Find a countertop that fits your style and budget

Countertops come in a variety of materials, sure to fit any budget. (Photo courtesy of Angie's List member Joshua A. of Clifton Park N.Y.)

Countertops come in a variety of materials, sure to fit any budget. (Photo courtesy of Angie's List member Joshua A. of Clifton Park N.Y.)

Kitchen and bathroom remodels remain among your best choices for gaining the best return on your investment. According to the National Association of Realtors’ 2010 Cost vs. Value Report, a major kitchen remodel can return nearly 69 percent on your investment, and a remodeled bathroom can yield 64.

One of the quickest ways to give your kitchen or bathroom a new look is to upgrade the countertops. That one small change can mean the difference between making a sale or extending the time your home remains on the market.

Though kitchens and bathrooms can bring in the greatest returns, they can be two of the most expensive areas to remodel. If trying to spend a reasonable amount, consider these budget-friendly countertop materials suggested by the International Surface Fabricators Association:

High-pressure laminate: Likely the least expensive option, a decorative laminate, which is manufactured by many companies, often gets a bad rap for the perception that it’s cheap plastic. The ISFA says most laminates are made up of paper that has been pressed between plastic resins using heat, which then is bonded to a firmer material like particle board or plywood.

Popular among homeowners because of its durability and design versatility, laminates come in a wide variety of colors and textures that mimic high-end granites, marbles and slates. Laminates also allow the appearance of materials that aren’t as kitchen-friendly, such as hardwoods. They also can be configured into unique patterns.

Highly rated Fab-Tex Countertops installed a Formica countertop in Chris Lanman’s kitchen. The homeowner says the countertop looks very similar to black slate. He has nothing but good words about his new countertop and his Grand Prairie, Texas, countertop installers.

“We are so pleased with their professionalism and expertise, and love our new look,” Lanman says.

Tile: Tiles are available in a variety of materials, from recycled glass to handmade porcelain. Like some other options, its shape and coloring can be left to the imagination of the homeowner. Cost will vary depending on the size of the tiles, size of the countertop and quality of material.

Concrete: This is an increasingly popular option, because of the homeowner’s ability to customize it according to color and design. ISFA reports that concrete countertops are desirable because rocks, shells or colored glass can be added. While this modern option may be popular, it will likely cost the homeowner more per square footage compared to laminate and tile. Concrete countertops are extremely durable but also lend a nice aesthetic alternative to more conventional kitchen countertops.

Wood: If you're interested in a more traditional and rustic look, an oak butcher-block countertop is an inexpensive option. This option might require more maintenance than other countertop materials. Wax or oil treatments might help prolong the life of a wood countertop.

While you’re shopping for new countertops, be sure to tell the contractor you’re working with a budget. Homeowner Norma Wheeler explained to Limpus Cabinet Sales Co., Inc., her Indianapolis countertop installation company, that she was on a budget and was shown several options of materials.

"[I] decided not to go with granite or solid [countertop] surface, since they had several nice laminates that achieved the look I wanted but enabled me to buy a better grade cabinet," she says.

If the contractor or company can’t provide you options that meet your budget or are unable to work in a price range in which you feel comfortable, check Angie’s List to find more countertop installation companies near you that can help you achieve the perfect look.


The article did state theses were lower cost options, but I agree with the others that if you're going to cover countertops, cover it thoroughly and completely. Thanks.

It would indeed be both good for business and consumers if Angies List provided some product comparison for various price ranges. That information is quite difficult to find locally. Angie's List is helpful but you can do more project based articles for the first timers such as myself. I like the idea of cutting costs where quality isn't an issue and splurging on one or two things that will just make me very happy. And, although a member of consumer reports, I'm not finding them as helpful with home project needs.

I was a fool to think Angie's list was of any value at all and this unprofessional piece proves it.

take me of this list please

I agree with Paul. I am in the process of choosing a new countertop for our kitchen and this article left so many viable materials out that it was not helpful at all.

This unfortunately is a puff piece, perfect for the Parade insert in the Sunday paper, but not useful at all for subscribers to Angie's List who, most probably, joined because they have a pending project. No articles would be better than useless articles because the puff pieces are diminishing the Angie's List brand.

agree with Paul what about marble? and old fashioned mexican yile blocks? article was shallow Thanks for listening Ben

Perhaps granite, soapstone, solid surface, quartz, and Paperstone do not fit the author's definition of "budget-friendly" options of which one can expect to spend a "reasonable amount."


I agree with Paul Lyman: this article is minimally helpful. How about a graph with pros and cons of various countertop choices?

Please share with me, your reply to Paul Lyman's question(s) dated 1/4/1212.

Why in the world would you offer an article prurporting to help find the right countertop and not list granite, soapstone, solid surface (Corian) or quartz (Silestone, etc.)? Not to mention rarer alternatives such as Paperstone? What was the pont of the article?

Please remove me from your mailing list..

Add comment


What is Angie's List?

Angie’s List is the trusted site where more than 3 million households go to get ratings and reviews on everything from home repair to health care. Stop guessing when it comes to hiring! Check Angie’s List to find out who does the best work in town.

Local Discounts

Daily deals up to 70% off popular home improvement projects from top-rated contractors on Angie’s List!