Garrettsville Caterers

in Garrettsville, OH

Sample Reviews


We organized a wedding reception for our daughter at a local venue.
, from
, helped us put together a menu and handled all the necessary rentals to make the affair a glorious success. Her wait staff were excellent. They were efficient and timely. They handled all aspects of our dinner, including the rental of plates, glasses and linens. Everything came in within the budget we had allowed and we felt like we were the most important clients that ever used their services. I would not hesitate in using their services again.
- Barry R.

It went fantastic.
chose a wide variety of dishes to satisfy both vegetarians and carnivores. The food was presented in a very appetizing manner and it was delicious and plentiful. Highly recommend the beef brisket, polenta with mushroom and zucchini and vegetable Kabobs ! The personnel providing the service were very professional and adaptable as the rain arrived. The two servers needed to adjust the serving area about 1 hour before my guests arrived and then again just before the guest of honor arrived. They knew what to do and treated my guests with respect and provided outstanding service.
I rated the price as a B, because it seemed a little high to me; but I never "price checked". I feel that I did get my money's worth based on the quality of the food, its presentation, and the competence of the servers.
- Pam C.

Garrettsville Catering Articles

Catering reviews in Garrettsville


Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
is run by Bound'ry and South Street restaurants in
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
. The food at the restaurants is fabulous -- and so is the catered food and service.
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
organized, set up a cocktail buffet for 50 or so people, provided 2 servers/staff, and cleaned up after the event ended. They did a great job, and I would definitely use them again.
- Christina N.

This was NOT a "food bank give away". This was advertised as a discounted purchase of groceries. I wrote a post afterwards on the facebook page of
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
COUNTY; I received comments & many private messages, relating to bad experiences. Those who did post thier bad experience openly were, as one woman stated, "attacked".
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
posted snide & defensive rebuttals. (Glass half empty,be a blessing, at the end of the day...) My post mysteriously disappeared ~ "accidentally deleted" according to
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
. Now, only "approved" messages are allowed. Naturally, the ones being approved are all "good reviews", applauding
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
herself is posting "kudos" to herself. As I told her, I appreciate her efforts, & I believe her heart was in the right place. I was not angry. I was giving an honest review of my experience. I am always trying to stretch our budget. I yard sale, & shop discount, as I did for this event. I PURCHASED this food. Below is a synopsis of my review on my experience, since it was "accidentally deleted". I do have pictures, as well, of all items. Those will be posted on another forum. "Just the facts";

I was at the pickup point,
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
Church, early ~
by 10:30 a.m. Event was to start at 11 a.m... There were already a line of
cars. That was expanded to 6 lines of
cars, for people showing up after the others first in line. I waited
over 2 hours & our line moved. Then
a volunteer jumped in & started moving the last incoming cars to the front
of the line. He was completely unaware
of how the vehicles were lined up in a “first come” order. Very disorganized.
It was so hot, & volunteers were walking around with ice cold bottles
of water, some with 2 or 3 under their arm.
None was offered to the people waiting; not even to the children or elderly. Shameful.
I got to the head of the line after 3 hours of waiting. A volunteer was actually SNIFFING the meat as
he was putting it in my cooler. (This
particular volunteer was wearing a camo bandana & glasses). I asked him WHY
he was sniffing the meat & he said (and this is a DIRECT QUOTE) ~ “If you
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
’t like it,
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
’t eat it”. Is that
the COMPASSION people are treated with??? Sure enough, all the meat was expired
& after being sniffed, I’m certain they aren’t fit to eat. “It is often fresh fruits & veggies - a
lot is organic - breads, tortillas, dairy products” I got a huge bunch of rotten bananas ~ they
are actually exploding ~ & strawberries with mold on them. It took me 7 minutes to get home, so the
excuse I’ve read about leaving it in the car in no way applies to me. I received no other fruits or veggies &
definitely not fresh. Organic? Nothing I received was organic. Dairy products? I received none. Tortillas ~ yes, with MOLD on them. I was told I’d receive a $100 worth of food
for $20. This is certainly untrue. Thankfully I can take the $20 I spent off of
- Molly H.

Very, very expensive for bag sliced
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
bread and 10-12
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
stack of corned beef. Asked for extra lean ($1.00 more) and got fat riddled, salty meant. Cheese was plastic-wrapped
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
brand!! All this and the price, tax included, $15.89!!!!
Service was shoddy with the waitress pushing extra condiments and food (at incredibly high prices) so fast my head began to spin. Noisy, crowded and difficult to get into the booth.
- holly W.

My daughter, who is a stickler for details, couldn't have been happier. She wanted an elegant presentation, and that is what
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
provided. For example, the starter for the dinner was plated beautifully, with the colors of the salmon and vegetables nicely contrasted. The main course, a duet of stuffed chicken and roast beef, was very tasty. I'm still trying to figure out the ingredients for the stuffing. Vegetarian, Vegan and Pescatorian guests were each served with the appropriate choice. The dessert b,uffet was dazzling. Instead of serving big clunky cakes,
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
put out all kinds of miniatures, wonderful chocolate covered fruits and pretzels, warm cinnamon buns, tarts - the list goes on. Take home bags were provided for departing guests with donuts and coffee.
- Naomi W.

This catering event with
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
was terrible! Our party started at 5pm; she told me she would be there around 2:30 to 3pm - she arrived at 4:30. this caused for confusion and my guests were not greeted at the door as I had asked. I requested 2 servers. Without consulting me she showed up with one server, also late and a bartender with an attitude. She told me what she expected as a tip and told me if I paid in cash, there would be no tax. She later rescinded that statement. What you see is not what you get with her. I would definitely not use her again and I would caution anyone else from using her.
- Mary Beth H.

On a scale of 1 - 10, I'd rate
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
's company,
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
, a 100. This experience was outstanding from beginning to end. My husband and I planned a "We Have Too Much Wine" party and decided to hire a caterer, since we were expecting approximately 45 people. While we entertain a lot, I'd never hired a caterer before, and I was a little apprehensive about giving up control. I called
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
after reading other reviews on Angie's List, and from our first conversation, I knew she was the right person. She asked good questions, made suggestions about which
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
d'oeuvres might work well for our party, and did a great job in putting together a menu. She visited our home about 10 days prior to the party to see our kitchen layout and table placement, etc. On the evening of the party, she arrived promptly at 6:00 (90 minutes prior to the start of the party) and immediately got to work. We heard the same one-word comment from several of our guests: "Amazing!". In fact, when she left the party, I told her she deserved a standing ovation, and those guests who were still there did, indeed, clap for her. The food was fabulous, she was professional, unobtrusive, hard working, and an all-around absolute pleasure to work with. We entertain a lot, and I can assure you that
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
won't be my first call - she will be my ONLY call. I will never have anxiety about hiring a caterer again, since I'll only hire
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
and we know the quality of her work. In fact, I now can't imagine having a party without her. I loved the food, her professionalism, her presentation (awesome!), and also the fact that I had only to put the tablecloth, candles and flowers on the table, and she handled the rest. Having her there allowed me the opportunity to enjoy our party, something that can be challenging to do if you're the one responsible for managing the food, etc. Several of our guests took her business card and I am sure that they will all be calling her for their own events. I don't generally gush when writing a review, but it would be impossible not to do so when it comes to
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
and her company. Call her - she is truly a consummate professional who will make your life much easier and your party a huge success!
- Laura C.

I went into the
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
's and placed 2 orders for a catering package, each to serve 30 people: 2 full deep covered aluminum trays (which is what how all the trays were) of Italian beef, 3 inch cut bread pieces, a large containers of sweet
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
, a large container of hot
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
, 2 full trays of fried chicken, 2 full tray of delightful special salads, a selection of dressings, 2 full trays of mostaccioli , a very large container of grated parmesan cheese, paper plates, serving utensils, and a large package of
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
's napkins. We and our guests were greatly impressed by the quality and quantity of the food. Many people made a point to tell us how much they enjoyed all of the food from
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
's. They said that they had ordered
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
's pizza in the past but did not realize that they had catering, too. Of course, we had a lot of food left over. We wanted to make sure that we would not run out of anything. Even days later, all of the food was still tasty. Everything was expertly prepared and delivered at the right temperature. There was plenty of gravy for the delicious beef. The bread was very fresh. The chicken was just right, not at all greasy or dry. The salads (2) were amazing. The mostacccioli had a delicious sauce and was covered with a
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
of melted mozzarella cheese. There were many amazing salad dressings to choose from. We will definitely order catering from
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
's of
Garrettsville Caterers Provider Name Locked
, Illinois again.


Food arrived on time and as requested. Food was fresh and delicious.
Vodka Sauce is amazing!
We were very pleased with the offering Fevola's was able to provide on the budget given for the office.

- Brian D.
110% Guaranteed Money Back

We think we're the best, and we can prove it.

Try an annual plan and if you want to cancel in your first year, we'll refund you 110%

Annual Plans Only

All Caterers in Garrettsville, OH

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

Alfonso's Restaurant & Market

7786 W 130th St
Cleveland, OH

Bake Believe

4215 Sterling Station Dr
Brunswick, OH

Belarusan American Center

11022 Webster Rd
Strongsville, OH


Newbury, OH

Cao Chocolates

9804 SW 77th Ave
Miami, FL


North Royalton, OH


Bedford, OH

Catering By Mark DiFeo

2196 E Market St
Fairlawn, OH

Chagrin Painting Co

PO Box 692
Newbury, OH


5700 Brecksville Rd
Independence, OH

Creative Options Catering

541 Forge St
Cuyahoga Falls, OH

Everyday Gourmet

6225 Oak Tree Dr. N
Lorain, OH

Executive Caterers

6111 Landerhaven Dr
Cleveland, OH

Gambitta's Party Center

160 E Aurora Rd
Northfield, OH

Greystone Hall

103 S High St
Akron, OH

Guy's Party Center

500 E Waterloo Rd
Akron, OH

Hickabillys Pizza & Ribs

15706 Waterloo Rd
Cleveland, OH

HoneyBaked Ham Co. and Cafe'

9354 Market Square Drive
Streetsboro, OH

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Garrettsville.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Caterer
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money