Indianapolis Cake Decorators

in Indianapolis, IN

Cake Decorating Reviews in Indianapolis


Our son had his first birthday party on Sunday. The cake that we had made by another bakery did not make it home in one piece. It cracked and fell apart.
We were out to find a replacement
Mouse Cake - which was not easy. Then, we found
place. She made arrangements for us to be able to get the cake in less than 24 hours.
It turned out great, and could not be happier with results. Thanks again!
- Michael O.

We hired
after seeing a positive review on Angie's List (we should have paid attention to the fact there was only one review). We thought the cost was competitive and our early impression of the company (by phone) was positive. At our initial meeting with
, there was some confusion about our appointment time. We had to wait a while because they did not have a record of the appointment we had established. The overall atmosphere of the bakery seemed frantic and disorganized.

During that first meeting, we requested a wedding cake with both chocolate and yellow cake.
was pushy and tried to talk us out of the yellow cake, saying that wasn't a popular choice for weddings. We insisted, saying that was our preference. She finally agreed and recommended we buy an addition sheet cake of white cake, saying that white cake is more traditional. At her suggestion, we paid for the additional white cake.

She followed our decoration design closely, but she asked us to provide our own ribbon for the
of the cake. This required us to make additional visits to her bakery, which was added hassle for us before our wedding.

The day of the wedding reception, we were very disappointed with the poor quality of service we received. She had agreed to deliver the cake between 4:00 - 5:00pm for our 6:00 reception. She knew our reception was in Martinsville and we paid an additional fee (in advance) for the added mileage for delivery. At 5:00 (her deadline), there was no sign of the cake. At 5:10, we called her. She said they were leaving Indianapolis and would be there shortly. We began to worry, since we knew it was at least a 40 minute drive.

At 5:30, we called again -- asking for an estimated arrival time. Guests were beginning to arrive and we still did not have a cake. At this point, she told us that the cake had not baked properly and that was why she was late. We were confused why she didn't say this in the first place, and we were not happy with her excuses. About ten minutes before our 6pm reception, she arrived with the cake. We then had to spend time arranging the table decorations around the cake while guests were already being seated.

After her discouragement of the yellow cake, we noticed that it was the first cake that people finished. Both the chocolate and the white cake were less popular with people. Her "buttercream" recipe isn't as rich as typical buttercream and tasted too sweet. In short, the cake was okay, but not overwhelming, It certainly wasn't worth the added hassle or the poor customer service.
- Matthew R.

Indianapolis Cake Decorating Articles

Cake Decorating reviews in Indianapolis


First, let me say that we sampled the cake and it was good. However, they weren't very flexible or creative. The price quoted was per slice of cake and all changes only increased the price. The price went up for fillings, for whether the cake was round or square, for a stand for the cake, for delivery of the cake, for whether we wanted decorations on only the front of the cake or all around the cake, for how many flavors of cake we wanted, etc. The cost just kept rising. What influenced our decision was that my daughter had a design she wanted and they weren't creative enough to do it. We ended up going with another company. My daughter showed the other bakery a picture of the cake she wanted, they said "sure, we can do that" and here's the price. Very easy compared to our experience with
Indianapolis Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked

We met with
Indianapolis Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked
by appointment and had a tasting of the various cakes available. She also worked with us on the decoration for the cake. The finished product was a
Indianapolis Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked
but elegant wedding cake which is just what we wanted. It was delivered and set up well in advance of the start of the reception. We had many good comments on the appearance and taste of the cake. It was very delicious! Great cake at a fair price!

When I got an original estimate on the cake it was way a little bit more than i planned on spending on a birthday cake. This particular cake is VERY intricate and difficult to make, But I gave the woman who helped me my budget and she worked tirelessly with me trying to find ways to have it still look awesome/just like the expensive one but with adjustments on the design here and there to bring the cost down. The final product turned out amazing! It was such a huge hit people could not stop taking pictures of it with their phones and emailing them to friends because they coudl not believe how real the sushi pieces looked!!
Indianapolis Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked
has been making cakes for my family for years and always does the most amazing job!! I would recommend her if you love delicious cake, working with people who are always so friendly and attentive, and cakes that look to good to eat!
- Anne W.

While planning my daughter's wedding, one thing quickly became clear: if we wanted the best-tasting cake around, we needed to use
Indianapolis Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked
of Carmel. Which we did. And it was marvelous. My daughter ordered a "
Indianapolis Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked
" cake that involved alot of writing. Everyone at the reception marveled at how beautiful it was. We had four different flavors and all were delicious. I would use
Indianapolis Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked
any time.

She did a nice job. I would recommend her again. She was punctual and responsive. They did everything they said. The quality was good and I had a lot of good reports about the cake. Everybody liked it. I would have liked it to have been a little less expensive though.

I'd never been into
Indianapolis Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked
before, but I'm sure I'll go back. Typically, I prefer to bake and decorate my own cupcakes (since I'm picky and moderately obsessed with cupcakes), but I was in a pinch and needed just a few. While I'm pretty sure I've got them beat on chocolate cake, their peanut butter frosting was delicious! The cheesecake cupcakes got some serious "Mmmms" from the people eating them, too. Part of the charm was that none of the cupcakes were 100 percent perfect. They looked good, they had character, but they didn't go so far as to end up looking pretentious. I had pretentious, perfect-looking cupcakes from another Indy bakery at a birthday party not too long ago and *that* bakery quite obviously sacrificed taste for was like eating really attractive cardboard. Not so at
Indianapolis Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked
. They have both style and taste.
- Casandra M.

Wonderfully! I ordered the cake about a week ahead of time. The staff was very helpful in helping me decide what size cake would be appropriate for a small bridal shower. The cake was beautifully decorated and very delicious. I would highly recommend
Indianapolis Cake Decorator Provider Name Locked

The last time I was there they even had a half price shelf so you could get cakes for half the price. The there staff are very friendly. The approximate cost listed is for a cake that feeds 8 to 10 people. Their prices are worth every penny. I will absolutely continue to use them!
110% Guaranteed Money Back

We think we're the best, and we can prove it.

Try an annual plan and if you want to cancel in your first year, we'll refund you 110%

Annual Plans Only

All Cake Decorator in Indianapolis, IN

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!


4850 E Southport Rd
Indianapolis, IN


Indianapolis, IN

Taylor's Bakery

8395 East 116th St
Fishers, IN

The Cakehole

2625 N Meridian St
Indianapolis, IN


Indianapolis, IN

The Morgan County Bakery

710 E Morgan St
Martinsville, IN

The Sweet Life

11009 Allisonville Rd
Fishers, IN

Tim's Bakery

6087 W Broadway
Mc Cordsville, IN


9500 E US Hwy 36
Avon, IN


Noblesville, IN

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Indianapolis.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Cake Decorator
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money