5 reasons you shouldn't cut down a tree

While removing a tree is always an option, it may have adverse effects (Photo courtesy of Kal Perry)

While removing a tree is always an option, it may have adverse effects (Photo courtesy of Kal Perry)

There are plenty of good reasons to remove a tree from your property, but sometimes unnecessarily removing a tree can have adverse consequences. We spoke to certified arborists and tree service experts from around the country who provided these reasons to reconsider cutting down or removing a tree.

1. The tree can be saved

If the tree has a treatable disease or pest issue, homeowners shouldn’t automatically consider tree removal as their only option, says Wes Kocher, a resource manager with the International Society of Arboriculture.  

Hiring a tree service with a certified arborist on staff can help you assess a tree’s overall health and provide possible treatments that can save the tree.

2. Lower energy bills

“If the tree is near the house and provides a significant amount of shade, it can lower that AC bill,” says Tim B. Pruett, Sr. of American Tree Service in Austin.

Tim Young of Tim Young Tree Service in Charlotte  agrees that shade from trees can reduce a utility bill by cutting the amount of energy needed to cool a home, but suggests that homeowners think about how trees can help in the winter by providing a windbreak. “Ideally, the best place to plant evergreens is on the north side of the house,” he says. “This can reduce the chill of the north winds [in winter], which can also reduce the power bill.”

3. Improved curb appeal and property value

If your tree improves the look of your home – and its value – think twice before removing it. “Well chosen, well-kept trees immediately draw the eye to the house and its character,” Young says. “A well designed landscape with appropriate trees will always draw a higher selling price than a lot with no trees or ill-chosen trees. If the tree you have enhances what you already have, by all means, keep the tree!”

This consideration is especially important for older, larger trees, says Lorenzo Romero of RF Tree Service in Houston. "A beautiful big tree takes 4 to 5 decades or more to grow," he says. "Is it worth it?"

4. Loss of privacy

Trees not only provide power savings, they can also provide privacy, particulary for homes on smaller lots. “This is a huge concern for customers when they have to remove a tree that they wish they didn’t have to – they have to give up some privacy,” says Trevor March, a ISA-certified arborist with Northwest Tree Specialists in Hillsboro, Ore.

5. Do you like it?

You don’t have to be a tree "hugger" to know that sometimes a tree is more than just a plant. If the tree was a gift or planted in the memory of a loved one – or simply inherited when you purchased the home – you may find it holds a certain emotional significance. “Liking a certain tree provides a certain psychological comfort when returning from a hard day of work,” Young says.


More Like This

Should you hire a tree service to cut down that tree?

4711330-1.jpg

One good reason to remove a tree is to prevent it from falling on people or structures.(Photo courtesy of Angie's List member Martin Bryan)
One good reason to remove a tree is to prevent it from falling on people or structures.(Photo courtesy of Angie's List member Martin Bryan)

Unless you’re a certified arborist or a dendrologist, you may not know the right reasons to cut down a tree on your property. Some situations – such as a tree potentially falling on your home or its occupants – make tree removal an obvious necessity, but other reasons for cutting down a tree can be more subtle.

Add comment

Anonymous reviews are Internet graffiti.  Angie's List has real reviews from real people.

What is Angie's List?

Angie’s List is the trusted site where more than 2 million households go to get ratings and reviews on everything from home repair to health care. Stop guessing when it comes to hiring! Check Angie’s List to find out who does the best work in town.

Local Discounts

Daily deals up to 70% off popular home improvement projects from top-rated contractors on Angie’s List!