-Find top-rated Service Providers
Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Port Jefferson Knee Replacement Surgeons

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Knee Replacement Surgeons to Avoid


Top Rated Knee Replacement Surgeons


Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews
See Verified Local Reviews

Over 463 reviews for
Port Jefferson Knee Replacement Surgeons from people just like you.

"This was an out-patient surgery. It was very successful. I only needed ibuprofin to manage post-op pain for a few days. I began physical therapy almost immediately." I have full range of motion back in my shoulder - I have recommended Dr. to friends and family. He's an excellent surgeon!

-Theresa S.

"I needed a new knee replacement and revision of a bad one from 8 years ago.. He was the only doctor we saw that was willing to try to fix the bad one. He did them" both at the same time at Hospital. I have been very impressed with Dr. , his staff, the hospital and my rehab. He and his staff have great communication with each other and the patient. They actually do what they say they will, when they say they will do it! Quite a difference from the other arrogant surgeon I had for the first, bad replacement. The care at was outstanding, clean, efficient and everyone not only did their job, but asked others if they needed help! Again what a difference from Good Samaritan expeirence. Nice to finally have a surgeon that listens to his patient. I have had great results! I highly recommend him to anyone needing knee replacement.


+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 3 Million People on Angie's List
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Over 3 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 3 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Port Jefferson

knee doctor

Knee Orthopedics

Some orthopedic doctors specialize in the bones, muscles and tendons of the knee, from treating ACL tears and arthritis to performing knee replacement surgery.

Heather Moon riding her horse, Dicey.

Read about how an orthopedic surgeon helped a Texas woman get back on the saddle with reconstructive ankle surgery.

Pain relief tablets, ice pack, ace bandage

Some injuries and pains caused while shoveling snow can be treated at home. Try these treatments to help ease the pain before you call a doctor.

two men bicycling on road

Learn about the causes, symptoms and treatment for Compartment Syndrome, a painful muscular condition.

mom and daughter at pediatrician

Marked by a sideways curve in the spine, scoliosis typically becomes apparent during childhood.

Angie's Answers

Sounds like you should be pursuing a disability claim.  Also, you could speak to your previous doctor frankly about your concerns.  
Have they made orthotics for your shoes that distribute your weight better? 

Whoops - I just realized that you may have been looking for Angie's List information on providers outside your home market. To see information on providers that aren't in your home Angie's List chapter, you can elect to pay a small addditional fee (generally about $15 to $20) to add another city's Angie's List to your existing memember.


Learn more about the add-a-city option here.

Hello, this is Kyle K from the Member Care Department.

I apologize for any confusion, but your membership has been expired since 07/18/2012. If you would like access to pain doctors in the Midland, TX area you will need to renew your membership. You can renew online at any time by signing in to your old account at www.angieslist.com. Once logged in, you'll be asked to rejoin, and you can just follow the prompt.
If you’d prefer to speak with someone over the phone, our Member Care Team would be happy to assist you. They can be reached toll-free at 1-888-944-5478. Don’t forget to check-out our money saving multi-year plans, too.

Thanks for writing! - Kyle K
Hello, this is Kyle K from the Member Care Department.

I apologize for my delay. I apologize, but orthopedic surgeons fall under our Orthopedics category which is included in the Health list. Currently, you're enrolled in our Basic membership which only includes access to our Home list.
If you'd like to upgrade your membership to the Plus or Premium plan, we'll be happy to assist you with this search. If interested, give us a call at 1.888.944.5478 and we'll take care of this adjustment. Again, I do apologize for any misunderstanding.

Thanks for writing! - Kyle K



This is James W. with Member Care. Thanks for posting your question.


It looks like when you signed up online on 8/5/2014, that you accidentally joined our greater Portland chapter instead of our Salem/Corvallis chapter that your zip code falls under. I have transferred your subscription to that chapter, so you will now have access to the correct area.

I hope this information helps! Please let me know if I can assist further. You can respond to this thread or submit a new Answers post. You can also reach us at 1-866-783-2980. We're open weekdays from 8:00 am - 9:00 pm and Saturdays 8:00 am - 5:00 pm ET.


Thanks again!

Knee Care reviews in Port Jefferson


I found out after the surgery; he lied to me and never administered the antibiotics he stated he would and never even called the Specialists at the hospital .. He caused an infection in the stitching. He allows his receptionists to do close ups when he's rushed. This she bragged to me. He also stated he could do a complete ACL in 18 minutes. All ...More this I discovered afterwards ; when the stitching became infected... This soft spoken doctor became furious when the hospital called and asked if he would remove the self dissolving stitches as they were infected and very sloppy with pieces of my dermis tied over my epidermis. It looked like a big zigzag with lumps. ........only pus and bleeding for months due to the infection. My PT even called him and spoke with his concern about it . I went down to his office to get my stitches cleaned out and he seemed quite mad at me for having a problem with his superior method of surgery. He stated it would be too painful and it needed to be done under anesthesia. While under he removed my bone screw that was holding my ACL. I did not ask or complain of this . When I asked why he did it he said it was healed????? It had only been 3-4 months since installing it. A few months later my ACL snapped with a loud pop and tremendous pain. I was just walking on my sidewalk. I called him and wanted to have him see it.... He refused to see me. I am in horrific pain each day..
I would encourage anyone to avoid this surgeon. I also found out afterwards his fellowship was awarded in Australia where their medical degrees are much easier to obtain and no one in the states does his type of ACL.
Also no one wants another doctor's mess up.
He advertises heavily...Clue ..none of the good docs need to.

- Frank K.

Everything went very well. I had a right total knee replacement on 6/29/15 and have had an excellent result. I have been pain free for the past 3-4 weeks, and can do things I have been unable to do for the past two to three years. I would recommend Dr. to anyone who needs orthopedic surgery. He is an excellent surgeon, very ...More professional, and very easy to talk to. This entire experience has changed my life.
- Joann B.

I did my homework before deciding on a surgeon. I wanted a surgeon who was the best "technician" In this area. I talked to people. His name came up a lot. These are very tough surgeries to endure. So is the rehab. Dr. told me if I did everything he told me to....my outcome would be great. It was challenging , but ...More I did. Everything is great. I couldn't ask for better outcomes! He may not be warm and fuzzy but I liked him very much. He is all business but with a sense of humor and cares about providing his patients with the very best care.
- Mary D.

I chose Dr. for my knee replacement surgery after talking to several physicians and each one recommended Dr. as their first choice because of his experience and expertise. Dr. performs over 700 knee and hip replacements each year and he and his staff have the process down to a ...More science. Dr. spent all of the time I needed patiently answering my questions before and after the surgery. His office staff and nurses are all friendly and efficient in responding to your needs, especially , and . The typical hospital stay is two nights and then you are sent home. Home rehab lasts for about two weeks then you are transferred to outpatient physical therapy. It is necessary to have someone with you 24/7 for the first week after surgery as you are not very mobile. Although a difficult surgery my knees have healed well and the arthritis pain I used to have is in the past. The secret is to do everything you are told in physical therapy. The most difficult part of the rehab process for me was difficulty sleeping. It is hard to get comfortable in bed and it seems as though the pain gets more intense at night. After 5-8 weeks it is no longer an issue. My right knee feels near normal after a year and the left knee after 3 1/2 months has a ways to go. I can do any activity after the surgery that did before including golf. I highly recommend Dr. if you are considering joint replacement surgery. Be aware that he is booked about three months in advance.
- Joseph H.

I wasn't interested with him either. When I went to him, I was under the impression that he would do the knee replacement. After he had me do everything that I did like the MRI, then he told me he didn't do this. The office people were great. They were always there. I didn't have to wait very long to see him. He didn't do anything for me.
- Barbara P.

excellent service and great bedside manner. office staff were helpful and friendly. I have no problems or concerns with continuing my treatment with Dr. who has taken care of many of my family members with ortho related issues.
- Diane W.

Dr was very kind, knowledgeable and helpful. I had gone to my GP complaining of back and leg pain. He referred me to Dr due to an MRI I had. Despite the fact that I should have been referred to my original surgeon Dr helped me. I was suffering from back pain sciatica and leg pain. I ...More first met Dr over 20 years ago when he operated on my 13 year old sons hip. He saved my son from having to have an artificial hip. I thought of him when I developed two cases of frozen shoulder over the past 2 years. During the second case of frozen shoulder he helped me with a ruptured disc in my back by sending me for an MRI and also referred me to a surgeon I highly recommend Dr
- Dorene E.

After evaluating a couple of doctors, I decided on Dr. because he had performed so many procedures and was overly confident in his ability to do a perfect procedure, even speaking of his surgery on his mother. Being in my 40's, this was important to me, knowing I would need surgery again and being active. Afterwards, I ...More was stunned to find that he mis-measured the cut and my leg was just under an inch longer than my other leg. Much to my dismay, he tried to tell my at my first follow-up that it was because of muscle loss. After PT and other consultations, he admitted his mistake and suggested shoe lifts for my other shoe, or possible other follow-up surgery. I am not sure how a practiced surgeon could make such a grievous mistake but now I am paying for it until some day in the future where I will have it redone, since having a perfectly good leg operated on doesn't make a lot of sense. I constantly limp, stand to the side and live with the pain. While anyone can make a mistake, as my husband is a carpenter, I also think that "measure twice, cut once" would have been the thought of the day instead of trying to see how fast a surgery can get done.
- Pamela S.

Knee Replacement Surgeons in Port Jefferson, NY

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

Advance at Home Physical Therapy House Calls

Nassau, Suffolk & Queens
New Hyde Park

Advanced Orthopedics

285 Sills Rd.

Alpert, Dr. Scott W.

33 Walt Whitman Rd
Huntington Station

Alpha Therapy Services

22 Jackson Ave Apt 2

AmeriCare Physical Therapy

1111 US Highway 22

Andrew A. Willis, M.D.

197 Ridgedale Ave.

Andronaco, Dr. John A.

385 Prospect Ave

AnnexMed Billing Services, Inc

45-06 Queens Blvd
Ste 209

Atlantic Spine Center

475 Prospect Ave.

Awad, Dr. John N.

75 Kings Highway Cutoff

Bauman, Dr, Phillip A.

345 W 58th St
New York

Becker, Dr. Simon

667 Eagle Rock Ave

Benatar, Dr. David A.

2631 Merrick Rd

Bergen Orthopedics

127 Union St


Shrub Oak

Bonavoglia, Dr. Joseph

1776 Broadway 57th St
New York

Boone, Dr. Peter S.

888 White Plains Rd

Brian McGinley MD

635 Belle Terre Rd
Port Jefferson

Central Westchester Neuromuscular Care, PC

550 Mamaroneck Avenue

Cordasco, Dr. Frank A.

525 E 71st St
New York

Day Family Chiropractic

24 Wyckoff Ave. Suite #2

DePaola, Dr. Fred

2444 New Jersey 34

Distrafano, Dr. Michael

140 STATE HWY 17 N

Dr. Bryan J. Nestor

535 E 70th St
New York

Dr. Stephany Garcia, PT, DPT

49 Hamburg Turnpike

Esprit Wellness

2 West 45th Street
New York

Fasullo, Dr. Gregg J.

231 Granite Run Dr

Feldman, Dr. Hal D.

33 Walt Whitman Rd
Huntington Station

Frank R. DiMaio, M.D.

877 Stewart Avenue
Garden City

Fred Cushner MD

210 E 64th St
New York

Function First Physical Therapy

119 West 23rd Street, Suite 804
New York

Garrow Family Chiropractic

2204 New Jersey 35

Garroway, Dr Robert

444 Merrick Rd

Goldman, Dr. Robert T

3505 Hill Blvd
Yorktown Heights

Hershman, Dr. Elliott B.

130 E 77th St
New York

Hudson Valley Bone and Joint

24 Saw Mill River Rd

Jaffe, Dr. Fredrick F.

301 E 17th St
New York

Long Island Bone & Joint

635 Belle Terre Rd
Port Jefferson

Longobardi, Dr. Raphael S

433 Hackensack Ave

Longobardi, Dr. Raphael S.

433 Hackensack Ave

Luks, Dr. Howard J.

19 Bradhurst Ave

Manhattan Orthopaedics PC

130 E 77th St
New York

Manhattan Orthopedic & Sports

1065 Park Ave
New York

Manhattan Sports Therapy

635 Madison Avenue, Floor 4
New York

Martin, Dr. David

888 White Plains Rd

Marwin, Dr. Scott E.

19 Beekman St
New York

McIlveen, Dr. Stephen J.

1 W Ridgewood Ave

Medical One New York, PC

20 East 46th Street
New York

Mendez, Dr. Daniel

500 Grand Ave

Metro Sports Med

85 Livingston Street

Metro SportsMed

4911 13th Avenue

Metro SportsMed Midwood

1309 Avenue J

Michael Maynard MD

535 E 70th St
New York

Michael Russonella DO

1111 Paulison Ave

Mirsky, Dr. Eric C.

1 Diamond Hill Rd

More, Dr. Robert C.

6 Sand Hill Rd

Moriarty Physical Therapy

301 Manchester Rd

Mount Kisco Medical Group PC

111 Bedford Rd


S.I.E,Shahab Pura, Sialkot-Pakistan.

Neuromuscular Rehabilitation

130 West 42 Street, Suite 1055
New York

New York Bone and Joint Specialists

67 W 55th St Ste 205
New York

Newton Medical Center

175 High Street

NuLife Med

250 Commercial St Ste 3003

Ny Pulmunary Association Pc

530 1st Ave
New York

NYU Hospital for Joint Disease

301 E 17th St
New York

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

660 Broadway

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

3480 Veterans Memorial Hwy

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

123 Maple Ave

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

444 Merrick Rd

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

45 Crossways Park Drive

Parron, Dr. John K.

235 Closter Dock Rd


7850 NW 146TH ST # 508

Personal Training Institute LLC

181 7th St
Garden City

Philip, Dr. Dambrosio

410 Lakeville Rd
Floral Park

Polakoff Dr. Donald R

111 Union Valley Rd

Port Jefferson Specialty Assoc

635 Belle Terre Rd
Port Jefferson


79 Kermit Ave
Staten Island


600 Mamaroneck Avenue

Rodriguez, Dr. José A.

130 E 77th St
New York

Rose, Dr. Howard A.

1010 Northern Blvd
Great Neck

Rupolo, Dr. John G.

148 Tulip Ave
Floral Park

Seideman, Dr. Bruce A.

600 Northern Blvd
Great Neck

Semble, Dr. Richard D.

99 Dutch Hill Rd

Shapiro, Dr. Jeffrey F.

1000 Northern Blvd
Great Neck

St Charles Hospital

200 Belle Terre Rd
Port Jefferson

Stuart, Dr. Reiber

257 Lafayette Ave

Sunshine Physical Therapy

297 Commack Road

SurgiCare of Manhattan

800 2nd Ave
New York

Synergy Orthopedics

25 Prospect Avenue

The WalkEZstore.com

3209 West Smith Valley Road

Total Physical Therapy

25 E Spring Valley Ave

Trokhan Dermatology LLC

235 Closter Dock Rd

Ultimed Healthcare PC

50 Franklin Lane, suite 201

Unis, Dr. George L

115 E 61st St
New York

Walsh, Dr. Raymond B.

6900 4th Ave

Workers Comp Doctor - DHD Medical

265 Madison Ave
New York

Zambetti, Dr. George Joseph

343 W 58th St
New York

Shop Local Knee Care Services in Port Jefferson, NY

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Port Jefferson.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Orthopedic Surgeon
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money