more pleasant experience with any jeweler; let alone business.
The ring was repaired in hardly any time, and looked better than ever!

- Donna Carol P.
A

Rating
They did a great job. Worked with my somewhat strange requests and were also willing to do some brainstorming with me around how to solve some logistical problems.
Long story short, they did a great job and were extremely accommodating. My bride to be is thrilled with the ring.


- david M.
A

Rating
I have a 15 year old Seiko kinetic watch that I had sitting in a drawer for about 5 years. After so many years of non-use, when I tried to use it it would "tick" for a little bit and then an hour later nothing. It would not keep the time. So I used Fast Fix and they got it working and it has been working great now for almost two years since I had it repaired. They did two services on the watch. (1)one was replace a battery (or was it a capacitor? I don't remember) and (2)the second service I can't recall (it has been two years so I forgot). Anyway, I waited purposely to delay my review to make sure the repairs would hold and my watch still works great. Fast Fix of
New Albany Jewelry Stores Provider Name Locked
mall earns my A review.
- John R S.
B

Rating
I wouldn't say the service was excellent, but it got the job done and it worked out. The tech had a bit of an issue installing the dishwasher and there's a minor nick on the door, but no other problems other than that and the dishwasher works.
- Darrell S.
A

Rating
New Albany Jewelry Stores Provider Name Locked
, (Owner) & her capable and dedicated assistant '
New Albany Jewelry Stores Provider Name Locked
' !
They Listen-Learn and recommend the right jesture in one of a kind items that whispeer and sometimes shout the range of Human Emotions that they have captured and available to help you give the Perfect items/gifts to those that you think and really care about !
Classes in selected Arts & Crafts are also available.
Botton Line: Try it ! You will LIKE it.
A unique experience !
Remember:
Some Can some CAN'T !
Some Do some don't !
Some Will some WON'T !
- Spencer P.
F

Rating
I sent my husband to the store with the diamonds and instructions as to how I wanted them made. They talked him into a totally different design that I hated. I went back to the store with the earrings and wanted them the way he had originally asked to be made. They refused and said that was too bad. I have never returned to the store since, nor will I ever. Go somewhere else where they will do what you request. I was so angry with their workmanship and lack of professionalism. I never wore the earrings.
- Patty C.

Jewelry Stores in New Albany, OH

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

ARGO & LEHNE JEWLERS

3100 TREMONT RD
Upper Arlington

Beechwold Custom Jewelry LLC

4663 N High St
Columbus

Bleeding Ink LLC

3697 Garden Ct
Grove City

Bloomin Beads, Etc.

4040 Presidential Parkway

BONNIE MOSELEY'S BENCHWORKS

1285 GRANDVIEW AVE
Columbus

Buckeye Pawn Shop

5029 N Walnut St
South Bloomfield

Buckeye Pawn Shop

2777 S High St
Columbus

Buckeye Pawn Shop

411 S Central Ave
Columbus

C & J JEWELERS

175 CLEVELAND AVE
Columbus

C M VALENTINE GOLDSMITH-GEMOLOGIST

14 W COLLEGE AVE
Westerville

CDI Diamonds & Jewelry

3664 W Dublin Granville Rd
Columbus

Chapel of Love

223 Harcourt Rd
Mount Vernon

Curiousity Shop Inc

3387 N High St
Columbus

DENIG JEWELERS

677 HIGH ST
Worthington

DIAMOND CELLAR

6280 Sawmill Rd
Dublin

DirectBuy of Indianapolis

8450 Westfield Blvd

Dunkin's Diamonds

5461 Bethel Sawmill Ctr
Columbus

Dunkin's Diamonds

Indian Mound Mall
Heath

Dunkin's Diamonds

1635 River Valley Circle South
Lancaster

Dunkin's Diamonds

2816 Maple Avenue
Zaneville

Elianna Designs

P.O. Box 886
Centerburg

Federal Gold Traders

4583 N. High St.
Columbus

Fisher Precious Metals

2151 West Hillsboro Boulevard

Gold Buyers of America

3652 W Dublin Granville Road
Columbus

Gold Buyers of America

2257 Stringtown Road
Grove City

Gold Rush Jewlers

5842 Emporium Sq
Columbus

GOLD STAR JEWELERS

592 W SCHROCK RD
Westerville

Greiner's Crafts LLC

40 Colony Sq Apt G

HADAR DIAMONDS INC

10601-G Tierrasanta Blvd.

Hoosier Jewelry

PO Box 272

I AM'S bling, L.L.C.

P.O. Box 30407
Columbus

J C Penny

2724 Eastland Mall
Columbus

Jack Seibert Goldsmith Jeweler

1741 W Lane Ave
Columbus

Jared Gallaria of Jewelry

1499 Polaris Pkwy
Columbus

JARED GALLERIA OF JEWELRY

5061 TUTTLE CROSSING BLVD
Dublin

JEWELRY BY MICHAEL

6295 Maxtown Rd
Westerville

JEWELRY FROM KESSER

1050 Beecher Xing N Ste A
Columbus

KAY JEWELERS

Columbus

Kimberly's Diamond Corner

1 N Liberty St
Powell

L H WAGNER JEWELERS INC

3975 BROADWAY
Grove City

MARY'S DESIGNS

PO Box 109
Lewis Center

MORGAN'S TREASURE

31 N State St
Westerville

PUGHS DESIGNER JEWELERS

44 S 2ND ST
Newark

Q2 Jewelry and Services LLC

319 Stoneridge Lane
Columbus

Refuel Salon

8512 Cotter st
Lewis Center

Refuge at the Mill Salon

64 Granville Street Suite 102

Sacred Bracelets

157 W California Avenue
Columbus

STAR JEWELERS OF BEXLEY

607 N High St
Columbus

The Watch Doctor

1357 Holton Rd
Grove City

The Watch Shop

304 S Hamilton
Columbus

TheColumbusCleanTeam.com

1420 Greenock
Columbus

Vidonish Stained Glass Studios

20 E Main St
Mansfield

WORTHINGTON JEWELERS

692 High St
Columbus

Y Sadiq Diamond

7227 N. High
Worthington

Shop Local Jewelry Services in New Albany, OH

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in New Albany.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Jewelry Store
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money