Bathtub refinishing too dangerous for DIY


Question: We've had our bathtub resurfaced twice, but with three kids it doesn't hold up well. It has peeled entirely off the bottom of the tub and is peeling away from the walls. I'd like it gone. How can I remove it?

Answer: Paul Burns, from the highly-rated Porcelain Tub Restorations in Bowie, Md., says that you can get hurt trying to do this yourself.

"You need a respirator and proper ventilation equipment. If you try to remove the peeling coating yourself you can pass out or burn yourself," Burns says. The products needed to remove the coating are very strong and can also melt and damage other parts of the bathroom.

“It’s important to look at why this failed before. There’s probably an issue – there could be previous damage that wasn’t repaired correctly or they didn’t use the proper primer or pull the drain. If the bathtub refinishing was done properly and if the tub was etched correctly, a good primer and topcoat were applied, and the drain was removed, the tub should last at least five years and up to 15," Burns says. 

If the kids are playing with hard toys in the bathtub and banging them against the tub and the walls, even a good refinished tub wouldn't be able to hold up. He suggests giving the kids softer toys.

The process is intensive and it can be hard to tell how hard stripping the tub is going to be ahead of time. Burns says that to strip a tub they charge $100 an hour, which includes labor and materials.

"Once it is stripped, you can see what it is like and then decide whether you want to keep it or get it done properly," he says.

Comments

I agree with everything Mr. Burns said in your article "Dangerous Bathtub Repair" except for the final comment. If your tub is an older tub (which most glazed tubs are) and you strip it down to its previously etched surface it may be leaching lead. I would not recommend leaving it in an unglazed condition. At the very least you should purchase a lead test kit to confirm there is no leaching lead, whether you have children in the house or not. We have been glazing tubs in Stamford, CT since 1971 and have not left one stripped tub unglazed. It's just not worth the risk with an older tub.

We regalze tubs all the time here in NYC, because of the complexity of replacing,cost and of course the old tubs are much stronger and bigger..I have used a company here for over 25 years,and never had a tub peel,chip,crack ,or yellow..My clients here in NYC are always very pleased..Thank you Kevin Klepper A-1 Home Improver Constr.Co.NYC

Mr. Burns is correct except that leaving the old tub without a professional finish will make it hard to clean. I have been reglazing tub professionally in Connecticut since 1996 and all my jobs have lasted since I started. Tub reglazing is not a DIY job as the proper preparation equipment and top coat reglazing materials are not available to an untrained professional.

Just go the Home Depot and buy a recoating kit for $30.00 I have used it on a victorian tub, and the results were great! Sorry, but professionals have been telling me for your I can't do all the work I have done in my house! Of course they will tell you that!

In response to Gregory's comments: I can't count the number of clients I have made for LIFE after they have bought a home kit from home depot. Except for those doing a tub in a rental, where they don't care what it looks like, all have not liked the results. It is very difficult to get a nice finish that makes your tub look like it is brand new (not glazed) without spraying it on. The difference is dramatic. The whole point to glazing is that others will never know you glazed the tub, it just looks new to them. A brushed on kit never gets that result.

My house was built in 1948 and by now, all of the windows have been painted shut. Is it possible to have my tub redone w/o having an open window? Vacating the house for a day or two would be difficult as I have pets.

Being a competitor of his, I couldn't agree more on his comments that it should be left to a professional. We strip and refinish more tubs than I care to mention that were done with the "home kit". It's like getting a can of spray paint to paint your car. It can be done, but never well. Refinishing a tub can be done, but unless you know the proper techniques to prepare the tub, it will eventually peel and never hold up well. The refinishing industry has gone under extreme changes with the technology available today, from molecular bonding agents to the coatings themselves. While the DIY kits serve a purpose as some stated here, getting a professional result can only be done by a professional.

Another option to refinishing is to use a bathtub liner. These liners go over old steel and cast iron tubs and carry a lifetime product guarantee. Refinishing is cheaper - but the liners provide a quality alternative you don't have to redo in a number of years.

Agreed. I've been reglazing bathtubs since 1993 and have stripped hundreds of tubs that have been "painted" with that worthless epoxy kit that Home Depot sells. There is no way to get proper adhesion due to the fact that they supply no etching supplies or primer. Further, due to the fact that the brushed-on finish is an epoxy, it yellows within the first year(that is, whatever hasn't peeled!).

i would like to remodel my home could you seen me a catalog

Add new comment

What is Angie's List

Angie’s List is the trusted spot where more than 1 million members go to get ratings and reviews on everything from home repair to health care. Stop guessing when it comes to hiring! Check Angie’s List to find out who does the best work in town.

More Like This

Video: Bathtub Refinishing Tips

Should you refinish or replace your bathtub? Refinishing your bathtub can freshen up the look of your bathroom and also keep your wallet from taking too much of a hit. Bathtub refinishers from Bowie, Md. and Plymouth, Minn., explain the process and give tips on maintaining a tub's finish.

Local Discounts

Daily deals up to 70% off popular home improvement projects from top-rated contractors on Angie’s List!