Fishers Cake Decorator

in Fishers, IN

47
Cake Decorator are
in Fishers

20
Cake Decorator in Fishers
are top rated

F
Rated by
Linda C.
"This was THE worst experience ever. We ordered a grand marnier cake which was said to have orange undertones. We also requested (in person as she wrote this down): NO fondant NO almond" flavoring Buttercream icing on the top and in the middle of the cake Roses on the top and asked her to make it look nice for a 75 year old woman’s birthday A picture strip around the side of the cake This is what we received: A bland, extremely dense dry cake Fondant on the entire cake--no icing Almond flavoring NO buttercream icing to be found anywhere No decorations except for one black decoration on top—no roses or other decorations at all The picture strip around the side of the cake We cut and served the cake and almost no one finished their cake. No one wanted to take the other half of the cake home and we will be throwing it out. Even the children did not want the cake. It was so dry and tasteless and add to that the almond flavored fondant, which was thick and chewy, it was disgusting. After writing to May she refused to acknowledge any wrongdoing and refused any type of a refund. We will never do business here again. Buyer beware.
A
Rated by
Kathryn O.
"The interaction was great from the start.
, the manager, took the time to find out what I wanted, gave some suggestions, provided her input, and really helped" to make the cake exactly what we were looking for. As an example, I sent her a photo of the beading on my dress and they were able to replicate that design on the cake. All of the guests LOVED the flavor of the cake and remarked on how beautiful it was. The delivery was prompt. There were no hiccups whatsoever. I highly recommend them!
A
Rated by
Diane K.
"I needed a small thank you gift for a bunch of different people. Custom decorated cookies were the perfect answer. I gave Barb the number of people and their professions.
" made the most beautiful cookies with sayings appropriate to each person on the list. The cookies were ready on time, looked beautiful, traveled well, and were delicious. I have used
for a couple of years but just never got around to writing a review. In the past they have provided custom designed cookies for grad parties, holiday parties, and other special events. They once made me a "Pink Lemonade" cake for a birthday. The top was covered (covered!) with baby pink seafoam frosting roses. The cake was light and delicate, not too sweet, with a lemony t***. And there were no leftovers.

Fishers Cake Decorating Articles

Cake Decorating reviews in Fishers

A

Rating
It was amazing. They made the cake and delivered it to a big party we had for my birthday. It looked amazing and tasted even better. We are already planning to get them to make another one for another birthday coming up in a few weeks.
- Justin O.
A

Rating
The transaction was done via email and over the phone. The cake looked exactly as I wanted it to look. It tasted awesome and everyone loved it. I will continue to use this cake company as long as I live in the area.
- Julia B.
A

Rating
This,is by far is the best place to buy cakes and pastries! Bought a cake
for my mother's special birthday and of course it was delicious! Very
reminiscent of years ago when we lived close by the bakery. We ended up
buying challahs and yeah Grandma Rolls They are still as good as ever.
The cake is the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- MARILYN M.
A

Rating
On ordering the cake, the people were extremely nice and very helpful. The cake was made on time, was a little bit pricey, but
Fishers Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked
rave reviews from our family. Well worth the wait and the price!
- Mary K.
A

Rating
Dolce is a clean, friendly bakery that has delicious treats. Whatever you choose will be awesome. Our favorites are the cookies with icing and the banana chocolate chip bread. I think it is a bit pricy, but it doesn't keep us from coming back!
- Michael C.
N

Rating
Three 1/2 weeks before graduation I contacted the bakery via the website email, but didn't receive a response. Two days later I contacted her via facebook. She answered straight away to say she'd be happy to do the cakes, and she never reads her email (though on the website it's the only way to contact her). Within 24 hours she messaged me some possible designs. I advised her I loved one, but would like to consider other possibilities for the second cake. I contacted her 5 times over the next 10 days, including asking a mutual friend to text her on my behalf, and never heard back from her. Three days before the party I had no choice but to use a chain bakery, as the individual bakers in our small town needed more time to fit my order in with the others they'd already taken. In the end our two graduates had 2-dimensional, run-of-the-mill cakes that were acceptable, but not the surprise I wanted to celebrate their accomplishments. Very disappointed and I still haven't heard back from the bakery!
- kim B.
C

Rating
The bakery which had been friendly and inviting in the past had changed considerably. The walls were painted black and a sign "By Appointment Only" hung on the door. I went in the door anyway and was rudely approached by the person working there. My husband and I had ordered cakes in the past with less than a weeks notice without a problem. When I asked to order a cake the person told me in a very arrogant way that this was a custom cake shop and they require several weeks notice for a cake. Very sad that this once wonderful little bakery had changed so much.
- Rui C.
110% Guaranteed Money Back

We think we're the best, and we can prove it.

Try an annual plan and if you want to cancel in your first year, we'll refund you 110%

Annual Plans Only

All Cake Decorator in Fishers, IN

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

1 Stop Birthday Shop & Sweet Treats

117 South 1st Street
Zionsville, IN

A PEACE OF CAKE PARTY & EVENT SERVICES

5640 Massachusetts Ave
Indianapolis, IN

A Piece of Cake

1275 W MAIN ST
Greenwood, IN

Angela's Treasured Memories

135 Pineview Drive
Carmel, IN

B.A. Sweets

10215 Noble Ct
Indianapolis, IN

Brenda's Cakes & Catering

6313 Rockville Rd
Indianapolis, IN

Cakes by Cathy Inc

7351 E 700 N
Needham, IN

CAKES BY NAN

6960 ORINOCO AVE.
Indianapolis, IN

Classic Cakes

1752 E 116th St
Carmel, IN

CLASSIC CONFECTIONS

7612 HOME DR
Fishers, IN

Cooking Greek

12955 Old Meridian St
Carmel, IN

Costco

9010 Michigan Rd
Indianapolis, IN

DJ Jammin Jay

855 Laurens Lane
San Antonio, TX

Encore Desserts & More

11852 Allisonville Rd
Fishers, IN

Euphoria

7107 Williams Creek Dr
Indianapolis, IN

Gee's Photography & Graphic Designs

5367 E. Culver St
Indianapolis, IN

Grafton Peek Inc

280 W Main St
Greenwood, IN

HEAVENLY SWEETS CAKES

610 Hannibal St
Noblesville, IN

Icing Academy

3100 Meridian Parke Dr, Suite N Box 250
Greenwood, IN

Indy Cakes

73 E Epler Ave
Indianapolis, IN

Kim’s Kake Kreations

5452 Madison Ave
Indianapolis, IN

Le Dolce Vita Patisserie

55 East Oak St
Zionsville, IN

Marias Bakery

5001 W Bay Ct
Plainfield, IN

MARSH SUPERMARKET

5624 GEORGETOWN RD
Indianapolis, IN

MARSH SUPERMARKET & PHARMACY

6965 W 38TH ST
Indianapolis, IN

MARSH SUPERMARKET - BAKERY

2140 E 116TH ST
Carmel, IN

MARY JANE LAMB

2835 S 1200 E
Zionsville, IN

MEIJER

1425 W CARMEL DR
Carmel, IN

Meijer Pharmacy

17000 Mercantile Blvd
Noblesville, IN

Nana's Sweets & Treats

Greenfield, IN

O' For Cake's Sake

Eagle Glen subdivision
Greenwood, IN

PAT-A-CAKES & COOKIES TOO

5649 PEBBLE VLG LN
Noblesville, IN

Sam's Club

7235 E 96Th St
Indianapolis, IN

Southboy Cakes & Catering

9106 Harrison Run Pl
Indianapolis, IN

SugarBean Cupcakes LLC

129 south peru st
Cicero, IN

SWEET SEDUCTIONS

10965 E CTY RD 700 S
Camby, IN

Sweet Tooth Bakery

1727 Southview Dr
Indianapolis, IN

Target

4850 E Southport Rd
Indianapolis, IN

TAYLOR'S BAKERY

6216 N ALLISONVILLE RD
Indianapolis, IN

Taylor's Bakery

8395 East 116th St
Fishers, IN

The Cakehole

2625 N Meridian St
Indianapolis, IN

THE FLYING CUPCAKE

5617 N ILLINOIS ST
Indianapolis, IN

The Sweet Life

11009 Allisonville Rd
Fishers, IN

Walmart

9500 E US Hwy 36
Avon, IN

WEDDING CAKES BY CARLENE

3205 WESTFIELD RD.
Noblesville, IN

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Fishers.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Cake Decorator
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money