Cedarhurst Caterers

in Cedarhurst, NY

Sample Reviews


This catering event with
was terrible! Our party started at 5pm; she told me she would be there around 2:30 to 3pm - she arrived at 4:30. this caused for confusion and my guests were not greeted at the door as I had asked. I requested 2 servers. Without consulting me she showed up with one server, also late and a bartender with an attitude. She told me what she expected as a tip and told me if I paid in cash, there would be no tax. She later rescinded that statement. What you see is not what you get with her. I would definitely not use her again and I would caution anyone else from using her.
- Mary Beth H.

On a scale of 1 - 10, I'd rate
's company,
, a 100. This experience was outstanding from beginning to end. My husband and I planned a "We Have Too Much Wine" party and decided to hire a caterer, since we were expecting approximately 45 people. While we entertain a lot, I'd never hired a caterer before, and I was a little apprehensive about giving up control. I called
after reading other reviews on Angie's List, and from our first conversation, I knew she was the right person. She asked good questions, made suggestions about which
d'oeuvres might work well for our party, and did a great job in putting together a menu. She visited our home about 10 days prior to the party to see our kitchen layout and table placement, etc. On the evening of the party, she arrived promptly at 6:00 (90 minutes prior to the start of the party) and immediately got to work. We heard the same one-word comment from several of our guests: "Amazing!". In fact, when she left the party, I told her she deserved a standing ovation, and those guests who were still there did, indeed, clap for her. The food was fabulous, she was professional, unobtrusive, hard working, and an all-around absolute pleasure to work with. We entertain a lot, and I can assure you that
won't be my first call - she will be my ONLY call. I will never have anxiety about hiring a caterer again, since I'll only hire
and we know the quality of her work. In fact, I now can't imagine having a party without her. I loved the food, her professionalism, her presentation (awesome!), and also the fact that I had only to put the tablecloth, candles and flowers on the table, and she handled the rest. Having her there allowed me the opportunity to enjoy our party, something that can be challenging to do if you're the one responsible for managing the food, etc. Several of our guests took her business card and I am sure that they will all be calling her for their own events. I don't generally gush when writing a review, but it would be impossible not to do so when it comes to
and her company. Call her - she is truly a consummate professional who will make your life much easier and your party a huge success!
- Laura C.

Cedarhurst Catering Articles

Catering reviews in Cedarhurst


I went into the
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
's and placed 2 orders for a catering package, each to serve 30 people: 2 full deep covered aluminum trays (which is what how all the trays were) of Italian beef, 3 inch cut bread pieces, a large containers of sweet
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
, a large container of hot
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
, 2 full trays of fried chicken, 2 full tray of delightful special salads, a selection of dressings, 2 full trays of mostaccioli , a very large container of grated parmesan cheese, paper plates, serving utensils, and a large package of
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
's napkins. We and our guests were greatly impressed by the quality and quantity of the food. Many people made a point to tell us how much they enjoyed all of the food from
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
's. They said that they had ordered
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
's pizza in the past but did not realize that they had catering, too. Of course, we had a lot of food left over. We wanted to make sure that we would not run out of anything. Even days later, all of the food was still tasty. Everything was expertly prepared and delivered at the right temperature. There was plenty of gravy for the delicious beef. The bread was very fresh. The chicken was just right, not at all greasy or dry. The salads (2) were amazing. The mostacccioli had a delicious sauce and was covered with a
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
of melted mozzarella cheese. There were many amazing salad dressings to choose from. We will definitely order catering from
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
's of
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
, Illinois again.


Food arrived on time and as requested. Food was fresh and delicious.
Vodka Sauce is amazing!
We were very pleased with the offering Fevola's was able to provide on the budget given for the office.

- Brian D.

Excellent! All selections of food were both pliniful and delicious. Staff was very attentive and helpful. As part of a separate contract,
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
also provided a Sunday Brunch at the bride & groom's house on the day after the wedding., offering great selections and a chef creating made-to-order omelets. Great service deserves great ratings!
- Michael H.

Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
and his crew went above and beyond what I expected!!
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
drove from
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
to Three
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
to cater my 50th birthday for 85 people. The
service was professional and I had many people tell me how great the food was. I highly recommend
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
- Lisa R.

The food was beautiful and delicious. Be sure to try the mini beef wellingtons!)
The staff was friendly and professional during the party, and fun after.
While I was not the one who had the party and hired
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
, i will certainly consider them when I need a caterer.
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
- Rick S.

Everything here was ready and beautiful for our event!
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
caterer was
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
Serock Catering who is nearby
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
.. The building is fascinating for anyone who enjoys classic archtecture. The food and drinks from
Cedarhurst Caterers Provider Name Locked
Serock were fantastic! We had a Great Gatsby style wedding that was our daughter's dream. we've received many, many compliments from our guests on a wedding / reception that will be remembered for a long time! EVERYTHING was 1st class!
- Michael H.

Everything went great. The food was delivered and set up. Everything was piping hot and there was more food than was requested. The food was very well prepared, had a great taste and flavor. The meats were tender and juicy. The vegetables were seasoned properly and hot. The bread/rolls were soft and delicious. All in all an awesome experience....More /> http://www.threesisterskitchentogo.com

- Anthony G.

They showed up on time (a bit early, actually), and set-up the food we had ordered. The food - we got several different types of sandwiches and salads - was EXCELLENT, and a good price for what you get. We just had an order for delivery, so that's all there was to it.
- Karen V.
110% Guaranteed Money Back

We think we're the best, and we can prove it.

Try an annual plan and if you want to cancel in your first year, we'll refund you 110%

Annual Plans Only

All Caterers in Cedarhurst, NY

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!


185 Vanderbilt Ave
Brentwood, NY

352 riverdale food center

352 riverdale ave
Yonkers, ny

3in1 Events

Brooklyn, NY

a & a design

23 White Birch Cir
Miller Place, NY

Academy of Professional Bartending School

363 North Ave
New Rochelle, NY

Ace Caterers

209 N. Atlanta Ave
Massapequa, NY

All State Cleaning Service

7823 264th St.
Glen Oaks, NY


151 lincoln ave
Newark, NJ


135 W 18TH ST
New York, NY


Danbury, CT

American Cheese

289 Railroad Ave
Sayville, NY

American Party Staffing, LLC

183 Vernon Ave.
Paterson, NJ


New York, NY

Anne Booth Catering

14 Arden Terrace
Mount Vernon, NY

Astoria complex catering hall

34-38 38th street 4th floor penthouse
New York,

Aunt Viv's Kitchen

800 Stafford Ave
Staten Island, NY

Avi Glatt

807 Avenue U
Brooklyn, NY

Back For Seconds Catering

25 High Street
Somerset, NJ

Baco Dumbo | Event Gallery

71 Jay Street
Brooklyn, NY
Cedarhurst Zip Codes

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Cedarhurst.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Caterer
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money