Columbus Caterers

in Columbus, OH

Catering Reviews in Columbus

A

Rating
It was a great experience. From the website, to emailing
to eating the delicious food, everything was great. Planning a 1st birthday party was a big deal for me. A caterer I was going to use (a friends recommendation) went out of business. I google caterers in my area and found
. After reading several reviews, mostly from wedding receptions, I decided to email.
called the next day and it was so easy working with him. He was very organized and knowledgeable and made excellent recommendations. Two gentlemen delivered the food at the time requested and set everything up. They were so nice and helpful. The food was delicious. All of my guests raved about it. Just served salads, sandwiches fruit and veggies but even
items were mouth watering.
's recommendations on the amount needed were spot on. It was so nice to be able to relax and enjoy my son's party. That alone was worth the money to me. I will definitely use them again for future events.
- Mindy H.
A

Rating
I have used
before after a recommendation from a reception center. I was having an outdoor reception at my home for 75 adults and children. The theme was a picnic and the guests of honor were vegetarian. When I contacted
about the party, I didn't know what I could have that wouldn't make the vegetarian food look like a side dish. He had great suggestions and we ended up with skewers of meat, shrimp and tofu that looked and tasted wonderful.
had suggested hot dogs for the children and the adults ate those too. The side dishes were wonderful and the morning breakfast of quiches, cinnamon rolls and a gorgeous fruit platter made the day. I can't recommend this caterer highly enough. He is so accommodating, down to earth, professional and a wonderful chef.
- MARGUERITE W.

Columbus Catering Articles

Catering reviews in Columbus

A

Rating
My wedding was at the Vault in downtown Columbus on Gay St. When meeting with the owner of the venue he highly suggested
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
for
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
and I am so glad he did! I set up an appointment to taste her food and tell her about what I would like to have (which was unique!). She was 100% supportive of everything I wanted and was priced beyond fairly for the quality of food she serves. The day of the even she was on time and always around when someone needed her. Her staff was also very nice! On top of the normal hors d'oeuvres that
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
made, my husband and I also wanted to have our favorite foods. So, they picked up the 150 chicken fingers from
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
' Canes and put out the pizza that was delivered from Hound Dog's. I felt like most people would have laughed at me, but she was so supportive and thought it would be fun! Then dinner came, I was SO impressed. We ordered
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
, veggie and regular, several different pastas and salads. The salads we beautiful and marked very clearly so everyone could get what they wanted. It was well above my expectation. Then near the end of dinner
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
was so worried about running out of
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
(because it was that amazing everyone wanted more!) and I thought that was very sweet! There was plenty of food for everyone, but I found it very touching she was worried about running out of just one item. Her staff cleaned up the place in no time and we were off to our honeymoon the next day! When I returned I was mortified to hear from
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
that one of my guests dates had broken one of her tables. She was very pleasant about it when she didn't have to be. I sent her the check along with a thank you note. I HIGHLY suggest you use
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
and her staff for your event. She will not disappoint!
- Melissa J.
A

Rating
We made the order a few days in advance and picked it up at noon on the party date. The roasted boneless turkey was of very high quality and was sliced fairly thick. It was placed on two plastic plates with plenty of very fresh lettuce and thick orange slices. We didn't need to add any decoration to the plates, which were served as the main dish at our potluck party to welcome visitors from Europe. The party was a great success.
- JAMES & MUTSUYO U.
A

Rating
My husband and I wanted to have a party for our 40th wedding anniversary. We booked a hall at our church and the administrator gave us a list of acceptable caterers. When asked pointedly who was the best, she gave us some recommendations. At first, I had trouble getting in contact with
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
. After initial contact, though, he was easy to reach and offered helpful suggestions for the kind of party that we wanted. He suggested some dishes and we agreed to his suggestions. We touched base on the phone and met personally several times before the event. I provided some of the plates, the wine, soda and beer to cut down on expenses. The party was following an evening mass. The appetizer table was set before we got there and I have NEVER seen a more beautiful vegetable tray arrangement. The meal was beautiful and best of all delicious. We had chicken piccata, and the chicken breasts were moist and wonderful. The Strawberry Mandarin Orange Cream Torte, which is the only dessert that he makes, was unbelievably beautiful and again delicious. The servers were helpful and efficient. The bar was even set up attractively. We never felt rushed or as though if we got up to dance, our half eaten cake would be gone. Our guests commented on that also. I have hosted 2 daughters' weddings. I have never had the compliments or inquiries about the caterer before. It has been a week since the party and people are still commenting about the food. He even gave some of the people his recipe for the chicken. I wish I had known about him before. I enthusiastically recommend
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
and will use him again whenever I can.
- MARGUERITE W.
A

Rating
I was in a tight spot because the restaurant doesn't open until 10:30 am on Sundays and the party started at 11 am. I explained this to the manager and he offered to let me pick up the food at 10 am instead which was wonderful! The food was great, tons of it and the guests all raved.
- EMILIE D.
A

Rating
Extremely well. This catering company goes all out. Their prices are amazingly reasonable, and they go the extra mile with small touches (flowers, table cloths). The food is delicious. We ordered hot food (pecan-encrusted chicken breasts) and it stayed hot. They had a varied menu. We really liked using this company.
- Sue H.
A

Rating
This was the first time we had used her services. We chose her because our kids go to school together and I found out that she caters and called her when we decided to have a party. She was really really good. It was beautifully done. We had hors d'oeuvre, two entr es- garlic and
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
beef tenderloin and grilled salmon with lime
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
sauce. She did asparagus in Dijon
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
vinaigrette, garlic mashed potatoes, and lovely frosted cookies with the date and our names on them, a chocolate fountain and fresh fruit and assorted dessert bars. Everything was perfect. There was the right amount of food and people are still telling me a year later how good the food was.
- SUZANNE H.
A

Rating
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
and
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
were fabulous.
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
asked all the necessary questions and my preferences. We set up meeting to discuss table arrangements and seating arrangements. The set up of the the venue was different than we expected and she handled it perfectly! She's knowledgeable and dependable. The food provided was excellent. We did a tasting prior to hiring them. The tasting was good and we went with them more because we trusted
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
but the food was amazing. They did a lot of coordination work as well...placing seating cards, table numbers, photographs, etc. They were great!
- Cathy B.
F

Rating
On September 28th, I received a call from Ms
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
to schedule a tasting for my 04/08 wedding reception (my mother and future mother-in-law were present during this conversation). At the end of the conversation I had understood the tasting to be held on October 8th. I informed my mother-in-law immediately, as she needed to cancel an appointment to attend the tasting. On Oct. 1st I received a voicemail from Ms
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
wondering where I was. I called her back as soon as I received the mess. Ms
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
's
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
of voice was one of distaste and not the least bit understanding. I throughly apologized if I had made the mistake, however Ms
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
continued to act as if I had stood her up. Not once did Ms
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
say she may have misunderstood. The issue: Ms
Columbus Caterers Provider Name Locked
must not work well when things go wrong unexpectedly, it was about her not the customer! I would not feel confident in her ability to handle my wedding reception. To this date she has not called me to reschedule, as she said she would.
- Lisa E.
110% Guaranteed Money Back

We think we're the best, and we can prove it.

Try an annual plan and if you want to cancel in your first year, we'll refund you 110%

Annual Plans Only

All Caterers in Columbus, OH

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order. To view top rated service providers along with reviews and ratings, Join Angie's List Now!

ARMANDO'S CATERING CO

1048 MORSE RD
Columbus, OH

ASIAN CONCEPTS INC

3120 Valleyview Dr
Columbus, OH

AVI DININD SVC

212 DUFF ST
Gambier, OH

BARBECUE CATERING BY ART YOHO

3088 WESTERVILLE RD
Columbus, OH

BASEMENT ROCK CLUB

391 NEIL AVE
Columbus, OH

BELLA DOMA

38 S HAMILTON RD
Columbus, OH

BELLISARI'S A CATERING CO

1433 W 3RD AVE
Columbus, OH

BENNY'S GOURMET LUNCHES

33 S JAMES RD
Columbus, OH

BERKSHIRE PARTY HOUSE

1848 ALEXANDER RD
Sunbury, OH

Berwick Manor Banquet Center & Catering

3250 Refugee Rd
Columbus, OH

BLUE MOON MEETING ROOM

1604 GATEWAY CIR
Grove City, OH

BOLTON FIELD GOLF CONCESSIONS

4632 SCENIC DR
Columbus, OH

BRAVO DEVELOPMENT

4644 KENNY RD
Columbus, OH

BREWMASTERS GATE

21 E STATE ST
Columbus, OH

BRIDGEWATER BANQUET

10561 SAWMILL PKWY
Powell, OH

BRYN DU MANSION

537 JONES RD
Granville, OH

BUCKEYE BOYS BBQ

28 NOBLE ST
Delaware, OH

BUCKINGHAM HOUSE

5 N 6TH ST
Newark, OH

CAFE COURIER

999 BETHEL RD
Columbus, OH

CAMERON MITCHELL RESTAURANTS

515 PARK ST
Columbus, OH

Join Angie's List to get the best local reviews in Columbus.

What Does My Membership Include?
  • Instant access to reviews for 700+ services
  • Exclusive service discounts - up to 70 percent off!
  • Top-notch support from our live call center
How does Angie's List work?
1. Say you need a Caterer
2. Angie's List has tons of detailed, local reviews.
3. Find a winner, and book them.
4. Angie's List is there to resolve any issues.
CBS
Good Morning America
Fox News
USA Today
The Wall Street Journal
MSN money