Steam heat system repairs require finesse


by Matthew Brady

Before finding an expert contractor, Angie's List member Elisabeth Tien of Sudbury, Mass., hardly needed an alarm clock in the winter. The steam heat in her 1790 home did the job about 3 or 4 o'clock most mornings.

"The heat would hit the cold pipes and it would do that cracking sound," she says. "A lot of people think that's normal, but it was really loud."

The systems - common throughout Boston and the Northeast - involve a boiler in the basement that forces steam up into radiators in each room.

Builders stopped installing them in the 1940s, says Charlie Lovett, owner of highly rated Lovett Plumbing & Heating of Arlington, Mass. "It's considered prehistoric and it's very inefficient," he says. But the systems are found in many older homes, so Lovett taught himself how to repair them.

Massachusetts doesn't require a contractor to have a hydronics license to work on home steam heat, but a licensed plumber or HVAC specialist is often needed to repair them.

Tien says she called four or five plumbers before hiring highly rated Trethewey Brothers Inc. in Boston. "Everybody had a different story about how to fix it," she says. "He knew what he was doing and it was done. No more sound." The repair required pitching a pipe at the right angle to allow the steam and condensation to move through the system.

Noise is the No. 1 complaint, contractors say, but they add that a properly set-up system should be virtually silent. "Many of them have been altered in ways that make it very difficult to keep them working the way they should have been working," says Dennis Foley of highly rated Dennis Foley Plumbing in Somerville, Mass. The main advantage to steam heat, he says, is that it is often cheaper to keep it running than to replace it with a modern system that could cost $20,000 or more.

Lovett also says that compared with a forced-air system, a radiant system such as steam can help allergy sufferers because air is not stirring up dust.

Steam heat isn't cheap, however. Tien says during the coldest part of the winter, she spends between $500 and $700 every three weeks on oil for her boiler. "It's pretty tough in the winter," she says. "It's not economical."

The pressure setting on a steam boiler is something homeowners should pay attention to, says Dan Holohan, a contributor to Old House Journal and founder of heatinghelp.com. "It's all about venting. The air has to get out before the steam can travel," he says. "Often when they can't get the air out of the system, they'll just automatically crank up the pressure, which kills the fuel bill. The Empire State Building runs on about a pound and a half of pressure, and yet a knucklehead will crank the pressure in somebody's house up to 5 or 6 pounds. Houses are meant to run literally on ounces of pressure.

 

Comments

The high cost of heat is not because of the delivery system (steam radiators) It is because the boiler is inefficient and the home is probably leaky and poorly insulated

We have a very efficient boiler furnace, baseboard radiators (very unobtrusive) and it is fed with natural gas - similar to forced hot air. I think it is a more comfortable heat - not so dry and yes, less dust. We are in the northeast and pay similar to our neighbors with forced hot air. It is a good alternative.

We've insulated our house, replaced windows and installed the most efficient gas fired steam boiler we could find (about 84% AFUE) - this has made the house much easier to heat, more comfortable, and because of insulation improvements we were able to downsize the boiler from 150Kbtu/hr input to 112K. We have reduced our fuel consumption by about 35% or so, and system has sufficient capacity to keep us quite warm on 0 degree days.

I hope Ms. Tien considers both replacing her boiler and insulating her home. I suspect she'll be plesantly surprised. I replaced my original boiler (it was converted to oil from coal in the 1940s and was quite the monster), and insulated the house. My oil consumption has dropped in half- and that includes raising the thermostat a couple of degrees, too! (Ms. Tien may also wish to consider her windows. I am in the process of replacing windows, now. In the interim, I continue to seal the original ones for additional oomfort.)

we bought the steam system by choice. It's even heat, no menopausal gusts of heat then cold waiting for thermostat to kick furnace blower in. Done right, it's efficient, noiseless, effortless, comfortable heat. Guess that's why it's used in Canada too. Builders stopped installing them in the 40's?? Yes typical alternatives are much less costly, i believe that's why "builders" stopped installing them. P.S. my neighbors just had theirs replaced...it was installed in 1905.

Steam Heat has some advantages. The cast iron radiators hold heat for a long period of time. Steam radiators release steam (humidity) into the air. The down sides are no zone control, high radiator temps, large volume of water to heat (compared to a hot water system) Generally low efficiency boilers. 85% AFUE or less. If you have a two pipe steam system, you should consider converting to a hot water system, especially if the boiler needs to be replaced. If you have a 1 pipe system- you are stuck with steam heat or an expensive conversion.

Steam heat systems are as, or more, economical to operate and comfortable as other systems. The earlier post claiming otherwise is by a writer that has a poorly insulated home or a low efficiency oil system. Steam beats forced air every time.

Add new comment

What is Angie's List

Angie’s List is the trusted spot where more than 1 million members go to get ratings and reviews on everything from home repair to health care. Stop guessing when it comes to hiring! Check Angie’s List to find out who does the best work in town.

Local Discounts

Daily deals up to 70% off popular home improvement projects from top-rated contractors on Angie’s List!