-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Payson Auto Repair

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Auto Repair to Avoid

27

Top Rated Auto Repair

41

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 429 reviews for
Payson Auto Repair from people just like you.

A
"
provided outstanding, will-use-him-again service. He was particularly good at working with our insurance company, State Farm, on our claim" involving damage our Flex had sustained to one of its front wheels. For instance, he gave us a great heads up about keeping an eye out for a possible bearing issue, which did, in fact, materialize a few days after I'd gotten my car back. Dealing with insurance companies on the supplemental stuff is no fun for anyone, but
made the situation better by making us feel taken care of throughout the process. I even misdiagnosed yet another thing wrong with my car a couple weeks later, at which point
was quick to invite me to bring it back in for him to test drive and run some diagnostics. It all turned out to be something unrelated and I felt a little foolish, but
did not really even laugh at me and gave us some sound advice about whether to have it (a transmission issue) addressed. All in all,
did great work and provided excellent customer service.

-Melanie D.

A
"The service was completed very quickly and looks great. They dropped me off at Enterprise and I enjoyed conversing with them at their shop. They have some really" high quality cars in the shop that they have repaired or are in the process of repairing. I would not hesitate to use them again. I do recommend calling prior to showing up at the shop. I missed the guy who runs the shop one day as he had to run to the bank. He was the only one doing quotes. It was no big deal. My truck was repaired and returned to me in under a week!

-Jarrod C.

+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Payson

Auto Repair reviews in Payson

A

Rating
I took my car to them for an estimate. It was a fair price for all the damage. Insurance paid the costs. My car had gouges on the rear bumper and was deeply scraped down the passenger side doors as well as the front pushed in. They had to replace the 2 passenger side doors as well as the front bumper. The rear bumper and hood was repairable. My biggest concern was the paint. On Lexus' the paint has a metallic finish. I was worried the the re paint wouldn't match the rest of the car.
When I saw the results of their work I was floored. It was perfect. All dents and scratches were gone and the paint was a perfect match to the rest of the car. There is no way to tell the car was in an accident.
They were great to work with. Friendly and professional. The inside of the car was cleaner than it ever was even though nothing was affected by the accident. They just decided to clean it up for delivery. It looked brand new like it did the day I picked it up from the Lexus dealer.
I couldn't be more pleased.
- ronald R.
F

Rating
They drove our vehicle 248 miles in the 22 days that they had it. Now our service engine light is on and they will not fix it. On Friday they told us it was ready and the trim was still messed up, then yesterday it still was not ready, and today they will not fix our engine light that is on due to them driving it, we wrote down the mileage before we dropped it off for insurance. They continued to push everything off on a woman, and I did not appreciate that at all. DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY!!! THE MANAGERS NAME WAS
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
AND THE OWNER.
- Marcus C.
A

Rating
I went with my son to to get an estimate to repair some scratches on his new car. The owner asked my son a few questions and recommend a very
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
fix. He said is would look good , not perfect but since he was a new driver it was what he would recommend. The other estimates were between $400 - 700 dollars. There was minimal cost associated with the buffing and touch up and he did it on the spot. I so appreciated his honest advice and willingness to do what was best for his customer, not what profited him the most. It was an incredible act of integrity that my son got to experience on his first venture in to the car repair world. I am a customer for life and would recommend them to anyone.

- Mary R.
A

Rating
Every aspect of working with
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
was outstanding. They provided an estimate in less than an hour. Because of my travel plans, my work was scheduled in a timely manner that was convenient for me. The repair work performed was excellent. I have a pearl coat paint on my car, and they matched it perfectly. They coordinated with the car rental company to have the rental delivered to and picked up at the repair shop. I would definitely use
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
again if the need arises.
- David B.
F

Rating
This was a nightmare in every respect. This used to be a body shop with a good reputation but it has lost its quality workmen. The 10 day work turned into 1 month. And the car came back damaged in multiple places -- scratched paint, dented doors, missing interior pieces, paint spray on trim, misaligned parts, improperly replaced parts, etc. They simply didn't respect my car. I had to spend more than $1000 at another body shop to have the work fixed and there's no telling what damage was done that will only become apparent some time in the future.



- Malcolm W.
A

Rating
I was the victim of a minor traffic accident in which the driver's side of the vehicle was dented and scratched. The windows also would not work as a result of the accident. My insurance company recommended
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
Collision, and I gave them a call. I was able to get an appointment within a few days, at which time
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
assessed the damage and set up a time for me to drop off my car. My insurance company had arranged with a local car rental company to meet me at
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
's location. I took my car to
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
and gave them my e-mail address. They contacted me within a couple of days about the progress of their work and kept me informed for the week that it took the work to be completed. I got my car back two days sooner than planned. The repair work looked quite nice, and
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
took the time to clean the car for me. They also arranged for the return of the rental car, which spared me some time and effort. Overall, my experience with
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
was a good one, and I would gladly use their service in the future.
- Vicki U.
D

Rating
Terrible experience. Asked to sign a form that had not yet been completed attesting to preexisting damage on the car. The woman at the desk acted as if I was being unreasonable because I wanted them to look at the car and complete the form before I signed it.
We were quoted 4 days to complete the work, but soon after we dropped of the car, we received a text telling us that the work would be complete in 9 days.
Repairs had several defects including the
Payson Auto Repair Provider Name Locked
lid being severely misaligned, paint defects and missing/misaligned emblems.
Returned the car for correction. Work ended up OK but far from perfect and don't trust the shop to do any further work. We never heard the words, "we're sorry" despite being inconvenienced.
Staff was nice enough, but the body work was just up to snuff.
- Neal R.
F

Rating
It took me a month for them to get my vehicle complete so I could take it home. They kept giving excuses why it was not ready, Needed parts, hard to find parts because it is a 2002 vehicle. They also told me that they could not find a replacement running board. Guess what, when we finally got the vehicle, there was a new running board on it. I called several times to check on the progress of the repairs and always the same answer, NOT READY. I called late on a Thursday afternoon to check on the progress, This about a month after they got the vehicle, and was told that all they had to do was a quality check and that it should not be more than a day. I finally called back on Monday and they said I could get the vehicle. My wife and I went there to pick up the car. I found that lights on the running board were not working and scratches on the plate around the headlights still had scratches on it. The manager told me that I rushed their quality control and they had 3 days to to it. I did not look under the hood, bad mistake, Now I find that they are panels missing and parts are not tight. This is one place I would NEVER take another vehicle to have repaired if they were the only place in Houston. They tell stories and do very bad work.
I have never treated so bad by a business in my life. The manager is the person I dealt with and he gets an 'F' for customer service. If you decide to take your car to be repaired there, make sure you take before and after pictures for your safety.
The cost of repairs were bore by Royal car wash due the damage they caused.
- Milton F. K.

Auto Repair in Payson, AZ

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

Action Automotive & Towing LLC

5720 Vernon St.
Miami

AE Recovery and Towing

5723 N 31st Dr
Phoenix

ALL MODELS AUTO BODY & REPAIR

493 ROUND VALLEY RD
Payson

ALL TOWING

HIGHWAY 87 RYE
Payson

Allstate Transmission And Auto Repair

5154 N 27th Ave Ste 103
Phoenix

ALOHA TOWING

359 EMERALD WY
Payson

American Soda Blasters

PO Box 72334
Phoenix

Arizona Auto -N- Towing

5959 S US Hwy 191
Safford

Auto Transporters Online

25108 Marguerite PKWY, Ste A-353

AUTO ZONE

109 E STATE HIGHWAY 260
Payson

AutoPartsNerd.com

(no pick-up)

BIG O TIRES

901 S BEELINE HWY
Payson

Big O Tires

1781 E Deuce of Clubs
Show Low

Big O Tires

2185 W Us Hwy 70
Thatcher

Big O Tires LLC

2469 N Walgreen St
Flagstaff

BRYDEN'S AUTO SVC INC

2730 E McDowell Road
Phoenix

Budget TV Inc

9641 Menaul Blvd NE

Car Repair of Scottsdale

2918 N SCOTTSDALE RD
Phoenix

CARiD.com

1 Corporate Dr

CARL'S TOWING

204 N TONTO ST
Payson

CARQUEST AUTO PARTS

805 S BEELINE HWY
Payson

CARSTAR Auto Body Repair Experts

3775 E Huntington Dr
Flagstaff

CHECKER AUTO PARTS

601 N BEELINE HWY
Payson

CHON'S PAINT & BODY SHOP

5489 S HIGHWAY 92
Sierra Vista

Combs Auto Repair of N Scottsdale

7421 E Adobe Dr
Scottsdale

Desert Automotive

4119 E Anderson St
Sierra Vista

Discount Tire Co

1230 South Milton Rd
Flagstaff

Elias Auto Parts

101 Frontage Rd
Pearce

EXCLUSIVE REFINISHING

201 N TONTO ST
Payson

Flagstaff Auto Glass Window & Tint

2360 E Huntington Dr
Flagstaff

FLETCHER TIRE

104 W AIRPORT RD
Payson

Floyd's Custom Cars and Transmissions

717 South Hacienda Dr.
Tempe

FUTURE TIRE

2416 NAVAJO BLVD
Holbrook

FUTURE TIRE INC

1384 E WHITE MOUNTAIN BLVD
Pinetop

Gateway Body Shop

9901 W Papago Fwy
Avondale

Geek Squad - Best Buy

2200 EL MERCADO LOOP
Sierra Vista

LA FORGE TOWING

909 N CHENNAULT PKWY
Payson

LATHAM'S COLLISION INC

2360 E HUNTINGTON DR
Flagstaff

Meineke Car Care Center

1830 E Route 66
Flagstaff

Montway Auto Transport

4740 N Cumberland Ave

Move My Automobile

5573 Bryan Drive

NATIONWIDE TRANSMISSIONS LLC

2710 E ROUTE 66
Flagstaff

Oil Can Henry's

1017 E Fry Blvd
Sierra Vista

PAYSON AUTO BODY

1017 S STOVER RD
Payson

Petits Auto Care Inc

500 Bartow Dr
Sierra Vista

Phoenix Towing Service

P.O Box 87946
Phoenix

RANDY'S DOWNTOWN GARAGE

302 E ROUTE 66
Flagstaff

Red Rock Auto & Cycle LLC

1630 w state rt 89a
Sedona

Red Rock Collision

2275 Shelby Dr
Sedona

Redrock Precision Motors

1425 W Hwy 89A
Sedona

Reliable Carriers Inc

41555 Koppernick Rd

Rojas Body Shop

552 N Morley Ave
Nogales

Sierra Service Center

296 E Fry Blvd
Sierra Vista

Sounds Good

2103 N Center St
Flagstaff

Steve Coury Buick GMC Allison Workhorse

6101 E Coury Dr
Camp Verde

Storms Automotive

PO Box 1069
Pinetop

SWJ TIRES & ACCESSORIES

1400 N BEELINE HWY
Payson

TERRY MARXEN CHEVROLET

1118 W ROUTE 66
Flagstaff

The Body Shop paint & body LLC

588 Myer Dr
Sierra Vista

The Specialist Inc

600 E Fry Blvd
Sierra Vista

TIRE PEDDLER

HIGHWAY 87 RYE
Payson

Tire Pro Automotive

671 Finnie Flat Rd
Camp Verde

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Payson.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Auto Repair
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money