Should I Repair or Replace a Broken Window Seal?

Angie's List member Ralph M. of Pasadena, Texas, replaced this window after a broken seal made it appear cloudy.

Angie's List member Ralph M. of Pasadena, Texas, replaced this window after a broken seal made it appear cloudy.

Dear Angie: Can low-E/argon gas be put in a window when the seal is broken, instead of replacing the entire window? – P.T., Philadelphia

Dear P.T.: Let’s start by clarifying the purpose of low-E and argon gas. Low-E (low-emissivity) coating is applied to window glass to help reflect heat. Adding argon gas between the panes of glass adds increased insulation to the window. Combined, they offer excellent energy efficiency for your home. A seal failure, though, will "oxidize" the low-E coating and argon gas, making the glass appear streaky or foggy.

Technically, yes, gas could be added to the window. However, from a practical standpoint, it might not be the best solution. The process to add the low-E coating and argon gas is an involved process typically done at the factory. However, some window repair companies have begun offering service at a customer’s home to correct a seal failure. These companies typically remove the insulated glass from the sash – the section of the window that holds the glass – and then reseal the spacer perimeter to prevent it from additional fogging. This is still relatively new technology, so before you go that route, be sure you’re going to get a guarantee.

RELATED: How Much Does it Cost to Replace Windows?

Typically, older double-pane windows consist of two panes of glass held together with caulk. With the glass expanding and contracting due to the weather, the seal would often fail, creating moisture in the windows. High quality replacement windows now typically use a glazing bead spacer that helps hold the glass in place, but moves with the glass, which helps eliminate that issue. If a window is equipped with a glazing bead, it is possible to remove the glazing bead, remove the glass, and have it replaced or remade into a new sealed unit that is a low-E/argon combination.

If the window is not equipped with a glazing bead, it’s likely the sash was constructed or assembled around the glass. If this is the case, it can be very difficult or altogether impossible to replace the glass.

foggy window due to broken window seal
This photo shows how Ralph M.'s window looked before the replacment job.

While it might be possible to replace the glass with a low-E/argon-filled glass, you should consider if the repair is worth the investment. A better option might be replacing the entire window with a newer window that is airtight and already equipped with the low-E/argon glass combination.

If you’re set against changing out the entire window, adding a new insulated pane of glass might be the most economical and practical way to go. Qualified window repair specialists in your area should be able to suggest a few different options that can work for your specific situation. Be sure to check out the company’s reputation before you hire.

Editor's note: This is an updated version of an article that was originally published on May 29, 2012.


Angie Hicks is founder of www.AngiesList.com, provider of consumer reviews and services. Email questions to askangie@angieslist.com or tweet #AskAngie. Follow her @Angie_Hicks.


More Like This

Low-e film and argon gas increase window insulation

52bb2bca-3980-4eeb-ba12-b40bc6808dfb.jpg

Ask your window installer about energy efficiency options. | Photo courtesy of Amy Summerville
Ask your window installer about energy efficiency options. | Photo courtesy of Amy Summerville

An expert window installer explains how low-e window film and argon gas provide superior insulation.

Add comment

Deals
Anonymous reviews are Internet graffiti.  Angie's List has real reviews from real people.

What is Angie's List?

Angie’s List is the trusted site where more than 2 million households go to get ratings and reviews on everything from home repair to health care. Stop guessing when it comes to hiring! Check Angie’s List to find out who does the best work in town.

Local Discounts

Daily deals up to 70% off popular home improvement projects from top-rated contractors on Angie’s List!