-Find top-rated Service Providers
Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Lancaster Plastering Contractors

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Plastering Contractors to Avoid

78

Top Rated Plastering Contractors

11

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews
See Verified Local Reviews

Over 8,833 reviews for
Lancaster Plastering Contractors from people just like you.

A
"We have used him many many times. He does excellent work, consistently. He is very professional. He takes a personal interested in make sure his clients are satisfied." He is a very gifted painter and very skilled. He is very artistic and it shows in his work. I wished I could give him an A+.

-MaryJeanette D.

N
"I was so happy they were able to start the job the week after we accepted the bid. The work is excellent and the pool is beautiful. There were a few glitches." The first day the crew showed up to drain our pool they forgot a part for the pump needed to drain the water. The second time they came they didn't bring all the tile needed so they had to come back to finish that job. Other than those minor screw ups I am very happy with the workmanship, the quality and the service.

-Bunnie D.

+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 3 Million People on Angie's List
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 3 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Lancaster

drywall installation and repair

Drywall

Many homes today have walls made of drywall. Learn drywall basics, drywall alternatives and get tips for maintaining and repairing drywall.

guy repairing plaster ceiling
Plastering, Painting - Interior

Dear Angie: How important is it to repair plaster before repainting? Our ceilings have peeling paint that we’re pretty sure was caused by past water damage. Since the water problem is no longer an issue, can we simply repaint the ceilings or should we first repair any underlying plaster damage? – Sara S., Elgin, Illinois

Angie's List
Moving, Painting - Exterior, Painting - Interior, Plastering, Plumbing, Plumbing - Drain Cleaning, Roof Cleaning, Roofing, Sewer Cleaning, Siding

For larger projects, especially those that may involve more than three different service providers, a general contractor to oversee your project may be required.

Angie's List
Handymen, Heating & A/C, Insulation, Plastering, Plumbing, Plumbing - Drain Cleaning, Remodeling - Basements, Remodeling - General, Remodeling - Kitchen & Bathroom, Remodeling - Modular & Mobile Home, Remodeling - Sunrooms & Patio Enclosures, Roofing, Windows, Windows - Safety & Security Film

Just as consumers don’t like it when they call for help and don’t get a return call, companies don’t like it when they invest a lot of time to provide an estimate and never hear that their bid hasn’t been accepted.

Angie's List
Appliance Repair - Large, Appliance Repair - Small, Builders - Garages/Barns/Sheds, Builders - Homes, Cabinet Making, Drywall, Electrical, Electronic Gadget Repair, Glass Block, Gutter Cleaning, Gutter Repair & Replacement, Handymen, Hardware & Home Improvement Stores, Hardwood Flooring Sales/Installation/Refinishing, Heating & A/C, Insulation, Landscaping, Landscaping - Hardscaping & Pavers, Landscaping - Lakefront, Landscaping & Lighting, Lighting, Painting - Exterior, Painting - Interior, Plastering, Plumbing, Plumbing - Drain Cleaning, Pressure Washing, Remodeling - Basements, Remodeling - General, Remodeling - Kitchen & Bathroom, Remodeling - Modular & Mobile Home, Remodeling - Sunrooms & Patio Enclosures, Roofing, Screen Repair, Septic Tank, Siding, Tree Service, Windows, Windows - Safety & Security Film

Don't tackle a DIY home repair without asking yourself these three questions.

Angie's Answers

?
My sister-in-law uses brite white toothpaste and rubs it into those small holes. No prep, no sanding.
?

I've used wall liner (it applies like wallpaper only thicker) to cover a multitude of "wall sins" over the years. In my opinion it's the greatest thing since sliced bread. It doesn't look cheap or tacky, it's inexpensive, non-labor intensive and not messy to install.

I used it for the first time about 15 years ago to cover a faux brick tile on my lower kitchen walls that couldn't be removed. It was either tear the wall down or take a chance on $40 worth of wall liner. It did the job beautifully and lasted. Since then I've used it to cover paneling, a badly gouged wall after a kitchen remodel and a wall that looked like a pegboard after floor to ceiling shelving was removed.

Friends and family (and realtors!) have been amazed by the transformation after applying this simple inexpensive product. 

?

Remember, you not only have to remove the popcorn texture, but also redo the ceiling in some other texture.

Price will depend on several factors:

1) how much the contractor you choose hates removing popcorn or textured ceilings - some charge $1 or so/SF extra just because they hate it. There are even some who bid total drywall replacement cheaper than removing the popcorn, so you have to first find contractors who are happy to do that work, or your prices will be out of the realistic range

2) if the popcorn predates about 1990, then it could likely have asbestos in it, which doubles or triples the price, and in many cases uncapsulating it with a spray coating and then removing the drywall entirely is actually cheaper than all the protective measures necessary if it is scraped off. 

3) whether the popcorn is primarily gypsum and vermiculite (comes off REAL easy) or was the plaster of paris variety, which takes a fair amount of soaking to soften it enough to scrape off

4) what type of finish you are replacing it with - if a textured ceiling, slapcoat, knockdown finish or paneling, not real problem. If you want to go with a perfectly smooth ceiling (generally a bad idea as any variations in the drywall on a ceiling surface really shows up dramatically), then it will demand a lot of care in preparing the scraped surface, and a complete surface drywall compound skim coat to smooth out the scrapes and gouges from the removal process.

5) what underlying conditions are - if there is a lot of furniture to move around (should go to adjacent rooms) or cover and work around, high-quality rug or hardwood floor to super-protect or such, will drive cost up.

I have seen costs run from as low as $0.60/SF to $1.25/SF (for removal only). Generally, remove and recoat with a surface texture of some kind (anything but smooth) and paint will run you about $2.50-3.50/SF.

Now the bad news - if asbestos containing, can run from $5-10/SF. Many homeowners in that situation go the other legal route - have it encapsulated with an asbestos-rated sealant by an asbestos contractor, then paint it and leave it for the next homeowner to decide what to do about it. Some contractors encapsulate it and then put a 1/4" thick drywall layer over it - this usually looks like a disaster unless it has a VERY rough textured finish on it, because putting drywall sheet over a rough surface like popcorn invariably means a wavy surface commonly looks like a gently rolling ocean surface.

?

Plaster reviews in Lancaster

A

Rating
was extremely professional and flexible, working around my schedule. He showed up promptly & all work was completed with the highest level of professionalism. I highly recommend his craftsmanship & he will definitely be my first call if I ever need any additional work completed in the future.
- John P B.
A

Rating
It took some time to schedule this job. We had an earlier estimate in March from another contractor, which was quite excessive. Also that contractor was not going to be available for some time. We initially contacted in to determine availability, and then followed up in September. He made time ...More to come out in late September to evaluate the job needed, and then we set some tentative dates for his return. The job was completed in about 3 hours. and his associate were very neat, and made every effort to minimize the dust involved. The job did require that part of the popcorn ceiling be scraped and smoothed. We will have return to complete the rest of the ceiling and painting for a modest additional cost.
- Nancy W.
A

Rating
provided a quote that was half the cost of the next lowest one we received. I believe he did this work for us as a self employed side-job. He was prompt at returning voicemail, and I was able to send him text messages as well. We had cracks showing up in the edges of our ceiling from settling over the years. The job entailed ...More removing the tape and texture at all the cracked locations and smoothing out the top portion of the walls where we believe there was a border at one time that was not properly removed leaving a noticeable on the smooth finished walls. performed the work over the course of 2 evenings after 5pm. Which was much appreciated so neither my wife nor I had to take vacation time. I've repaired popcorn textured ceiling before, but the stuff in a can just doesn't match very well. was able to make the necessary plaster and texture repairs which look extremely good. The patched portions match perfectly with the rest of the ceiling. I can't comment on the cleanliness, because we're planning on replacing the carpet so I told him he didn't have to put down a tarp (which he brought) or bother cleaning up afterwards. We plan on painting ourselves, so we really just needed someone to make the plaster repairs that we're not very good at doing. I would Highly recommend to anyone who just need some plaster work done and don't want to spend a lot of money.
- Douglas D.
A

Rating
did a great job and was easy to work with. He works very efficiently saving everyone's time. He does a very thorough job and does what he says he will do. Thanks!
- jason P.
A

Rating
was a man of his word... He returned my call the next day and asked when it would be a good time to get together and look at what needed to be done... He was running a little late from another appointment and he called to tell me (I greatly appreciate that in someone)and gave me another time just a few hours later... He looked ...More over and listened to all I had to say and gave me a price which was much lower than I had anticipated... We discussed the time he would show - which was only 2 days later - He again showed promptly went right to work and before the end of the day I was very happy - especially when he cleaned and swept the areas he had worked in and after inspection was pleased to write him a check... During the process He was quite the gentleman and we talked about may issues, he was just a fun man to talk to and seemed very knowledgeable about general issues (politics, hunting, home repair) - but really mattered most - plastering... which he has been doing from childhood helping his father and grandfather, which were also plasterers. Do not hesitate to hire this individual - This was the first time I had met him, but I asked for some cards of his business and he gave me several, which I have already started to disperse..... Great job completed
- Kevin B.
A

Rating
was a professional right from the start. He quickly replied to my call for an estimate to plaster a newly built kiva fireplace kit, and immediately came to my house to provide the estimate. After it was provided, the job was scheduled, and the work was completed in 3 days, as promised.
The results are stunning. The variance ...More plaster finish he created adds elegance, class, and charm to the space, and it's exactly what I envisioned for the room. I wish there was a category of A+ in this review because the quality of his work is superb.
He's a true craftsman, and I would recommend him to anyone who wants the quality and class.


- Bryan N.
A

Rating
Cliff was very professional. He responded quickly to my email, arrived at the designated time, and maintained a very neat working area. He matched the fan pattern exactly and thoroughly cleaned the working area before leaving.
- Tracy M.
A

Rating
This contractor is one of the most responsive that we have ever worked with, after a ton of experience dealing with many different kinds of contractors. was so professional, respectful and courteous. He sent the team to work on our home and they arrived and completed the entire job very promptly as he was aware off the need ...More to finish the job before a storm was forecasted to arrive. Also, was very thoughtful to follow up with is after the job was completed to ensure we were completely satisfied with the outcome.
- James N.

Plastering Contractors in Lancaster, OH

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

ABSTRAKT PAINTING

142 W SCHREYER PL
Columbus

ADAMS CUSTOM PAINTING

98 KEENE DR
Westerville

AFFORDABLE HANDYMAN

3477 Boxelder Pl
Columbus

All American Stucco and Services

239 Southfranklin st
Columbus

All Around Home Maintenance

698 Musgrove Rd
Chillicothe

ALL CHOICE HOME IMPROVEMENTS LLC

346 Wyndham Park S
Westerville

Allterior Painting

2422 Deming Ave
Columbus

Boyden Renovations LLC

3310 Cabin Rd
Grove City

BRUCE HERRMAN

Columbus

Buckeye Building Solutions Ltd

52 Westerville Sq #217
Westerville

Buckeye Custom Painting

1840 Stouder Dr
Reynoldsburg

BURWELL BUILDERS

433 W. Main St.
Lancaster

Cabo 21 - Renovations

755 Richard CT

Camelot Construction and Design

3842 Carberry Dr
Dublin

Capocciama Painting

854 Sweeting Ave.
Columbus

CARRIE ROGERS STUDIO

6500 HOWARD RD
Sunbury

CASTLE DRYWALL

266 N SYLVAN AVE
Columbus

Centennial Preservation Group LLC,

600 N Cassady Ave Ste D
Columbus

Central Ohio Handyman Services, LLC

314 Prairie Run Drive
Sunbury

Cimarkai, LLC

3077 Remington Ridge Rd
Columbus

CNF Electric & Home Improvement Ltd.

8 Miami Street
Mount Vernon

Columbus Home Makeover LLC

5018 Gore St
Canal Winchester

Committed Construction Company

901A Robinwood
Whitehall

Coontz Painting

4496 Hartwell Rd
Columbus

Countryside Renovations

10550 Crouse-Willison Rd.
Johnstown

CP Drywall

6182 Doewood St
Columbus

DAVID HOWELL

13712 STONEHENGE CIR
Pickerington

Davy Painting

3116 Greenlawn Ave
Millersport

Deluxe Home Maintenance

5890 Sawmill Road Ste 100
Dublin

Details, Details Inc.

3700 Riverside Dr. #801
Columbus

doctor of decorating.com

11195 poplar creek rd

FANNIN DRYWALL

PO BOX 232
Vinton

Fine Touch Remodeling, LLC

2170 Britains Lane
Columbus

Gott Construction

PO Box 2993
Westerville

Great American Maintenance Company

2663 Beulah Road
Columbus

Griffey Remodeling

5730 Westbourne Ave
Columbus

Grit360 LLC

Riverside dr
Dublin

Handyman Matters of Columbus

6969 Worthington Galena Rd
Columbus

HB Good & Sons

2614 Scioto Pointe Ln
Columbus

Hoch's Painting

150 Orchard Ln
Westerville

Hometown Handyman

P.O. Box 292538
Columbus

I Can Fix That!

383 Fairgrounds Dr
Piketon

J D Painting Plus LLC

5540 Mueller Lane
Pickerington

Knight Construction

107 S Belmar Dr
Reynoldsburg

Luxury Bath

8596 Cotter St
Lewis Center

M & D Construction

129 E Taint St
Washington Courthouse

MADHUNT PROFESSIONAL PAINTING

9638 Meadow Wood Dr
Pickerington

Majestic Drywall

1850 Dividend Dr
Columbus

MLS Construction LLC

5529 Mossy Creek Drive
Dublin

NAC CONSTRUCTION

5105 TUSSIC RD
Westerville

noAppdeals

PO Box 2415
Newark

O.C.D. Restoration LLC

PO Box 156
Lancaster

Precision Drywall, INC

3308 N State Route 61
Sunbury

Professional Home Improvement

8023 Rush Street
Grove City

Quality Touch Drywall Design

6591 Open Common Way
Winchester

Ravemor Property Services

5316 Franklin St
Hilliard

Red Head Rehabs

1541 N Laurel Avenue

REFRESHING TOUCH PAINTING CO

1320 Roley Rd.
Baltimore

Regency Wallcraft

1933 E Dublin-Granville Rd
Columbus

Rescue Roofing & Siding

360 W Waterloo St
Canal Winchester

RH HOMES LTD

9646 Sharron Drive
Canal Winchester

Rhino Painting LLC

Pauline Ave.
Columbus

Rising Height Unlimited

2420 Performance Pkwy
Columbus

RiteWay Construction Services, Inc

2720 Airport Dr
Columbus

RIVERSIDE RENOVATION LLC

5280 RIVERSIDE DR
Columbus

Rosati Windows

4200 Roberts Road
Columbus

Ross Painting Services LLC

706 N Mount Pleasent Ave
Lancaster

Senior Living by Design

921 Eastwind Drive, Suite 101
Westerville

Services Galore Inc

398 Holtzman Ave
Columbus

SOS Construction & Drainage, LLC

1540 Porter Ln
Centerburg

Stauffers Painting Systems LLC

1170 Penny St
Columbus

Taylor's Painting Plus

5230 s Leedom road
Chandlersville

The Waterworks

550 Schrock Rd
Columbus

Tom Webb's Drywall

1080 Gibbard Ave
Columbus

TONY STIGGER CUSTOM PAINTING

123 1st st
Columbus

Universal Construction

PO Box 785
Verona

Wall-Eye Painting

4623 Pleasant Chapel Rd.
Newark

Shop Local Plaster Services in Lancaster, OH

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Lancaster.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Plaster Repair
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money