-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Hilliard Plastering Contractors

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Plastering Contractors to Avoid

99

Top Rated Plastering Contractors

41

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Only 29% of Hilliard Plastering Contractors are reliable
  • Tardiness is the #1 complaint against Hilliard Plastering Contractors
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 11,002 reviews for
Hilliard Plastering Contractors from people just like you.

C
"I was quite excited about selecting
Pools as I had met with a number of pool companies and felt this company was the most professional. "
F is appears professional and he is a good salesman. Unfortunately, that is where it ends. He is not a good listener and is more focused (after the signatures are dried on the contract) with justifying his lack of clear communication than with providing the consumer with what they asked. Both the rock painter and
Reed are excellent.
was responsible for startup and lighting, he was communicative, efficient and a man of his word. The quality of the work was done well - so far. My biggest complaint is that the project manager and pretty much everyone else within the company is non-responsive when issues arise. The color of my pool is NOT what I expected it to be. I went in to select the products and
F had the photos of my existing pool which was a dark bottom and looks like a lagoon. I told him that I wanted the same look. He encouraged and recommended a more monochromatic look - I asked him if he was sure that wasn't too light and he said "no" just one shade lighter and a little more on the green side. Well, lets just say that it was not "one shade lighter" but significantly lighter and not at all what I wanted. He showed me no pictures of the color of the water and in hindsight, I should have asked rather than trust his professional opinion since it was very clear he didn't know what he was talking about. You can imagine my disappointment after spending $20,000 and finding a pool that looks nothing like what I anticipated.
F's response was "you signed the paperwork." And he is correct, I did sign the paperwork and was told the end result was going to be one thing and it ended up being something else. I suppose I should be thankful he even responded, the rest of the company did not respond AT ALL. I called, I emailed to be able to talk with someone so I could discuss the issue and come up with some resolution but NO ONE with any decision-making ability would respond. The disappointment was so great with my pool I was willing to share the cost to have it done the correct way but NO ONE contacted me. For me, as a consumer, I can only say the experience left a bitter taste and that I do NOT recommend this pool company for sheer service issues. The quality of the pool work is ok. They were quick and efficient although they did break some landscape lighting which they did not repair and left a small mess. I do not believe asking to discuss the disappointment is asking too much and their non-responsiveness is not acceptable for a company that is listed on Angie's list. I have hesitated in putting this review up on Angie's list primarily because I was hopeful that someone would eventually respond. January 10, 2015, I have heard nothing. RECENT COMMUNICATION THIS WEEK (February 26) - Six months after the completion of the pool I finally am getting an invoice for the last payment on the addition of lights. When I brought the issue up again because I am still so disappointed - they are changing their story saying that the owner had offered to redo the pool at their costs and I rejected the offer - which is completely UNTRUE. Regretfully, I could not and would not recommend this company to anyone.

-Vivian L.

A
"
has just finished our project and we could not be happier with our experience working with him and the results. So much so that we have him" estimating other project that we would like to do in the near future. He finished on schedule as promised. We would highly recommend
for any of your future projects.

-Mark A.

+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Hilliard

Drywall and plaster

Knowing how your interior walls are constructed and what they are made of can help you take better care of your home, as well as provide effective maintenance. You can make small repairs yourself, but the more extensive the job the more likely you'll need a drywall repair contractor to make the wall smooth again.

Angie's List
Moving, Painting - Exterior, Painting - Interior, Plastering, Plumbing, Plumbing - Drain Cleaning, Roof Cleaning, Roofing, Sewer Cleaning, Siding

For larger projects, especially those that may involve more than three different service providers, a general contractor to oversee your project may be required.

Angie's List
Handymen, Heating & A/C, Insulation, Plastering, Plumbing, Plumbing - Drain Cleaning, Remodeling - Basements, Remodeling - General, Remodeling - Kitchen & Bathroom, Remodeling - Modular & Mobile Home, Remodeling - Sunrooms & Patio Enclosures, Roofing, Windows, Windows - Safety & Security Film

Just as consumers don’t like it when they call for help and don’t get a return call, companies don’t like it when they invest a lot of time to provide an estimate and never hear that their bid hasn’t been accepted.

Angie's List
Appliance Repair - Large, Appliance Repair - Small, Builders - Garages/Barns/Sheds, Builders - Homes, Cabinet Making, Drywall, Electrical, Electronic Gadget Repair, Glass Block, Gutter Cleaning, Gutter Repair & Replacement, Handymen, Hardware & Home Improvement Stores, Hardwood Flooring Sales/Installation/Refinishing, Heating & A/C, Insulation, Landscaping, Landscaping - Hardscaping & Pavers, Landscaping - Lakefront, Landscaping & Lighting, Lighting, Painting - Exterior, Painting - Interior, Plastering, Plumbing, Plumbing - Drain Cleaning, Pressure Washing, Remodeling - Basements, Remodeling - General, Remodeling - Kitchen & Bathroom, Remodeling - Modular & Mobile Home, Remodeling - Sunrooms & Patio Enclosures, Roofing, Screen Repair, Septic Tank, Siding, Tree Service, Windows, Windows - Safety & Security Film

Don't tackle a DIY home repair without asking yourself these three questions.

Angie's List
Drywall, Electrical, Handymen, Heating & A/C, Insulation, Landscaping, Lawn & Yard Work, Plastering, Plumbing, Landscaping - Lakefront, Painting - Exterior, Painting - Interior, Doors, Plumbing - Drain Cleaning, Landscaping - Hardscaping & Pavers, Landscaping & Lighting

Angie shares her experience trying to work in the middle of a renovation project at Angie's List.

Angie's Answers

?
My sister-in-law uses brite white toothpaste and rubs it into those small holes. No prep, no sanding.
?

I've used wall liner (it applies like wallpaper only thicker) to cover a multitude of "wall sins" over the years. In my opinion it's the greatest thing since sliced bread. It doesn't look cheap or tacky, it's inexpensive, non-labor intensive and not messy to install.

I used it for the first time about 15 years ago to cover a faux brick tile on my lower kitchen walls that couldn't be removed. It was either tear the wall down or take a chance on $40 worth of wall liner. It did the job beautifully and lasted. Since then I've used it to cover paneling, a badly gouged wall after a kitchen remodel and a wall that looked like a pegboard after floor to ceiling shelving was removed.

Friends and family (and realtors!) have been amazed by the transformation after applying this simple inexpensive product. 

?

Remember, you not only have to remove the popcorn texture, but also redo the ceiling in some other texture.

Price will depend on several factors:

1) how much the contractor you choose hates removing popcorn or textured ceilings - some charge $1 or so/SF extra just because they hate it. There are even some who bid total drywall replacement cheaper than removing the popcorn, so you have to first find contractors who are happy to do that work, or your prices will be out of the realistic range

2) if the popcorn predates about 1990, then it could likely have asbestos in it, which doubles or triples the price, and in many cases uncapsulating it with a spray coating and then removing the drywall entirely is actually cheaper than all the protective measures necessary if it is scraped off. 

3) whether the popcorn is primarily gypsum and vermiculite (comes off REAL easy) or was the plaster of paris variety, which takes a fair amount of soaking to soften it enough to scrape off

4) what type of finish you are replacing it with - if a textured ceiling, slapcoat, knockdown finish or paneling, not real problem. If you want to go with a perfectly smooth ceiling (generally a bad idea as any variations in the drywall on a ceiling surface really shows up dramatically), then it will demand a lot of care in preparing the scraped surface, and a complete surface drywall compound skim coat to smooth out the scrapes and gouges from the removal process.

5) what underlying conditions are - if there is a lot of furniture to move around (should go to adjacent rooms) or cover and work around, high-quality rug or hardwood floor to super-protect or such, will drive cost up.

I have seen costs run from as low as $0.60/SF to $1.25/SF (for removal only). Generally, remove and recoat with a surface texture of some kind (anything but smooth) and paint will run you about $2.50-3.50/SF.

Now the bad news - if asbestos containing, can run from $5-10/SF. Many homeowners in that situation go the other legal route - have it encapsulated with an asbestos-rated sealant by an asbestos contractor, then paint it and leave it for the next homeowner to decide what to do about it. Some contractors encapsulate it and then put a 1/4" thick drywall layer over it - this usually looks like a disaster unless it has a VERY rough textured finish on it, because putting drywall sheet over a rough surface like popcorn invariably means a wavy surface commonly looks like a gently rolling ocean surface.

?

Plastering reviews in Hilliard

F

Rating
It has taken over 3 weeks to even get appointment scheduled and I called him the day after I bought it. When appointment came up they didn't show up and I had taken off work to be home when they came.
- mary S.
C

Rating
They spilled paint on my floor and tile which almost made it's way to my carpet and ruined it. Thankfully the paint hasn't stained the floor too badly there is just a lighter spot where they spilled it. They were supposed to paint a two-story foyer and some spackling in my sun-room, which I told them ahead of time. and they didn't even bring their own ladder, luckily I had one they could use. They never finished the spackling I needed done, but I understood because it had to dry, and they explained it me so I could get it done when they left. They were very nice people but they didn't seem very professional with the work I wanted done. They did an ok job. This wasn't the worst experience that I've had but it wasn't the best, it was just average.
- John D.
A

Rating
Completed the job in 3 days. Took 1/2 day to remove and haul away old plaster and tile. Took a full day to
Hilliard Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
new ceramic tile and trim tiles, new fittings, and deck-o-seal, and another day to replaster. Started filling the pool on the 4th day. Did start-up of pool chemicals. Our pool is beautifully restored. They were very careful to not leave a mess in our landscaped garden. We are very happy. We highly recommend
Hilliard Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
.
- Kitty B.
F

Rating
He showed up the first day on time. Nice guy. Seemed to have the proper materials and got busy with his work. When he quoted the job he said it would take a day and a half. We felt the price was fair if he was going to spend 12 hours on the job. The job took him 3 hours one day and 3 hours the next day. That made his quote way over priced for us. He was supposed to call the next day to let us know if he could come back and finish but he showed up unexpectedly and started sanding his work while we were running around the house trying to cover our furniture. In the end he left us with a mess. There was fine white dust everywhere. It took my husband and I longer to clean our floors and furniture and windows than the contractor spent doing the job. He came with cloths for our oak floors but failed to cover them completely and bits of spackling and paint ended up on the floors plus all the sandy grit. He began to realize that he needed to protect our heart of pine windows that are not painted but failed to keep them safe. We know that all the paint and spackle we found on the windows and floors came from him as this house has not been painted since the carpet was pulled up and the floors refinished. He did not have adequate tools to clean up after himself. He used old leftover ceiling paint, as he told us, to put the texture in and texture areas that were sanded down. He left with his full payment in hand before we could inspect and see the work as it was all wet. Once it dried out the texture he applied was 3 to 4 times more than what was originally on the walls and ceiling. We had a fine texture as this is an old house. He applied a thick and rough coat. Something we will have to live with as on his quote it says "texture as well as possible." We have discovered places that he did not retexture and cracks that were supposed to be repaired were just slapped on with textured paint and the cracks are still there. Supposedly he's been in this business for several decades but someone has to be at the bottom of the skill set and he meets that criteria. We were getting ready to have the interior of the house painted. DW painting, which we used for the exterior of our home, recommended this person to get the walls prepped for them to paint. His work was so awful and the clean up was so exhausting that we lost hope in having another contractor come into our home. We cancelled DW painting as they didn't seem concerned about the quality of Jos's work. That was disturbing. We area now in the process of painting our home and since we have painted many homes in the past, although not our profession, we feel confident and the work is looking good. As we paint we keep coming across more and more of the contractor's messy work. At least now we are taking care of our floors and woodwork that we concerned would not be taken care of by an outside contractor.
- Fay F.
A

Rating
They did a professional job and we had no issues with the work. They were easy to schedule with and arrived on time. I would recommend them to my friends and family.
- John W.
C

Rating
Well.... We asked that all of the nail
Hilliard Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
, scratches, etc be filled, sanded. The previous home owner had a large opening in one wall with a shelf to store the old style tv. That was to be dry-walled to hang a tv mount and on the other side of the wall, in the closet, a hole cut for access to cables (They forgot the access). We discussed at length about our color choice and how it would read over the darker existing color, whether or not primer should be used, how the color might be affected by the light in the room, etc. It did take me some time to decide on color, and they were very accommodating. There was some issues with scheduling but it was worked out after several phone calls. They started to paint and when a section of a wall was done, I went to check on the color. It looked nothing like the sample and saying I did not like it was an understatement. They said to let them finish one coat around the room and I would change my mind.... That didn't happen. Back to the drawing board of picking another color.
Hilliard Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
also convinced me not to use color on my ceiling and to use a shade of white. I can't stand white ceiling's, but they said if I didn't like it, they would change it. I chose a white that isn't really white for the ceiling. Months later and I still am unsure. As for the walls, I ended up using the color that
Hilliard Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
painted my closets. Everyone thought I was nuts because it seemed so bright, almost overwhelming in the closet, but I really love it. We have bubbles in the paint, and where they used caulk or something in a drywall seam, it is rather ugly and VERY noticeable. Where I had put a sample color was never taken care of properly, the wall is very bumpy. The room was left with a
Hilliard Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
of drywall dust... There are touch ups galore, but after what seemed like forever to get this room painted in the first place, I will do the fixes myself. Oh... The paint isn't very good either, which surprised me as it is
Hilliard Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
Super Paint. It doesn't clean all that well.
- Jennifer M.
A

Rating
He was great. He was full of ideas, did a great job, and was very helpful. He really knew what he was doing; I can't say enough good things about him.
- Tracey M.
A

Rating
Hilliard Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
and his crew did a great job. The job was worked on nearly every day during the construction period. The quality of the work is very high. We have and would recommend
Hilliard Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
and
Hilliard Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
to our family, friends and neigbors.
- Donald S.

All Plastering Contractors in Hilliard, OH

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

Above And Beyond Painting LLC

8185 Green Meadows Dr N
Lewis Center

ADAMS CUSTOM PAINTING

98 KEENE DR
Westerville

AFFORDABLE HANDYMAN

3477 Boxelder Pl
Columbus

All American Stucco and Services

239 Southfranklin st
Columbus

All Around Home Maintenance

698 Musgrove Rd
Chillicothe

ALL CHOICE HOME IMPROVEMENTS LLC

985 Landings Loop S
Westerville

ALL SEASONS WALL SYSTEMS llc

636 PLYMOUTH ST.
Columbus

ALL STAR PAINTING

1144 Mcneil Drive
Blacklick

AllStar Ceiling & Walls

5020 Winslow Dr.
Columbus

Allterior Painting

2422 Deming Ave
Columbus

Artistic Drywall LLC

357 W William St
Delaware

Basic Maintenance Repair

2663 Lindora PL
Columbus

Boyden Renovations LLC

3310 Cabin Rd
Grove City

Buckeye Building Solutions Ltd

52 Westerville Sq #217
Westerville

Buckeye Custom Painting

1840 Stouder Dr
Reynoldsburg

Buckeye House Painting

2772 Sawbury Blvd
Columbus

Cabo 21 - Renovations

755 Richard CT

Camelot Construction and Design

3842 Carberry Dr
Dublin

campbell plastering llc

135 n terrace ave
Columbus

Capocciama Painting

854 Sweeting Ave.
Columbus

CARRIE ROGERS STUDIO

6500 HOWARD RD
Sunbury

CASTLE DRYWALL

266 N SYLVAN AVE
Columbus

Centennial Preservation Group LLC,

600 N Cassady Ave Ste D
Columbus

Cimarkai, LLC

3077 Remington Ridge Rd
Columbus

Columbus Home Makeover LLC

5018 Gore St
Canal Winchester

Committed Construction Company

1889 Maryland
Columbus

Coontz Painting

4496 Hartwell Rd
Columbus

Countryside Renovations

10550 Crouse-Willison Rd.
Johnstown

DAVID HOWELL

13712 STONEHENGE CIR
Pickerington

Davy Painting

3116 Greenlawn Ave
Millersport

DC Painting & Handymen

5007 Inspiration Dr
Hilliard

Deluxe Home Maintenance

1213 Creekside Place
Reynoldsburg

Details, Details Inc.

3700 Riverside Dr. #801
Columbus

DICKSON HOMES INC

6700 LISAMARIE RD
Columbus

doctor of decorating.com

11195 poplar creek rd

Down Under Faux

36 Prince Street

FANNIN DRYWALL

PO BOX 232
Vinton

Fine Touch Remodeling, LLC

2170 Britains Lane
Columbus

G Whitley Painting Inc.

4751 Kaufman Road
Plain City

GEORGE F NEFF & CO, LLC

491 N POWELL AVE
Columbus

Gil's Drywall

636 Carpenter St
Columbus

Gott Construction

PO Box 2993
Westerville

Great American Maintenance Company

2663 Beulah Road
Columbus

Gregory Pack Painting

500 Blenheim Rd.
Columbus

Griffey Remodeling

5730 Westbourne Ave
Columbus

Grit360 LLC

Riverside dr
Dublin

Handyman Guys, Inc.

2580 Billingsley Rd
Columbus

Handyman Matters of Columbus

893 High St
Columbus

HB Good & Sons

2614 Scioto Pointe Ln
Columbus

His & Hers Fix-It

118 Greenland Dr

HOCH'S PAINTING

150 Orchard Ln
Westerville

HOME REMEDIES

771 FRANKLIN AVE
Columbus

HOMEFIXOLOGY

8774 COTTER ST
Lewis Center

Hometown Handyman

P.O. Box 292538
Columbus

Honey to Do Ltd

47 Millfield Ave
Westerville

I Can Fix That!

383 Fairgrounds Dr
Piketon

Icon General Contracting Services

6423 Harbinger Ln
Dayton

Jim Breidenbach Home Repairs

824 Chelsea Avenue
Columbus

JOHNSON PAINTING SERVICE

843 Ludwig Dr
Columbus

Jon Miller

5292 Sinclair Rd
Columbus

Jordan's Home Maintenance

1104 Horeshoe Rd
Delaware

JUST REPAIRS/LIBERTY GENERAL INC

507 WOODSIDE DR
Pataskala

KENTON LOY

239 BREVOORT RD
Columbus

KEVIN FULLEN PAINTING

5555 DAVIDSON RD
Hilliard

Knight Construction

107 S Belmar Dr
Reynoldsburg

Legacy Home Services

5195 Hempstead Village Center Drive
New Albany

Luxury Bath

8596 Cotter St
Lewis Center

M S Moyer & Sons

442 Barnett Rd.
Columbus

MADHUNT PROFESSIONAL PAINTING

9638 Meadow Wood Dr
Pickerington

Majestic Drywall

1850 Dividend Dr
Columbus

Mark Monnette Masonry

3087 Grange Hill Pl
Dublin

MASTERCRAFT

4175 Lyman Dr
Hilliard

Meisters LLC

2121 Arlington Ave
Upper Arlington

MLS Construction LLC

5529 Mossy Creek Drive
Dublin

Mr Fix It

3413 LaCoste Ln
Columbus

My Handyman

8323 Lewis Center Rd
Westerville

NAC CONSTRUCTION

5105 TUSSIC RD
Westerville

New Images Painting & Wallcovering

16210 Township Rd 389
Frazeysburg

NJW Construction

4193 Crumley Rd
Lancaster

O.C.D. Restoration LLC

PO Box 156
Lancaster

OWDOM CONTRACT LABOR LLC

4136 Anson Drive
Hilliard

Palmer Builders LLC

4000 Leap Rd #1181
Hilliard

PAPER & PAINT

1835 STILTON AVE
Columbus

PARTICULAR ABOUT TRIM

6000 Forestview Dr
Columbus

Precision Drywall, INC

3308 N State Route 61
Sunbury

Professional Home Improvement

8023 Rush Street
Grove City

Quality Touch Drywall Design

4152 Summit Drive
Columbus

R J Buoni Painting Inc

5242 Center St
Hilliard

Ravemor Property Services

5316 Franklin St
Hilliard

REFRESHING TOUCH PAINTING CO

1320 Roley Rd.
Baltimore

Regency Wallcraft

1933 E Dublin-Granville Rd
Columbus

REITTER STUCCO INC

1100 KING AVE
Columbus

Rescue Roofing & Siding

360 W Waterloo St
Canal Winchester

RH HOMES LTD

9646 Sharron Drive
Canal Winchester

Rhino Painting

1727 E Frankfort St
Columbus

Rinehart Decorating, LLC

1864 Shadow Creek Ct
Powell

Rising Height Unlimited

2420 Performance Parkway
Columbus

RiteWay Construction Services, Inc

2720 Airport Dr
Columbus

RIVERSIDE RENOVATION LLC

5280 RIVERSIDE DR
Columbus

Roark Remodeling LLC

8171 Newark Ave
Westerville

Rosati Windows

4200 Roberts Rd
Columbus

Ross Painting Services LLC

706 N Mount Pleasent Ave
Lancaster

Ruby Home and Hauling Services

3401 Maize Rd
Columbus

Services Galore Inc

398 Holtzman Ave
Columbus

Stauffers Painting Systems LLC

1170 Penny St
Columbus

Stiles of Ohio Inc

PO box 20330
Columbus

Sunlight Housepainting

PO Box 164
New Albany

Taylor's Painting Plus

5548 Copenhagen Dr
Westerville

The Consumers Painting Company

1022 E. 16th Ave.
Columbus

The Durable Slate Co

1050 N Fourth St
Columbus

The ERS Group LLC

5834 Mayfield Rd
Mayfield Hts

THINK PAINTING INC

321 W NEW ENGLAND AVE
Columbus

Thomas Custom Painting

PO Box 566
Hilliard

Tingle Painting LLC

10776 Thrailkill Rd.
Orient

Tom The Handyman & Inspector

822 Tanglewood Dr
Springfield

Tom Webb's Drywall

39 Waters Edge Ln
Centerburg

TONY STIGGER CUSTOM PAINTING

123 1st st
Columbus

Transform Construction

360 W Third Ave
Columbus

U S Pro Painters LLC

4504 Springfield Xenia Rd
Springfield

Universal Construction

PO Box 785
Verona

Village Handyman

5706 Bashaw Dr
Westerville

WALL-EYE PAINTING

6592 HAWTHORNE ST
Columbus

Westoff Services

2015 W 5th Ave
Columbus

Shop Local Plastering Services in Hilliard, OH

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Hilliard.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Plaster Contractor
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money