-Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Indianapolis Plastering Contractors

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Plastering Contractors to Avoid

121

Top Rated Plastering Contractors

43

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews

Over 13,292 reviews for
Indianapolis Plastering Contractors from people just like you.

A
"I called the main company phone line to request an appointment to get a quote for repair work. The person that answered took my contact information to pass to someone" in the field to call me back and make arrangements. I received a return call within 2 business days. They were fairly flexible with scheduling, trying to work around my work schedule while trying to find someone that would already be in my area of town during the same time frame.
was the person that was sent to look at the requested work. He was available a few hours before the scheduled time and called to see if I would be available for him to come by. He looked over the requested work, gave me an idea of how he recommended proceeding and how much time would be involved. After calling into his boss,
gave me a price quote which was well below what i was expecting to spend. He then gave me a phone # of someone to call to schedule time to have the work done. Again, they were very flexible with scheduling a time that worked well for me. On the repair day,
again came out after calling to confirm that I was available. The work was all professionally completed in almost the exact amount of time that was predicted. The final cost was exactly what was originally quoted.
cleaned after himself when he was done and even looked at another room that I might want to have more work done down the road. Every aspect of my experience with this company exceeded expectations. I would definitely recommend using their services.

-Reese J.

F
"It has been my experience that when a service provider cannot return calls on a timely basis, it's a pretty good indicator of the quality of work they will perform....

-Cathy C.

+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Over 2 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 2 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Indianapolis

Drywall and plaster

Knowing how your interior walls are constructed and what they are made of can help you take better care of your home, as well as provide effective maintenance. You can make small repairs yourself, but the more extensive the job the more likely you'll need a drywall repair contractor to make the wall smooth again.

guy repairing plaster ceiling
Plastering, Painting - Interior

Dear Angie: How important is it to repair plaster before repainting? Our ceilings have peeling paint that we’re pretty sure was caused by past water damage. Since the water problem is no longer an issue, can we simply repaint the ceilings or should we first repair any underlying plaster damage? – Sara S., Elgin, Illinois

Angie's List
Moving, Painting - Exterior, Painting - Interior, Plastering, Plumbing, Plumbing - Drain Cleaning, Roof Cleaning, Roofing, Sewer Cleaning, Siding

For larger projects, especially those that may involve more than three different service providers, a general contractor to oversee your project may be required.

Angie's List
Handymen, Heating & A/C, Insulation, Plastering, Plumbing, Plumbing - Drain Cleaning, Remodeling - Basements, Remodeling - General, Remodeling - Kitchen & Bathroom, Remodeling - Modular & Mobile Home, Remodeling - Sunrooms & Patio Enclosures, Roofing, Windows, Windows - Safety & Security Film

Just as consumers don’t like it when they call for help and don’t get a return call, companies don’t like it when they invest a lot of time to provide an estimate and never hear that their bid hasn’t been accepted.

Angie's List
Appliance Repair - Large, Appliance Repair - Small, Builders - Garages/Barns/Sheds, Builders - Homes, Cabinet Making, Drywall, Electrical, Electronic Gadget Repair, Glass Block, Gutter Cleaning, Gutter Repair & Replacement, Handymen, Hardware & Home Improvement Stores, Hardwood Flooring Sales/Installation/Refinishing, Heating & A/C, Insulation, Landscaping, Landscaping - Hardscaping & Pavers, Landscaping - Lakefront, Landscaping & Lighting, Lighting, Painting - Exterior, Painting - Interior, Plastering, Plumbing, Plumbing - Drain Cleaning, Pressure Washing, Remodeling - Basements, Remodeling - General, Remodeling - Kitchen & Bathroom, Remodeling - Modular & Mobile Home, Remodeling - Sunrooms & Patio Enclosures, Roofing, Screen Repair, Septic Tank, Siding, Tree Service, Windows, Windows - Safety & Security Film

Don't tackle a DIY home repair without asking yourself these three questions.

Angie's Answers

?
My sister-in-law uses brite white toothpaste and rubs it into those small holes. No prep, no sanding.
?

I've used wall liner (it applies like wallpaper only thicker) to cover a multitude of "wall sins" over the years. In my opinion it's the greatest thing since sliced bread. It doesn't look cheap or tacky, it's inexpensive, non-labor intensive and not messy to install.

I used it for the first time about 15 years ago to cover a faux brick tile on my lower kitchen walls that couldn't be removed. It was either tear the wall down or take a chance on $40 worth of wall liner. It did the job beautifully and lasted. Since then I've used it to cover paneling, a badly gouged wall after a kitchen remodel and a wall that looked like a pegboard after floor to ceiling shelving was removed.

Friends and family (and realtors!) have been amazed by the transformation after applying this simple inexpensive product. 

?

Remember, you not only have to remove the popcorn texture, but also redo the ceiling in some other texture.

Price will depend on several factors:

1) how much the contractor you choose hates removing popcorn or textured ceilings - some charge $1 or so/SF extra just because they hate it. There are even some who bid total drywall replacement cheaper than removing the popcorn, so you have to first find contractors who are happy to do that work, or your prices will be out of the realistic range

2) if the popcorn predates about 1990, then it could likely have asbestos in it, which doubles or triples the price, and in many cases uncapsulating it with a spray coating and then removing the drywall entirely is actually cheaper than all the protective measures necessary if it is scraped off. 

3) whether the popcorn is primarily gypsum and vermiculite (comes off REAL easy) or was the plaster of paris variety, which takes a fair amount of soaking to soften it enough to scrape off

4) what type of finish you are replacing it with - if a textured ceiling, slapcoat, knockdown finish or paneling, not real problem. If you want to go with a perfectly smooth ceiling (generally a bad idea as any variations in the drywall on a ceiling surface really shows up dramatically), then it will demand a lot of care in preparing the scraped surface, and a complete surface drywall compound skim coat to smooth out the scrapes and gouges from the removal process.

5) what underlying conditions are - if there is a lot of furniture to move around (should go to adjacent rooms) or cover and work around, high-quality rug or hardwood floor to super-protect or such, will drive cost up.

I have seen costs run from as low as $0.60/SF to $1.25/SF (for removal only). Generally, remove and recoat with a surface texture of some kind (anything but smooth) and paint will run you about $2.50-3.50/SF.

Now the bad news - if asbestos containing, can run from $5-10/SF. Many homeowners in that situation go the other legal route - have it encapsulated with an asbestos-rated sealant by an asbestos contractor, then paint it and leave it for the next homeowner to decide what to do about it. Some contractors encapsulate it and then put a 1/4" thick drywall layer over it - this usually looks like a disaster unless it has a VERY rough textured finish on it, because putting drywall sheet over a rough surface like popcorn invariably means a wavy surface commonly looks like a gently rolling ocean surface.

?

Plaster reviews in Indianapolis

B

Rating
This was a one day job. The crew was there on time, and did exactly what they proposed plus some additional work which was thrown in at no additional charge. They finished on time, and the quality of the work was good.
- Mary B.
B

Rating
I was eager to get some plaster repair done, so happily purchased the big deal for 3 hours of plaster/dry wall repair work. When the
Indianapolis Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
person talked with me, it was clear they were not able to perform the plaster repair I needed. They were polite.
- MARY ALICE M.
A

Rating
I am a property manager, and have dealt with many, many contractors. I have come to think of true plaster work as not only a skill but an art. Mr.
Indianapolis Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
fixed our cracked ceiling in the living room and the breakfast room. What he did with this 1929 home is nothing short of remarkable. Everything smooth, and I'm guessing it looks better than it did when the home was first built. Mr.
Indianapolis Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
is punctual, polite and knows his business. My advice is not to bother with anyone else because I'm sure he is often called in to fix blotched jobs on other homes. He has been in the business many years, and his experience shows. I also thought the price was reasonable, as he was at our home several days to make sure the plaster was setting correctly as he built it up. ALSO, very important, he tented the area he was working in -- this eliminated a lot of plaster dust going throughout the home. You can tell from the get-go this man is a pro.
- JOSEPHINE L.
A

Rating
The project went great and exceeded my expectations. I found
Indianapolis Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
to be professional, punctual, and knowledgeable. His work was top-notch. We had water damage under our bedroom window which caused the plaster to crumble in some places. It is an old house, built in 1928, and he noted that the area had gone through a repair before. He removed and repaired the loose plaster and even repaired a few other places at no additional expense - the wall above the window and an area near the ceiling - that weren't included in his original estimate. The repaired area was deep and took time to dry so it took a few days to totally complete the job. He showed up on time each morning to assess and complete as promised.
- Richard G.
A

Rating
The plaster work was excellent. He repaired the cracks so that you would never know there was a problem. The painters also did an excellent job putting two coats everywhere. They were prompt, professional and clean. I would highly recommend them and we will certainly use them again.
- STEVE W.
A

Rating
Indianapolis Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
did a wonderful job of repairing my old, beat up plaster walls. The crew was very polite and professional and even made allowances for my working at home (I'm an online trainer); they would ask if it was OK to make noise if I wasn't on the phone. I will be calling them for future projects!
- Pamela O.
A

Rating
Indianapolis Plastering Contractors Provider Name Locked
did a great job Re-plastering the crack on the ceiling, You can't even tell the crack was there. The color and pattern matches almost perfectly. I would recommend them to anyone that needs there drywall or ceiling plastered.
- Ben C.
D

Rating
Took weeks just to get scheduled. I called to confirm the schedule and they still didn't have our request on file. I knew I would have to pay for sheet rock, but was not aware that I would also have to provide tape, spackle, and tools for the job.
- Mark A.

Plastering Contractors in Indianapolis

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

A & D Hydra Clean Inc

6440 Michigan Rd
Indianapolis

Aaron France

3668 Central #5
Indianapolis

Accelerated Home Improvements

720 Village Dr
Indianapolis

ACE Construction & Remodeling Inc

1930 Indiana Ave
Anderson

Advanced Walls and Ceilings LLC

2110 S Pittenger Rd
Selma

All Phase Construction Services Corp.

318 N Drexel Ave
Indianapolis

All Phase Group Inc

6317 Evanston Ave
Indianapolis

All Things Carpentry

108 Smith St
Whitestown

Andy's Custom Painting Inc

1118 W 78TH ST
Indianapolis

B & A Home Remodeling LLC

5639 Woodside dr
Indianapolis

BCA PAINTING & CONSULTING

2941 ANGELINA DR
Indianapolis

Bill Whitt

2105 E 46th St
Indianapolis

BILL WHITTENS QUALITY PAINTING SERVICES

2626 BUTTERFIELD DR
Indianapolis

Blankenship Drywall

2860 Harlan St
Indianapolis

BLICE EDWARDS at STUDIO 54

1101 E 54th St
Indianapolis

BOB MOSS

1984 E 56TH ST
Indianapolis

Bone Dry Interiors Exteriors

4825 W 79th St
Indianapolis

Boss Construction

496 Polk Street

BRIGHT VIEW WINDOW CLEANING

11650 CAPISTRANO DR
Indianapolis

Bulldog Home Remodeling and Repair

1308 E Ohio St
Indianapolis

Burdine Perfection Services

205 E. Tilden Dr.
Brownsburg

Case Design/Remodeling Indy

99 East Carmel Dr
Carmel

CertaPro Painters of Indianapolis

5151 N Shadeland Ave
Indianapolis

Circle City SkyLights

2455 N Central Ave
Indianapolis

Coffman Construction

4975 Gibbs Rd
Plainfield

Color Theory LLC

3720 W. Race St
Bloomington

Complete Restoration Services, Inc.

2208 Production Dr.
Indianapolis

Connor & Company Inc

1101 Central Ave
Indianapolis

Construction Services of Indianapolis

6212 Northern Lane
Indianapolis

Cooper Plastering

1518 Maxine Rd
Indianapolis

Cooper's Construction LLC

1040 Nelson Ave
Indianapolis

Cornerstone Painting & Drywall LLC

13163 N Elster Way
Fishers

CRAIG KINNAMAN

4740 E 78TH ST
Indianapolis

craigs remodeling

2800 E 39th St
Indianapolis

CREATIVE EXISTENCE

4406 BUXTON COURT
Indianapolis

CUSTOM DRYWALL

7426 W Stinemyer Rd
New Palestine

D&T Construction

P.O. Box 44
Shirley

Danny Dunn's Drywall and Plaster Repairs

10067 Penrith Dr.
Indianapolis

Dave's Home Improvement

21672 Hinkle Rd
Noblesville

David Schulz

5140 Norwaldo Avenue
Indianapolis

DC Contracting

604 East Mill St
Summitville

Devries Custom Painting

13265 Allisonville Rd
Fishers

DISTINCTIVE FINISHES

2116 Joe Pool Dr

DLS & ASSOCIATES, INC.

8145 Moore Rd
Indianapolis

Door To The Past

8539 E 96th St
Indianapolis

DRU'S HUES

1724 Ellen Dr.
Indianapolis

DT Drywall

880 Orion Dr
Franklin

DUKATE FINE REMODELING INC

2111 HOLIDAY LN
Franklin

Edens Painting and Remodeling LLC

8747 Fielding Ln
Indianapolis

ELT plastering/drywall&E.I.F.S

3438beasley
Indianapolis

Eternity Construction

8015 Ridgegate E Dr
Indianapolis

Everett Barnard Construction

7721 Swails St
Indianapolis

FALLIS PAINTING & DECORATING

4212 N STATE RD 3
Rushville

Faux DFW

Indianapolis

Fauxbello Finishing

1126 Rutledge Court
Noblesville

Fentress Builders Inc

6006 E 38th St
Indianapolis

Figy Construction

1130 Janet Dr
Greenwood

Fine Painting Inc

7363 Oaklandon Rd
Indianapolis

Fine Remodeling LLC

1923 Randall Rd
Indianapolis

Freedom Home Services, Inc.

13160 La Canada Blvd
Fishers

Fresh Colors Painting LLC

6011 E Hanna Ave
Indianapolis

GICKO ROOFING CONTRACTORS

6004 N Ewing St
Indianapolis

GIL CO CUSTOM PAINTING

12740 Hearthstone Dr.
Fishers

Gray's Home Improvements

5567 West 43 Street

Greg Mrakich Painting LLC

1007 W 72 St
Indianapolis

GuyCo Homes & Remodeling

150 Vista Park Way
Avon

HAARBYE RESTORATION & REPAIR

408 N TIBBS AVE
Indianapolis

Haleys Painting

5464 Mark Ln
Indianapolis

Hancock Home Improvement

523 west 600 north
Alexandria

Handy Helps

533 Maple Lane
Brownsburg

Handy Repair Guys LLC

1389 W 86th St
Indianapolis

Handyman Connection

5610 Crawfordsville Rd
Indianapolis

Hayes Construction Co

2505 S County Road 625 E
Plainfield

HD Contracting

1739 N 600 W
Greenfield

Hester's Construction Company, LLC

10359 Harrow Place
Indianapolis

Hofsommer Construction LLC

10252 Orchard Park Dr S
Indianapolis

Home Experts

7225 S. East St.
Indianapolis

HOME REFINEMENTS

5123 E SAINT CLAIR ST
Indianapolis

Hoosier Carpenter

318 N Vine St
Plainfield

Imagine It

9087 Riverbend Ct
Indianapolis

Indiana Professional Contractors LLC

2031 Silver Ln Dr
Indianapolis

IndyPro Painting

5481 Hollow Oak Court
Indianapolis

Infinity Construction Services

PO Box 29148
Indianapolis

Integrity Design & Remodeling

5404 Chico Grey Dr
Indianapolis

Integrity Property Services Inc

1426 Brook Pointe Dr
Indianapolis

Jack Apollos

3602 Fletcher Ave
Indianapolis

Jacoby & Associates LLC

PO Box 30696
Indianapolis

James Ping

S Side
Indianapolis

Jason Schwedler Construction LLC

PO Box 20087
Indianapolis

JC VEERKAMP INC

1444 OLIVER AVE
Indianapolis

Jeff's Handyman Painting and Housecleaning

9546 E Raymond St
Indianapolis

Jersey Construction

4133 N Grand Ave
Indianapolis

John Cooper

3742 e 55th St
Indianapolis

Johns Handyman Service

4524 E Shady Ln
Mooresville

JON LAUSCH PAINTING

1538 E 74TH ST
Indianapolis

JONES PAINTING

1051 W SUMNER AVE
Indianapolis

Just Perfect Painting & Wallcoverings

7053 Grosvenor Place
Indianapolis

Keesee & Sons

1309 E Main St
Crawfordsville

KNAUSS PROPERTY SERVICES

7229 CRITTENDEN AVE
Indianapolis

KOHLMEYER REMODELING

5603 N CARROLLTON AVE
Indianapolis

L & W PAINTING INC

P.O. Box 3893
Carmel

Landis & Landis Kitchen & Bath Remodeling

2520 E Fairfax Rd
Indianapolis

LARRY PFINGSTON

2325 FRISCO PL
Indianapolis

Leising Home Improvement

13119 Derbyshire Ct
Carmel

Linehan’s & Sons Inc

2306 REFORMERS AVE
Indianapolis

M J Robbins Construction Inc

6829 Hawthorn Park Dr
Indianapolis

M.A.D. ABOUT FAUX

12159 THICKET HILL CIR
Carmel

Madison County Cabinets Inc

9592 W 650 S
Pendleton

MATTINGLY HOME IMPROVEMENTS

219 N East St
Pendleton

McClees Enterprise Inc

7636 Castleton Farms W Dr
Indianapolis

MCKEAND CONSTRUCTION

50 S MAIN ST
Indianapolis

Mike Thalheimer

11788 Tylers Close
Fishers

MIKE'S HANDYMAN SERVICE

424 BEECH PARK DR
Greenwood

My Home In Indy

5440 Rosslyn Ave
Indianapolis

P N K DRYWALL & PLASTERING

4740 E 78TH ST
Indianapolis

Patch & Repair Co

14002 E 206th St
Noblesville

Peak Exteriors

One Court Place

Pinnacle Painting Inc

545 Plainville Dr.
Westfield

PREFERRED CREATIONS

13503 ALL AMERICAN RD
Fishers

PRO FINISHING

10064 PARTRIDGE PL
Carmel

Quality Synthetic Coating

7315 Mt Herman Ave
Indianapolis

QUICK'S QUALITY CONSTRUCTION

5510 S Main St
Fountaintown

Randy Gioe Construction

627 S 214th St
Sheridan

Real Estate Solutions

1111 E 54th St
Indianapolis

Red Head Rehabs

12004 Hatteras St

Red Rabbit Construction

11215 E. 121st St.
Fishers

Rick's Roofing & Construction

1415 South 19th Street
New Castle

Rickleff Sons & Daughters Painting

1220 Fairbanks Dr
Carmel

Riley & Sons

3810 N Bolton Ave
Indianapolis

Rockstar's Home Improvement

3550 n hawthorne ln.

Ron's Pool Repair

8336 N Masters Rd
Indianapolis

RSR

Indianapolis

SB10 Contracting LLC.

3356 Voigt Dr.
Carmel

SCHWENZER REMODELING SERVICES

11532 BOONE DR
Indianapolis

Scott Cambridge Interiors & Remodeling

1434 Green Spring Way
Greenwood

Short's Painting Inc

PO Box 26733
Indianapolis

Shulkin Custom Painting

5884 W Falling Waters Dr
Mc Cordsville

SOLUTIONS IN CARPENTRY

4550 N. Mitchner
Indianapolis

Stevens Drywall LLC

9485 E 191 St
Noblesville

TCS PLASTERING

588 COVERED BRIDGE RD
Greenwood

The Fireplace Specialist

103 East Iroquois Street
Kentland

TRIM IT UP LLC

11711 N College Ave
Carmel

Truflow Painting

5074 Norwaldo Ave.
Indianapolis

TS Home Solutions

6749 E 17th St
Indianapolis

Two Sisters Painting

1117 W Epler Ave
Indianapolis

White Construction

2328 Sickle
Indianapolis

Wolff Construction Service

PO Box 5014
Zionsville

Shop Local Plaster Services in Indianapolis

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Indianapolis.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Plaster Repair
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money