Catering reviews in Madison

C

Rating
Based on the great communication and customer service before the event and great ratings they'd received from wedding related publications, we were very surprised by how the event itself went. There were numerous little things (and some bigger) that did not go as planned. We didn't expect everything to go perfectly, since that is an unrealistic expectation, but the number of issues we experienced exceeded what we consider acceptable. For example, we did not receive the remainder of our wedding cake at the end of the event. We called the restaurant the following day as soon as we learned that we had not gotten the cake. We did not receive a response for 3 days and it was via email. (In my mind, if you call, you should receive a call back, not an email.) When we later addressed this issue with the owner, she said that we should have called her directly, but we do not have a record of receiving her personal number. She also blamed us for the oversight, because my husband and I left before the event ended. I know I should have specifically designated someone to make sure we got the cake, but I didn't think it was necessary. My father spoke to a member of the staff at the end of the event to settle the bar bill. No one mentioned the cake to him or anyone else that was helping to clean up after the event.
- Nathan M.
A

Rating
I chose
Madison Caterers Provider Name Locked
restaurant to be the site of my wedding reception.
Madison Caterers Provider Name Locked
, the owner, was open and upfront with exactly, what I would be getting and exactly how much it would cost. She did more for me, than I would have asked her to, and was open to ideas as to how to keep my cost down.
- SARA N.
A

Rating
They ain't cheap, but the quality of the food was excellent. They came and departed on time & responded to calls and e-mails promptly before the event. There were no slip ups or stutters. Everything was carried out in a highly professional and efficent manner. I suppose one gets what one pays for. I would highly recommend this company.
- Robert S.
110% Guaranteed Money Back

We think we're the best, and we can prove it.

Try an annual plan and if you want to cancel in your first year, we'll refund you 110%

Annual Plans Only

All Caterers in Madison, WI

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

24 CARROT CATERING

1017 Hampshire Pl
Madison, WI

24 CARROT CATERING

1 S PARK ST
Madison, WI

3 FAT GUYS CATERING

702 N MIDVALE BLVD
Madison, WI

Alliant Energy Center

1919 Alliant Energy Center Way
Madison, WI

ARTAMOS MEATS

714 S WHITNEY WAY
Madison, WI

BADGER COLUMBUS CLUB LLC

5256 VERONA RD
Madison, WI

BARABOO ARTS

202 EAST ST
Baraboo, WI

BELLINI ITALIAN RESTAURANT

401 E WASHINGTON AVE
Madison, WI

Blue Plate Catering

8401 Greenway Blvd
Middleton, WI

BULL'S BBQ

3442 DORCHESTER WAY
Madison, WI

Cao Chocolates

9804 SW 77th Ave
Miami, FL

Caricatures By Paul

404 North Carroll Street
Madison, WI

Chefs For Seniors

3086 Providence Street
Sun Prairie, WI

CIRCOLO CATERING

100 CROSS COUNTRY RD
Verona, WI

Couture Celebrations

105 N Catlin St
Edgerton, WI

Cranberry Creek Restaurant & Catering

6308 Monona Dr
Madison, WI

CRANDALL'S CARRYOUT & CATERING

6401 UNIVERSITY AVE
Middleton, WI

Crandall's Catering

641 University Ave.
Middleton, WI

CROWNE PLAZA

4402 E WASHINGTON AVE
Madison, WI

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Madison.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Caterer
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money