-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Carthage Tire Shops

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Tire Shops to Avoid

31

Top Rated Tire Shops

10

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Only 24% of Carthage Tire Shops are reliable
  • Tardiness is the #1 complaint against Carthage Tire Shops
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 393 reviews for
Carthage Tire Shops from people just like you.

A
"The manager stayed on top of his parts supplier to make sure the repair work wasn't delayed. The mechanic tested parts of the air conditioning system before" replacing them, which saved about $600 vs, their original estimate. When is the last time you spent $600 less on car repairs than you expected?

-JOHN A.

A
"We have taken both of our cars to Hillside for many years. They've always done good work and we've never felt ripped off or taken advantage of. This visit" resulted from sudden rough idling after hitting a bump. We dropped off the car Sunday night. It was fixed the next day and runs quieter now with no problems.

-William B.

+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Carthage

Tires

Tires not only transfer the engine’s horsepower directly to the road, their grip ensures your car handles, turns and brakes safely. Overlooking tire maintenance can lead to poor fuel economy, poor handling and possibly hazardous driving conditions.

snowy house
Garage Doors, Roofing, Holiday Decorating, Gutter Cleaning, Pest Control/Exterminating, Lawn & Yard Work, Carpet Cleaning, Chimney Sweep, Fireplaces, Electrical, Handymen, Housecleaning, Animal & House Sitting, Cabinet Refacing/Restoration, Lighting, Wallpapering, Plumbing, Heating & A/C, Auto Service, Auto Tires, Allergy & Immunology

It's the time of year when the winter weather can take a toll. Follow this winter maintenance checklist to protect your home, your car and your health.

If you live in an area with frequent snowfall, it's wise to make sure that your tires have enough traction depth for slippery conditions. (Photo by Fred Patton).
Auto Tires

The special tread design of snow tires, also known as winter tires, allows drivers to move easily through snow and ice, say tire experts on Angie’s List.

Causes of tire dry rot.
Classic cars, Auto Tires

Mechanics say you shouldn't drive with tires that have dry rot. Learn how you can repair tire dry rot and what steps you can take prevent it.

Many new cars are not equipped with spare tires, forcing their owners to find alternatives. (Photo courtesy of Marc Yount's Tire Pros in Evans, Ga.)
Auto Tires

In an effort to increase fuel efficiency, many manufacturers are eliminating the car spare tire from new vehicles. How much does it cost to add a spare tire?

Tire Buying And Repair reviews in Carthage

A

Rating
My car battery and the remote starter they installed needed to be re-programmed. They did it free of charge in a quick & efficient manner. The customer service is excellent.
- Joseph H B.
A

Rating
AMAZING. This company has been in business for 40 years and it has been family owned the whole time for people wanting to stay local. They drove me to work for free after I dropped my car off , and they even stayed after hours so I could get my car after work. They did a great job and I felt like the job was executed perfectly. I purchased a big deal to get my oil changed so the price felt right. However, I did see that they normally charge $94 an hour for labor. Which I think is high but most businesses locally owned are a little higher. Will be going back, very friendly family and staff.
- Jordan S.
F

Rating
When I arrived, I was told I could not have the tires put on the front of my front wheel drive car. They are required to place them on the back. I agreed to have my tire alignment checked. Forty-five minutes after they took my car into the shop area, I was told he had looked everywhere and he could not find any of the four tires I had been told were in stock. I was told they had tires for my car but they were more expensive. I agreed to purchase two of them. I explained I no longer had time for an alignment. He stated he was sorry for the delay and they would just put the two tires on the front of the vehicle, which they did. It was going to cost me $50.00 to put the new tires on the back and put the back tires on the front. I was charged $65.96 to put the new tires on the front. When I left NTB, I noticed my car had a shimmy. It was especially noticeable at highway speed. My husband took my vehicle to a local mechanic to have it checked. He was told the new tires were not balanced when they were put on my car. I have not had any shimmy since the mechanic balanced the tires.
- Jacque J.
A

Rating
This seems to be a well run family business that cares about customer service. All around nice, thoughtful people, thorough in their communication. They all strived to do a good job and insure that we were satisfied. I would recommend to friends or family and would go back for any of these services.
They worked with us on the price and gave us a break where they could. I thought the repair work was very reasonably priced and the autobody work prices seemed to be comparable to work we've had done at other places.
The customer service couldn't be beat.
- Denise S.
A

Rating
Bought tires from this company a year ago +- One lost air. Took it in and they fixed for free. Manager
Carthage Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
extremely personable. Made the experience very pleasant rather than irritating.
- Susan L.
B

Rating
I have been going to this service center back in the days when it was Tire Center but also managed by
Carthage Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
. Service has been great and I stayed when it became a Firestone store, as
Carthage Tire Shops Provider Name Locked
was the manager.
- Joseph S.
A

Rating
He's absolutely someone you can trust. They did a great job. We buy all our tires there. They have the best tires at the best prices. No one's close. I would absolutely recommend them to others.
- Robert E.
A

Rating
I had taken the car just for air (5 service stations had broken pumps) with the intent to set up an appt. Instead they checked all the tires (others were low) discovered the problem. They offered me the choice of attempting to fix then, but a part could break leaving me without a car. They ordered the part ultimately not needed when I returned in 2 days. All is well. I have used them many times and have always been pleased. They don't nickel and dime. They are knowledgable and do good work.
- Barbara H.

All Tire Shops in Carthage, IN

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

BestOne Tire & Service

18 S 6th Street
Vincennes

Big O Tires

203 SE 3rd St
Washington

BUSSARD AUTOMOTIVE & PRFRMNC

1209 E SMITH ST
Warsaw

Button Motors Inc

1220 E Boulevard
Kokomo

D & S Auto Repair

3021 S Hwy-31

Dickmeyer Automotive

106 E Columbia St
South Whitley

Eriks Chevrolet

1800 Us Hwy 31 Byp S
Kokomo

HALL'S AUTO RECYCLERS INC

2265 W US HIGHWAY 6
Ligonier

Hiday Motors Inc

633 N Main St
Bluffton

HOOSIER FOREIGN AUTO SVC

7892 SCHUMAN RD
Brookville

Indy Tire

1718 E Havens St
Kokomo

Ken's Auto Repair & Tire Center

210 East George St
Batesville

Kent's Automotive Service Team

11121 State Rd 32 E
Noblesville

Kirtlan Automotive

750 South Cass St
Wabash

Knapp Tire Co Inc

119 S Bill St
Francesville

Line-X Of Indy

8448 Moller Rd
Indianapolis

Madison Auto Service LLC

605 Clifty Dr
Madison

Marks Service Center

6500 W Kilgore Ave
Yorktown

Matthews Buick GMC

1101 N Baldwin Ave
Marion

MERRITT'S TRUCK & AUTO REPAIR

1025 Touby Pike
Kokomo

Midas Auto Svc Experts

1901 North Broadway
Muncie

MILLENNIUM LINING & ACCESSORIES

905 N RACEWAY RD
Indianapolis

Monteith Tire - Middlebury

132 Orpha Dr
Middlebury

Penske Honda

PO Box 40319
Indianapolis

Power Automotive

104 S Baum St
Fremont

Ray's Automotive Center

3060 CENTRAL AVE
Columbus

Reber's Repair

62 N Lafontaine St
Huntington

SCHROEDER SALES & SERVICE, INC.

1001 W PARK DR
Huntington

Scott County Tire

1530 N Gardner St
Scottsburg

Scott's Auto Body

1310 E Division St
Demotte

Smith Tire Service

2335 N Detroit St
Warsaw

Snider's Service Center

3749 S. Western Ave.
Marion

STOOPS AUTOMOTIVE GROUP

4055 W CLARA LN
Muncie

Tom Tepe Autocenter

426 E Indian Trl
Milan

Toney Oil Co

396 S Main St
Marengo

Towne View Auto Clinic Inc

1465 State Rd 252
Martinsville

WIDENER AUTOMOTIVE INC

704 E PEARL ST
Batesville

York Chevrolet Buick GMC Truck

1501 Indianapolis Rd
Greencastle

Zurcher Tire Of Marion

1801 S Western Ave
Marion
Carthage Zip Codes

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Carthage.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Discount Tires
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money