-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Fishers Cake Decorators

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Cake Decorators to Avoid

29

Top Rated Cake Decorators

19

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 455 reviews for
Fishers Cake Decorators from people just like you.

A
"Food is very good, service is friendly and helpful. The line can get long at times, but it's worth the wait. The prices are reasonable. The
" is well organized and decorated with art which is for sale. It is a very popular place.

-Dru O.

A
"I did have to call in twice to make sure I was able to order but when I called in the second time, she told me I was next to call since I wanted the order for Friday" and she just finished her Thursday customer orders. I think her name was
, their cake decorator. Picked them up early in the morning and was told they were excellent. Will definitely use them again! Thank you for taking the task of baking from me :)

-JENNIFER R.

+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Fishers

Cake decorating

Ordering a custom cake for a special occasion is a big job, whether it’s a birthday cake or wedding cake. Refer to this guide page for information on cake types, costs and tips for ordering.

How to plan a graduation party
Special Events, Cake Decorating

Here's how to ensure you have sweet treats for your kid's graduation party

Personalize a special cake by topping it with something that reflects the guest or guests of honor, such as this shell for an ocean-loving couple's wedding cake. (Photo courtesy of Angie's List member Rocio Q. of East Lansing, Mich.)
Cake Decorating

Planning a cake for a wedding, engagement, shower, birthday, anniversary or other special event? The right topper can set the tone. Choose one that reflects the personality of the guest, or guests, of honor.

Your cake can look like a professional piece with practice and some tips from the pros. (Photo courtesy of Angie’s List member Colleen F. of Chicago)
Cake Decorating

Cakes go with many of life’s celebrations, such as birthdays, reunions, successful events, weddings and more. Here are some cake decorating ideas to reflect the spirit and theme of your party.

Angie's List
Cake Decorating

Cake decorating is a popular art form. Edible masterpieces can be created using a wide variety of techniques. Complex cake decorating ideas may take time and practice to master but the basics are easy for beginners.

Cake Decorating reviews in Fishers

A

Rating
My son and I worked with the wedding cake specialist at
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
. We explained that we wanted an atypical cake: one tier only. I had a picture of a bridal bouquet that we were ordering from the florist and asked if
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
could duplicate the design with buttercream frosting roses, white ones with a few pink ones intermixed, on the top of the cake. She said they could, and we ordered the cake, two layers (one white, one chocolate) with white icing and the icing roses covering the top of the cake, which would serve 45. On the wedding day, the cake arrived right on time, delivered by a member of the family that has owned the bakery for more than a century. He thought the cake was beautiful, and it was. Actually, it was spectacular. A number of guests took pictures of it before it was cut. And every piece had roses on it! Everyone said it was delicious and asked where it had come from. I will never buy a cake again from anyone but
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
.
- Margaret Z.
A

Rating
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
took a picture I found online and my sketches and created a really awesome graduation cake for my son. It contained everything he did in high school (archery, photography), his high school logo and the logo of the college he will be attending. It had a highway leading between the two and my favorite a camera with his picture in the lens. It was an intricate cake that looked great and tasted great.
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
did a great job of wrapping up his high school experience into a cake. He was very happy with it and so was I. Not only was I happy with the outcome, but very happy with the process too;
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
asked questions and was very engaged during the process. Totally worth the drive to Harleyville for this amazing cake.
- Shonda M.
A

Rating
ANYONE who wants an absolutely delicious, out-of-this world cake for your wedding reception needs to go to
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
! EVERYONE at my daughter's reception RAVED about the cake and the cream puffs
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
made. They were trying to figure out how to get more slices- thank goodness they didn't get the top
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
, or my daughter and son-in-law wouldn't have anything to celebrate their first anniversary- LOL!
My daughter and son-in-law met with
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
to taste the cake- they immediately ordered the cake THAT SAME DAY! As my daughter said "Mom, there was no discussion or hesitation about ordering from
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
- her cake is FANTASTIC!"
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
was very easy to work with- not the pushy, in-your-face, "I've been doing this for years" type of person that we encountered at a bridal show.
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
will do whatever you want- you can bring in a picture, or she will ask you questions about what type of cake you are looking for. She was at the reception making sure the cake was placed correctly on the stand and also in the back making sure it was cut correctly. She even told us how to preserve it for their first wedding anniversary!
Then there were the cream puffs- WOW! Also melt-in-your-mouth delicious! Everyone wanted extras of those too!
I will definitely use
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
again! I recommend anyone needing a cake for a special event call
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
to make it- she will NOT disappoint! You will just have to exercise restraint so you don't eat the entire cake!


- Janice S.
D

Rating
EVERY one of the 5 was LOUSY! We had a bakery in GA that makes
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
cupcakes and these didn't even compare. I expect the cake part to be larger than the average
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
. The
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
was hard and stale. We ordered 2 - A Red Velvet
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
cupcakes (one for the birthday girl) - and you know the 'muffin top' part had evidently baked over to another
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
top and they LITERALLY just tore the two cupcakes apart, iced them and sold them. Horrible, horrible birthday
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
. It was SO BAD the restaurant would not even serve them out of the box. The manager said the horrible looking cupcakes would reflect poorly to other customers in their restaurant even if we brought them. don't ORDER their cupcakes - trust me, you won't know they are bad until they are served and by that time - it's too late.
- Modesta F C.
A

Rating
I asked for a 2 tier cake...top
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
chocolate and bottom
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
white, both with raspberry filling and buttercream frosting. Both layers were incredibly moist and delicious. The presentation was exactly what I wanted and the price was unbeatable! Had I gone to any of the chain bakeries (Walmart,
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
's, etc.) this cake would have easily cost me over $100 and it definitely wouldn't have been as delicious!


- Amanda C.
A

Rating
I had a good experience with them. It was easy. The cake was good and delicious. It was moist. They were all professional. It's a small place, so it wasn't intimidating. They were personable.
- Amber S.
A

Rating
I received her name from a friend who had a cake done previously by her. I was told she is new to the industry but because she does the cakes from home and is still trying to establish herself, she provides very specialized attention and service for a below
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
price. I give it only a short time before she is capable of charging almost double what she is currently! The Superhero cake she did for my friend was 3 tiers and had the Incredible Hulk's fist punching through the top! It was outrageous! She is a very friendly and courteous lady whom was always available when I called. I highly recommend her!
- Keith E.
A

Rating
MMMMMMmmmm
My favorites here:
Tres Leches Cake - I've tried to copy it by making it myself at home but cant come close
Guava Cheese Pastries!!!
All the other flavor pastries
Love their hot and cold coffee!
Fishers Cake Decorators Provider Name Locked
!
All their food is absolutely delicious. The wait time for the line then too receive your food may be long, so make sure you aren't in a rush when you come here and apart from the forgotten drink orders once or twice this place is awesome.
- Jennifer W.

Cake Decorators in Fishers, IN

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

1 Stop Birthday Shop & Sweet Treats

117 South 1st Street
Zionsville

A Peace of Cake Party & Event Services

5640 Massachusetts Ave
Indianapolis

A Piece of Cake

1275 W MAIN ST
Greenwood

Angela's Treasured Memories

135 Pineview Drive
Carmel

B.A. Sweets

10215 Noble Ct
Indianapolis

Brenda's Cakes & Catering

6313 Rockville Rd
Indianapolis

Cakes by Cathy Inc

7351 E 700 N
Needham

CAKES BY NAN

6960 ORINOCO AVE.
Indianapolis

Classic Cakes

1752 E 116th St
Carmel

CLASSIC CONFECTIONS

7612 HOME DR
Fishers

Costco

9010 Michigan Rd
Indianapolis

Delilah's Desserts

918 Lafayette St.
Anderson

DJ Jammin Jay

855 Laurens Lane

Encore Desserts & More

11852 Allisonville Rd
Fishers

Euphoria

7107 Williams Creek Dr
Indianapolis

Gee's Photography & Graphic Designs

5367 E. Culver St
Indianapolis

Grafton Peek Inc

280 W Main St
Greenwood

HEAVENLY SWEETS CAKES

610 Hannibal St
Noblesville

Icing Academy

3100 Meridian Parke Dr, Suite N Box 250
Greenwood

Indy Cakes

73 E Epler Ave
Indianapolis

Kim’s Kake Kreations

5452 Madison Ave
Indianapolis

Le Dolce Vita Patisserie

55 East Oak St
Zionsville

Marias Bakery

5001 W Bay Ct
Plainfield

MARSH SUPERMARKET

5624 GEORGETOWN RD
Indianapolis

MARSH SUPERMARKET & PHARMACY

6965 W 38TH ST
Indianapolis

MARSH SUPERMARKET - BAKERY

2140 E 116TH ST
Carmel

MARY JANE LAMB

2835 S 1200 E
Zionsville

MEIJER

1425 W CARMEL DR
Carmel

Meijer Pharmacy

17000 Mercantile Blvd
Noblesville

O' For Cake's Sake

Eagle Glen subdivision
Greenwood

PAT-A-CAKES & COOKIES TOO

5649 PEBBLE VLG LN
Noblesville

Sam's Club

7235 E 96Th St
Indianapolis

Simple Taste Inc

979 Keystone Way
Carmel

Southboy Cakes & Catering

9106 Harrison Run Pl
Indianapolis

SugarBean Cupcakes LLC

129 south peru st
Cicero

SWEET SEDUCTIONS

10965 E CTY RD 700 S
Camby

Sweet Tooth Bakery

1727 Southview Dr
Indianapolis

Target

4850 E Southport Rd
Indianapolis

TAYLOR'S BAKERY

6216 N ALLISONVILLE RD
Indianapolis

Taylor's Bakery

8395 East 116th St
Fishers

The Cakehole

2625 N Meridian St
Indianapolis

THE FLYING CUPCAKE

5617 N ILLINOIS ST
Indianapolis

The Sweet Life

11009 Allisonville Rd
Fishers

Walmart

9500 E US Hwy 36
Avon

WEDDING CAKES BY CARLENE

3205 WESTFIELD RD.
Noblesville

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Fishers.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Cake Decorator
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money