-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Knee Replacement Surgeons to Avoid

49

Top Rated Knee Replacement Surgeons

30

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 395 reviews for
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons from people just like you.

A
"Dr
was very kind, knowledgeable and helpful. I had gone to my GP complaining of back and leg pain. He referred me to Dr
" due to an MRI I had. Despite the fact that I should have been referred to my original surgeon Dr
helped me. I was suffering from back pain sciatica and leg pain. I first met Dr
over 20 years ago when he operated on my 13 year old sons hip. He saved my son from having to have an artificial hip. I thought of him when I developed two cases of frozen shoulder over the past 2 years. During the second case of frozen shoulder he helped me with a ruptured disc in my back by sending me for an MRI and also referred me to a surgeon I highly recommend Dr

-Dorene E.

D
"After evaluating a couple of doctors, I decided on Dr.
because he had performed so many procedures and was overly confident in his ability" to do a perfect procedure, even speaking of his surgery on his mother. Being in my 40's, this was important to me, knowing I would need surgery again and being active. Afterwards, I was stunned to find that he mis-measured the cut and my leg was just under an inch longer than my other leg. Much to my dismay, he tried to tell my at my first follow-up that it was because of muscle loss. After PT and other consultations, he admitted his mistake and suggested shoe lifts for my other shoe, or possible other follow-up surgery. I am not sure how a practiced surgeon could make such a grievous mistake but now I am paying for it until some day in the future where I will have it redone, since having a perfectly good leg operated on doesn't make a lot of sense. I constantly limp, stand to the side and live with the pain. While anyone can make a mistake, as my husband is a carpenter, I also think that "measure twice, cut once" would have been the thought of the day instead of trying to see how fast a surgery can get done.

-Pamela S.

+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Salt Lake City

Orthopedics: Knees

Some orthopedic doctors specialize in the bones, muscles and tendons of the knee, from treating ACL tears and arthritis to performing knee replacement surgery.

Excess weight puts more pressure on weight-bearing joints, particularly the knees. This can eventually lead to knee replacement. (Photo by The San Antonio Orthopaedic Group)
Orthopedics - Knee & Leg

Does being overweight put you at higher risk of knee replacement surgery? Yes, but a small increase in activity and decrease in weight can make a difference.

As differences between men and women's knees are better understood, effective treatments can be targeted specific to women with knee pain, says Closkey. (Photo by Karen Geswein)
Orthopedics - Knee & Leg

Knee pain is a common problem that interferes with daily activity and women may be at a higher risk. One highly rated provider shares causes and solutions.

Knee Doctor
Chest/Thoracic Surgery, Health Education/Workshops, Lab Services - Drug & Alcohol Testing, Orthopedics - Knee & Leg, Otolaryngology, Primary Care - Osteopathic Medicine, Skin & Body Care - Vein Treatment, Therapy/Respite Camps

An unwelcome sign of aging is alleviated with orthopedic surgery.

Chest/Thoracic Surgery, Health Education/Workshops, Lab Services - Drug & Alcohol Testing, Orthopedics - Knee & Leg, Otolaryngology, Primary Care - Osteopathic Medicine, Skin & Body Care - Vein Treatment, Therapy/Respite Camps

A common joint disorder is fought with a natural compound supplement. But is it enough?

Angie's Answers

?
?
Sounds like you should be pursuing a disability claim.  Also, you could speak to your previous doctor frankly about your concerns.  
Have they made orthotics for your shoes that distribute your weight better? 
?

Whoops - I just realized that you may have been looking for Angie's List information on providers outside your home market. To see information on providers that aren't in your home Angie's List chapter, you can elect to pay a small addditional fee (generally about $15 to $20) to add another city's Angie's List to your existing memember.

 

Learn more about the add-a-city option here.

?
Hello, this is Kyle K from the Member Care Department.

I apologize for any confusion, but your membership has been expired since 07/18/2012. If you would like access to pain doctors in the Midland, TX area you will need to renew your membership. You can renew online at any time by signing in to your old account at www.angieslist.com. Once logged in, you'll be asked to rejoin, and you can just follow the prompt.
 
If you’d prefer to speak with someone over the phone, our Member Care Team would be happy to assist you. They can be reached toll-free at 1-888-944-5478. Don’t forget to check-out our money saving multi-year plans, too.

Thanks for writing! - Kyle K
?
Hello, this is Kyle K from the Member Care Department.

I apologize for my delay. I apologize, but orthopedic surgeons fall under our Orthopedics category which is included in the Health list. Currently, you're enrolled in our Basic membership which only includes access to our Home list.
 
If you'd like to upgrade your membership to the Plus or Premium plan, we'll be happy to assist you with this search. If interested, give us a call at 1.888.944.5478 and we'll take care of this adjustment. Again, I do apologize for any misunderstanding.

Thanks for writing! - Kyle K
?

Hi,

 

This is James W. with Member Care. Thanks for posting your question.

 

It looks like when you signed up online on 8/5/2014, that you accidentally joined our greater Portland chapter instead of our Salem/Corvallis chapter that your zip code falls under. I have transferred your subscription to that chapter, so you will now have access to the correct area.

I hope this information helps! Please let me know if I can assist further. You can respond to this thread or submit a new Answers post. You can also reach us at 1-866-783-2980. We're open weekdays from 8:00 am - 9:00 pm and Saturdays 8:00 am - 5:00 pm ET.

 

Thanks again!

Knee Care reviews in Salt Lake City

F

Rating
The pain had increased over the years and numbness had set in. I went to Dr Companioni and his first reaction was that the numbness did not concern him. I had an MRI done and after that I was in so much pain I could barely walk. I called his office and they told me I could come in that same day as he was on vacation the next week. I got there at 2:30 at my scheduled time and waited for an hour. I found there was blood on the exam table. When the doctor came in, he was not even there for 5 minutes and he said the MRI looked fine. He told me the pain and numbness did not concern him and that in his opinion I needed physical therapy to strengthen the muscles in my legs. When I went to leave the office, I asked for the MRI and they said they did not have it. They said he pulled it up through a site online. I was told he would have the physical MRI when I had this done but the office is now contradicting that. They seem to have no care or concern that I am in extreme pain. I will never go there again.
- Brittany D.
A

Rating
I needed both knees replaced and we went to Dr. VanFlandern because a family friend had an excellent result. My knees were in rough shape and it was less than a month from when I first saw him until surgery was scheduled.

Dr. VanFlandern gave me his number in case I had questions. He called me the night before I entered the hospital to make sure I was all set. He called my wife after surgery and visited me the next morning and every other morning I was there at 5:30AM.

Everything has gone well with the knee replacement and I believe he did an outstanding job. The incisions are very neat and healed rapidly. He is consistently rated one of Boston's "Top Docs" and deserves the title.
- Dana S.
C

Rating
I ended up receiving PRP injections through another provider and I am hoping that after the soreness I will be well. I will not return to Dr.
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
. He IS a nice man but he simply has too many patients to be able to really listen and understand pain levels, etc.
- Kaye B.
A

Rating
Dr.
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
previously performed a total knee replacement for me and he was wonderful. I am very happy with the results and the care I received. This time around, he did arthroscopic surgery on my shoulder and I couldn't be more pleased. The procedure was explained in detail, including pictures from the surgery. All my questions were answered and he worked with me to design a physical therapy plan. Dr.
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
is very practical, explains procedures in easily understandable terms, and offers options to his patients. I feel very confident in recommending him to anyone with knee or shoulder issues! He is very professional, thorough, and inspired confidence in me as a patient. I will continue to seek his advice for orthopedic problems.
- Sheila S.
A

Rating
The surgery was very successful. Now, two months later, my wife is walking again with only occasional support of a cane (which she will not need in the near future), but most importantly, she is walking without pain! What a difference from her condition before the hip replacement. We highly recommend Dr.
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
and his staff.
- DAN F.
C

Rating
II had the surgery in April of 2014 at the Hospital For Special Surgery in NYC. The first two weeks were amazingly easy. I was told to do as much as I could and I did. The beginning of the third week, I started to go downhill. I was told it was tendenitis. Since I have had tendonitis, I was doubtful. I was now on a walker and crutches. I kept getting progressively worse. The crutches were beginning to affect my wrists, arms and shoulders and my right leg which had had a gluteus medius tendon reattached in 2008, was beginning to feel the stress of all the weight being placed on that leg. Dr.
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
told me that the bone was not liking the post and it could take six months. This was very different from the 4 week recovery that I was
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
to believe would be the case. There was no disclosure that it could be anything but perfect. I was told by Dr.
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
that I was not putting enough weight on the leg and that I shouldn't use crutches but a cane. I couldn't. I knew the pain was shocking and intense and kept communicating this, but the xray showed nothing. Finally an mri revealed that there was a fissure in the femur bone. At four months, Dr.
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
told me recovery could take up to a year, but that at six months, if I really couldn't stand it, he could do a revision by entering again, shortening the post and filling the cavity with glue. At that point, I began looking for a second opinion. I left Dr.
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
at 4 months. Cancelled appts and never showed up again. I was never contacted by him or the Hospital for Special Surgery (or rather The Hospital for Special Surgeons), to see how I was or why I had disappeared.
I found Dr. Patrict Meere,whose speciality is revision, at NY
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
's Bone and Joint in NYC. He did an MRI and indicated that there was inflamation around the post and that it looked like it wouldn't heal. He said a proper revision would be a posterior replacement as the position of the post in the anterior surgery angled the post towards the femur. If you are old or slightly overweight, there is the possibility that the minute you put weight on the leg, the post breaks through the femur which it had in my case. He did not recomment entering through the anterior place again as there were nerves that could be permenently damaged and did not recommend glue and a smaller post as the femur was injured and he didn't think glue on live, injured bone tissue was a good idea. He suggested a longer post which bypassed the fissure in the femur giving it time to heal and NO GLUE.
I had the surgery with Dr. Meere in October of 2014. In three weeks I was walking with a cane. In six weeks I was back walking without any help. I was contacted by NY Bone and Joint to see how the surgery had gone after two months, and if I had needed any revision or other aid after the surgery. I was very pleased with the follow up of NY Bone and Joine.
I highly advise anyone considering Anterior Hip Surgery to get a second opinion from a Posterior Hip Surgery Surgeon.
Dr. Meere says that he is not recommending it for anyone as he is seeing them fail at six months, 1 1/2 years, etc. He said Dr.
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
surgery was good, but the surgery shouldn't have been recommended for me. By the way, In Dr.
Salt Lake City Knee Replacement Surgeons Provider Name Locked
patient notes, he says that I was told that revision would be a possibility, which was a lie. He never painted anything but blue skies about the surgery and my recovery forecast.
Please be careful before you opt for this anterior surgery. I found only positive comments about it on the web. But six months on crutches is brutal. At 73, it is very h****** the rest of your body. I would have been so much better not risking this kind of outcome and doing the posterior surgery from the very beginning. I wanted a speedy recovery. What I got was complete failure. When Dr. Meere opened me up at six months, the ball and post fell out. There was zero healing. Had I not found Dr. Meere, I would have been in serious trouble. Thanks to Dr. Meere, I am now walking two miles a day with my dog.

- Zoe K.
A

Rating
Very professional, honest. Old school but very educated and knowledgeable. I feel comfortable & confident in his ability to help me with my knees. He is the first doctor that did not just want to rush me into surgery. He was very honest about weight, and go to physical therapy. He treated my condition rather than just operate. Gave supartz injections to help with the pain. Overall very honest, not money hungry, and very capable. The only issue is when he would have to rush into surgery and I had to reschedule, other than that I was very pleased.
- Mark B.
A

Rating
Dr. Torke was very knowledgable of the type of problem I was experiencing with my knee. He was quite pleasant and professional. I was very supportive of the alternative procedures made available to me. A quality medical experience.
- Alan G.

Knee Replacement Surgeons in Salt Lake City

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

A New Day Spa & Salon

3975 south highland dr.

Albano, Dr. Joe

82 S 1100 E
Salt Lake City

Assoc. in Ortho. Surgery: Dr. J. Douglas Burrows

3336 Pioneer Pkwy #102
Salt Lake City

Bacon, William C

1055 N 500 W
Provo

Bean, Dr. Charles P

2121 Robins Dr
Layton

Benjamin Hansen MD

11800 S State St
Draper

Bourne, Dr. Michael H

1160 E 3900 S
Salt Lake City

Brady, Dr. John H.

3723 W 12600 S
Riverton

Calton, Dr. Thomas F

4403 Harrison Blvd
Ogden

Calton-Harrison Clinic

4403 Harrison Blvd
Ogden

Center Orthopedic/Rehab Excllnc

3584 W 9000 S
West Jordan

Central Utah Clinic

1055 N 500 W
Provo

Central Utah Clinic PC

700 W 800 N
Orem

Comprehensive Orthopedic Specialists

82 S 1100 E
Salt Lake City

Cooley, Dr. Vernon J.

5848 S Fashion Blvd
Salt Lake City

Davis Orthopedic and Sports Medicine

2132 Robins Dr. #230
Layton

Dean Walker MD

3725 W 4100 S
Salt Lake City

Donald A Schmidt MD

9844 S 1300 E
Sandy

Dr. Brian Mackey

3584 W 9000 S
West Jordan

Dr. Dennis H. Gordon

3336 Pioneer Pkwy
Salt Lake City

Dr. James G. Macintyre

3584 W 9000 S
West Jordan

Dr. Leslie Rassner

82 S 1100 E
Salt Lake City

Dr. Mark Scholl

4888 S Highland Dr.
Salt Lake City

Dr. Matthew H. Lyman

2132 Robins Dr. #230
Layton

Dr. Peter R. Silvero

3336 Pioneer Pkwy #102
Salt Lake City

Dr. Russ Toronto

5662 Cougar Lane
Salt Lake City

Dr. Wade Sessions

3584 W 9000 S
West Jordan

Endurance Orthopedics and Sports Medicine

4888 S Highland Dr.
Salt Lake City

Freedom Healthcare

8899 S 700 E
Sandy

Granger Medical Clinic

3725 W 4100 S
Salt Lake City

HANDI-RAMP INC.

510 North AVE

Hanson, Dr. Tyler

702 E S Temple
Salt Lake City

Harris, Dr. Les

3584 W 9000 S
West Jordan

Hess, Dr. Michael M.

1551 Renaissance Towne Dr
Bountiful

Hofmann, Dr. Aaron A

590 Wakara Way
Salt Lake City

Howe, Dr. David J

82 S 1100 E
Salt Lake City

IHC Sandy Health Care

9500 S 1300 E
Sandy

Intermountain Health Care

4403 Harrison Blvd
Ogden

Intermountain Medical Group

370 9th Ave
Salt Lake City

Intermountain Medical Group

370 E 9th Ave Ste 205
Salt Lake City

Intermountain Sandy Clinic

9500 S 1300th E
Sandy

Jackson, Dr. Jeffrey D.

1160 E 3900 S
Salt Lake City

Jeffrey Smith MD

1067 N 500 W
Provo

Johnston, Dr. Eric C.

1551 Renaissance Towne Dr
Bountiful

Kent Samuelson MD

324 10th Ave Ste 100
Salt Lake City

Kimball, Dr. Gordon R

9844 S 1300 E
Sandy

Lone Peak Orthopedics

9844 S 1300 E
Sandy

Luce Chiropractic & Sports Care

10437 South 1300 West
South Jordan

Mariani, Dr. Marc E.

1160 E 3900 S
Salt Lake City

Momberger, Dr. Nathan

5848 Fashion Blvd
Salt Lake City

Mountain Orthopaedics Llc

1551 S Renaissance Towne Dr
Bountiful

Mountain Orthopedics

1551 Renaissance Towne Dr
Bountiful

Neighborhood Acupuncture & Healing Arts

12582 south Fort St.
Draper

Nicholas Goucher MD

4403 Harrison Blvd
Ogden

Optimum Clinical Research

82 S 1100 E # 402
Salt Lake City

Orthopedic Specialty Group

324 10th Ave Ste 100
Salt Lake City

Oval Sports Medicine

6322 S 3000 E # 140
Salt Lake City

Oval Sports Medicine

6322 S 3000 E # 140
Salt Lake City

Pellatt, Dr. Morton M.

9500 S 1300 E
Sandy

Physician Group of Utah

406 W. South Jordan Parkway, Ste 500
South Jordan

Powell, Dr. Amy P

590 Wakara Way
Salt Lake City

Rice, Dr. Robert S.

2121 N 1700 W
Layton

Richard Jackson MD

700 W 800 N
Orem

Robert Jackson MD

1055 N 500 W
Provo

Rosenberg Cooley Metcalf Clinic

1820 Sidewinder Dr
Park City

Salt Lake Orthopedic Clinic

1160 E 3900 S
Salt Lake City

Sandy Clinic

9500 S 1300 E
Sandy

Tanner Clinic

2121 Robins Dr
Layton

The Active Joint Institute

11762 S State Street
Draper

The WalkEZstore.com

2309 West Smith Valley Road

TOSH–The Orthopedic Specialty Hospital

5848 S Fashion Blvd
Salt Lake City

University of Utah Orthopedic Center

590 Wakara Way
Salt Lake City

University Orthopedic Center

590 Wakara Way
Salt Lake City

Shop Local Knee Care Services in Salt Lake City

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Salt Lake City.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Orthopedic Surgeon
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money