-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Knee Replacement Surgeons to Avoid


Top Rated Knee Replacement Surgeons


Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Only 49% of Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons are reliable
  • Tardiness is the #1 complaint against Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 1,251 reviews for
Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons from people just like you.

"This guy is the Michelangelo of hip and knees. I have sent people to him and everyone raves about him. He is the best! The hospital that he works in is absolutely" stunning too. You think you are going into a resort. It's been about a month since the surgery and the recovery is longer than I hoped, but when I went to see him a few weeks ago he said I am ahead of schedule in healing time.

-Jerry M.

"I have been going to him for about fifteen yes. I was a runner and had knee problems. He kept me going. He is very knowledgeable. He was able to tell me exactly" what was wrong with my knee. He really seemed to know what he was doing. He told me what my options were and he never pushed me. I really appreciated the fact that he was honest to me. He is very personable and has a great bedside manner. When some of the staff in the hospital did some incorrect things for my care, he took care of everything. I felt that he was my advocate and was interested in my healthcare.

-Sallly B.

+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Staten Island

knee doctor

Orthopedics: Knees

Some orthopedic doctors specialize in the bones, muscles and tendons of the knee, from treating ACL tears and arthritis to performing knee replacement surgery.

Excess weight puts more pressure on weight-bearing joints, particularly the knees. This can eventually lead to knee replacement. (Photo by The San Antonio Orthopaedic Group)
Orthopedics - Knee & Leg

Does being overweight put you at higher risk of knee replacement surgery? Yes, but a small increase in activity and decrease in weight can make a difference.

As differences between men and women's knees are better understood, effective treatments can be targeted specific to women with knee pain, says Closkey. (Photo by Karen Geswein)
Orthopedics - Knee & Leg

Knee pain is a common problem that interferes with daily activity and women may be at a higher risk. One highly rated provider shares causes and solutions.

Angie's List
Orthopedics - Knee & Leg

Knee injuries are the most common ailment that runners experience. If you run and experience pain, do you need a knee brace? What kind is best? What should you do first? Is a brace the best solution?

Matthew Brady
Orthopedics - Knee & Leg

As baby boomers desire to stay fit, hip and knee replacement surgeries are growing increasingly popular.

Angie's Answers

Sounds like you should be pursuing a disability claim.  Also, you could speak to your previous doctor frankly about your concerns.  
Have they made orthotics for your shoes that distribute your weight better? 

Whoops - I just realized that you may have been looking for Angie's List information on providers outside your home market. To see information on providers that aren't in your home Angie's List chapter, you can elect to pay a small addditional fee (generally about $15 to $20) to add another city's Angie's List to your existing memember.


Learn more about the add-a-city option here.

Hello, this is Kyle K from the Member Care Department.

I apologize for any confusion, but your membership has been expired since 07/18/2012. If you would like access to pain doctors in the Midland, TX area you will need to renew your membership. You can renew online at any time by signing in to your old account at www.angieslist.com. Once logged in, you'll be asked to rejoin, and you can just follow the prompt.
If you’d prefer to speak with someone over the phone, our Member Care Team would be happy to assist you. They can be reached toll-free at 1-888-944-5478. Don’t forget to check-out our money saving multi-year plans, too.

Thanks for writing! - Kyle K
Hello, this is Kyle K from the Member Care Department.

I apologize for my delay. I apologize, but orthopedic surgeons fall under our Orthopedics category which is included in the Health list. Currently, you're enrolled in our Basic membership which only includes access to our Home list.
If you'd like to upgrade your membership to the Plus or Premium plan, we'll be happy to assist you with this search. If interested, give us a call at 1.888.944.5478 and we'll take care of this adjustment. Again, I do apologize for any misunderstanding.

Thanks for writing! - Kyle K



This is James W. with Member Care. Thanks for posting your question.


It looks like when you signed up online on 8/5/2014, that you accidentally joined our greater Portland chapter instead of our Salem/Corvallis chapter that your zip code falls under. I have transferred your subscription to that chapter, so you will now have access to the correct area.

I hope this information helps! Please let me know if I can assist further. You can respond to this thread or submit a new Answers post. You can also reach us at 1-866-783-2980. We're open weekdays from 8:00 am - 9:00 pm and Saturdays 8:00 am - 5:00 pm ET.


Thanks again!

Knee Care reviews in Staten Island


My partial knee replacement collapsed causing a lot of pain and resulting in a crooked leg. Dr.
Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
was ready to simply dismiss the whole series of symptoms I was experiencing at the time. He recommended a "wait and see" approach despite my increasing amount of pain and inability to progress in Physical Therapy. I basically had to throw a fit before he'd recommend an MRI that revealed extensive damage to the other compartment in my knee. Based on the MRI findings I was told I needed a full knee replacement. Questions I should have asked: Why wasn't an MRI showing the full extent of the damage to my knee done before the Partial Knee replacement ? How long & painful will the recovery be ? Do you cut my ACL tendon for the full knee replacement. If so, why ? They tell you your ACL tendon is not necessary ( after the fact - if you happen to discover they've cut it ). I'm still in pain, daily, sometimes w/ each step, 4mths. post OP from the Full knee replacement. Dr.
Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
is now doing full knee replacements with a prosthesis that doesn't require cutting of the ACL tendon ... too late for me. His staff is hit or miss. Sometimes you get a good response, within a reasonable time frame (1 week or less). Other times no response at all to the message you've left. You rarely get a
Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
to call and actually speak to a person. I'm left w/ the feeling that the whole place is like a high-priced auto chop shop. That's certainly how I'm being treated. If you value personalized care, concentrated treatment based on individual cases, don't go to Dr.
Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
- Kathy T.

Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
never returned my call. Office refused to see me. Because of this I developed complication necessitating reduction of bone under anesthesia which could certainly have been avoided. I suffered more pain, a hospitalization and a large ded tale expense.
- Nancy H.

|WOA is a typical busy group practice, with that bit of feeling like being on an assembly line. Staff is pleasant, but businesslike. Waits are not excessive. (That's one of the up sides to being businesslike.) Once when I was there and some people were waiting longer than usual, a staff person came out and made an announcement explaining the delay and which doctors were running late. I thought that was very considerate, even though I was not one of the people affected. I also liked that they didn't immediately see surgery as THE solution. Treatment seems to be helping. I have nothing to compare them to regarding pricing. I was pleased that my copay was discussed as part of treatment planning.
- Martha G.

You can't even see my scars. The professionalism and office staff is all top notch. He makes sure you are not in pain while in rehab. I highly recommend him. Fly to Dallas and have him fix it. Only healthy people are in the building so you don't have to worry about infections. I was in a walker 5 hours after surgery. Stopped using that after about a week. Never used crutches or a cane. I hope I don't have to use them again in the future but I will if I break another bone.
- Dennis P.

Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
explained everything I needed to know prior to surgery, provided a class on preparation for the majoy surgery, and has his staff very well-trained to answer all our questions and be available for assistance. My recovery has been quick, easy, and without problems. My xray of the new hip joint is perfect. I am very satisfied with his skills, knowledge, and support staff. I look forward to his replacement of my knee in the future.
Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked

- Karen A.

He is a good doctor. He knows his stuff. I attended a program at a retirement community where he gave a talk where his patients would speak about their cases. It gave his patients an opportunity to learn from fellow patients about what to expect. He is very friendly and caring. About 50% of the crowd were previous patients who were eager to speak and it was all positive experiences.
- Julie S.

Everything has gone excellent! He is a perfectionist. He brings his own staff with him to the hospital so that they know the patients and they are there before, during, and after the surgery. Dr.
Staten Island Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
is very thorough. He is upfront with his patients so that you know what to expect. He sees you before surgery, during, and is great with follow up. He and his staff are all hands on, great, and have wonderful bedside manner.
- Denise S.

I have no complaints and everything was handled very well. His office is very good. He is busy and I did have to wait in the waiting room for quite awhile, but that is only a minor issue.
- Matthew B.

All Knee Replacement Surgeons in Staten Island, NY

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

Advanced Orthopedics & Sports Medicine

408 Airport Executive Park

Alexiades, Dr. Michael M

523 E 72nd St
New York

Alpert, Dr. Scott W.

33 Walt Whitman Rd
Huntington Station

Alpha Therapy Services

22 Jackson Ave Apt 2

Altchek, Dr. David W.

525 E 71st St
New York

AmeriCare Physical Therapy

1111 US Highway 22

Andrew A. Willis, M.D.

197 Ridgedale Ave.

Andronaco, Dr. John A.

385 Prospect Ave

Awad, Dr. John N.

75 Kings Highway Cutoff

Bauman, Dr, Phillip A.

345 W 58th St
New York

Benatar, Dr. David A.

2631 Merrick Rd

Bergen Orthopedics

127 Union St


Shrub Oak

Boettner, Dr. Friedrich

523 E 72nd St
New York

Bonavoglia, Dr. Joseph

1776 Broadway 57th St
New York

Boone, Dr. Peter S.

888 White Plains Rd

Day Family Chiropractic

24 Wyckoff Ave. Suite #2

Deehan, Dr. Michael A.

57 Us Highway 46

DePaola, Dr. Fred

2444 New Jersey 34

Distrafano, Dr. Michael

140 STATE HWY 17 N

Dr. Bryan J. Nestor

535 E 70th St
New York

Elite Restaurant Equipment

153 21st St

Enker, Dr. Paul

1991 Marcus Ave
New Hyde Park

Esprit Wellness

2 West 45th Street
New York

Fasullo, Dr. Gregg J.

231 Granite Run Dr

Feldman, Dr. Hal D.

33 Walt Whitman Rd
Huntington Station

Frank R. DiMaio, M.D.

877 Stewart Avenue
Garden City

Fred Cushner MD

210 E 64th St
New York

Function First Physical Therapy

119 West 23rd Street, Suite 804
New York

Gallick, Dr. Gregory S

2780 Morris Ave

Garrow Family Chiropractic

2204 New Jersey 35

Garroway, Dr Robert

444 Merrick Rd

Gladstone, Dr. James

5 E 98th St
New York

Goldman, Dr. Robert T

3505 Hill Blvd
Yorktown Heights

Harwood, Dr. David A.

2 Worlds Fair Dr

Heal-Rite PT

2626 East 14th Street

Healthcare Associates In Medicine

3311 Hylan Blvd
Staten Island

Healy III, Dr. William

196 E Main St

Hershman, Dr. Elliott B.

130 E 77th St
New York

Hospital for Special Surgery

535 E 70th St
New York

Hudson Valley Bone and Joint

24 Saw Mill River Rd

Jaffe, Dr. Fredrick F.

301 E 17th St
New York

John Reilly MD

3311 Hylan Blvd
Staten Island

Klein, Dr. Gregg R.

10 Forest Ave

Luks, Dr. Howard J.

19 Bradhurst Ave

Madrid, Dr. Ivan J Fernandez

359 2ND AVE
New York

Manhattan Orthopaedics PC

130 E 77th St
New York

Manhattan Orthopedic & Sports

1065 Park Ave
New York

Manhattan Sports Therapy

635 Madison Avenue, Floor 4
New York

Mark Hartzband MD

10 Forest Ave

Martin, Dr. David

888 White Plains Rd

McIlveen, Dr. Stephen J.

1 W Ridgewood Ave

Medical One New York, PC

20 East 46th Street
New York


1055 Gibson Rd

Mendez, Dr. Daniel

500 Grand Ave

Michael Maynard MD

535 E 70th St
New York

Michael Russonella DO

1111 Paulison Ave

Mirsky, Dr. Eric C.

1 Diamond Hill Rd

More, Dr. Robert C.

6 Sand Hill Rd

Moriarty Physical Therapy

301 Manchester Rd


10 E 33rd St
New York

New York Bone and Joint Specialists

67 W 55th St Ste 205
New York

Newton Medical Center

175 High Street

NuLife Med

250 Commercial St Ste 3003

Ny Pulmunary Association Pc

530 1st Ave
New York

NYU Hospital for Joint Disease

301 E 17th St
New York

O'Brien, Dr Stephen J.

525 E 71st St
New York

Oh, Dr. Young D.

210 Westchester Ave
West Harrison

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

660 Broadway

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

1728 Sunrise Hwy

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

3480 Veterans Memorial Hwy

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

123 Maple Ave

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

444 Merrick Rd

Parks, Dr. Michael L.

535 E 70th St
New York

Personal Training Institute LLC

181 7th St
Garden City

Philip, Dr. Dambrosio

410 Lakeville Rd
Floral Park

Polakoff Dr. Donald R

111 Union Valley Rd


79 Kermit Ave
Staten Island

ProHealth Care Associates

2800 Marcus Ave
Lake Success

Putterman, Dr Eric

1800 Walt Whitman Rd

Rahway Edison Orthopedic Group

867 St. Georges Ave.

Robbins, Dr. Steven G.

1500 Pleasant Valley Way

Rodriguez, Dr. Jose A.

130 E 77th St
New York

Rodriguez, Dr. José A.

130 E 77th St
New York

Rose, Dr. Howard A.

1010 Northern Blvd
Great Neck

Rupolo, Dr. John G.

148 Tulip Ave
Floral Park

Schiuma, Dr Anthony

2830 E Oakland Park Blvd

Sean Lager, MD

50 Mount Prospect Ave

Seideman, Dr. Bruce A.

600 Northern Blvd
Great Neck

Semble, Dr. Richard D.

99 Dutch Hill Rd

Shapiro, Dr. Jeffrey F.

1000 Northern Blvd
Great Neck

Somers Orthopaedic Surgery & SPM

664 Stoneleigh Ave

St Charles Hospital

200 Belle Terre Rd
Port Jefferson

Stuart, Dr. Reiber

257 Lafayette Ave

Su, Dr. Edwin

541 E 71st St
New York

Summit Medical Group

34 Mountain Blvd

Summit Medical Group

150 Floral Avenue

SurgiCare of Manhattan

800 2nd Ave
New York



The WalkEZstore.com

2309 West Smith Valley Road

Torpey, Dr. Brian M.

776 Shrewsbury Ave

Total Physical Therapy

25 E Spring Valley Ave

Trokhan Dermatology LLC

235 Closter Dock Rd

Ultimed Healthcare PC

50 Franklin Lane, suite 201



Unis, Dr. George L

115 E 61st St
New York

Walsh, Dr. Raymond B.

6900 4th Ave

Weissberg, Dr. David J

379 Oakwood Rd
Huntington Station

Westchester Medical Group

210 Westchester Ave
West Harrison

Zambetti, Dr. George Joseph

343 W 58th St
New York

Zuckerman, Dr. Joseph D.

301 E 17th St
New York
Staten Island Zip Codes

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Staten Island.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Orthopedic Surgeon
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money