-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Ithaca Auto Repair

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Auto Repair to Avoid

26

Top Rated Auto Repair

54

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 503 reviews for
Ithaca Auto Repair from people just like you.

C
"The quality of the work was fine. Not exceptional but acceptable. Abra was close and had a $1200 estimate compared to 3 others at about $1500. Once they got the" car, they "found" more damage. New estimate was $1800 a 50% increase which included a labor rate increase. In fairness, it was a few months from the time we go the estimate until the work was done. This fact was not disclosed to us; only after we combed the new estimate did we discover it. They eventually honored the original labor rate, but if we had wanted to take the car elsewhere it would have cost 2 hours of labor to put it back together. We got the call the car was ready but it was taken to a different location for repair work so we had to wait for them to bring it back to this location. They are only open until 5:30 but we weren't sure we'd be there in time so we paid for the repair at about 4:30 so they could leave it where we could pick it up after hours. We finally hear back after 5 that the technician didn't/couldn't/wouldn't put it back together. So we couldn't get the car until the next day. We unexpectedly freed up by 5:00 to pick it up even though the keys and receipt were to be left in the car and locked. We went into pick them up. The receptionist was not able to give me the keys and receipt even though it was already paid for. In the mean time, I inspected the vehicle only to discover the fog light was not working and antenna had fallen off. She told me I had to speak to
. She was very indifferent. We had to wait for 20 minutes while
was on the phone. While we were waiting my son crawled under the car to notice that the fog light was not plugged in and was able to just screw the antenna back in. When we told her that and asked for the keys, she still said I had to wait for
. Finally some other person came to give me keys and receipt. My insurance company had warned me that some body shops will low ball the estimate to get you in the door then "find" more damage once they get in to it. We paid this repair out of pocket so the extra was not charged to insurance.

-Laura P.

A
"excellent. when a few additional problems were identified (small leak in AC system) they were fast on scheduling and making the additional minor repairs.

-Richard W.

+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Ithaca

Auto Repair reviews in Ithaca

A

Rating
I was very impressed how smooth the process went. The estimate took 20 minutes and was the best I found in the area. The actual repair went without any hitches and they only had my car for two days. They even washed and vacuumed then vacuumed my car. The staff was very helpful and extremely nice. I would definitely recommend them.
- conrad S.
A

Rating
The owner is wonderful - extremely communicative and service-oriented. I didn't have to worry about a thing, except dropping my car off and picking it up. And the work they do is beautiful - they take pride in body work. I hope to not have any more accidents, but if I do, I will go to
Ithaca Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
!
- Kristi M.
A

Rating
After a traumatic car accident I was shocked to discover that I had to pay the total cost of repairs to my car due to Michigan's No Fault laws (and my lack of full coverage). Three other places estimated the damage at $5, 000 plus.
Ithaca Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
at B & B went out of his way to bring down the cost by using used parts when he could instead of new ones to $2600. The work was "excellent" and they saved me a lot of money. I would highly recommend this company and the people there.
- Judith A.
N

Rating
The staff was extremely helpful and efficient at setting up my repair. After determining the correct color for my vehicle's make and model, they ordered and painted the bumper ahead of time so that I was only out of the car for 5 hours, rather than the two days that the insurance company estimated. Everyone at ACE was extremely friendly and hardworking. They even washed my car for me! Amazing people and phenomenal service! The new rear bumper is a perfect match and looks great!
- Alaina N.
A

Rating
The work they did is beautiful. The price was good, they even gave me 10% off for being an Angie's List member. The painting was perfect, you can't even tell there was any work done. This is a family run business and they are always so nice and professional. Talk to
Ithaca Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
, he's great!
- JOSEPH K.
A

Rating
It turned out very well. They have great quality of service. No difficulties getting the car in for service. They deliver what they promise to deliver.
- Paul B.
A

Rating
They did okay and it is a place that we would go back to because they did a reasonably good job. My husband said they did even more than they said they would. At first, he thought the price was a little expensive, but I think it turned out pretty well because they did several other little things. It looked like it was a smallish place. Their price was okay and they also got it done earlier than they said they would.
- Michael G.
A

Rating
It went great the car looks like new. The job was finished within the time he told me it would be and he was always very professional, friendly and helpful. I found out this job would have cost me more had I gone to someone else.
- Catherine P.

All Auto Repair in Ithaca, NY

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

ADVANCE AUTO PARTS

380 ELMIRA RD
Ithaca

ADVANCED TOWING

503 GOSS ST
Ithaca

AJ FOREIGN AUTO

130 CHERRY ST
Ithaca

Audio Video Depot

4 Emmett Street
Canisteo

AUTO BODY WORKS

520 ESTY ST
Ithaca

AUTO ZONE

309 ELMIRA RD
Ithaca

AutoPartsNerd.com

(no pick-up)
Bronx

Autoworks

1278 Dryden Rd
Ithaca

Belle Mead Garage

2454 US Hwy 206

Bobby Wilbur Auto Repair

83 Elk Point Rd
Livingston Manor

BRUCE'S TIRE

740 S MEADOW ST
Ithaca

Burritt Motors

340 New York 104
Oswego

Butch's Automotive Service, Inc.

30 Edward Street, PO Box 86
Arcade

CHARLIE'S TOWING & REPAIRING

1941 ELMIRA RD
Newfield

Clinton Auto Service Inc

3727 State Rte 12B
Clinton

Cole Muffler

223 Elmira Rd
Ithaca

CRISPELL AUTOMOTIVE INC

1920 SLATERVILLE RD
Ithaca

Dan's Tire & Auto Service Center Inc

48 Batavia City Ctr
Batavia

Dewey's Auto Repair

182 Main St
Hoosick Falls

EAGLE TRANSMISSIONS INC

714 LAKE ST
Elmira

ED'S AUTO SALES & GARAGE

3157 A LAKE RD
Horseheads

ELM CHEVROLET

301 E Church St.
Elmira

Fast Lane Garage

651 Erie St
Elmira

Ferrario Auto Team

2472 Corning Rd
Elmira

Fox Auto Group

150 Robert Dann Dr
Painted Post

Fran Noble Auto Repair

1323 Newsome Rd
Arkport

Geek Squad - Best Buy

40 CATHERWOOD RD
Ithaca

Geek Squad - Best Buy

950 COUNTY ROAD
Elmira

H & H AUTO SALES

644 ENFIELD FALLS RD
Ithaca

Herky Miller Inc

3300 Babcock Blvd

HUNT'S AUTOMOTIVE

225 ELMIRA RD
Ithaca

Innovative Edge Detailing

3072 Fluvanna Ave
Jamestown

ITHACA AUTO PAINT SUPPLIES

207 ELMIRA RD
Ithaca

Ithaca Auto Service

312 4th Street
Ithaca

ITHACA TIRE & AUTO CARE CTR

917 W STATE ST
Ithaca

J S AUTO PARTS

109 E Seneca St
Ithaca

Jimmy's Sales & Service

2871 Jones Bridge Rd
Mount Morris

KENT BROWN TOYOTA

951 COUNTY ROAD
Elmira

KLOPP'S TRANSMISSION & AUTO

362 PARK AVE
Corning

KOST TIRE & MUFFLER

361 ELMIRA RD
Ithaca

Kost Tire and Auto Care

361 Elmira Rd
Ithaca

LANE'S AUTOMOTIVE

1850 Danby Road ( Rte 96b)
Ithaca

Lansing Auto Body

2037 E Shore Dr
Lansing

Maguire Automotive Group

370 Elmira Rd
Ithaca

Mavis Discount Tire

231 Elmira Rd
Ithaca

McGeachie's Body Shop

1232 State Rte 122
Constable

Monro Muffler Brake & Service

338 Elmira Rd
Ithaca

Monro Service Center

88 Grove St
Massena

Montway Auto Transport

4740 N Cumberland Ave

Moore's Tire Sales

45 N Main St
Sherburne

Move My Automobile

5573 Bryan Drive

Orleans Ford

1405 S Main St
Medina

OSBAND BODY SHOP

2118 OSBAND AVE

Parts Authority Warehouse Inc

67 Whitson St
Hempstead

Patterson's Service Station

221 N Aurora St
Ithaca

PERFORMANCE TRANSMISSIONS

1229 EAGLE ST
Sandusky

Phelps Wholesale Automotive

13 Waterwagon Rd
Lansing

Reliable Carriers Inc

41555 Koppernick Rd

Rich's Garage

468 Hayts Rd
Ithaca

Schara's Auto Sales and Service

308 Main Street
Groton

Simmons-Rockwell

784 County Rd
Elmira

Snyder Repair Shop

33 Ford Hill Rd
Lansing

Steve's Body Shop

6508 State Rte 3
Mexico

T&W Automotive

3925 Salt Works Rd
Medina

TABER STREET AUTO REPAIR

805 TABER ST
Ithaca

Tallmadge Tire Service

1285 State Rte 318
Waterloo

TALLMADGE TIRE SVC

358 ELMIRA RD
Ithaca

TIOGA AUTO PARTS

424 W STATE ST
Ithaca

Vision Dodge Chrysler Jeep

920 Panorama Trail S
Rochester

Watertown Auto Repair

26109 NYS Rte 283
Watertown

Webster's Garage

152 Main St
Moravia

William T Pritchard Automotive

304 S Cayuga St
Ithaca

Wink's Body Shop

720 W Court St
Ithaca

Woods Automotive

58 W Main St
Cambridge
Ithaca Zip Codes

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Ithaca.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Auto Repair
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money