How I transformed a dirty house into my dream home: Part One

by Melyssa Donaghy

As a single woman, taking on a large older home with endless cosmetic issues, neglected yard, sky high utility bills and a myriad of mechanical problems was daunting. Actually, it was terrifying.

I am one those people who would never feel fulfilled living anywhere but in an old house. I learned that without renovation experience or unlimited cash, anyone can create a dream home by taking small bites at a time, learning as you go.

I was lucky. My realtor, Nanci Haber’s prime directive for me was “location, location, location.” After six months on the hunt, and declaration I would not live anywhere less pleasing to me than my downtown apartment, my realtor was at her wits end. Like most house hunters, I had champagne taste on a beer budget.

One day, she told me about a neglected property on a beautiful avenue in one of Indiana’s most prestigious historic neighborhoods. I hated the house with its chalky white crumbling stucco, glossy black trim, cracked plaster, crusty peeling woodwork, painted-over wallpaper, ground-draping tree limbs and ugly carpet which hid the hardwoods. The Berber carpet was everywhere except the kitchen, bath and a six-foot square patch in the foyer where large granite tiles were mortared directly to the hardwood floor. Ironically, the selling agent marketed both the granite foyer and Berber carpet.

I could not see the potential in the house, but my realtor convinced me that I could take it on and transform it over time. She expertly advised that the property was my golden opportunity.

The math made sense. I needed the tax deduction and could afford the down payment and mortgage. It was $50,000 less than comparable homes.

It had a functional bath and decent working kitchen. I had a view of gorgeous well-maintained 1920’s mansions with park sized lots. I made the seller put on a new roof by exclaiming to my realtor there was no way I would move into a house with an 18 year old roof. I later learned she believed I would lose the house by making the demand. As it turned out, the seller was indeed motivated enough to meet the request.

I moved into a big dirty house with good bones in August 1998. I was so overwhelmed that I cried on that day. Then, I began its transformation with what I knew. I cleaned.

Over this series of monthly columns, I will share the details of my projects beginning with my early contractor mistakes before I accessed Angie’s List for referrals.

Angie's List advertising representative Melyssa Donaghy purchased a Prairie style stucco home in the Indianapolis historic neighborhood of Meridian Kessler in 1998. The home had “great bones,” but was a neglected eyesore. It is one of many gracious properties across the nation transformed by Angie's List remodeling contractors.

More Like This

How I transformed a dirty house into my dream home: Part Two


The finished product for this sparkling bathroom was far from where it started.
Photo by Lindy Keyser
The finished product for this sparkling bathroom was far from where it started. Photo by Lindy Keyser

Columnist says a desirable 1920s home must have a first-level half-bath.

Add comment


What is Angie's List?

Angie’s List is the trusted site where more than 3 million households go to get ratings and reviews on everything from home repair to health care. Stop guessing when it comes to hiring! Check Angie’s List to find out who does the best work in town.

Local Discounts

Daily deals up to 70% off popular home improvement projects from top-rated contractors on Angie’s List!