-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Fairport Auto Repair

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Auto Repair to Avoid

52

Top Rated Auto Repair

131

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 1,114 reviews for
Fairport Auto Repair from people just like you.

F
"I really do not know what happened to this place. There were so many great reviews I trusted my car repairs to them, as paid for by an at fault driver's insurance." The first time through they lost my keys, dug a deep scratch in the bumper they had just ordered, painted and installed, and it didn't seem to bother them that the whole thing was out of alignment and the
wasn't opening properly. They simply wanted to push it out the door, finished or not. I again trusted that with their great reputation this would be fixed, and I was told that parts would be ordered and things would be fixed. A week goes by and I haven't heard anything so I call back- nothing has been ordered and nothing has been done. With many phone calls to their shop and to the insurance I finally have the car back in the shop, well over a month since the initial accident. I am promised multiple contacts when I would be told an estimated finishing date, which never happened. Not once did Mr.
actually contact me when he said he would and I was stuck waiting the whole time. Once I finally get a phone call a message is left telling me the car will be ready to go in the morning and all they have to do is wash it. After a three hour drive back to
(in the middle of moving) I am dropping off my car at the rental agency and getting a ride over to the shop, so I call to let them know- when I am told the car is not ready (despite saying that it would be). I show up and I'm again told it's ready... except they failed to repair a piece under a door panel I was directly told would be addressed when I dropped off the car. After pressing the issue my car is passed to the car washer who starts trying to rip off the door panel without removing all the screws and damages it. I have to tell him there is a fastener behind the door handle, because he apparently is not trained in this kind of work and is trying to rip the panel off. Even his co-worker makes fun of him as a result. He then ends up scratching it even more because he stumbles over it on the ground once it is off. Sharing this with Mr.
didn't seem to bother him at all and this same car washer is raising his voice, cussing at me, and slamming a door- with the boss right there. Again
did nothing to correct this behavior and instead of fixing the vehicle the car washer went to complain to his co workers. The inner panel of my door panel is now scratched and the speaker grill even had plastic
sticking out where the panel was damaged. No attempt to fix this was made, and even when it was directly pointed out,
did not care. Mr.
directly lied to me on several points making up excuses saying he had not been able to talk to people about issues he already said were discussed with them the week before. He tried to back out of previous statements and assurances, and showed no follow through. It is clear that the people working at this shop are not skilled technicians and they take no pride in their work. There are images on the website of vehicles being carefully painted in a controlled and clear booth. I personally saw exterior body parts being painted with primer spray paint from a rattle can with plenty of dirt flying in an open door garage. It is clear that at one point this was a great shop and the older brother was always great about following up and contacting me as he said he would at the start of the process. They side contracted a muffler shop which I think did a great job as well, but it was a separate business. Also, in regards to the location. Though I was not aware of it a car rental driver pointed out to me that about every other business in that area was a strip club. Pricing seemed reasonable, and would have been rated higher if product and services paid for were delivered. Most other shops will at least clean the car if you have work done there, some even offer to detail it as part of the price. This shop cleaned areas worked on, but nothing else.

-Kenneth B.

A
"The glass portion of my Tundra's outside rear view mirror had been knocked loose. I visited with
at
's" Automotive (also on Angie' List) and he referred me to
Repair. I talked to
at Precision and he immediately looked at the glass piece, put some grease on the back of it, and pushed it into place on the mounted holder (something I tried to do several times without success). He then looked at me and said "It's on the house." It's refreshing to see a business that isn't always after the all-mighty dollar, still offering assistance in a professional and courteous manner.

-Bill A.

+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Fairport

Auto Repair reviews in Fairport

A

Rating
This is a family run, 27-year-old business built on honesty, skill, experience and knowledge.
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
gives a lifetime warranty for work done in his shop and he stands behind that for every customer. My car needed extra care due to pearlized paint requiring five sequential coats.
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
and his wife,
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
, went to work in my behalf with two different insurance companies in two separate jobs to raise the authorized cost from the insurance adjustor's initial estimate to what would enable the work to be done correctly to
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
's standards, considering his lifetime warranty. He also negotiated and shopped around for new parts when the insurance company specified used. I am so impressed with this man's earnestness and honesty and high standards, I want share my experience with Angie's List members and most enthusiastically recommend
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
!
- Lynn T.
A

Rating
Beyond everything else...completely trustworthy. It's overwhelming and intimidating to be thrust into an area which you have no knowledge or experience. You worry about being over-charged, jazzed with a bunch of buzz words, scared into agreeing to unnecessary work. Save yourself some time and angst...go directly to
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
Auto Body. Best estimates, no BS, guaranteed satisfaction, old-fashioned customer service and attention.

I'd challenge anyone to identify the repaired area...perfect paint match on a weathered 10 year old car. He's been in business for 35 years which says it all.





- Frank T.
D

Rating
I had my
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
there to be repaired and even after I called and asked them to double check that my windows were rolled up before the tech was done, they left my windows down during a very
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
week. So now I have had to spend extra money to have the water removed.
- Robert D.
A

Rating
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
has 8 locations in the Twin Cities and I was referred to them
for scratch work by Maplewood Toyota. The dealership uses this
provider (an adjacent block from the dealership) and was highly
complimentary about the quality of
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
work. I talked with
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked

about scratches on my Prius. He gave me alternatives; he explained
the costs associated with each; he well explained the limits of what
could actually be done. I chose a
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
treatment because the
final choice was to not replace the applique, which would have been the
preponderant majority of the costs - and did not seem necessary.
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
and the front desk staff made me feel welcome and confident in their
commitment to find the right solution that would match my expectations.
I am delighted with the results.
For any future paint or collision repair needs, this will be my first and only
choice for help.
- Jane D.
A

Rating
They do fantastic work, at a very fair price and in the time they promise. I got two other bids from shops who wanted to repaint the whole car, practically, for more money. It clearly wasn't necessary.
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
is personable and super professional. Love this shop!

- Kate C.
A

Rating
He tried. I bought a lift gate on e bay and it was severely damaged on shipment by Pilot shipping.
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
the owner called me when it arrived and would not accept it. It had been dropped and toppled off a forklift or truck and was beyond repair.
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
the owner undid the packing. (poor packing) and took pictures of the damage for me to use for a claim. The owner is
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
. A quality and trustworthy person. Went beyond his responsibility in his treatment of me and the problem. He will get the business again when I can find another lift gate.
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
is a pleasure to work. Being a senior without much money
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
was sensitive to my needs and worked with me on this lift gate replacement. I hope to settle with the supplier and get another lift gate. The workmanship of cars at his shop look to be top quality work and I look forward to his work in the future.
- James G.
A

Rating
There was some damage to my front bumper. Even though I went through my insurance,
Fairport Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
honored the Insurance estimate and got the bumper replaced. I dropped off my car in the morning and was able to pick it up the same day as promised. The process was seamless and the service was excellent. I would highly recommend them to my friends. I wish them the very best.

- Karthic M.
A

Rating
I've been going to Andys for years. Always great service and honest pricing. I would never go anywhere else for any car issues. Very knowledgeable and friendly.
- robin L.

Auto Repair in Fairport, NY

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

A & M Automotive & Transmissions

3581 Fancher Rd
Holley

A-AIRPORT TRANSMISSIONS INC

690 RIDGE RD W
Rochester

AAMCO Transmissions

398 W COMMERCIAL ST
East Rochester

AAMCO Transmissions

1521 Mt Read Blvd
Rochester

ABREY MECHANICAL SERVICES

PO Box 1130
Webster

Action Towing & Service

275 Marketplace Dr
Rochester

Advent Automotive - Victor

6600 New York 96
Victor

Arieno's Collision

1096 Ridge Rd. W.
Rochester

Auto Expressions

630 Ridge Rd W
Rochester

AUTO FINISHERS SUPPLY CO

1711 CLINTON AVE N
Rochester

Auto Transporters Online

25108 Marguerite PKWY, Ste A-353

AutoPartsNerd.com

(no pick-up)
Bronx

Baris Auto Inc

135 N Main St
Fairport

Barry's Auto Center

4579 Lake Road S
Brockport

BARTH TOWING

871 RIDGE RD
Webster

Bauman's Auto Service Inc

76 Cedarfield Commons
Rochester

BERGEN SALES INC

PO Box 400
Bergen

BOB HASTINGS COLLISION

110 Despatch Dr
East Rochester

Brent Johnstone

7265 Slocum Rd
Ontario

Brian's Alignment and service

3801 W Ridge Rd
Rochester

BROTHERS COLLISION-MECHANICAL

4401 LAKE AVE
Rochester

BROWNCROFT SERVICE CENTER

365 NORTH WASHINGTON STREET
Rochester

BRYAN AUTOMOTIVE PARTS

509 WATSON RD
Fairport

C & C AUTO SVC & SALES

1141 NORTON ST
Rochester

Carpenters Auto Service

2930 Chili Ave
Rochester

Carriage House LLC

1298 Clifford Ave
Rochester

Charles W Schrader Inc

686 Clinton Ave S
Rochester

Chris and Rods Auto Service

79 Donovan st
Webster

CJK Contracting

Rochester

CLAR'S ELMWOOD AUTOMOTIVE

870 ELMWOOD AVE
Rochester

COLUMBO'S COMPUTER REPAIR

773 Meigs St
Rochester

Coreys Repair and Transport

297 Hook Rd
Farmington

CORTESE FORD

2500 W HENRIETTA RD
Rochester

Crane's Automotive Service Inc

332 W Main St
Honeoye Falls

CRISTO COLLISION WEST LLC

40 Stace St Ste 1
Rochester

Culver Auto & Detail Sales/ Service

1387 Culver Rd.
Rochester

CUSTOM TRUCK CREATIONS

347 HOGAN RD
Fairport

D & B Auto Service

90 Mount Hope Ave
Rochester

D.C. Collision Inc.

2141 Empire Blvd
Webster

DIAL-A-TIRE INC

111 S MAIN ST
Fairport

DICK IDE HONDA

875 Panorama Trail S
Rochester

DING DOCTOR OF ROCHESTER INC

6227 COUNTY ROAD
Farmington

DOAN DODGE-CHRYSLER-JEEP-RAM

4477 RIDGE RD W
Rochester

Dobbs Family Auto Service Inc

115 West Ave
Canandaigua

Dorschel Automotive Group

3817/3855 W Henrietta Rd
Rochester

DOYLE CHEVROLET INC

740 RIDGE RD
Webster

Dunn Tire - Henrietta

3300 W Henrietta Rd
Rochester

East Avenue Auto

1656 East Ave
Rochester

EFS Auto

12 Pixley Industrial Pkwy Ste 5
Rochester

EFS Auto Care

22 Marway Circle
Rochester

ELM CHEVROLET

301 E Church St.
Elmira

Elmer's Brighton Garage

1848 Monroe Ave
Rochester

Emanon Towing

3000 Clinton Ave S
Rochester

EMERSON COLLISION SVC INC

2589 RIDGEWAY AVE
Rochester

Exit 11 Auto, Inc.

7283 W Henrietta Rd
Rush

FABRICATION ONE IN AUTOMOTIVE

2057 MOUNT READ BLVD
Rochester

FAIRPORT AUTO SERVICE LLC.

739 Whitney Rd Building B
Fairport

Ferrel's Garage Inc

365 University Ave
Rochester

FETZNER COLLISION INCORPORATED

2485 Dewey Ave.
Rochester

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

7374 PITTSFORD PALMYRA RD
Fairport

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

6480 BROCKPORT SPENCERPORT RD
Brockport

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

1891 DEWEY AVE
Rochester

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

630 RIDGE RD E
Rochester

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

369 JEFFERSON RD
Rochester

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

2210 RIDGE RD W
Rochester

Firestone Complete Auto Care Store

950 Elmridge Center Dr
Rochester

First Choice Automotive

1685 Dewy Ave
Rochester

FRED FOTI COLLISION

671 WHITNEY RD W
Fairport

Garber Collision Center

3890 West Henrietta Road
Rochester

Geek Squad - Best Buy

2345 MARKETPLACE DR
Rochester

Geek Squad - Best Buy

7550 Commons Blvd
Victor

Geneva Foreign & Sports

2787 Lyons Rd
Geneva

George & Bob's Service

3392 Saint Paul Blvd
Rochester

Gladstone Service Inc

5420 W Henrietta Rd
West Henrietta

GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER CO

3925 DEWEY AVE
Rochester

GORDY'S SUNOCO

3108 EAST AVR
Rochester

GRACE AUTO REPAIR

722 RIDGE RD.
Webster

GRAVES AUTO SVC

300 BROADWAY
Rochester

HENRIETTA COLLISION INC

929 ERIE STATION RD
Rush

Hoselton Chevrolet

909 Fairport Road
East Rochester

Infinite Audio Inc.

1116 Route 31
Macedon

JET Automotive Service & Repair

431 Western Drive
Henrietta

Jim's Service Center

635 Norton St
Rochester

JME Automotive Inc

646 Route 104
Ontario

JME COLLISION

131 Route 104
Ontario

JT Sound

21 Colin St
Livonia

K & J AUTOMOTIVE

560 AVIS ST
Rochester

KONG's Garage

1460 Hudson Ave Ste 1
Rochester

KOST TIRE & MUFFLER

335 Court St
Binghamton

Kost Tire Auto Care

3543 W Henrietta Rd
Rochester

KURT'S GARAGE

1315 Hudson Ave
Rochester

LANCE'S AUTOMOTIVE

1666 STATE ROUTE 104
Ontario

LEBRUN TOYOTA

2435 STATE ROUTE 332
Canandaigua

Lefebre's Auto Service

PO Box 16006
Rochester

LeRoy Collision

7000 W. Main Rd.
Leroy

LEWIS GENERAL TIRES

3870 W HENRIETTA RD
Rochester

Mac's II Collision & Mechanical Service

3301 Brighton Henrietta Townline Rd
Rochester

Macedon Auto Center Inc

2309 Macedon Center Rd
Palmyra

MAETEC POWER INC

388 MASON RD
Fairport

Maintenance Auto

1260 Commercial Dr
Farmington

MASTER TOWING SVC

16 LONESOME RD
Fairport

Mazda of West Ridge

4692 Ridge Road West
Spencerport

MECHETTI AUTOMOTIVE & TIRE

15 1/2 North Main Street
Fairport

MICHAEL'S AUTO BODY REPAIR

215 LYELL AVE
Rochester

Midas

281 Bay Village Dr
Rochester

MOLYE CHEVROLET, INC.

115 W. Main St.
Honeoye Falls

MONRO MUFFLER BRAKE

1860 STONE RD
Rochester

MONRO MUFFLER BRAKE

7387 VICTOR PITTSFORD RD
Victor

MONRO MUFFLER BRAKE

7275 PITTSFORD-PALMYRA RD
Fairport

Monro Muffler Brake Inc

3077 Monroe Ave
Rochester

Montway Auto Transport

4740 N Cumberland Ave

MORRIS AUTO REPAIR AND COLLISION INC.

52 LIGHTFOOT ST
Rochester

Move My Automobile

5573 Bryan Drive

Nichols Brothers Collision Inc

701 W Main St
Rochester

Nick's Auto Shop

151 Ridge Rd. E
Rochester

NU LOOK COLLISION

840 LEHIGH STATION RD
West Henrietta

NU LOOK COLLISION INC

15 ELMGROVE PARK
Rochester

NU-LOOK COLLISION

70 OCONNOR RD
Fairport

NU-LOOK COLLISION CENTERS

1301 EAST RIDGE ROAD
Rochester

Nu-Look Collision Inc

280 Monroe Ave
Rochester

Panorama Collision Inc

108 N Lincoln Rd
East Rochester

PARTS PLUS AUTOSTORE

1340 FAIRPORT RD
Fairport

Patrick Buick GMC

4700 West Henrietta Rd
Henrietta

PATRICK COLLISION

4700 W HENRIETTA RD
Henrietta

Patrick Pontiac Buick & GMC

4700 W Henrietta Rd
Henrietta

PERINTON AUTOMOTIVE CENTER INC

20 JEFFERSON RD
Fairport

PHILS AUTOMOTIVE

1364 STATE RTE 104
Ontario

RALPH HONDA

3939 RIDGE RD W
Rochester

Randall Buick GMC Cadillac

2555 State Rte 332
Canandaigua

RAY KERHAERTS GARAGE INC

1396 RIDGE RD W
Rochester

Ray Sands Glass

3315 Chili Ave
Rochester

REDi Imports

144 Railroad St.
Rochester

Redline Transmission Of Rochester

686E Pullman Ave
Rochester

Reliable Carriers Inc

41555 Koppernick Rd

Riverside Service Joe Legno's

3333 E River Rd
Rochester

Roc City Auto Service

200 Buffalo Road
Rochester

ROCHESTER PAINT & PERFORMANCE

5461 RIDGE RD W
Spencerport

RON NANNINI SERVICE

315 COMMERCE DR
Rochester

RON'S AUTO REPAIR

2175 EMPIRE BLVD
Webster

Rytek Automotive

68 Oconnor Rd
Fairport

Sam LoVetro Automotive

44 Richmond St
Rochester

Schoen Place Auto

319 E Chestnut St
East Rochester

SCOTTY'S AUTOMOTIVE INC

1886 MONROE AVE
Rochester

Sewilo and Sons Automotive

4753 Route 104
Williamson

Simmons-Rockwell

784 County Rd
Elmira

SNYDER'S AUTO COLLISION

7676 W HENRIETTA RD
Rush

sps pool services

78 rocmar drive
Rochester

STEREO SHOP

2613 Ridge Rd W
Rochester

Sutherland Auto Sales

3830 Monroe Ave
Pittsford

The Muffler Shop II Inc

1334 Fairport Rd
Fairport

TIRE WORLD STORE

2049 EMPIRE BLVD
Webster

TODD'S TOWING

352 MACEDON CENTER RD
Fairport

TOTAL CAR CARE

2151 E HENRIETTA RD
Rochester

Townline Garage

105 West Main Street
Honeoye Falls

TRANSMISSION CLINIC-ROCHESTER

286 ROUTE 31F
Fairport

Tydings Automotive Service Station

1968 Ridge Rd E
Rochester

Underground Paint Shop

401 Elmgrove Road
Rochester

VAIL AUTOMOTIVE

757 SOUTH AVE
Rochester

Van Bortel Ford

71 Marsh Rd
East Rochester

Vanderstyne Toyota

4374 W Ridge Rd
Rochester

Vesa's Automotive

1235 University Ave
Rochester

Vesa's Automotive

1235 University Ave
Rochester

Vision Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram of Penfield

920 Panorama Trail S
Penfield

Vision Dodge Chrysler Jeep

920 Panorama Trail S
Rochester

Vision Ford

770 Panorama Trl S
Rochester

VOGEL'S COLLISION SVC

100 WINTON RD N
Rochester

Walker Auto Repair

1480 Walker Lake Ontario Rd
Hilton

Wilbert's U-Pull It

4936 Rte 104
Williamson

Ziebart - Rochester

2440 W Henrietta Rd
Rochester

Ziebart Car Detailing Experts

1505 Lyell Ave
Rochester

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Fairport.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Auto Repair
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money