-Find top-rated Service Providers
Find top-rated Service Providers

Find Top-Rated Columbus Title Companies

Angie's List helps you hire the best - and avoid the rest!

Title Companies to Avoid

128

Top Rated Title Companies

5

Prevent buyer's remorse with us

  • Over 3 million people trust Angie's List to help make the right choice
  • Be informed to avoid costly mistakes
  • Shop with us to ensure a fair price
  • Our complaint resolution team will help if a project goes bad
+See Verified Local Reviews
See Verified Local Reviews

Over 120 reviews for
Columbus Title Companies from people just like you.

A
"As a First time home buyer looking at investment properties i got in touch with in mid 2014. Off the bat offered" to help me out in areas that was beyond his requirements, i thought that he was just selling me his services. My interactions of the past 16 months with has made me realize how wrong i was in judging him. he is a professional to the core and goes over and beyond to help his customers, even potential customers i might add. When finally in Aug 2015 our offer for a multi family property was accepted i got in touch with again who explained to me what to expect now that our offer was accepted. My lawyer suggested a title company of his own which was a really bad one to say the least. with i was able to get honest answers and he gave me a quote within a day. Despite my lawyers resistance i chose to go with and i can confidently state that i do not regret that choice for a single moment. he was responsive at all points in time to my queries and even helped me save money. my lawyer suggested that for the closing to happen a survey was absolutely necessary without which a loan would not be sanctioned. educated me by explaining that was not the case and it was upto us the buyer whether we wanted a survey or not He gave me an itemized breakdown of his title services which i found to be very easy to understand. the other companies suggested by my lawyer would only give a bulk pricing. In the last evening before the scheduled closing i sprung a surprise on (due to my ignorance) that there were 3 tenants occupying the property and that i intended to keep them as tenants. this mean that had to immediately rework the HUD forms and get credits from the seller for the pro-rate rent and transfer of security deposits. took it in his stride and had the whole issue sorted out in a couple of hours. Needless to say that is part of my A team and i will be using his services for my future real estate endeavors.

-Reji V.

A
"Mr. was awesome. He questioned all the questions we had. He communicated with us throughout the process and followed up. He had the settlement" statement ready at least 2 weeks before our closing date to review the figures and if any changes or updates needed. Everything went so smooth and the customer service was impeccable. The fee was reasonable compared to another title company that we used from our realtor when we sold our house 3 months prior to this transaction. Our experience with Mr. was just AWESOME! He even continued to follow through with us to give us a heads up for any important document coming into our mail. We highly recommend Eagle Title Company in . :)

-MARY O.

+Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Shop, Search and Save from anywhere!

  • Offers are exclusively provided by highly rated companies
  • Angie’s List members have access to exclusive discounts on local services
  • Shop, schedule, and stay on top of progress from any device
  • Our 30 Day Refund Guarantee means you can buy with confidence!
+Join 3 Million People on Angie's List
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services

Over 3 million people trust Angie's List.

  • Your Membership Includes:
  • Instant access to top rated businesses covering 700+ services
  • Our Complaint Resolution Team to help when a project goes bad
  • On-the-go access to our iPhone, Android, & iPad apps
Find top-rated Service Providers
See Verified Local Reviews
Shop, Schedule, and Save on Services
Join 3 Million People on Angie's List

Local Articles in Columbus

Angie's Answers

?

I bought my last house and also sold it FSBO.  For me, both ends of the process were simple and relatively hassle free. 

I advertised in the paper once a week and had an open house every Sunday for about three weeks.  I also had an FSBO sign in the front yard that I would put balloons on (for attention) when I had the open house.  It sold quickly. 

The cost of an attorney to go over the paperwork was MUCH less than the price of a relator.  I bought one of those ready-made packages from the nearest office store, read it over and made a few changes to it.  Then I had the attorney look it over.  I think it saved some money having the attorney just look over the document and make changes rather than having him create the entire thing. 

 When I decide to move out of my current house, I will definitely go FSBO again.

?
Yes! Movie tickets, 2 hours at the spa, 10 rides at your local "iFly", etc. Bottom line: You know your clients. Find out what they do to reward/pamper themselves and give them that!

Hope this helps!

David Gowans

?
?
?
?

Title Company reviews in Columbus

A

Rating
This is our third time closing on a home, so it was a pretty standard affair. Both the seller and our realtor were not available to attend the closing and and his team had everything prepared. Initial phone conversations were handled well, but I do remember calling frequently to confirm that the closing team was prepared for ...More our closing and feeling a bit rushed on the phone. The wire procedure for the funds needed to close were a bit odd as I was told that in the state of Florida cashiers checks are no longer accepted on the day of closing due to fraudulent checks. Despite this minor communication issues via phone, we would select Services again if we decide to sell this home when we are relocated with the military in a few years.
- melissa F.
F

Rating
This title agency is owned by N. (formerly of and Dreidame) DO NOT TRUST THIS COMPANY gave every assurance that this property was protected like in a "lock box" no one could touch it. Property was paid off completely with cashiers' check ...More we thought.....Defective documents, fraudulently submitted into court pleaded for assistance from "trustee" that thought to escape his wrongful acts HE DID NOTHING!!!! L&D Title filed an irrevocable trust in county ohio that was not reported to IRS for Identification when grantor died. N. attorney now at Frost Brown and accepted trustee position. He filed separate worthless General Warranty from homebuilder http://www.ca6.uscourts.gov/opinions.pdf/06a0617n-06.pdf served time in federal prison for not paying off underlying mortgages on buildings in Kentucky 2003. Cashiers check to for $159,900 paid to Homes by included full owners policy of title from L&D Title. Copy of contract given to and we thought as owner of L&D Title, an attorney read the contract and issued the owners policy to protect us from mechanics liens that and I had endured on other property we owned 368 Walnut Lane in Mason Ohio. knew it was worthless and never issued title policy but filed documents in County Ohio. Kallick paid for this property to be included in this trust with Mr. as trustee while he underwent chemo. Mr. failed on every level to protect his client Kallick knowing all the while that the General Warranty which usually carries full assurance of title insurance this same attorney issued a Quit Claim negating any title insurance if there had been any in the first place. was trying to cover his tracks (again see fraud against pensioners worthless trust http://www.enquirer.com/editions/2004/02/28/biz_electrojet28.html in 2004 he did this to make sure no inheritance to heir was possible. also did deathbed POWER OF ATTORNEY with Kallick that allowed him to further defraud this TRUST on file in County Ohio and keep the proceeds. Never trust this person and he is a lawyer and no one can seem to charge him for these acts. Lost property in foreclosure with fraudulent documents also from C&R title submitted into record. Sued my attorney and was told I NEVER OWNED THE PROPERTY in the first place so they could NOT give it to me even though I was relentless sued in County Ohio and Title, Apex Title, Lawyers Title and First American Title all knew the proper paperwork was not done by N. and L&D title.
- robin F.
A

Rating
I've purchased several properties in the past, and this condo was by far, the most complicated! The seller moved to Italy, causing a series of issues. was outstanding in protecting my interests and making sure the transaction was fully legal and without problems. The seller had executed a Power of Attorney in the US to ...More have his brother-in-law work on his behalf for the condo sale. However, because the seller was in Italy and not a US citizen, it caused problems and was not valid. Fidelity Title would not close without the proper documentation, and for that, I am extremely grateful. (The real estate agents suggested moving to a different title company that would let it go through, but I refused). So it took a month for the seller to actually bother to get the documents he needed in Italy. (He needed an apostille, or a notarized form from the US Consulate). When that arrived, it was only a fax copy, and the seal was not visible so the copy could not be recorded. Fidelity did offer a couple of suggestions that day, but we all agreed we needed the original, which was still in the mail. So I waited yet another week to get the original, and we finally closed! But that's not the end of the story! Because we had changed the closing so many times, the condo fees were late. So a month after closing I was assessed a late fee that the seller should have paid, and Fidelity should have known about. So I called the general manager, , and he immediately looked it up, realized the error and said Fidelity would take care of it. It was only $35, but after all the other issues with the seller, I did not feel I should pick up the cost, and Fidelity stepped up, and took care of it immediately. I will use them for any future real estate transaction I have. They understand more than just local laws, and they are careful to protect themselves as well as the new owner.
- SARA S.
C

Rating
We used as the closing agent for a recent home purchase. My wife and I are not inexperienced home buyers - this is probably or 4th or 5th purchase over the past 15 years - and so we know what to expect and when there are problems. I have to say that my experience with was by far the worst with a closing ...More agent that I've ever had. When it came to scheduling the final closing, the closing agent was so rigid and inflexible with regard to scheduling, and was so rude and unfriendly about it that it ended up frustrating everyone else involved in the process (real estate agents, bank, seller). If the closing agent had taken the energy she put into pointing fingers at the bank and put it instead into trying to find a solution to accommodate people and communicate effectively, I'd be writing a very different review.
Remember that you have a choice in closing agents for your real estate purchase. If you're buying in Skagit County or the San 's, I'd advise that you work with someone else.
- Sam B.
F

Rating
From start to finish, dealing with this company was a nightmare. I didn't receive the settlement statement until the morning of the day closing was scheduled. It was incorrect. We went back and forth three times, and it was still incorrect after three revisions. By that point, we were out of time before the closing. I was told by both the ...More bank and my realtor to go to closing and the title agent there would sort it out.

When I arrived at closing, I told the title agent, , that the settlement statement was incorrect. He refused to even consider that it was wrong, would not go through the numbers with me, and repeatedly stated that I was wrong and the statement was fine. This is a breach of his fiduciary duty; if either party states that the settlement statement is wrong he had a duty to remedy the situation. Not only that, but he was incredibly rude the entire time. We went forward with the closing, since I was being undercharged and the seller did not appear to care that he was being overcharged, as he did not raise any objections even after being informed the numbers were incorrect. Later in the closing, I objected to a statement that had made, because it was wrong. He told me repeatedly that I was wrong, he was right, and then stated, "you're just going to disagree to everything, aren't you?" Overall, this company, and in particular were incredibly unprofessional and disrespectful. I will never use this company again, and would advise anyone thinking of using them to look elsewhere. It's hard to believe that they're still in business with these unethical and unprofessional employees/practices.
- Jenifer M.
A

Rating
I utilized for two separate transactions this year and couldn't be more pleased. The staff's attention to detail and true customer service ranks as exceeding my expectations. I interfaced with the owner on both transactions and he went above and beyond what is expected in my opinion.
On ...More my most recent transaction, I called Eagle at the last minute due to delays in getting documents. didn't hesitate to say he would help with this last minute request and would wait for me. We had to sign and notarize documents for an out of state transaction which needed to be sent back the same day. took the time to make sure it was completed properly double and triple checking everything.
If you are in need of a Title Agency that provides old fashion customer service, you need to talk with at Eagle Title first.
- Geoffrey C.
A

Rating
My home purchasing process was long and complicated and seemed to be like one thing after another. The title company was great and was instrumental in the loan closing at my desired time. The seller's realtor said that was the best closer he'd ever worked with in 20 years.
- Jeffrey A.
A

Rating
Five years after using to buy our house, I contacted them in need of a copy of the survey of the house. They were professional and quick, sending me the survey PDF via email right away. This saved me $400 for having to get another survey done for a renovation permit. They really do seem to put their customers first. Thank ...More you, , at .
- Douglas F.

Title Companies in Columbus

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

A TEAM TITLE AGENCY LLC

8101 N HIGH ST
Columbus

Amerititle

150 E Main St
Columbus

AMERITITLE EAST

7654 SLATE RIDGE BLVD
Reynoldsburg

APEX TITLE AGENCIES

445 HUTCHINSON AVE
Columbus

ARROW TITLE AGENCY

4200 REGENT ST
Columbus

ASSURANCE TITLE AGENCY OF OHIO

2015 W 5TH AVE
Columbus

ASSURED OHIO TITLE AGENCY INC

3311 LONGSTRETH PARK PL
Columbus

ATI TITLE AGENCY OF OHIO INC

450 W WILSON BRIDGE RD
Columbus

Auction Ohio

2931 E Dublin Granville Rd
Columbus

BARRISTER LAND TITLE ASSURANCE

6100 E Main St Ste 108
Columbus

BELK Tile

6955 Worthington Galena Road, Unit A
Worthington

BEXLEY TITLE INSURANCE LLC

2369 E MAIN ST
Columbus

BUILDER TITLE CO

4016 TOWNSFAIR WAY
Columbus

BUTLER REPORT CO

150 E MOUND ST
Columbus

C M PENTELLO & ASSOC

373 S HIGH ST
Columbus

CAPCITY TITLE AGENCY

398 S Washington Ave
Columbus

CAPITAL AREA TITLE AGENCY

338 S HIGH ST
Columbus

CARDINAL TITLE

141 E Town St Ste 200
Columbus

CHARTER TITLE AGENCY

94 NORTHWOODS BLVD
Columbus

CHICAGO TITLE INSURANCE CO

121 W MAIN ST
Columbus

CHICAGO TITLE INSURANCE CO

100 S 4TH ST
Columbus

CHICAGO TITLE INSURANCE CO

150 E Wilson Bridge Rd Ste 130
Columbus

CHICAGO TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY- WORTHINGTON

150 E WILSON BRIDGE RD
Columbus

COLEGROVE TITLE

21 NORTON RD
Columbus

COLUMBUS TITLE AGENCY

8101 N HIGH ST
Columbus

CONTRACT PROCESSING & TITLE

2602 OAKSTONE DR
Columbus

CornerStone Title and Closing LLC

11423 Upper Gilchrist Rd
Mount Vernon

COURT STREET TITLE

1395 E DUBLIN GRANVILLE
Columbus

COVENANT TITLE SVC

501 MORRISON RD
Columbus

COVENTRY TITLE AGENCY INC

41 S HIGH ST
Columbus

CREEKSIDE TITLE AGENCY

6100 CHANNINGWAY BLVD
Columbus

CRESENT TITLE

200 E CAMPUS VIEW BLVD
Columbus

CUSTOM TITLE SVC INC

202 W JOHNSTOWN RD
Columbus

DANTER & CO

363 E TOWN ST
Columbus

DISCOVERY TITLE AGENCY

8001 RAVINES EDGE CT
Columbus

Eagle Land Title Agency, Inc.

216 Bradenton Ave
Dublin

ECLOSERS.COM

909 W 5TH AVE
Columbus

ELITE LAND TITLE

3755 Attucks Drive
Powell

ESQUIRE TITLE SVC

300 SPRUCE ST
Columbus

EXPRESS TITLE SVC

100 E CAMPUS VIEW BLVD
Columbus

FIRST AMERICAN TITLE CO

5900 SAWMILL RD
Dublin

FIRST AMERICAN TITLE CO

341 S 3RD ST
Columbus

FIRST AMERICAN TITLE CO

1388 CHERRY BOTTOM RD
Columbus

FIRST CLASS CLOSINGS

32 W HOSTER ST
Columbus

FIRST LIBERTY LAND TITLE

2600 OAKSTONE DR
Columbus

FOCUS TITLE

200 E CAMPUS VIEW BLVD
Columbus

FOUR CORNERS SEARCH SVC

556 Butler Ave
Columbus

FRANKLIN TITLE AGENCY

450 W WILSON BRIDGE RD
Columbus

FREEDOM TITLE AGENCY INC

2676 BILLINGSLEY RD
Columbus

GALLANT & GALLANT

632 S LAZELLE ST
Columbus

GOLDEN TITLE AGENCY

5329 N HIGH ST
Columbus

GREAT AMERICAN TITLE AGENCY

6800 Lauffer Rd Ste B
Columbus

GREATER COLUMBUS TITLE CO

88 W MOUND ST
Columbus

Green Tree

345 Saint Peter St

H E R REAL ESTATE

77 E NATIONWIDE BLVD
Columbus

HENDERSON TITLE AGENCY

100 E Wilson Bridge Rd Ste 105
Columbus

HILLTOP LAND TITLE AGENCY

2904 W BROAD ST
Columbus

HOME SECURITY TITLE

2550 CORPORATE EXCHANGE DR
Columbus

HUMMEL TITLE AGENCY

2154 E Main St Ste 301
Columbus

HUMMEL TITLE AGENCY INC

21 E STATE ST
Columbus

INDEPENDENT TITLE SVC

729 S FRONT ST
Columbus

INTEGRITY TITLE AGENCY LLC

8101 N HIGH ST
Columbus

INVESTERS FIRST TITLE AGENCY

65 PARSONS AVE
Columbus

LAND & MORTGAGE TITLE AGENCY

24 E GAY ST
Columbus

LAND AMERICA LAWYERS TITLE

5665 N HAMILTON RD
Columbus

LAND AMERICA LAWYERS TITLE

8101 N HIGH ST
Columbus

LANDSEL TITLE AGENCY INC

961 N HAMILTON RD
Columbus

LAWYERS TITLE COMMERCIAL DIV

1 W NATIONWIDE BLVD
Columbus

LEGACY LAND TITLE

100 E Wilson Bridge Rd Ste 105
Columbus

M B TITLE

399 E MAIN ST
Columbus

MAGEE TITLE AGENCY LLC

1103 SCHROCK RD
Columbus

MANOR TITLE LLC

8101 N HIGH ST
Columbus

MARINERES TITLE AGENCY LLC

250 W OLD WILSON BRIDGE RD
Columbus

METROPOLITAN TITLE CO CENTRAL

1580 FISHINGER RD
Columbus

MEYMAX TITLE AGENCY

32 W HOSTER ST
Columbus

NATIONS LENDING SVC

6363 PRESIDENTIAL GTWY
Columbus

NATIONS TITLE AGENCY

6525 BUSCH BLVD
Columbus

NATIONS TITLE AGENCY

3700 Corporate Dr Ste 200
Columbus

NATIONS TITLE AGENCY

6343 PRESIDENTIAL GTWY
Columbus

NEW HORIZONS LAND TITLE LLC

850 KING AVE
Columbus

noAppdeals

PO Box 2415
Newark

NORDIC TITLE AGENCY

760 Morrison Rd
Columbus

NORTHWEST TITLE

4200 Regent St Ste 210
Columbus

NVR Inc

11700 Plaza American Dr

OHIO BAR TITLE INSURANCE CO

8740 Orion Pl Ste 310
Columbus

OHIO EXECUTIVE TITLE

3400 N HIGH ST
Columbus

OHIO LAND TITLE AGENCY

1105 SCHROCK RD
Columbus

OHIO TITLE CORP

1900 Polaris Pkwy Ste 450
Columbus

OLD NATIONAL TITLE OF COLUMBUS

250 W OLD WILSON BRIDGE
Columbus

ORANGE TITLE LLC

8000 RAVINES EDGE CT
Columbus

PEOPLES CHOICE TITLE AGENCY

32 W HOSTER ST
Columbus

PILLAR TITLE AGENCY

3857 N HIGH ST
Columbus

PM Title, LLC

3800 Broadway
Grove City

PREFERRED TITLE & GUARANTY

291 E LIVINGSTON AVE
Columbus

PRINCIPLE TITLE AGENCY

4200 Regent St Ste 210
Columbus

PRITSOLAS TITLE

373 S HIGH ST
Columbus

PURE TITLE AGENCY LTD

3386 SNOUFFER RD
Columbus

QUALITY CHOICE TITLE

1670 FISHINGER RD
Columbus

QUALITY CHOICE TITLE

8351 N HIGH ST
Columbus

REALLIVING HER

4183 PARKWAY CENTRE
Grove City

RELIABLE RESEARCH

373 S HIGH ST
Columbus

RLM TITLE AGENCY INC

5686 OLIVER ST
Columbus

SCIOTANGY TITLE INC

5151 REED RD
Columbus

SOUTHERN TITLE AGENCY-COLUMBUS

3400 N HIGH ST
Columbus

STERLING TITLE AGENCY

100 E Wilson Bridge Rd Ste 105
Columbus

SUPERIOR LAND TITLE AGENCY INC

6797 N HIGH ST
Columbus

TITAN LAND TITLE LLC

909 W 5TH AVE
Columbus

TITLE AGENCY OF WORTHINGTON

77 E Wilson Bridge Rd Ste 101
Columbus

TITLE CO LTD

1824 E BROAD ST
Columbus

TITLE FIRM

399 E MAIN ST
Columbus

Title First Agency

250 E Town St
Columbus

TITLE FIRST AGENCY INC

6641 N HIGH ST
Columbus

TITLE FIRST AGENCY INC

4740 REED RD
Columbus

TITLE FIRST AGENCY INC

999 POLARIS PKWY
Columbus

TITLE FIRST AGENCY INC

555 S FRONT ST
Columbus

TITLE LINK

500 W WILSON BRIDGE RD
Columbus

TITLE PRO

200 E Campus View Blvd Ste 200
Columbus

Total Title Services, LLC

7333 East Livingston Avenue Suite D

TOWER CITY TITLE AGENCY

438 E WILSON BRIDGE RD
Columbus

TOWER CITY TITLE AGENCY

200 E CAMPUS VIEW BLVD
Columbus

TRANS OHIO RESIDENTIAL TITLE

3 EASTON OVAL
Columbus

TRIDENT TITLE AGENCY INC

33 N High St Ste 702
Columbus

UNITED RESEARCH NETWORK LTD

3620 N HIGH ST
Columbus

UNITED SEARCH ASSOC

373 S HIGH ST
Columbus

UNITY TITLE

1720 ZOLLINGER RD
Columbus

VALMER LAND TITLE AGENCY

1 E CAMPUS VIEW BLVD
Columbus

VANGUARD TITLE AGENCY LLC

8000 RAVINES EDGE CT
Columbus

VILLAGE COMMUNITIES LLC

250 CIVIC CENTER DR
Columbus

WILLIAMSON TITLE AGENCY INC

1 Amazon Pl
Columbus

WINTER LAND TITLE CO

600 S HIGH ST
Columbus

Xclusive Home

7652 Sawmill Rd.
Dublin

Shop Local Title Company Services in Columbus

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Columbus.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Title
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money